Unbelievable! A video of an officer being polite and respectful while stopping a person carrying AND videotaping. He doesn't even pitch a fit when guy won't ID.
Posted Jul 22, 2011, 8:00 PM UTC
Posted Jul 22, 2011, 8:00 PM UTC
I know we have rights, but it seems some people are just out there trying to test the limits. Why not ID? The guy was being polite and just asking. I'm all for flaunting your rights, but some people are just idiots.
The guy probably wanted to be on his way. It didn't look like he had anyone with him, and probably wanted to walk by himself. From his perspective the Officer is being intrusive and holding him up. He didn't tell the cop to go off himself, he just didn't want to be bothered.
Or he could just be a dick, but we don't have to jump to that conclusion.
and probably wanted to walk by himself
I have a very hard time believing he was just out for a walk. He was probably trying to make the exact video that he did. He wasn't just going for a walk with his gun and camera (or cell phone). He was hoping to get stopped by the police. Now, I have no idea if he was hoping they would freak out so he had it on tape or if he just wanted to see what reaction he would get, but either way he wasn't just "out for a walk".
I agree. Awful convenient to be just out for a walk down the street with a camera and gun. I have a carry conceal permit and i do carry but i don't flaunt it or carry in places i know would cause problems. Just because you have the right to do something doesn't mean you should. Cheers to the cop who handled it professionally even with someone looking for a story to tell.
Thanks, you are saving us quite a bit of stress... and consequently some stress-related hospital bills.
What's the point in having the right if you don't intend to use it?
I have a right to call you a scumbag piece of shit cocksucker faggot nigger. Whats the point of me having that right if I don't intend to use it, scumbag piece of shit cocksucker faggot nigger?
[deleted]
More tasteful, sure. More effective? Unlikely.
you can call me a scumbag piece of shit cocksucker faggot nigger all day long if that's what brings you happiness, it doesn't bother me. but when a cop asks me for ID for no reason, that bothers me.
Can I ask why it bothers you? I mean obviously it would be situational dependent on whether or not you have a legitimate reason to not show him (trying to hurry for example) but I am just curious why it bothers you? If it is a situation where you are not in a hurry and it in no way affects how the rest of your day goes then why does it matter? Just curious.
I don't think you understand the word 'right'. A right is not an obligation. It's a freedom that you may exercise at your choosing. I have the right to say whatever I want, but I choose not to, because the trade-off is not worth it in that instance. A right does not mean free from consequence.
And just as you have the right not to cooperate with the police, you also have the right to cooperate with them.
I think the reason people make videos like this is to remind police officers and citizens that you have these rights and police can't take them away from you, though some do anyways
Why would you cooperate with an institution that is only going to be damaging to you?
Because in many cases it isn't going to be damaging to you?
You have a right to remain silent...
To be fair, there are a LOT of things you can do that seem innocent and compliant to a simple request from an officer that can come back to bite you. Even simple statements can be made that can be twisted around if you find yourself in court.
Generally speaking, not answering anything other than the bare minimum required when speaking to police can be a wise thing to do. It makes you sound like an arrogant douchebag, though, and in some cases the police will get rather pissed with you and may harass you more for it (or at least intimidate you for it.)
Listen up, douche. The thing about your rights is that you have them and dont have to justify using them.
The cops know the guy doesnt have to say his name, so why dont they just leave him alone to make everybodies life easier?
How on Earth this got as many upvotes as it did is ridiculous.
Perhaps there are people who didn't see it 2 days ago so this is the first they have heard of this?
Just wish people would use the search function as is explicitly stated every time you post a new link.
I'm really torn on the issue. I love that this is getting such great exposure, particularly because that's my hometown, but this video has seriously been posted and gotten major attention multiple times a day this whole week. I think my problem is with the major Karma whoring that people are using it for.
In the end it's a good thing.
[deleted]
They're both Marines. That guy could have shot the gun 15 times into the air in front of the cop and they would have gone to the bar when he was done his shift.
