r/netsec•
puppetless

I joined this subreddit, but I think it is too advanced for me. I'm interested in internet security, but most of the posts go over my head. Is there a subreddit more suited to my level?

I'm looking for a subreddit similar to this one; where news articles and current events are submitted.

It appears, (and correct me if I'm wrong) that this subreddit seems more for people who are in the industry or work with security as a full time job....I'm a home user and very much a novice when it comes to these things. So I guess I'm looking for a ''non professional'' version of this subreddit. I've looked in the related subreddits sidebar and nothing quite seems to fit the bill. (Also checked the sidebars of /r/techsupport and /r/24hoursupport, no luck) Any help would be much appreciated.

Posted Nov 15, 2011, 1:26 PM UTC

257113
Julian702•

For the home user that is not interested in Googling things you do not understand, or wish to ask about (we'd actually like explaining stuff), then there's not much for you to do except keep your computer's security patches up to date and dont clickety click on everything that can be clickety clicked (be suspicious of all attachments and links).

But I suspect that the best course of action for you is to keep hanging around. Each time you dont get something and do even a little bit of research, it's laying a foundation for the next thing you don't get... Eventually, those little pieces will come together and form one big "OMFG That's Awesome" in your head.

210
puppetlessOP•

lol that's actually very wise advice. Try to understand 5% of submissions. I think I will give that a try. Hitting up wikipedia every now and again won't kill me.

56
crummy_water_tower•

I'd like to second Julian702's advice. I'm in pretty much the same situation as you, but I've been hanging around here for a couple of months and have learned a lot. The stuff that seems to be really technical really isn't that bad once you google it and read a little bit about it; I think it's just an unfamiliarity with the terminology more than anything that makes it seem overly daunting.

36
RamonaLittle•

Same here. I don't have a chance to look up everything, but once I've seen an unfamiliar term a number of times in different posts, I figure it must be something important, so I'll read Wikipedia and do some Googling until I have at least a vague idea what it means. I figure after I do that enough, I can put the pieces together like Julian702 said.

Also I think sometimes people are too quick to blame their own ignorance for not understanding something, when maybe the article or whatever is just badly written. The people who really know their stuff are often able to explain it clearly enough that anyone can understand it (maybe with some supplemental Googling). So if I don't understand one article but it seems like an important topic, I'll look for other sources, or just keep the topic in the back of my mind to read about later.

13
altrdgenetics•

I think that goes without saying for any industry. Some of the best people who know what are going on are also the worst at scaling their explanations.

1
anonymous_hero•

I've felt the same with Proggit and HN before. I still don't understand everything, but I've learned a lot.

Oh, and on netsec, I'm in the same boat as you again :)

2
[deleted]•

I'd choose an area that interests you and do some research. As you start to learn that area, more will open up and before you know it you will at least get the idea behind all of the different areas of security (crypto, pentesting, coding, network, systems, policy etc). All of these areas interconnect in some ways, it seems most people start out in one or two and end up doing them all. Also I'd suggest the Shon Harris CISSP book, it's really gives you a good base and after a few times through you should really grasp the important concepts and from there you can expand where most interests you.

2
Jibrish•

I'd say you should read up on networking theory a bit and how widely used encryption styles work (ssh, what is ipsec etc.). That should kind of fast forward you to barely knowing what these people are talking about (like myself).

2
Orca-•

Just by reading the odd security post on other sites (and in the last few months, here), I've learned enough to be dangerous.

So do as Julian is suggesting and stick around. :]

2
mossbackfarm•

one more novice....I get 5-10% of it now, but when I started lurking here a few months ago, it was probably closer to 3% (SWAG)

Right click - search google for "*" can get you pretty far. Well maybe up to 10% anyway...

1
Nixhatter•

My new go to statement for security advice "dont clickety click on everything that can be clickety clicked "

37
MonsterMuncher•

Although my response to users wanting to learn how things work is play around and click on everything.

