r/lgbt•
lifeinneon

Dear r/lgbt, it always hurts more coming from within.

So, I had a fun Halloween crossdressing, how was yours?

Oh. Sigh Here we go again.

Much has already been said about SilentAgony's costume and understandly frustrated reaction to being told it was offensive. This post isn't about SilentAgony in particular, though her costume serves as a timely example of hurtful imagery that is all too common. So before anything else, to SilentAgony: I get why you're frustrated. It's not easy being piled on about something you thought would be all in good fun.

I want to expect better. This kind of thing always hurts more coming from within the community because I do expect better.

The fact of the matter is, what I saw in that picture wasn't a drag queen. When I hear the words "drag queen" I think this: Pandora Boxx Rupaul Manila Luzon Drag is performance.

Sadly, the costume instead read more as this or this or even this STOCK PHOTO image.

If you want to know the harm negative imagery does to people, just look around at this subreddit.

  • How many of us here are still struggling with internalized baggage that was heaped upon us when we were closeted, or pre-transition, and is being heaped upon us still?

  • How many of you have lamented that Kurt on Glee makes people think "all gay guys are like that"?

  • How many lesbians here have felt that twinge of discomfort at wearing flannel, or leather? And for those who do, has it never bothered you that you need to take that extra effort to explain that you "just don't give a fuck"?

  • How many bi people here have found themselves hastening to explain that they're not promiscuous after telling someone they're bi?

  • How many not bi people have gotten fed up at being told "everyone's a little bi"?

  • How many people here are frustrated by how opulent Pride can be? How many are afraid we're alienating straight allies?

  • How many trans women here do everything they can to avoid looking like nothing more than a man in a dress?

I know I struggle with that last one every day. Knowing it's coming from internalized BS doesn't help one bit when it comes to coping and getting through the day.

You see, I first told my parents about being trans when I was 6. And that's not even the youngest among the r/trans regulars. I didn't avoid transition because I wasn't allowed to. I didn't avoid it because my parents told me I couldn't, or the school wouldn't let me, or because I was bullied. They bought me the pink Big Wheel; they'd have done anything if it meant enough to me.

I didn't transition for the past 22 years because to me, transsexuals looked like SilentAgony's caricature. I didn't understand the difference between crossdressers and transsexuals. I, naively, thought "sex change" was just about genital surgery and wearing grandma dresses in public. It meant being the permanent butt of society's jokes. It meant being a prostitute and a victim.

This year, thanks to the folks over at r/trans, I've broken through that. I am happier than I have ever been, and I am on my way to being who I always ought to have been. But I'm still carrying a lifetime worth of baggage.

When you look at the picture of me in drag as my old self, know that that is what I still see in the mirror every day.

When you look at that picture of SilentAgony as a "drag queen", know that the idea, and the fear, of looking like that is why I am doing this at 29 and not 19.

Last week Monday, I got my new driver's license, with my new name and an F. But that day was overshadowed by the fact that I barely made it to the DMV. I spent five hours that morning agonizing over the fact that I didn't want to be seen in public. I didn't go to class. I never left my room. All because when I looked in the mirror, I saw a man staring back. It doesn't happen every day, or most days. But some days I still see that old face there and I can't bear the idea that I'm expecting people outside my door to take me seriously as a woman.

And again, I'm not mad at SilentAgony. But, frankly, I don't care what the intent behind the costume was. Whatever it was intended for, that's not what I saw. That's not what many of the trans people who saw the post saw. We saw the mocking depiction of our lives and our insecurities that has been used against us by someone within our own community, who then defiantly argued for their right to use that imagery. And this is not a unique situation. Every time "Why is T with LGB?" comes up here, this same kind of argument cycles around again and again.

We are all hurt by gender role policing. L, G, B, and T. That is why we are together. That is why we need one another, and why it hurts more when mockery comes from within.

So yes, I will plant the flag on this and say that just like "faggot" could only be used or reclaimed by the gay community, that imagery of an unkempt, unshaven man in a dress is for the transgender community to use or reclaim. (We're not talking about drag performers, mind you) That imagery has been a weapon used against us, and to see it trotted out by r/lgbt is disappointing.

