ArmstrongRotor•

A very long time ago I worked on APN-141 which operates on 4.275 and 4.325 GHz. The receiver was not what I'd call selective. One of the more heavily used 5G frequency ranges is 3.3–4.2 GHz. I imagine that might cause problems. Don't know if the APN-141 is still used and I expect newer altimeters would perform better. But they probably weren't designed expecting the more challenging RF environment that 5G will bring.

9
LP0249OP•

Considering the aircraft that went into... I'm surprised but at the same time very much not.

1
HinermadUSA [E]; CAN [A, B+]•

A lot would depend on how selective the receiver is on the altimeter. A 5G signal could conceivably desensitize it enough that it couldn't receive an echo from the ground reliably.

Intermodulation between a 5G signal and a transmitter in some other service could cause spurious signals within the altimeter's operating band too.

4
Geoff_PR•

A lot would depend on how selective the receiver is on the altimeter.

The FAA usually operates in a risk-adverse mode when comes to compromising aviation safety. I suppose an FAA response of tightening up the specifications of new-manufactured instruments could be in order.

I'd like to know if anyone has made any noise about this potential use conflict earlier?

5
KD7TKJCN85oj [General]•

From one of the comments on the linked site, it looks like DoD, NOAA, and NASA had all raised red flags.

3
Geoff_PR•

Then that's gonna be problematic, if the spectrum has been leased.

But if the choice is between commercial use and aviation safety, safety's gonna win that battle.

What a mess...

5
Auton_52981•

I think it would depend heavily on the selectivity of the particular unit in question. MOST of the RadAlt's I have dealt with were tested to reject strong EMI outside their band. But when I was in college (a very long time ago), I did work on an old Bendix unit that was very sloppy. Not only were the emissions well outside the band, it also responded to signals that it should have rejected. I was assigned this unit as a design project to create a notch filter to clean up it's selectivity. That was not too difficult, but the thing was using a vacuum tube for the final amplifier output stage. My instructor specifically admonished be "not to mess with" the transmit side. I later learned that at the end of the semester he pulled out the notch filter I installed and handed it to another student the next semester.

4