My Irish stout is a total disaster...

Brew Humor

Setting up for my 6pm Zoom meeting I decide to grab a home brew. I have a batch of Irish stout that is just about fully bottle conditioned and I put a bottle in the fridge the night before.

I pour the beer and it looks light. I knew I had watered the wort down to hit my target fermenter volume because I BIAB’d in a too-small kettle, but this was disappointing. Doesn’t look like Guinness at all. I Google Guinness homebrew recipes and videos, comparing the color from videos to my own. “Guinness is actually dark red” they say. Okay, mine’s pretty red, but not remotely black.

So I taste it. The roasted barley is barely coming through. It’s there, but so light. What the hell, is it that watered down? Did I get the recipe wrong? My ratios from the recipe I used look right. The color and flavor are all wrong. Maybe my yeast did something to it—I used British ale yeast instead of Irish ale yeast.

I already told my friends I had stout for them. This isn’t stout, and I’m gonna have to drink a whole 5gal batch of this failure beer in shame and isolation. I mean, it tastes good, but it’s definitely not stout. It’s disappointment in a bottle.

I go back downstairs after my meeting to rinse the bottle out and I look at the cap again. Whoops. That wasn’t my stout! It was a bottle of amber ale that was in there next to the stout. I don’t label the bottles, just the caps. I pulled the amber by mistake. And it’s a good amber ale... but it’s no stout.

We’ll try that again tomorrow. Maybe this time I’ll pop the right top.

TL;DR: poured an amber ale thinking it was my new Irish stout, became disappointed, still HAHB though.

Posted Mar 9, 2021, 1:49 AM UTC

9234
xnoom•

This post was a real roller coaster ride.

60
Craig_White•

It was the amber ale who dunnit

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

22
beagerOP•

Yes for sure. This was my second batch ever and I topped it up trying to compensate for the lower amount of mash water due to small equipment. The gravity was close even after topping up but I still feel like I had efficiency issues due to the equipment.

After that batch I did an IPA and the yield was low, but the gravity was good. Excited to bottle that one this week. Cheers!

3
jonny24eh•

Hah! What a twist. Wish I had a homebrew right now

13
beagerOP•

If you brew some, label them really well!

10
jonny24eh•

I actually did just start labelling them two brews ago, after I attempted a split batch yeast comparison and then lost track of which yeast was which lol

3
beagerOP•

Ah yes, the self-double-blind taste test. For science!

5
celeryhead69•

How after all that emotion were you able to not crack the stout? Can you please crack the stout? For me?

6
beagerOP•

I did not want my idiot mode tasting the beer after such a profound self-own. I will open it today, hopefully with a more intelligent presence.

6
funkychickenscampBlogger•

Haha, I use different colored bottle caps but occasionally have to label the caps if there's some crossover. One time I found a bottle in the closet with a "P" on it and thought it was the last of my year old Pineapple/habenero/ brett/orval dreg saison. I was so excited and put it in the fridge from when I came back from a vacation. It was a "P"umpkin beer instead, and the year of aging was not kind. Hope your stout is awesome.

4
beagerOP•

Hah! I label by batch number but I already know my chicken scratch will lead me to confuse two brews at some point again.

2
tato_salad•

I always use unique colors for my caps. I look to see what I have left in my fridge/ my case of homebrew before I choose a bottle capcolor.

3
ItWasLikeWhite•

Me too, caps are cheap, not free though. I still think am saving on work and the swear jar compared to if i were to label.

1
tato_salad•

I label too.. but usually only the beers I give out. I have a Silhouette cameo and use sticker paper. I design my own labels and they get cut out with an offset.

Most recent https://imgur.com/kxGtAzr

Usually they're a bit more square but it depends on my label. I'm rolling through several "rapper" series beers.. Wee Heavy D and the boys Snoop D o Doubel G Hose of pain irish red Alt diurty Bastart (That got all drank before I made the label)

2
ItWasLikeWhite•

Nice work. Might consider doing that too. It is not like i am going to be the one removing those if I give them out.

1
tato_salad•

easiest labels to pull off honestly, they come off in one piece.

At this point I have my "in recycling" bottles, and my "in the basement" bottles. I know which beers/ciders have the easy labels (angry orchard rules by the way). The rest aren't' worth my time and I just send them back to the recycling

1
lordofthepi•

" I’m gonna have to drink a whole 5gal batch of this failure beer in shame and isolation. "

The tag line to this sub

3
nobullshitebrewing•

meh,, a week aint gonna kill you

2
aladdin_insane•

I truly don't understand this. With all the good beer in the world, anything that I don't love gets dumped. If I don't need the space, I'll sometimes let something age out for 6 weeks, or so. Other than that, I'll pour anything that I wouldn't serve and be proud of.

1
tcn5020•

This is so hilarious because I did the exact same thing with the same beers last week. Totally freaked out until I realized the mistake. Also started tape labeling my beers the next day lol. Cheers.

2
scrib_blez•

I'm conditioning my first brew at the moment and it's a stout so at first this felt like some serious foreshadowing. Glad your stout is ok though!

2
beagerOP•

Enjoy your stout, cheers!

2
cvl37•

Ha this is one of the best posts I've seen here for a while :D

2
IAPiratesFan•

I usually got both grey and black bottle caps when I was bottling back in the day. So I knew what they were based on the color of the caps. I also got little round stickers at the dollar store and put them on the caps too. My cousin’s husband homebrews and bottles it all. He puts post it notes on the bottles and then secures the post it notes with rubber bands.

1
Emp4th_neversleeps•

Wow. My emotions....
A good mantra I feel for brewing is: It's better to have a little beer that is great, than a lot of watered down swill.

1
gruffabro•

Cool story bro

1
beagerOP•

Thanks m8 I’ll tel it again if u give me a dollar

1
roamingcoder•

When I bottled I used different colored caps for different brews. Glad to hear everything is okay!

1
ateaseottawa•

I mean, unpopular opinion here, but guiness is very close to flavorless. Not unenjoyable, but as close to flavorless a beer can get.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
naliko_dobipa•
1
beagerOP•

Well, yes and no

1
naliko_dobipa•

So, tankard is half full, yes?

1
buffaloclaw•

Just call it an Irish Red Ale instead. Because that's what it basically is if you shorted on the roasted barley

1
sandysanBAR•

Not gonna lie, you had me in the first half

1