Dear r/lgbt, it always hurts more coming from within.
So, I had a fun Halloween crossdressing, how was yours?
Oh. Sigh Here we go again.
Much has already been said about SilentAgony's costume and understandly frustrated reaction to being told it was offensive. This post isn't about SilentAgony in particular, though her costume serves as a timely example of hurtful imagery that is all too common. So before anything else, to SilentAgony: I get why you're frustrated. It's not easy being piled on about something you thought would be all in good fun.
I want to expect better. This kind of thing always hurts more coming from within the community because I do expect better.
The fact of the matter is, what I saw in that picture wasn't a drag queen. When I hear the words "drag queen" I think this: Pandora Boxx Rupaul Manila Luzon Drag is performance.
Sadly, the costume instead read more as this or this or even this STOCK PHOTO image.
If you want to know the harm negative imagery does to people, just look around at this subreddit.
-
How many of us here are still struggling with internalized baggage that was heaped upon us when we were closeted, or pre-transition, and is being heaped upon us still?
-
How many of you have lamented that Kurt on Glee makes people think "all gay guys are like that"?
-
How many lesbians here have felt that twinge of discomfort at wearing flannel, or leather? And for those who do, has it never bothered you that you need to take that extra effort to explain that you "just don't give a fuck"?
-
How many bi people here have found themselves hastening to explain that they're not promiscuous after telling someone they're bi?
-
How many not bi people have gotten fed up at being told "everyone's a little bi"?
-
How many people here are frustrated by how opulent Pride can be? How many are afraid we're alienating straight allies?
-
How many trans women here do everything they can to avoid looking like nothing more than a man in a dress?
I know I struggle with that last one every day. Knowing it's coming from internalized BS doesn't help one bit when it comes to coping and getting through the day.
You see, I first told my parents about being trans when I was 6. And that's not even the youngest among the r/trans regulars. I didn't avoid transition because I wasn't allowed to. I didn't avoid it because my parents told me I couldn't, or the school wouldn't let me, or because I was bullied. They bought me the pink Big Wheel; they'd have done anything if it meant enough to me.
I didn't transition for the past 22 years because to me, transsexuals looked like SilentAgony's caricature. I didn't understand the difference between crossdressers and transsexuals. I, naively, thought "sex change" was just about genital surgery and wearing grandma dresses in public. It meant being the permanent butt of society's jokes. It meant being a prostitute and a victim.
This year, thanks to the folks over at r/trans, I've broken through that. I am happier than I have ever been, and I am on my way to being who I always ought to have been. But I'm still carrying a lifetime worth of baggage.
When you look at the picture of me in drag as my old self, know that that is what I still see in the mirror every day.
When you look at that picture of SilentAgony as a "drag queen", know that the idea, and the fear, of looking like that is why I am doing this at 29 and not 19.
Last week Monday, I got my new driver's license, with my new name and an F. But that day was overshadowed by the fact that I barely made it to the DMV. I spent five hours that morning agonizing over the fact that I didn't want to be seen in public. I didn't go to class. I never left my room. All because when I looked in the mirror, I saw a man staring back. It doesn't happen every day, or most days. But some days I still see that old face there and I can't bear the idea that I'm expecting people outside my door to take me seriously as a woman.
And again, I'm not mad at SilentAgony. But, frankly, I don't care what the intent behind the costume was. Whatever it was intended for, that's not what I saw. That's not what many of the trans people who saw the post saw. We saw the mocking depiction of our lives and our insecurities that has been used against us by someone within our own community, who then defiantly argued for their right to use that imagery. And this is not a unique situation. Every time "Why is T with LGB?" comes up here, this same kind of argument cycles around again and again.
We are all hurt by gender role policing. L, G, B, and T. That is why we are together. That is why we need one another, and why it hurts more when mockery comes from within.
So yes, I will plant the flag on this and say that just like "faggot" could only be used or reclaimed by the gay community, that imagery of an unkempt, unshaven man in a dress is for the transgender community to use or reclaim. (We're not talking about drag performers, mind you) That imagery has been a weapon used against us, and to see it trotted out by r/lgbt is disappointing.
Posted Nov 1, 2011, 8:32 PM UTC · edited
Thank you for your post! I feel like transgendered people are often overshadowed or ignored by the LGBs, and the less everyone hears their voices the more ignorance pervades the community.
It sounds like SilentAgony didn't mean to offend. This doesn't mean she's not responsible for her offensive caricature, it means that she (especially as a mod!) needs to better listen to the trans voices in LGBT. Unfortunately, even after receiving several comments explaining why such a display was offensive, it sounds like she never opened up to what the people in the affected group were trying to say.
LGBT really needs to work on inclusivity; I absolutely agree that it hurts more coming from within a trusted group.
Anyways, thank you so much for speaking up and I support you 100%. Also, huge respect for your costume, that must have been emotional but empowering. I hope that every other day of the year you're recognized as the beautiful woman you are.
I'm trans (if you care: pre-everything woman, out to family), and I don't appreciate that it seems to be implied here we all agree/agreed on this.
I know I rather would have supported SilentAgony's and rmuser's defence until I read OP's explanation a few minutes ago. I don't mean to imply or state anyone should be silenced; I am not in any way challenging your explicit statement quoted here; I'm only out to refute the implication I read into this.
(If you didn't mean to imply that, I am every kind of sorry for incorrectly reading it into this.)
Sorry if I seemed to imply that I was speaking for trans people as a whole, rather I was referring to the specific posts in that thread made by trans people.
I do think it's important that we don't lump everyone into a whole. While sometimes groups can share general ideas, it's important that individual voices are still heard.
Thanks for the post, and sorry for the confusion; I'll try to word my posts better next time :)
Yep, that's what I figured.
Great =)
You didn't. Coplex is being oversensitive.
I disagree, I think Coplex was being exactly as sensitive as she needs to be. She had a concern, she voiced it, and then they reached an understanding. On the other hand...
_____ is being oversensitive. Sounds an awful lot like gaslighting to me. ಠ_ಠ