Just as long as they also read and understand any warning messages before pressing OK

11
Nixhatter•

Step 1. Learn how to use a sandbox properly

Step 2. Clickety Click

12
phjr•

Until next sandbox escape bug. False sense of security.

3
[deleted]•

Click-fraud bot disagrees.

0
crdoconnor•

For the home user that is not interested in Googling things you do not understand, or wish to ask about (we'd actually like explaining stuff), then there's not much for you to do except keep your computer's security patches up to date and dont clickety click on everything that can be clickety clicked (be suspicious of all attachments and links).

There is WAY more than that, and frankly that isn't even very good advice. Being suspicious of ALL links on the internet?? You'll never use the internet if THAT'S your approach. There's a ton more:

  • How to choose secure passwords (this is pretty complicated - even most experts can't agree on how to do it).
  • Where to keep your passwords to keep them secure.
  • How to keep your secure data safe from prying eyes.
  • How to avoid having your web browsing habits eavesdropped.
  • Common vectors for malware/spyware delivery. Assessing risks.
  • When/where to use your credit card.
  • Habits to adopt to increase your personal security.
1
Julian702•

I completely agree with you that these are important topics and should be taught in school as early as 2nd grade (my kid took the lessons very well). But the operative phrase behind my original post was #1 directed at this particular OP, and #2 "For the home user that is not interested in Googling things you do not understand, or wish to ask about".

1
Nixhatter•

I don't think this subreddit is very advanced. It's common not to know exactly what's behind every post, that's why you click and read about them. If you're worried, then you'll just have to do some wikipedia hunting as well.

34
puppetlessOP•

Ok, that's fair enough. I assumed that everyone understood these post titles.

15
[deleted]•

I am sure that a small SMALL minority do. But a lot of "full time security" engineers as you put it, have very precise buckets of knowledge (this the related Reddits on the side bar). I often have to break out my google-fu skillz to find out what is what and why

18
puppetlessOP•

Aha, ok.

5
me_z•

I second that. I am a Security Engineer and I find myself googling/researching a lot. No one knows everything.

12
scopegoa•

go to reverseengineering.reddit.com if you want a taste of advanced.

2
atomicfrog•

Just to add one more reason to stick around, this is a great sub reddit to keep an eye on as emerging threats will sometimes get mentioned here not long after they hit the web. Sometimes sooner, but we won't go into that.

3
I_RAPE_CATDOGS•

I started to make some pretty basic backtrack 5 tutorials but I'd recommend starting with the metasploit megaprimer. Even if it's a little too advanced for you just watch all the videos and once you have a better understanding of penetration testing/network security you can try to exploit a windows xp box running in a VM. I'm focusing more on the offensive security side of network security so this might not be what you're looking for, if it isn't just start learning the basics(OSI model, wireshark, bt5, setting up routers/bridges)

If enough people are interested in learning anything related to network security I'd be willing to help make tutorials for a subreddit dedicated towards noobs.

EDIT: subscribe to reddit.com/r/LearnNetworkSecurity I should have the first tutorial uploaded by tonight.

23
sedawkgrep•

I dunno - I think metasploit is cool, but is not at all a good primer on network security. To really understand 'network security', I think you have to spend time doing administrative work.

In my old black|white hat days, it was common that the biggest and worst vulnerabilities in an environment were from poor administrative practices, not from unpatched vulnerabilities. I relied equally on my SA and network experience as well as finding/writing exploits to gain access to resources. Had a not had the admin experience, I would've been at a severe disadvantage when finding myself in unfamiliar territory. (Like back in the days of DG-UX or Everex or Ultrix or VAX/VMS or...)

Just my $0.02.

5
todbatxTrusted Contributor•

I agree, actually working IT is a fine way to pay your dues in security-land.

Also, I usually recommend the OffSec stuff for Metasploit 101. In addition, we've published four or five vulnerabilities (old) that we don't have exploits for -- great way to get your first exploit out, if you're interested in going down that route.