Posted Nov 1, 2011, 8:32 PM UTC · edited

132113
pkbooo•

Thank you for your post! I feel like transgendered people are often overshadowed or ignored by the LGBs, and the less everyone hears their voices the more ignorance pervades the community.

It sounds like SilentAgony didn't mean to offend. This doesn't mean she's not responsible for her offensive caricature, it means that she (especially as a mod!) needs to better listen to the trans voices in LGBT. Unfortunately, even after receiving several comments explaining why such a display was offensive, it sounds like she never opened up to what the people in the affected group were trying to say.

LGBT really needs to work on inclusivity; I absolutely agree that it hurts more coming from within a trusted group.

Anyways, thank you so much for speaking up and I support you 100%. Also, huge respect for your costume, that must have been emotional but empowering. I hope that every other day of the year you're recognized as the beautiful woman you are.

31
Coplex•

needs to better listen to the trans voices in LGBT.

I'm trans (if you care: pre-everything woman, out to family), and I don't appreciate that it seems to be implied here we all agree/agreed on this.

I know I rather would have supported SilentAgony's and rmuser's defence until I read OP's explanation a few minutes ago. I don't mean to imply or state anyone should be silenced; I am not in any way challenging your explicit statement quoted here; I'm only out to refute the implication I read into this.

(If you didn't mean to imply that, I am every kind of sorry for incorrectly reading it into this.)

3
pkbooo•

Sorry if I seemed to imply that I was speaking for trans people as a whole, rather I was referring to the specific posts in that thread made by trans people.

I do think it's important that we don't lump everyone into a whole. While sometimes groups can share general ideas, it's important that individual voices are still heard.

Thanks for the post, and sorry for the confusion; I'll try to word my posts better next time :)

6
Coplex•

I was referring to the specific posts in that thread made by trans people.

Yep, that's what I figured.

Thanks for the post, and sorry for the confusion; I'll try to word my posts better next time :)

Great =)

3
TroubleEntendreDestination Girl•

Sorry if I seemed to imply that I was speaking for trans people as a whole, rather I was referring to the specific posts in that thread made by trans people.

You didn't. Coplex is being oversensitive.

0
[deleted]•

I disagree, I think Coplex was being exactly as sensitive as she needs to be. She had a concern, she voiced it, and then they reached an understanding. On the other hand...

_____ is being oversensitive. Sounds an awful lot like gaslighting to me. ಠ_ಠ

3
KingOfSockPuppetsArt, Music, Writing•

I think there's a key semiological difference not being pointed out real well in the other thread (that you address lifeinneon). That difference is this:

-Silentagony's main defense is that she's 'sorry she offended people' with her costume, but that it's her right to parody and deconstruct gender. Fine, whatever. But it's not that it's offensive to trans people, it's that it's traumatic. What's really bugging me is that she's unapologetic about that. You pointed it out silent, and it was mentioned in the Halloween thread, but her costume is a pitch-perfect stand-in for the 'man in a dress stereotype' that strikes to the very core of the fears of a lot of MtF individuals. Fine, you're deconstructing gender with your meta performance. But when that meta performance is literally causing emotional distress to people, people in a supposedly safe space that stands in solidarity with them, some form of apology should be expected. I really can't overstate that that costume has a lot of potential to be traumatic (and was). I'm still struggling with my gender identity and where I fit in, and it's triggered a little dysphoria for me personally.

This isn't just about what is/is not appropriate gender performance, as a lot of the other thread is about. Given this is r/lgbt, if your performance is valid, but can literally cause emotional distress, an apology and some sort of understanding isn't a tall order. Especialy, especially from a moderator.

tl;dr: costume not just offensive, can literally cause trauma. That's the problem.

26
lifeinneonOPDream In Digital, Live In Neon•

but her costume is a pitch-perfect stand-in for the 'man in a dress stereotype' that strikes to the very core of the fears of a lot of MtF individuals.

Thank you. I'm glad someone dug that meaning out of all of that word vomit, since that's exactly why this cuts so deep.

21
myfavcolorispink•

I realized I was trans was I was 15 or 16. Then I started looking into what I could do for it, and everything I stumbled across was, very sparingly, people who didn't pass well at all or, much more predominantly, drag queens. This scared me into denial for 8 years because I wanted to be a girl not some dude in a dress. When pop culture only shows drag queens, and uses any male gender variance as the butt of a joke it makes self acceptance incredibly hard.

