We had family worship last night.
We watched a short video with two experiences about how materialism is bad (which, okay, fair) and how much happier your life will be if you didn't work so much and "devoted your life to Jehovah" (not so fair, but I digress). In the Q&A afterwards where my mom interrogates my PIMI brother and I to parrot back phrases from the video, my mom asked "what did our brother (guy from the video) do to fix things?" And my younger brother replied "sold things he didn't need, became more active in rhe congregation, gave to the poor and stuff like that."
My mom laughed at the last part and said "the video never said he gave to the poor!"
Being the closet socialist I am, this stuck out to me. Indeed, the video never once mentioned the Witness guy giving to the poor. Rather, that's what my brother would do were he in that situation, and assumed that because that's what Jesus said to do in the Bible that the video said the same thing. But that's not what was said, and I know why: the bOrg doesn't want Witnesses giving to the poor; they want Witnesses giving to the cult.
I thought it was interesting how my mom kind of indirectly implied Witnesses giving to the poor was an absurd idea. Clearly, this is yet another instance of the bOrg trumping the Bible they claim to revere.
Posted Feb 11, 2021, 5:05 PM UTC
Witnesses rarely give to the poor. If done, it's usually an individual's choice, and most likely done to 'give a witness.'
Yup. The only giving is giving them a magazine or tract. “ be warm and well fed” Gods kingdom will get them a burger
Or its done in secret because the giver knows he/she will catch crap for it from the elders. "Why did you give money to a SOUP KITCHEN?! That money could have gone to Brother Tony's Macallan fund!"
This is us. This weekend we're handing out supplies to homeless rather than zoom service. Also give out sandwiches and beer at other times. Only mu closest friends know.
You're making a real difference for real people in need. :)
I was never in the cult but from friends who were, and from posts like this, I get the feeling there’s a lotttt of drinking.
You’ve got the older people obsessed with family image but are super abusive drunks to their family. Then you’ve got younger people like my friend who drank just to tolerate being stuck in the same house with the drunk abusers.
It’s not like this is unique to jw families but my impression is that people find it hypocritical (or at least ironically at odds with jw propaganda), expressing that through jokes like yours. Am I understanding this correctly or am I reading into this all too much?
You're not wrong. Officially, getting drunk is frowned on. Most JW gatherings I went to growing up were dry. Behind closed doors was another matter entirely. I've known my fair share of JW closet drinkers. It's sad, really. When your cult life sucks but you're not allowed to admit, you have to cope somehow.