(nb: I work at/for/on/with Metasploit)

2
pigeon768•

I'll have to check that out. I've made attempts to learn metasploit before, always ended up being unable to make any progress.

Also, for people who don't like flash or streaming video in general:

for i in $(seq 1 2); do wget http://videos.securitytube.net/Metasploit-Megaprimer-$i.mp4;done
for i in $(seq 3 17); do wget http://videos.securitytube.net/Metasploit-$i.mp4;done
5
I_RAPE_CATDOGS•

You can also just torrent them!

Pirate Bay

Demonoid

8
pigeon768•

Oh, hey, that's a much better idea.

1
drew3000•

I would really be into something like that. As a noob.

3
I_RAPE_CATDOGS•

I just made the subreddit r/learnNetworkSecurity

If anyone else is interested in posting tutorials/videos on the basics of network security let me know. Also if you want a certain topic to be covered you can post a request and I'll try my best to either make a tutorial or point you in the right direction.

12
[deleted]•

Consider xposting over in ureddit as well!

6
I_RAPE_CATDOGS•
2
RockDiesel•

Thanks for creating that subreddit. Definitely looking forward to learning from it.

3
I_RAPE_CATDOGS•

No problem. I just finished recording the first tutorial on how to install BT5 r1 in a VM now I just have to finish up the power point slides, it should be uploaded by tonight.

4
na85•

That should be side-barred.

3
drew3000•

Sweet. Will check it out. Thanks for starting this!

1
mk_gecko•

sorry-- your username is too vulgar for me to want to have anything to do with you. There are probably a bunch of other people who feel the same way but will never tell you.

-7
veritablequandary•

Can't tell if goofing or incredibly self-righteous...

frynarroweyes.bmp

5
I_RAPE_CATDOGS•

That's your loss then.

3
[deleted]•

The fool looks at the finger that points at the sky.

3
sedawkgrep•

I hope you're joking.

2
RamonaLittle•

I'd recommend starting with the metasploit megaprimer.

Just started watching, and have to say it's totally worth it just for the guy's accent. "wulnerability" FTW!

3
dbl_edged•

Everyone that says stick around and look things up as you need are right. Heck I learned to read that way. I would read stuff way over my head and just look up words in the dictionary that I didn't know. Did I understand all of the subjects I was reading? Nope. Eventually it all built on itself though.

People around here are pretty decent too. There are a bunch that are willing to answer questions. Having people around that don't have a PhD in mathematics asking questions about crypto helps some of us figure out a way to explain things without overwhelming and alienating. I pissed off a CEO at my last job with a presentation on passwords complexity. I could tell my presentation was going over his head so I tried to dial it down a little so he would understand the concepts I was trying to get across to him (why we can't have 3 character passwords... tough stuff). He got all offended because he felt I was talking down to him at that point. Some of us find that happy medium a hard balance to maintain. That said, there are jerks in any forum but don't automatically assume someone is being an ass if their answers to your questions seem snarky. Sometimes the best way to learn something is to teach it.

Just my 2 cents...

11
I_RAPE_CATDOGS•

“Never memorize something that you can look up.” ― Albert Einstein

9
BarfingBear•

True, but you also need to know the basics. I can look up the details of the OSI model but I need to understand how it works.

4
Theon•

Relevant question, how can I best learn about security? I find the topic very interesting, but same as puppetless, there's still quite a lot of posts I don't understand.

9
LucidNight•

Be apt at asking how things work and why. Before you play with security you need to know how something works. For example take a smaller item like SSH, a service many of us use. Figure out how it works and WHY it works that way. So there are posts on this subreddit that we use it because it uses encryption, why? Ask why it picks the type and go research why! These things called certificates are used sometimes, why? Look it up, understand why they are used and then play with using them. It really helps to have a certain style of mindset when learning security. When you figure out the why you can start looking into how to secure it which will come easier to you. Even when looking into something small you can learn a lot of concepts that will apply to other topics and items. Do not try and just learn "security", there is so much information involved and concepts that you will have a hard time. Pick a smaller subset that interests you and go from there.