(To the trans people who don't pass that I potentially offended in this post: I'm really sorry. I'm always impressed by your moral fortitude to stick it out and be yourself, I'm not that strong. Please don't take offense to what I said, I couldn't think of any better way to say it and I felt it was necessary to my story. )

21
lifeinneonOPDream In Digital, Live In Neon•

Sounds like me. I still don't pass well, I know it. So that's a huge source of stress for me. The struggle I have right now is that I am exactly where I never wanted to be: stuck in between. I swing back and forth between incredibly happy and cripplingly insecure.

Lots of folks try to be supportive by talking about body acceptance, but my issue isn't a matter of low self-esteem. I barely pass. That's not self-esteem. That's me living in reality and my friends trying to use kid gloves. :P I love them for it but damn it feels like I'm being humored sometimes.

Edit: Don't worry. :) I didn't find your post offensive.

13
myfavcolorispink•

I just started hormones last week. I can't cross dress because I still totally see guy when I do. But that does mean I can still easily pass as a guy. I can see how scary that would be to sit in the no mans land in between. (The word choice in that sentence made me laugh a little)

I have noticed what you mean about feeling humored. It's like I can see I don't pass, I appreciate the complement, but I think you are just saying that to make me feel better. I hope things go well for you in the future.

7
lifeinneonOPDream In Digital, Live In Neon•

You too! :) That's a huge step you've taken and I wish you the best with it. I know how excited I was that first week.

I didn't really want to go full time when I did, but I was starting a new semester at college and I was starting a new job. I only wanted to introduce myself to all those new faces one time. So I rushed the process a bit so that six months later I wouldn't have to deal with the misgendering and name mistakes as people tried to relearn who I was.

Living full time is great. In most situations it just feels more natural. People describe me as radiant because I am never not smiling. And it's all genuine. I love my life.

The dark side of it is that I know exactly how I look. I know exactly where things stand appearance-wise because I know how I get treated by people who don't know me by name. That part makes me want to hide in my house until I get FFS. However, that would make it difficult to earn enough money to get it. :P And I'd feel that awful anxiety whether I was home or out anyway, and if I just sat around hiding, I'd be adding cowardly failure to the pile of problems and regrets. :P

It's a process. I'm in the middle of it. I can still see the light at the end of the tunnel, so I'm ok. :)

7
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
lifeinneonOPDream In Digital, Live In Neon•

Hugs

I'm so sorry. :-/ But I know how it goes. FFS has been my goal from day 1. So many people tried to tell me "Oh, just wait and see how hormones go." Not necessary. I have a more masculine bone structure than most guys. I knew to keep my expectations low pre-FFS. Doesn't mean it isn't a chore some days.

Even having moderate expectations, it's tough. I started at 28. I knew before I started this would take much more than just long hair and a little makeup, like some folks. I keep my jealousy in check pretty easily now, because for the most part, I am happy. I don't get stared at, but I do get uncertainty the first time someone tests the waters with a pronoun. They usually guess female, but it's obvious that they're guessing.

But yeah, I didn't have dysphoria before. I now know the true meaning of body dysphoria. Until I was on hormones, I didn't know what I was missing, and I didn't realize my own diminished capacity for simple happiness. So there is no way I would ever go back just for the comfort of being invisible again. But with it has come the absolute certainty that I am not passing at least half the time.

1
[deleted]•

I wanted to say something in your original thread about this, and just didn't get around to it (lazy redditer here). Now it's even more relevant...

This:

I barely pass.

Is definitely a hard thing to deal with. I think (and I think a lot of other people do as well) it's something you will get past. But the amount of courage and confidence you've shown us so far, both addressing your own disphoria and what you see as a problem, that is something which I do actually admire.

3
lifeinneonOPDream In Digital, Live In Neon•

Thank you. :-) I appreciate the support.

1
TroubleEntendreDestination Girl•

Yeah, body acceptance is a nice (privileged) idea. When it's used as a way to keep from talking about real world problems faced by those of us who live in bodies that society doesn't accept, well...

"Just accept yourself" don't put food on the table.

2
a3wagnerDISREGARD THAT, I SUCK COCKS•

I'm going to have to ask a really, really obtuse question, so I apologize: why am I supposed to be offended by SilentAgony's post? What is the image on the pumpkin?

