r/anime•
virtualstar

ranking Kunihiko Ikuhara anime

Discussion

hey r/anime! Kunihiko Ikuhara is one of my biggest inspirations in all mediums when it comes to storytelling. his works have had a huge impact on me and how I interpret literary (i.e. all mediums that use written scripts) works. I believe all of his works have strengths and weaknesses, but I would like to know how you would rank them in order of most to least favorite. as for me:

Utena - shocker. it is a classic masterpiece. I don't have to expand too much on this I think. what sets it apart from his other works is its length, which allows for much deeper character development.

Yuri Kuma Arashi - unpopular opinion to rank it this highly? I suppose that the incredibly heavy use of symbology is not for everyone, and most of the characters as a result are quite shallow. however I found the use of symbols extremely compelling. this is one of the densest anime when it comes to the thought-generated-per-episode-ratio, lol. I also really loved the storybook-like art direction and the brilliance of the pure visual symbols throughout. the lily fading into doves-motif for example is genius. I also think this is the funniest of Ikuhara anime because it recognizes just how ridiculous it is and embraces it.

Mawaru Penguindrum - this had some of the most interesting symbology and storytelling elements Ikuhara ever conjured. topics such as feeling unloved, abandoned, or completely replaceable in society are fascinating. I loved the characters and visual direction. the use of advertisement logo design elements and societal infrastructure design elements as the basis for the aesthetic perfectly instills the air of brutal anonymity. my issue with this series is how janky it is in its atmosphere- each episode is a zany rollercoaster of hamfisted humor and complex character development. this made the series overall difficult to digest, even if its storytelling peaks are completely brilliant.

Sarazanmai - another interesting anime, still brilliant, but overall feels less memorable than his other works. unlike Yuri Kuma Ikuhara managed this time to present complex characters despite being a short anime. whereas I feel like the characters and the story told was solid, the artwork and symbol use is probably the least inventive yet. the formulaity this time quite hurt the series. where Yuri Kuma abandoned its mahou shoujo formula largely after episode 3, Sarazanmai overutilizes this formula for just a tad too long. but lets be honest, even Ikuhara's least amazing work is still great anime.

Sailor Moon - is it bad? not at all. in fact, I consider the seasons directed by Ikuhara to be the strongest Sailor Moon has ever been. the Ikuhara-esque sinister undertones to the narrative are just perfect for Sailor Moon, which on the surface is quite innocent. however let's be honest and admit that Ikuhara was very limited by having to interpret the concepts invented by another creator. the weaknesses are those that are integral to the show itself- formulaity, filler episodes, and being targeted toward a younger audience.

now I want to hear your thoughts on Ikuhara's body of work!

Posted Nov 18, 2020, 10:24 AM UTC

84
Kookospuurohttps://anilist.co/user/Kookospuuro/•

Ikuhara shows are some of my favorite ones too, though I haven't watched Sailor Moon. Yet.

But I'd rank them sorta like:

  • Mawaru Penguindrum (9.4): One of my top tens. Loved it and I really gotta give it a rewatch soon
  • Sarazanmai (8.4): Was quick and fulfilling, could have used some more time though
  • Utena (8.1): Very thick with everything and lots to unpack, maybe a tad too long and circly time to time
  • Yuri Kuma Arashi (8.0): Very cute and fun show of girls finding what they once lost. Lulu best bear.

All of them are some of the most memorable shows I've seen and I'm already waiting for the next Ikuhara banger.

3
bropex•

Utena>penguindrum >>> yuri kuma arashi > sarazanmai

3
cosmiczarhttp://anilist.co/user/Xavier•

Penguindrum (excels in basically every way) > Sarazanmai (wrecked me emotionally more than anything else he did) > Adolescense of Utena (its climax is the best think Ikuni has ever done) > Revolutionary Girl Utena (very good, but also a bit too long) > Yuri Kuma Arashi (not very memorable)

Haven't watched Sailor Moon outside of a couple of episodes as a kid

2
Btw_kekhttps://myanimelist.net/profile/kek_btw•
  • Utena: I can't say that i "understand" it but I think I get it. This is in part to it being kind of part of my life for 7 years but also I think it's fun in it's silly, obtuse way while also being very aesthetically pleasing as well as an interesting and pretty complex social commentary about abuse cycles, gender roles, and fairy tales.

  • Penguindrum: honestly I do not remember much from this show other than barebones plot and a general affinity towards its OPs/EDs/general stuff like characters, visuals, etc. I feel like it could overtake Utena if I rewatched it but that's as much as I can say

  • Yuri Kuma Arashi: Tbh kind of hammy but I did like it. I really would not mind rewatching it and getting a second take

  • Sarazanmai: I think its short runtime hurts it a lot. Still fine of course but I definitely did not connect with the cast as much as the above three

  • Sailor Moon: in the "unranked because I haven't seen it tier." tragic I know

1