6
finder3690•

YES! This can't be stressed enough! You've got to walk before you can run. Understand the OSI model, really learn TCP/IP and the various protocols around them. once you have solid knowledge of networking you can really start playing with and understanding the basics of exploitation.

Security is a very broad field and everybody specializes in different areas but if you can really wrap your head around the low level stuff (Keywords: ARP, ICMP, UDP, TCP, IP) and can get a grasp of how HTTP and standard web attacks work, you can build a really solid foundation for understanding a lot of the basics of remote exploitation. In time, you can really bone-up on concepts of programming and start to tackle subjects like buffer overflows, shell-code, privilege escalation, etc...

4
mwerte•

So what you're saying is "be a 3 year old".

I think that's perfectly apt as I'm always looking into how things work, and how to take them apart. Always the "why"

2
me_z•

Reading, reading reading, and experimenting. Going to a hackerspace sometimes is a nice experience too. Also, if you can shell out the time and money for Defcon, it may be worth your while.

edit: Experimenting LEGALLY*

5
Theon•

Reading what in particular?

And regarding hackerspaces and defcon... I'd visit our local hackerspace but I'm a little afraid of looking out of place or even being ridiculed as I'm just 15 years old. And I don't live in the US, so Defcon is out of question entirely.

1
me_z•

If you're a novice, as most people start out as, then I would recommend the following:

The Basics of Hacking and Penetration Testing: Ethical Hacking and Penetration Testing Made Easy

Hacking For Dummies

Grey Hat Hacking

Hacking Exposed - 5th Edition - May be outdated

Network Security Bible

So now people here may disagree on the books I've suggested, and that's fine, but it definitely depends on what you're trying to learn and/or accomplish. Google is a great place to start as well without spending a fortune on books.

Some great websites:

SANS Dark Reading

I'm sure you can find plenty more.

And always ask questions, even if you think its a stupid question. Being on Reddit and having the luxury of anonymity, you can ask away without worrying about getting personally ridiculed.

As far as hackerspaces and defcon, they were just a suggestion. If you ever are able to get to a hackerspace though, I highly recommend it.

15
Fewleftstanding•

There is a 6th Edition of Hacking Exposed.

Good list though! I've seen those books discussed a lot.

4
GiantNinja•

nice list. Gonna have to check these out

1
RamonaLittle•

I don't live in the US, so Defcon is out of question entirely.

Videos from the talks at Derbycon are online. I'm not a security pro, but I'm finding them more understandable than I expected.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
[deleted]•

Thats not quite the same. Defcon builds community. I find my vost valuable assets are people's who's opinions and skillsets I have grown to respect.

1
puppetlessOP•

Right now I'm combining a new interest with internet security. I just joined Diaspora a few days ago, and so as well as idly surfing Diaspora, I occasionally search under the hashtag: #security, or similar words. I found a little gem that someone posted: ''Basic internet security''. Of course, me being me, I've only read the intro, but I intend to read it all at some point!

Of course, a subreddit would be ideal, but this is what I'm doing right now. Perhaps you could do something similar...if you are into facebook or twitter, (or reddit obviously!) you could have a crack at combining both.

3
WornOutMeme•

Read more.

3
puppetlessOP•

Yes sir. Happy Birthday.

2
[deleted]•

Thanks for that link!

2
TheKevan•

I am another reader piling on who is interested but misses on much of the details.

1
I_RAPE_CATDOGS•

Start by installing Backtrack 5 r1. I'm going to be uploading a tutorial on how to install it in Oracle VM virtual box over at /r/learnnetworksecurity.

1
foil-time•

Read many books, break many rules.

1
BarfingBear•

Yes, and likely misquoting Picasso here, you have to learn the rules before you can break them. In infosec, you'll be dealing with engineers, who focus on just getting things to work. You need to know convince them why that's not enough, and sometimes that means showing them how they're broken.