Edit: okay, I think I get it. For some reason it didn't occur to me that that was a costume (derp). I thought it was just someone presenting at a time when they felt comfortable enough to do so. I think I can see what all the fuss is about (but it still takes a lot of courage to dress like that, don't you think? And not just for Halloween).

17
lifeinneonOPDream In Digital, Live In Neon•

In her words, she is dressed as a drag queen. But to many observers she's a woman dressed as a stereotypical unkempt "man-in-a-dress". That imagery is often used to ridicule transsexuals.

14
a3wagnerDISREGARD THAT, I SUCK COCKS•

Yeah, I answered my own question by using the highly-touted "search" function. >_< I had thought about how I would feel if someone dressed up as "gay." The answer is that I would feel really strange. I am not a caricature just because of that one quality.

Same thing here.

10
nailz1000•

I thought it was a gender-queer costume.

1
smischmalshe-wizard•

Yeah, I just read it as some really blatant genderfuckery at first. Of course, most genderqueer folks don't look like that either, but I guess there aren't really built up cultural stereotypes for genderqueer people like there are for trans women, so it would be okay.

1
alsoathrowaway•

Speaking from a position of relative ignorance (so feel free to downvote me), I'm going to have to disagree. I think that for a cis woman to dress up as a man dressed up (very poorly) as a woman is a relatively safe choice for a Halloween costume - safer, for example, than for an actual male to dress up poorly as a woman (which is already a common enough costume choice).

9
a3wagnerDISREGARD THAT, I SUCK COCKS•

Oh what, I thought this was a man dressing up poorly as a woman. Now I'm just really confused. :\

7
alsoathrowaway•

Ah, yes, that is a crucial component of the issue. This was a woman dressing up as "a drag queen" - or, more specifically, as a man dressing up poorly as a woman. On the one hand, I can understand how the fake beard shadow and chest hair and toilet paper are important markers as to what she was trying to do, without which she.. well, just would've been dressed as a woman, which for a woman is a pretty lame Halloween costume. And in fairness, it was a clever idea.

Still, while she intended it to be read as "drag queen", the way it comes off (at least to anyone who knows that she is in fact a woman) is, at best, "lazy and ineffective crossdresser" (mildly offensive), and at worst, "pathetic, poorly-passing joke of a trans woman". The latter was not, obviously, her intent, but it's unfortunate that she didn't see that potential implication before putting the costume together. (And of course her defensive and angry behavior when that was brought up - rather than simply being able to step back and go "Wow, okay, I can totally see where that would offend people, and I'd like to apologize for that; here was what I had been trying to do..." - didn't help at all, either.)

And, of course, if "drag queen" was what she was going for, what she should have done is to go completely balls-out (pardon the unfortunate pun) over-the-top feminine, with let's say some ridiculous shoes and a ton of impeccably-done makeup, with a huge wig, or something like that. It would have been immediately identifiable, still clever (in terms of the woman-as-man-as-woman thing), and probably wouldn't have offended anybody.

Oh well.

14
lifeinneonOPDream In Digital, Live In Neon•

(And of course her defensive and angry behavior when that was brought up - rather than simply being able to step back and go "Wow, okay, I can totally see where that would offend people, and I'd like to apologize for that; here was what I had been trying to do..." - didn't help at all, either.)

That's what pushed this from facepalm-worthy to hurtful; the inability or unwillingness to take responsibility.

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

6
a3wagnerDISREGARD THAT, I SUCK COCKS•

Ah, now it all makes sense. Thanks for clearing that up for me!

3
lifeinneonOPDream In Digital, Live In Neon•

In reply to your edit, I understand the confusion. I am the one who is using their pre-transition appearance as a costume. SilentAgony is dressed as a poorly passing male crossdresser or mtf transsexual.

In short, I'm engaging in self-deprecating humor. I and others felt SilentAgony was crassly mocking trans people, trans women in particular. In her words:

I did it because being a lesbian dressed as a drag queen is hilarious.

However, the premise of the humor of this outfit is something that makes my daily life significantly shittier than it needs to be.

7
newlyminted•

I am extremely disappointed with SilentAgony, her post had no decorum, and was unsuited to r/LGBT. It would likely have been better received and more suitable in r/womynbornwomyn. I just want to forget what I saw, and try not to rage.

