The myth of legislative term limits. Hint: They hurt more than help.
baltimoresun.com/opinion/op-ed/bs-ed-jensen-0...Posted Feb 24, 2021, 2:12 PM UTC
Posted Feb 24, 2021, 2:12 PM UTC
In theory this is a good argument but I don't see how having regular incumbents in government offices and on government committees takes away any power from lobbyists. Clearly with the system in place currently lobbyists already hold a lot of sway with politicians, by not having term limits these leaders get to run and run and run as often as they'd like under the guise of 'experience and seniority' which can also mean that lobbyists can establish long term relationships with them. Term limits won't magically fix everything but pointing to lobbyists and experience is not a compelling argument against them.
It's not that having experienced legislators takes away power from lobbyists, it's that lobbyists are much more influential when they're the only source of institutional information. Instituting term limits would be a huge gift to special interests with experienced lobbyists. It would also give those special interests a larger pool of potential influential lobbyists they could hire by making there be more former elected officials. Plenty of former lawmakers will still want to hang around their former offices but they would be doing so on behalf of whoever pays them instead of their constituents. How does that help anything if you're concerned about special interests having power?
Easy fix, implement lobbyist reforms/bans while enacting term limits. Lobbyists aren't required for our democracy so why are we pretending like they're an inescapable feature that need to be accounted for when choosing our representatives?
Generally speaking, if you think anything in government has an easy and simple fix, you're wrong.
Lobbying is protected under the first amendment of the US Constitution. Putting aside the impacts it would have on those who lobby on behalf of the public good, banning lobbying probably wouldn't be constitutional. So in that sense, it really is just a feature of our democracy, or really any democracy.
Allow the lobbyists to speak to the politicians, but not give the politicians anything of value (no meals, trips, etc.).
Speaking with elected representatives is fine but where does it say that they're entitled to speak with officials and offer an incentive for legislating in certain ways?
You understand it is very hard to put regulations on lobbyist, seeing as anyone that talks to a election offical about anything could be consider a lobbyist.....
Not all people who speak with elected representatives offer some sort of incentive though.
This is technically about a specific Maryland bill, but I thought this was still an interesting subject for this sub. I see people talk about legislative or congressional term limits like they're great ideas, but the reality isn't that simple.
In my thoughts they will hurt, but only for the short, in the long term they help.
From Michigan, term limits for legislature positions are horrible in the long term
do mind if I ask why do you say that?
Our legislature in Michigan is a complete fucking mess run by lobbyists and the unelected staff, who more easily bribed, It is a shit show. The elected offical get voted in and are gone before they have the knowledge to do anything.
Yes, this seems obvious to me. Term limits are important for executive positions, where one individual is given significant power over others. They don't make sense for legislative positions, where each individual only gets one vote in the body. The important legislative power is the power to write laws, and there is nothing about term limits that would improve outcomes there.
As a reminder, this subreddit is for civil discussion.
In general, be courteous to others. Debate/discuss/argue the merits of ideas, don't attack people. Personal insults, shill or troll accusations, hate speech, any advocating or wishing death/physical harm, and other rule violations can result in a permanent ban.
If you see comments in violation of our rules, please report them.
For those who have questions regarding any media outlets being posted on this subreddit, please click here to review our details as to our approved domains list and outlet criteria.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
I disagree. It's not a bad point that we should prefer experience, but I still believe that abusive seniority hurts more than helps. An 18 year limit is fair. 12 would be better.
Did you read the article?
Yes
So you're fine giving lobbyists substantially more power just because you don't always like leadership?
No. Just because the author thinks inexperienced congresspeople will empower lobbyists doesn't make it true. If you're worried about that, stand behind new laws that limit lobbying.
[deleted]
Hi Randomabcd1234. Thank you for participating in r/Politics. However, your submission has been removed for the following reason(s):
If you have any questions about this removal, please feel free to [message the moderators.](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose?to=/r/politics&subject=Question regarding the removal of this submission by u/Randomabcd1234&message=I have a question regarding the removal of this [submission]%28/r/politics/comments/lrdtap/the_myth_of_legislative_term_limits_hint_they/?context%3D10000%29)
this is a bad take.
Is there any reason in particular you think that?
lots? here are some:
thinking that imposing term limits would give more power to lobbyists is a slippery slope (and like, not a logical one) that would require actively allowing them to take more power, which isn't necessary in imposing term limits. one does not necessarily follow the other, and saying it does is irresponsible.
thinking that the entrenched legislators we have now are necessarily more knowledgeable than "fresh blood" gives them way too much credit. have you heard these idiots speak?
the average age in congress is also 57-60, where the average age in the country is 38ish. many of them started when they were much younger and are just owned by lobbyists now.
I don't see how this article wasn't written by a lobbyist.
Hi, I am from Michigan, we shortsightedly did this, everything in this article happened, it is horrible. We can't undo because a majority of voters don't understand what happen.
this is what money in politics gets you.
[removed]
Why would we want Congress full of people that don't know what they are doing and have no loyalty to or experience in the institution.
Term limits means a congressman will start looking for a new job right away, and start selling favorable bills in exchange for a cushy next job
My limited understanding is that that's basically what happens in Mexico, which has one term limits. Lawmakers either toe the party line in hopes of getting an unelected position with the party, or they try to find some industry benefactor to work on behalf of that they can be paid by when they leave office.
We can look closer to home, like to Michigan.....