"Return to Darkness" is NOT about filling a blood and gore quota
"Return to Darkness" is one of the design pillars for D4. In the wake of Blizzcon I've seen a lot of confusion over one of the common criticisms of D3: that the game wasn't dark enough.
D3 was filled with blood and gore, but because of the tone and art style they chose, with blended, saturated colors, exaggerated models, and Snidely-Whiplash monologuing, it inevitably feels cartoonish. All too often the tone of D3 is bathos.
It's a mistake to think that the painterly art style of D3 was per se a problem for the game's tone. They could have easily created something like the terrifying classical paintings of Bosch or Goya, but they didn't; they made something that felt more like a comic book or rated-M Warcraft game. (Promisingly, one of the other D4 design pillars is "Old Masters", and in interviews the team has cited Rembrandt, Remington, and Inness.)
Darkness isn't about blood and gore. It's about danger. It's about fear. The atmospheric, gothic, and horror elements of earlier Diablo games felt absent from D3. Mortal life in the world of Sanctuary is nasty, brutish, and short, and victories against evil are pyrrhic and short-lived. Players need to feel that.
Darkness is about sound and music. D3's music is often bombastic and overwrought, better suited to a medieval action epic. (There's nothing wrong with an over-the-top medieval epic—and I actually think most of the score is excellent—but it's not what Diablo was.) The score from the first two games is far more ambient, haunting, and restrained. Go back and listen to a track like Catacombs or Caves. (Even when Uelmen, the composer for the first two games, is more orchestral, he usually makes something more melancholic and atonal. Listen to his early concept for the D3 theme.)
Darkness is about the rhythm of gameplay. You're not just a whirling superhero cutting through enemies; you have to spend time fathoming haunted corridors and darksome caves. Exploration alone is a rich opportunity to grip players with a sense of dread. Go back and play D1: there's real terror every time you open a new door or hear a skittering noise in the outer dark.
Ultimately a "Return to Darkness" is about the psychological, the atmospheric, and the unseen. In the earlier games, everything from the light radius to the pastiche of Western religious symbology fed into this. These are the things that worm their way into your brain and teem nightmares.
Posted Mar 1, 2021, 1:51 PM UTC · edited