2
foil-time•

That is a really good point. As an example, I've worked network security in some places where machines were locked down so tight that you couldn't switch your keyboard or mouse port without making a call, all the way to local admin rights given to machines by default. The rules change drastically from place to place as companies manage risk differently. I know that's not exactly what you were getting at with your reply, but rules are always changing and there are always people trying to get by them either maliciously or for convenience.

1
chrispoole•

You may be interested in watching/listening to Security Now, a podcast and advert for SpinRite (I jest).

Seriously though, some of Steve's explanations are good (especially his recent TCP/IP series), which may fit in the area you're describing.

7
anonspangly•

The sets of episodes on fundamentals of computers (from logic gates all the way on up) and of crypto (but without being too brutal on the maths) are also really good.

4
staticchevalier•

I'm not sure about an alternate subreddit, but if you are really interested in security I would suggest picking up a Security+ book. The information won't make you a pro, but it should explain the basics.

6
goldencrazy•

Maybe it’s just me, but I’ve met many a security professionals that could use to learn Security+. It is one of the more basic certs but as the field grows, the bottom end of knowledgable people grows.

Many professionals would still get a lot from going back and learning Security+ especially those who have been in the field a long time, but never got any formal education and haven’t been able to keep up with all the different topics.

6
I_RAPE_CATDOGS•

I just made r/learnNetworkSecurity and Network+ is a perfect place to start, even if you don't get the cert the book teaches you a lot of the basics. I read it 3 years ago but I still haven't forgotten the OSI model.

2
thebigch•

I've come to realize that most security professionals enjoy sharing their knowledge and don't mind explaining things..... once. It only becomes an issue when the recipient isn't willing to do some of the leg work themselves and dig into the information provided. I'll tell you everything I know with the expectation that you'll remember or write it down long enough to go dig deeper on your own. If you come back and ask the same question twice due to lack of effort, I probably won't be as willing to help next time. Apologies for the rant. Some issues at work have made me think about this a lot lately.

5
[deleted]•

Reading up on the things that sound interesting will get you quite far. Places like securitytube and even youtube have lots of good conference presentations available that even if you dont understand all of it, you'll get the introduction section and maybe some new things to google for.

theregister.co.uk is normally a good source of security news made digestible for non experts. Lurking in irc rooms can be useful as well? As someone else suggested, grabbing a security+ or CISSP book could work. People may laugh at CISSP but as an introductory text it's quite good. I got mine for £4 in a charity shop :D

2
puppetlessOP•

Thanks for the register tip. That's exactly what I'm looking for....news that I can browse, and tips that I can implement pretty swiftly. Now that I think of it, lifehacker is a very good one also. I need to update this post with what I've learned at some point tonight.

1
Runnergeek•

It was my understanding that the CISSP was highly respected in the security field.

1
BarfingBear•

It's a mile-wide and three inches deep. It's good for the basics.

1
[deleted]•

my impression so far is that its regarded well in security management circles but not in technical circles, but because it covers everything can be a useful introduction to security concepts for beginners

1
BarfingBear•

Be careful about The Register, as they tend to jump to conclusions.

1
spencerclark•

Everyone here is saying stick around and just learn as you go, I would say that is true. However I do have a recommendation if you are willing to go off the reddit.com reservation? I listen to Steve Gibson's podcast on twit.tv He and Leo Leporte host a show together that talks about netsec related stuff. They are also archived if you wanted to watch some of his older podcasts (but still very useful). Just be aware that he says Um and has to take time to compose his thoughts. Sorry Steve, still I love you buddy.

It's just a thought. I just wanted to throw that out there in case no one has yet.

2
BarfingBear•

I find that listening to him at double-speed is just right. It took about 30 episodes to get over his run-on sentences, but you get used to it. Also fast-forward at appropriate spots. All in all, it's good stuff.