Also, why is this unbelievable? The guy with the gun was respectful, did what the officer asked, and was white. Also, sounds like they're near Boston or somewhere in Massachusetts? Definitely in the Northeast. They're both reasonable adults acting reasonably, and the cop probably knew he was on camera for most of that time. Now make the camera hidden, and 2 guys from completely different backgrounds. If the interaction was the same, that would have been remarkable.
Actually, the cop IDs himself as being from Oceanside PD at the end. Looks like that's in CA, especially when combined with the open carry and the end links.
Unfortunately, this is surprising due to the recent stories about the opposite happening: police going after individuals for filming using wiretap laws.
Well, California and the Northeast are pretty similar politically. I have read about the ridiculous arrests due to people filming cops in action. But I was under the impression that it was localized in the Midwest. I still don't think it's pretty remarkable. It's nice to see, sure. But I have seen plenty of new "look at what this stupid cop did" videos crop up since that started happening, so I don't think it's everywhere. Especially not in incredibly liberal places like the coasts.
Northeast is a very general statement, especially when you have places like New Hampshire and MA right next to each other which are pretty much polar opposites when it comes to gun laws.
I'm not familiar with the gun laws in NH and MA because I don't live there and have never really been interested in owning a gun. I was speaking more to the general liberal sentiment of those states.
Here in PA it's illegal to audio record police, so cops have the right to stop and question you any time they think you are doing more then taking photos of them. On the other hand we have a pretty hard castle doctrine that essentially lets you shoot anybody (even cops if they don't have a warrent) that forces their way onto your property without your permission. So it's not all bad.
EDIT: I stand corrected by tsk05, it ** IS NOT** illegal to openly audio record police during active duty in PA.
... Really? I live in NJ right outside of Philly and I never knew that. TIL.
[deleted]
Here in PA it's illegal to audio record police
What? Can you link to cases? It's only two states where I think they somehow decided that it is, and neither is PA. It was also MD but a judge ruled that it's not illegal and nobody has been charged with it since (or at least there hasn't been a public case).
Edit: Google search shows a man was arrested in 2007 for wiretapping. All charges dismissed. Another man was arrested in 2009, all charges dismissed. ACLU sued after charges were dismissed on behalf of second man. Police settled for about 50k. A quote reads:
"In September 2010, Allegheny County and the District Attorney's Office agreed to issue a memo reiterating to district attorneys and local police chiefs that recording police officers performing their duties in public does not violate the Wiretap Act."
[deleted]
Wait, what? No no no. You completely misunderstood what I meant. I meant that most cops act like this. Especially when they don't feel threatened. I don't have a problem with cops at all. You flew way off the handle about that, friend. It is just you. Work on your reading comprehension and conversation skills.
Is this really surprising for America?
No. It's just reddit bias. I have had good and bad experiences with cops, likewise with any group of people.
Why yes, yes it is.
Then he beat the guy up, took the video and uploaded it himself.
This needs more upvotes, all of the upvotes even. There are so many videos of police officers NOT doing their job well, we need more like this.
This has been posted too many times in the last few days.
Take all the donuts!
Nice guy.
Summary: everyone followed the law, and you're amazed. That's sad.
Bad description. Instead: Everyone followed the edge cases of the law, which for the sake of simplicity need to exist. I personally find it more a sort of individualist fixation than anything interesting... the usefulness of the law is mainly found in where the bulk of the cases are, not the strange outliers.
This is reddit, people think cops are out to get you and lock you up and are from another planet. Great video, all the law enforcement officers I have met are just like that guy. Seriously, they are all just guys doing a job to make sure chaos does not break out. Cool chap, although the guy with the camera would not disclose his last name. Which I personally find weird, what does he have to hide?
it seems to me that the whole point of the video is that he is enforcing his rights....and one of them is to not identify himself.
yeah. I do not know what I was thinking at the time. I think I wanted to waste someones time, and troll them. But meh, w/e.
THANKS BRO
the problem with this video and the people praising the cop for remaining calm, not being violent, etc.. is that this is how it should happen EVERY TIME. its sad that were now applauding a cop for doing what he should do
The problem is that people don't realize this is how it happens 99% of the time and we only hear about the complete fuck ups.