Edit: Missing adjective.

13
TroubleEntendreDestination Girl•

It would likely have been better received and more suitable in r/womynbornwomyn.

...that exists?

3
newlyminted•

I have no idea, the inspiration just struck, and no matter whether it exists or not, it illustrates the point. I was about to put r/WBW (I have not one clue whether it exists either), but in the end, I felt spelling it out would be more widely understood than an acronym.

There's no way in hell I'll ever check to see whether these subreddits actually exist. :P

2
SophiePorter•

They don't but that the movement to legitimize transsexual discrimination still exists is depressing :(

1
Coplex•

I pretty much agree with OP now. I want to add that in my opinion and from what I have seen, people initially didn't articulate it as well as you did, and I think that made the discussion more difficult than necessary. (I didn't follow all of it though.)

This is a very important part in this regard:

Whatever it was intended for, that's not what I saw. That's not what many of the trans people who saw the post saw.

While SilentAgony didn't mean to mock trans women, the imagery she used is indistinguishable from what others would use to do so.

If this ambiguity didn't exist, that is, if she could and did dress up as "lazy male crossdresser" without possibly being mistaken for that (incorrect) stereotype of trans women, I don't think any of this would be an issue.

(And I have no idea why she'd call it a "drag queen" when "lazy male crossdresser" fits much better.)

12
lifeinneonOPDream In Digital, Live In Neon•

While SilentAgony didn't mean to mock trans women, the imagery she used is indistinguishable from what others would use to do so.

This, this, and this.

5
AliceHouse•

I dunno. I always imagined the lgbt community to be a haven for those like myself who never exactly sexually matured appropriately and with much confusion. I always imagined that because I imagined that certain alignments in today's society with certain natural bodys urges would lead to confusion.

i just sort of wish we could all be who we wanted to be without hurting anyone for being what they are. even pirates.

11
starlilyth•

"This is who I am. It is a culture, not a costume." Sound familiar?

8
Coplex•

I think this is oversimplifying the matter at hand.

The campaign using that slogan seems to address costumes where the intent was to mock a particular group using (incorrect) stereotypes about the group.

What we have here is, as explained, not intended to mock trans women, and while intent isn't everything, I think it must be noted that the actual intent was (apparently) to mock "lazy male crossdressers" (or "lazy/bad drag queens" or whatever). The problem is that unfortunately there is this (incorrect) stereotype of trans women as what in effect is equal to "lazy male crossdressers".

Therefore, as I initially stated, I think referencing that slogan/campaign doesn't fully address the matter.

7
starlilyth•

I disagree. I think the point being made by the campaign was that the costumes were not intended to make fun of anyone; they simply thought they were being funny/cute/clever, and the unintended consequence was they made mockery of whomever they were stereotyping.

The same as SilentAgony did.

10
Coplex•

they simply thought they were being funny/cute/clever

Oh well. All of my fate in humanity is lost then. All of it.

I should mention that I've only seen a few of the campaign's posters so far. Yes, if that's the point of the campaign then I do agree with you that it does apply. (Then again, maybe the point isn't communicated clear enough? I didn't get it without your explanation.)

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
dshigure•

Sad to say it, but the way the mods acted on this matter set back my hope in humanity a tad. The mod posted something that hurt a significant portion of the subreddit she is modding, and refuses to listen to why it hurts. It must be our fault because she was funny as shit and we just have no sense of humor. The other mod also joined right in in her defense, making an offensively false claim that nobody provided an argument for why it's offensive. Our pain was just dismissed in a puff of smoke.

You have to be super oblivious if you need an explanation as to why a caricature of a demographic such as this makes for an offensive costume. You have to be arrogant to completely dismiss the explanation once you ask for it.

8
kittyneko•

SilentAgony tends to pull this shit, however, along with rmuser blindly backing her up.

3
Casey234•

Hmm, as an aside, SilentAgony is dating Zinnia Jones? http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FO0MUZm-Yew

I still think this whole thing is quite blown out of proportion though. Anyway, if you're reading this, SilentAgony, please tell ZJ she's awesome.

7
mariesoleil•

ZJ is rmuser, the other r/lgbt mod.

