
Castaing
u/Castaing

"Return to Darkness" is one of the design pillars for D4. In the wake of Blizzcon I've seen a lot of confusion over one of the common criticisms of D3: that the game wasn't dark enough.
D3 was filled with blood and gore, but because of the tone and art style they chose, with blended, saturated colors, exaggerated models, and Snidely-Whiplash monologuing, it inevitably feels cartoonish. All too often the tone of D3 is bathos.
It's a mistake to think that the painterly art style of D3 was per se a problem for the game's tone. They could have easily created something like the terrifying classical paintings of [Bosch](https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/17/Hieronymus_Bosch_
Priests are in a bad way, and I think the class situation is worth discussing with all of the exciting Year of the Mammoth announcements. I don’t believe the class needs “fixing,” because I don’t believe Priests are broken, but they are a little lost. (Priests aren’t even the worst class right now - that would be Paladins or Hunters, but I contend that’s more due to the failure of the Grimy Goons rather than anything inherent to those classes.) Dragon Priest is a competitive deck. Reno is still kicking about. But many key Priest cards rotated out of Standard without replacement (Velen’s Chosen, Lightbomb, Deathlord, Sludge Belcher), cards like Drakonid Operative brute-force Priests into arch
Priests are in a bad way, and I think the class situation is worth discussing with all of the exciting Year of the Mammoth announcements. I don’t believe the class needs “fixing,” because I don’t believe Priests are broken, but they are a little lost. (Priests aren’t even the worst class right now - that would be Paladins or Hunters, but I contend that’s more due to the failure of the Grimy Goons rather than anything inherent to those classes.) Dragon Priest is a competitive deck. Reno is still kicking about. But many key Priest cards rotated out of Standard without replacement (Velen’s Chosen, Lightbomb, Deathlord, Sludge Belcher), cards like Drakonid Operative brute-force Priests into arch
Most card ideas seem to be for Legendaries or wild effects. Here are some subtler class concepts. (x-post r/hearthstone)
imgur.com/a/BIlEpBlizzard have said they want expansions to be larger in scope than any one raid or dungeon. Here are some expansion concepts. (x-post r/hearthstone)
imgur.com/a/TMLEHWith Blackrock Mountain likely the next adventure, I thought it'd be fun to brainstorm ideas for the expansion to follow. Instead of raids or dungeons, expansions can draw from broad themes (like GvG) or whole regions (like the WoW expansions).
Earlier this week, u/thedronk made an excellent post for his card Kil’Sorrow Cultist. It’s a well-designed card in its own right, but it got me thinking about the wider implications of Silence.
Silence is a practical, powerful mechanic, removing all card text from a minion, but it’s probably the Hearthstone mechanic that most challenges Blizzard’s own design philosophy: it’s not very fun.
It could even be argued that Silence is anti-fun. It’s a universal off-switch. And while counterplay is an important component of the game’s strategic potential,
Wind Serpent
Art by James Ryman and property of Blizzard.
Most of the cards being posted this week seem to have wild effects (not that there's anything wrong with that), so I wanted to post something much more plain.
A Beast with Spell Damage could be a useful tool for control Hunters, and might breathe new life into little-seen cards like Multi-Shot.
Ultimately this means little, but "Muster for Battle" isn't a recognizable ability or phrase from Warcraft lore; "Call to Arms" on the other hand, hearkens all the way back to Warcraft III. It's also the name of a classic Warcraft track. You could even have those catchy bells ring when the spell is cast.
u/psione recently posted about Blizzard’s desire for more than just lists of requested features; they want deeper, more detailed feedback. To meet that desire, I’ve tried to collect some of the best suggestions, analyses, and community projects from the past couple years. This is meant to be an aggregate, not an editorial, so some of the entries may be contradictory; I merely try to give a fair summary of each.
I will say that the general consensus, at least among the Reddit and Team Liquid communities, seems to be that Legacy of the Void needs a thorough gameplay review – so
MtG has the 'color pie.' Here is a Hearthstone 'color chart' I threw together. (x-post r/hearthstone)
imgur.com/a/bx1YU#0In Magic: The Gathering, there is a concept called the 'color pie,' or 'color wheel,' which is a representation of the flavors, philosophies, and mechanics that differentiate the five colors in the game. I thought something similar could be useful for Hearthstone so I threw one together. I'm sure it can be improved.