"god bless america" says it all
what does it say exactly?
It says all of it.
It says: god bless america.... I thought the quotations would "help".
Upvote. We need more responsible cops like this one.
TL;DR version of this text below!
Remember, everything you say can and will be used against you.
Remember the video? Don't talk to cops.
You can't have small talk with cops and keep your right to remain silent.
from the Right to silence article on Wikipedia:
The person approached is not required to identify herself or answer any other questions, and may leave at any time. Police are not usually required to tell a person that she is free to decline to answer questions and go about her business; however, a person can usually determine whether the interaction is consensual by asking, “Am I free to go?”
Police may question a person detained in a Terry stop, but in general, the detainee is not required to answer. However, many states have “stop and identify” laws that explicitly require a person detained under the conditions of Terry to identify himself to police, and in some cases, provide additional information.
As of February 2011, there is no U.S. federal law requiring that an individual identify herself during a Terry stop, but Hiibel held that states may enact such laws, and 24 states have done so.
Do Note however, this happened in Oceanside CA, and that state does not have such a law.
Also:
There is a conflict between Miranda and Raffel v United States that remains unresolved by the U.S. Supreme Court. In Raffel v U.S., and in law enforcement practice, the court finds that at the very moment a suspect cooperates and answers questions and/or consents to search, the suspect gives up those rights and must continue that cooperation and consent through to that person's possible/eventual arrest, trial and judgment. Therefore, in the United States, by cooperating with police in any way prior to arrest, a person gives up Fourth and Fifth Amendment rights that under Raffel technically cannot be reclaimed later, after arrest and Miranda notification of those rights. This in reality renders Miranda warnings rather limited in effect, since police do not have to advise a person of his or her rights until after he or she self-incriminates and/or is arrested; if the person has cooperated prior to arrest, then the arrestee has already surrendered most of the rights of which the police are advising that arrestee.
now, read that again:
[If you cooperate] and answers questions and/or consents to search, [you give] up those rights and must continue that cooperation and consent through to [your] possible/eventual arrest, trial and judgment.
Therefore, in the United States, by cooperating with police in any way, [you give] up Fourth and Fifth Amendment rights that [..] cannot be reclaimed later.
So he did the only thing that is possible to protect his rights: Not Cooperating.
TL;DR Version: If a cop asks you anything, don't give him anything, unless you're required by law to do so. If you give him anything, you're not required to give, you're required by law to give him everything. (at least in the US)
REEEEEEEEEPOST
Third time in as many days!
[deleted]
Something tells me that the cop might be a little bit less lenient if the person carrying wasn't an ex-Marine.
"Jeremy" just strikes me as a douche bag. He's carrying an unloaded pistol... and a video camera... and is just WAITING for the officer to do something.
His next video will push the boundaries a little farther, and the next a little farther than that, until a cop finally has enough gray area or uncertainty to act, and then "Jeremy" is going to be screaming about police brutality or how abused their authority or whatever.
Don't get me wrong, he has all of the rights he's exercising... but this is just stupid attention whoring.
The cop deserves a free beer.
If his only intention is to provoke the police so they look bad, why would he upload this video at all?
Just a hunch, but I think his intention is to get attention. When the provocation -> sensationalist video didn't pan out, he decided to upload it anyway.
Attention is attention.
Or perhaps he's trying to raise awareness of people's rights, and encouraging them to stand up for them. That's certainly what this officer did, and I think it was a good message.
[deleted]
And you know damn well that would have been splattered all over the news. Following which the same people who are touting his rights to act the way he acted would be the next ones in line lighting up the cop for ignoring such an obvious threat and allowing the "gun wielding maniac" to roam free.
It's called having your cake and eating it too...it's the American Dream.
Or maybe his cell phone? Crazy! Walking around with a cell phone just WAITING! "Jeremy" is such a douche
Ok fair point... it could be a cell phone camera, and that would explain why he wasn't filming immediately. But I still can't help but view this as a series of steps.