3
Casey234•

I did not realise this. Wow, now I feel stupid.

3
[deleted]•

This made me cry in the middle of a school library o.o

7
[deleted]•

Well, it didn't offend me, therefore nobody should be offended by it. Humph.

That's how we do this, right?

7
lifeinneonOPDream In Digital, Live In Neon•

Now you're getting it!

;-)

3
lysa_m•

You're wonderful. Thank you for saying this.

Might you be open to some minor disagreements?

How many of you have lamented that Kurt on Glee makes people think "all gay guys are like that"?

One of the reasons I like Kurt is that he's completely himself and that I'm not sure that "he" is necessarily correct: Kurt is not just gay, but gender-variant in some very serious ways. He seems to naturally associate with women in ways that Blaine (for instance) never does. (And I would suggest that between Kurt, Blaine, Brittany, and Santana, there's plenty of diversity of queer characters on that show.) And when he is forced to play the male role, he fucks with it: He wears a tux to match the women's dresses and sings Barbra Streisand songs.

Though I was never into guys, I see in Kurt a whole lot of myself as an awkward semi-closeted-even-to-myself trans girl enduring the hell of adolescence and high school. Far from being a gay stereotype, Kurt is to me a nuanced portrayal of a gender-questioning adolescent, and probably the most interesting and well-developed character on the show.

How many not bi people have gotten fed up at being told "everyone's a little bi"?

I'm not bi, even a little bit. I'm 100% lesbian. But I say that myself, to remind myself that the 100% might be closer to 99.998%. Maybe there's one guy on the planet that I would be into. Maybe I shouldn't worry about whether I'm attracted to a man or a woman, and just let my attraction exist. I would prefer to live in a world where the gender of the person you date is no more significant than their hair color or height, even though in that world I would still date only women.

How many people here are frustrated by how opulent Pride can be? How many are afraid we're alienating straight allies?

Not really one little bit. It's not more opulent than many predominantly straight events (see any major college campus at Halloween, or any Spring Break destination). I'm not going to apologize for other queer people having some fun.

Anyway, those are just alternative points of view that I have, and I hope you can agree that there's room for reasonable people to differ.

6
lifeinneonOPDream In Digital, Live In Neon•

I know there's a lot of us who don't buy into those points (Most of them don't apply to me. In re-reading it I realized my sentence was potentially ambiguously saying that I agreed with all of them). But they're examples of the internalized crap many of us have picked up over the years.

5
banana-stand45Art, Music, Writing•

People were asking for an explanation of why SilentAgony's post was offensive and I feel that this beautifully explains it. More people need to see this response as to why that image was hurtful.

When I first clicked your link (without looking at the title), I thought "oh, its just another chick going in drag". When I re-read the title, I realized the symbolism behind this attire. I just want to give you snaps for being brave in yourself as a woman. My partner still hates pictures of himself as feminine and maybe we can try this in a few years :) So thank you

6
[deleted]•

can i just say that youre super awesome to the max

6
[deleted]•

TIL so very much. I am deeply appreciative of this subreddit, and thankful for the time lifeinneon took to explicate this issue. I work with race, and have been slowly, too slowly, moving to gender as well.

5
jkl420kg•

Thank you for standing up for me (and yourself). It's hard to explain why stuff like this costume hurts me so much, but you did a very good job. So thanks and many hugs.

5
wolfanotakuSpirit•

Everything you said was so heartfelt.

I know that he meant it as a joke, but for some of us it struck hard.

4
uragaaruHarmony•

I'm tired of people using "humor" to condone bullshit like that. One it's an insult to humor. Two, it's sn insult because it implies those who are offended are too stupid to "get the joke".

23
yourdadsbffgaysha gown•

Two, it's sn insult because it implies those who are offended are too stupid to "get the joke".

Or worse: "Oh, you're just being oversensitive."

12
wolfanotakuSpirit•

Well put! Humor is too often used as a shield for what something really is.

5
[deleted]•

"Wassamatta, can't take a joke?" is a bully cliche. It's not only rude and hurtful, but boring and predictable.

5
blazingsaddle•

You put this all a lot more calmly than I could have. Well done!

Also, nailed it.

4
[deleted]•

Thank you. That's all <3

4
lifeinneonOPDream In Digital, Live In Neon•

:-)

2