r/exjw•
ProbablyPimo

We had family worship last night.

PIMO Life

We watched a short video with two experiences about how materialism is bad (which, okay, fair) and how much happier your life will be if you didn't work so much and "devoted your life to Jehovah" (not so fair, but I digress). In the Q&A afterwards where my mom interrogates my PIMI brother and I to parrot back phrases from the video, my mom asked "what did our brother (guy from the video) do to fix things?" And my younger brother replied "sold things he didn't need, became more active in rhe congregation, gave to the poor and stuff like that."

My mom laughed at the last part and said "the video never said he gave to the poor!"

Being the closet socialist I am, this stuck out to me. Indeed, the video never once mentioned the Witness guy giving to the poor. Rather, that's what my brother would do were he in that situation, and assumed that because that's what Jesus said to do in the Bible that the video said the same thing. But that's not what was said, and I know why: the bOrg doesn't want Witnesses giving to the poor; they want Witnesses giving to the cult.

I thought it was interesting how my mom kind of indirectly implied Witnesses giving to the poor was an absurd idea. Clearly, this is yet another instance of the bOrg trumping the Bible they claim to revere.

Posted Feb 11, 2021, 5:05 PM UTC

11544
Mereustrainul•

Witnesses rarely give to the poor. If done, it's usually an individual's choice, and most likely done to 'give a witness.'

42
machinehead70•

Yup. The only giving is giving them a magazine or tract. “ be warm and well fed” Gods kingdom will get them a burger

12
Suzzanne75•

Or its done in secret because the giver knows he/she will catch crap for it from the elders. "Why did you give money to a SOUP KITCHEN?! That money could have gone to Brother Tony's Macallan fund!"

11
WorkingItOutSomedayType Your Flair Here!•

This is us. This weekend we're handing out supplies to homeless rather than zoom service. Also give out sandwiches and beer at other times. Only mu closest friends know.

4
Suzzanne75•

You're making a real difference for real people in need. :)

2
sterexx•

I was never in the cult but from friends who were, and from posts like this, I get the feeling there’s a lotttt of drinking.

You’ve got the older people obsessed with family image but are super abusive drunks to their family. Then you’ve got younger people like my friend who drank just to tolerate being stuck in the same house with the drunk abusers.

It’s not like this is unique to jw families but my impression is that people find it hypocritical (or at least ironically at odds with jw propaganda), expressing that through jokes like yours. Am I understanding this correctly or am I reading into this all too much?

1
Suzzanne75•

You're not wrong. Officially, getting drunk is frowned on. Most JW gatherings I went to growing up were dry. Behind closed doors was another matter entirely. I've known my fair share of JW closet drinkers. It's sad, really. When your cult life sucks but you're not allowed to admit, you have to cope somehow.

1
[deleted]•

JWs are so far from humanitarian. They're the most selfish individuals on the planet.

35
loveofhumans•

To any outsiders here. You only have to watch the jw as they file in to a convention then grab all the best seats. I have seen people on walkers denied the roomier seats because some "steward" (usher) had taken them for he and his family. The lady victim in tears said to me and i quote; "Conventions are the most selfish times for Jehovahs witnesses."

When the area set aside for elderly and infirm are hogged by the families of the E &I because they want to sit with their mother/grand mother. What is it that they cant be away from same for the hours of a convention.?

6
[deleted]•

Yup. Doesn't matter how many times Convention Etiquette came up, attendants always saved seats. One year they saved premium seats(a whole row) for a family that only lasted 2 hours in them, while we queued outside from the crack of dawn just to get semi decent ones. Selfishness at it's finest. I have a story about how hospitality is done in the country of my birth, but I'm reserving it for my book. If I told you, you wouldn't believe me.

7
loveofhumans•

would not believe? Try me.

2
freegirl77•

You're so right. Jesus was all about the poor and the less fortunate. Jws do not give to charity. Ever. Like your mum, my mum is aghast at the idea. They breed a very unkind set of people in this cult.

19
jesushadasixpack•

Once a couple of people came to our local KH who said they were hungry and couldn’t afford food. Our elder directed them to a church in our community that has a soup kitchen and small food bank, and told them to come back to the KH for spiritual food. They didn’t come back.

18
ProbablyPimoOP•

Good for them. If nothing else, the WT's stinginess makes it harder to get converts.

12
Suzzanne75•

What's really sad is I've known JWs who were told to go to 'false religion' for help because the org couldn't be bothered to help its own. When help DID come from within the congregation, it was always from an individual JW and not an organized effort by the congregation as a whole.

2
Thsrry•

Family worship and bible study equals watching a video. That's just sad.

15
ProbablyPimoOP•

My younger brother struggles to focus on anything more substantial. And THAT just leads to my mom being mad that he's bored. So video it is.

7
Thsrry•

No doubt it's easier for everyone

3
luckynedpepper-1•

Charity = good. Socialism = bad.

You give your things to help others. I will give my things to help others. I will not give your things to others. You will not give my things to others.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
StarTemple•

LOL "From the mouth of babes" the WT cult Pharisees stand exposed and condemned.

The WT would LOVE JWs to have more money to give to THEM ALONE. But they cannot encourage JWs to step on the career hamster wheel and off the WT hamster wheel, so they work this angle, because many JWs would also be out for good in no time IF ONLY they took a day off of the WT gas.