A) leave the house carrying a firearm, but not your ID?
B) do something that raises the attention of the police. If they're in an open carry state (I guess they are)... then what is this person doing that would raise the attention of the police? Walking on the side of the road with their holster on their hip? I guess the cops could have been driving by and saw the guy and just wanted to talk to him about it? shrug
C) when the police approach, turn on a video recording device. Fair enough, but this implies that you're expecting something awful to happen if you need to protect yourself immediately on the arrival of the police. [ Side discussion... carrying a gun to exercise a right, but using a video camera for protection... that's an interesting social commentary. ]
D) refuse to give them any information about yourself, and sound like a dick in the process. I realize this is subjective (but that's to be expected, right?) I've never had an problem with the police. I don't feel like my rights are being infringed upon at all hours of the day. I own a handgun. I generally feel like I have nothing to hide, because I'm not doing anything wrong, and if a cop asked me my name, I'd tell him my name was Steve... just like if anyone else asked me my name, I'd tell them it was Steve. So when I hear someone ask someone else their name, and they say "I'm not going to tell you because I don't have to". Then it sounds like they're being a dick. That's my world view, and I'm sticking with it.
E) upload video to youtube...
I said this in another post, but I think it's worth repeating... doing things doesn't make us who we are, it's HOW we do those things. The WAY that "Jeremy" carried himself out, while within the law, made him a douche... You can argue against that all day, and I'll still think the guy is a douchebag, and you can think I'm a douche, and we can all think everyone else is a douche, and nothing will change there.
With the push by law enforcement to stifle any kind of dissent weather it be by force, lies or intimidation, this kind of douchebaggery is necessary to show us that a reasonable encounter can occur and to show them that the public is becoming aware of our rights and how to handle the encounter.
[deleted]
This is the best counter argument to what I'm saying, and I respect that. I think you're right. Upvotes!
Without context, it's just a guy being difficult, and a cop trying to do his job. In context (which I'll admit, I'm only familiar with on a very superficial level), this could be taking place in an area where the police need to be put into check for constantly abusing their power.
We do need to hold people accountable, but I guess I personally just choose to avoid provocation.
Exactly, my friends don't seem to think that those "bate car" shows and the fake police hookers you see on cops are such bullshit.
that's a rather large and unprovable assumption. i suggest you let what facts we do have to paint the picture and not tailor the narrative to your preconceived notions.
if it werent for people like him doing this, it only gets worse. obv.
Then why is he a douchebag? Because he is exercising his rights? Fuck that.
Why? For doing his job? Give me a break.
No, he's a douche because he's clearly looking for trouble.
And how do you know that? Because he's legally carrying a gun and has a video camera on his phone? Please.
The whole thing smells. Open carry with a handgun with a video camera rigged and other videos touching on open carry. It's pretty clear the officer thinks it's a setup from the way he was careful to identify himself and his department exhaustively for the camera at the end.
He's trying to intentionally provoke the officer. It's people like Jeremy that cause cops to snap and start beating other people like Jeremy.
I have the right to listen to music with explicit lyrics. I have a right (during daylight hours) to listen to that music at a high volume in my car.
I have the right to do so while parked next to an elementary school.
Doing so makes me a douchebag.
Just because we have the RIGHT to do something, doesn't mean that the WAY we exercise these rights is irrelevant. I never said the guy was breaking any laws... he has the right to exercise his rights, and I have the right to think that he's being a douche by attempting to be provocative.
And yes... every cop that does his job correctly deserves a free beer. Positive reinforcement is great... you should check it out.
No cops are evil don'tcha know, we'd be much better if we policed ourselves...like Somalia.
Yes and No, he deserves one for doing his job.......the way that 97.3% of other cops would have acted like power abusing pieces of shit.
just because 97.3 (of your bs statistic) of cop vids are ones cops being assholes, doesn't mean that's how even a large fraction of them act. Cause let's face it, people start taping usually after the policeman has proven to be a dick.
Hyperbole. Please learn the term. <3 But actually, yes, living in LA for the past several years I can tell you that this is how a large percentage of cops act.