Houserules for Androids and Aliens

:AnA: Androids & Aliens

Although Troy's adopted various house rules in the Giantslayer game, they haven't really done anything like that in their Androids and Aliens game. I’ve found this a bit surprising. For example, given Joe’s repeated (and reasonable) complaints about the difficulty of landing combat maneuvers, they could adopt the (pretty common) house rule of having maneuvers target KAC+4 instead of KAC+8.

If you could suggest one house rule for them to adopt, what would it be?

Posted Jan 23, 2021, 7:38 PM UTC

1311
Yoffien:Della: Lil' Deputy•

I would assume he doesn’t run houserules for A&A for the simple reason that they just don’t know Starfinder as well as they do Pathfinder so Troy doesn’t feel confident trying to adjust it.

12
Scoopadont•

Didn't know they had a lot of house rules in giantslayer beyond the crits and fumbles. I think they avoided in in starfinder as most weapons do something interesting on crits already

Combat maneuvers are impractical to do on the fly, they can be fine if you're specifically built for it though. Some issues I've experienced if you do implement the KAC +4 rule are if a player does then build for it, they're way too successful and enemies will almost always succeed against players with them.

I honestly think they should just houserule away starship combat like most starfinder groups already do. Tinkering with the ship and choosing upgrades can be fun but it's clear that the mechanics grind on them all.

9
whimperateOP•

Re house rules: I think they’ve also implemented house rules in Giantslayer regarding hitting friendly targets when firing into melee, and then there’s the 69/86 roll results on d100 rolls...

Re maneuvers: Yeah, another popular one I’ve run into is that everyone gets the Improved Maneuver feats for free. That has the same effect for non specialists (making the roll 4 easier to make), but prevents specialists from then taking those feats and getting even better at maneuvers.

Re starship combat: Yeah, while I like starship combat using the options in the Starship Operations Manual (like the Budget limits on ship builds, boarding rules, and the like), Troy really seems to hate running them. :(

2
Scoopadont•

I think the hitting friendly targets only comes up from fan fumbles, forgot about the 69 on d100's though! I've actually implemented that one into my games, hah.

I like the idea of giving each player a free improved maneuver of their choice at character creation actually, will definitely consider something like it for my next game.

I haven't read the starship operations manual through yet, although some of the new upgrades I've come across definitely caught my eye. Lots of ship upgrades that aren't directly related to starship combat which are nice.

3
whimperateOP•

Re the hitting friendly targets house rule: It’s easy to forget! But it’s the one they’re complaining about here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/TheGlassCannonPodcast/comments/e0sgba/that_dumb_ranged_house_rule/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=mweb

Other house rules they’ve used that I’d forgotten about:

—On level ups, the GM and player both roll for HP, and take the highest (unless it’s the same value, in which case it’s a re-roll).

—Unconfirmed 20s use exploding dice.

—Resting grants Con+lvl HP instead of just HD HP.

—Discontinued house rule: Prepared spell casters only have to memorize their high level slots, and can choose their lower level slots on the fly.

6
GabeB11:Bread::Joe: Bread Boy•

If I’m not mistaken they also got rid of the HP house rule and just do the regular amount of healing

3
Generic_Reddit_Bot•

69? Nice.

I am a bot lol.

4
roll_with_punches:Lorc: Desk Ranger•

The number one recommendation I would make would be around trick shot, resolve the trick DC check and attack with the same D20 roll. It very clearly is a major pain point for Skid as a player, and would help move things along (in theory) by eliminating extra rolls.

Example: Skid rolls a 13 first compares and resolves with his bonus to trick shot, then compares to bonuses to attack (applying any bonuses from succeeding on the trick DC)

2
ThroughlyDruxy:Log:Praise Log!•

that makes trick attack way too powerful unless you then decreased trick attack damage.

4
Sarlax•

Better approach: Skid should take 10 on the Trick check when he can and Troy should just tell Skid the DC, either immediately before or immediately after the first trick check. And the same with ACs.

It doesn't make sense that the PCs can't evaluate how tough their opponents are. Dax would see an alien's quick reflexes and heavy armor and know that it would be very hard to hit. Hiding the AC makes the game less realistic, because it makes the PCs unable to act rationally in response to information they do have.

It would only make sense to hide AC if some part of the bonus can't be detected, such as a high Dex character who hasn't moved yet or the invisible safety of the Ring of Protection, but once those bonuses have been tested in combat, a GM should just cut the shit and tell the PCs the AC. It would make combat a lot faster, because a player just has to keep in mind the roll they need on the die.

Back to Skid: Troy should should either a) tell Skid the trick DC up front so Skid can decide to take 10 or roll, or b) let Skid try either approach based on Knowledge checks and narrative clues, then reveal the DC after the result is known.

If Troy doesn't want to play ball, fine, but Skid can still try half this tactic by always taking 10 first. If the first try works, then his his turn is twice as fast every round after that and he doesn't have to feel as frustrated. If the take 10 trick fails, he's about where he would be anyway if he'd rolled the first attack.

4
whimperateOP•

Yeah, for well-built operatives, I think taking 10 virtually always hits the DC for reasonable opponents. And that would certainly speed up the trick attack routine.

1