THAT is why although the Gb wished like hell JWs had more money to give to them, they will NOT risk the means by which that could be possible. A dollar from a penned JW cow is worth more than ten possible dollars from a richer JW, which is zero WT dollars when they wake up faster and bail.

So, the GB ALWAYS encourages more WT hamster wheel time instead.

9
camred85•

I remember after a hurricane wittinesses did a relief work, after the work was done they expected the members who got the work done to give them thier insurance checks.

How the hell is that considered voluntary relief if thier having to pay for it.

One particular brother was sent a bill, he asked me and another brother "how much do you think was the material". We said probably abound $1500, he said the recommended amount was $4000.

9
ProbablyPimoOP•

Thieves, the lot of them.

3
redditing_againFormer elder, inactive, and mostly POMO!•

That's why I always say that I'd totally support a religion that truly followed Jesus--nothing more, nothing less. Love everybody (except corrupt religious leaders), no need to shun, give to the poor, and only two laws: love god, and love your neighbor. Beards don't matter, you can accept blood, meet together in groups of two or more if you want, heck you can even be accepted if you're gay since Jesus never talked about that.

Not that I ever expect to be religious again, but a true Jesus-based religion wouldn't be too bad.

7
IterAlithea•

What I dream to follow with my family someday if I’m ever free from the borg.

1
heblacc42•

People are found to be more generous when charity is allowed to be voluntary and not a government-imposed tax. That’s why socialism fails and that’s just another aspect to the insidious nature of the Watchtowers New World System of Things being a socialist hellhole.

It allows the leaders to exert more and more authoritarian control while the lower class (no room for a middle class in the name of forced equality) are all subservient and take what they can get and are deprived of the dignity of choice to use their free will as autonomous people. But it’s normal to see the idealistic virtues of socialism when you’re young. Once you’re older is when the reality sets in and you understand it is a pipe dream being pushed by greedy elitists who are selling a false bill of goods to decent people who just want to make the world a better place. It never works. At least thanks to our economic system so much extra wealth is generated that social programs for those who really need it are feasible. The political corruption has been allowed to flourish for too long and has spoken trillions of our taxes in this way giving a false sense of failure in the part of capitalism. Crony capitalism must be dealt with. It is being used to make people see socialism/communism as a viable alternative when it never ever is. It’s just an even easier way for the elites to rob us. The thought of being drones for the Watchtower in a fake utopia where everything you get is given or assigned and not up to you to decide is a wake up call that it is a fraud.

6
loveofhumans•

as we are anon here I can tell you I will often give a few dollars to street people. Why? They have a need and I have (the modest) means.

6
ProbablyPimoOP•

Good for you! It grinds my gears when people refuse to give a dollar or two to homeless people.

1
loveofhumans•

ditto.

1
Suzzanne75•

"Now, now, Junior! Don't get what Jesus told his followers do confused with what WT tells its followers to do!"

5
rivermannXI'm not the Candyman•

implied Witnesses giving to the poor was an absurd idea.

Right?

Hopefully this make her do a double take and question herself; " hey, wait a minute..."

3
Suzzanne75•

The discouraging of actual charitable giving from the platform was what gave me the kick in the ass I needed to get off the fence and never go back. There was no way I wanted to be associated with that heartless lot.

3

"Giving to the poor? That's rich! LOL. Only people in Christendom who don't have the hope of the kingdom to solve poverty, give to the poor. We know better! We give to Christ's anointed brothers. You need to study more. Jesus didn't commend and reward the sheep for giving to the poor. He gave them life in paradise for helping his anointed brothers. Those fools in Christendom thinks Jesus will reward them for giving to the poor instead of giving to our Governing Body. They obviously don't know Jesus."

3
Aposta-fish•

When they do give they boast about it, a jw female gave half a sandwich to a homeless guy then proceeded to post it on her Facebook page.

2
ProbablyPimoOP•

Pharisees.

1
biguylilwifegood people dont need a deity•

It’s because it is an absurd idea haha

2
EddyGahini•

I am surprised that your mom not only noticed that the boy said that, but she actually made a comment about it!

"Give to the poor", that is a very normal and natural thing to say. Even if you don't really mean it, you still say it because it is a nice cliché, a very "human" thing to say, so to speak.

That your mom laughed in a way that says "that is something you shouldn't have said", I find it disturbing! What this org does with normal sense of humanity!

You right though; they want you to put it 💰💲in that box instead 😂😅😆

2
ProbablyPimoOP•

I was surprised, too! That's why I had to come here and make a post about it :p

2
tinososa6•

One time out in field service, a homeless guy came up to us and asked us if we had any money. Everyone stayed quiet and looked at the elder of the group to see if he would say anything and all he said was that he didn't have any cash and everyone else was just quiet. Then as he was walking away one of the sisters had the audacity to offer him a tract instead. He just kept walking lmao

2
ProbablyPimoOP•

That's... awful. How far they're gone that their only response to their inborn guilt is to give useless pamphlets.

1
296_89-300_02•

1980s we were told that giving to people like our Bible students...excuse me, giving to our "Bible Studies".....would make "Rice Christians". Rice Christians as in people in impoverished countries being given food by (other religion's) missionaries, so they accepted the religion for the food/rice. Giving things/food/old clothes to people would encourage them to study with us, instead of them studying for knowledge and "The Truth". We don't want to make Rice Christians, now do we...wth??

2