2
chronospike•

Another good suggestion I would give is try out a hacker trainer site like enigmagroup.org or hellboundhackers.org. Both octhese sites have live servers setup for particular styles of web hacking and programming that will ease you into some of the broad security topics you want to learn about. Their forums are also full of people who will help you understand why the things you're learning are so pertinent today.

Edit: forgot to say enigmagroup has their own security news site attached at news.enigmagroup.org as well as a wiki at hakipedia.org for the terms that you'll keep reading about.

2
TexAg90•

First of all, don't worry about the fact that you don't know something. I am the head of information security for a large multinational corporation, and I don't understand a lot of what is posted in here. Anyone that claims they understand every aspect of information security is full of it. You already have valuable wisdom that many in this field don't - to admit you don't know everything and ask for help.

If I knew everything about all that was posted here I would not be here. I come from a network security background, so lots of the examinations of exploit code goes way over my head. But it's interesting so I try to understand it.

The security field is very much a community. I share information with my competitors and they share with me. We learn from the successes and failures of each other. It's why I enjoy it so much. It's constantly evolving and always challenging.

There is some very good advice on here for you. Just keep reading and immersing yourself in it.

2
EryHax•

Just keep reading. When you don't understand ask and/or Google it. It's the best way to learn - all it takes is motivation. If you're willing to look around for answers you'll find them.

1
joe_fnord•

I still don't get a lot of the deep technical details of all this but one thing that has helped is leisurely working my way through this:

Mike Meyers' CISSP Certification Passport

It really covers a lot of ground and helped to clarify things for me, even if I only read it whenever I feel like it.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
generic_0•

One tip is that if something is highly upvoted here, it usually means that it is either simple enough for a high number of visitors to understand (like some of password policy type posts) or important enough that being aware of the problem's existence is helpful (high profile malware and attack strategies). Either way it's worth checking out.

1
MTCONE•

May I suggest watching Hak5

I think you could learn a lot from this IPTV show.

1
djscsi•

One of the best ways to improve/learn is to put yourself in situations that are "over your head" - Reading stuff like this is a great way to learn. It might seem advanced now, but keep reading/googling/learning and pretty soon you'll understand most of what people are talking about, even though you may not fully understand the underlying technologies.

An analogy might be playing a video game against someone who is wayyyy better than you at it. At first you'll get your ass whooped and it won't be fun, but you'll improve much faster than if you were playing against someone with a similar skill level, and soon you'll be the one whooping ass.

also r/networking is at a lower technical level generally, but you should still stay here and learn.

1
gsan•

There are countless times I have learned something from staring at a screen of scrolling packets, pure hex or high verbosity debug output. You might not know what any of it means, few do. You couldn't even explain what you were doing to anyone else. But you see patterns, you recognize something out of all that and it sends you closer to achieving your goal. Your brain does that. I suggest you keep reading, read the comments, people answer questions and break down concepts all the time. Your brain will find the patterns and you will learn. Half the work in this industry is having the constitution and determination to do that. Also, learn to program a language. Writing your own ad-hoc tools can be invaluable in this area.

The internet is self-documenting, nearly everything is described in RFCs. Read them before you go to bed at night. Those are typically very well written and clear as there is a big email whoopty-do with people incessantly arguing about semantics before they are published. It should be obvious though that something like RIP is going to be a tad easier to understand than some of the security protocols. In your favor, most of this doesn't change much so you only have to learn it once and most of what you learn is applicable across many domains. I.e. once you get the concept of a source TCP port, you kinda understand how it works for UDP, and that applies over IP or IPv6! You can do this!

1
Tunk•

I would suggest heading over to r/programming and r/linux.
From there you can branch off to dozens of other related reddits and they help give you a base to work off.
Grab a copy of damn vulnerable linux (discontinued) and various damn vulnerable apps to tinker with.

Stay in r/netsec and use netsec as a reference for interesting stuff to research and learn.

1