Is it true that Trosky was opposed to the trade unions? If so, why? Why would the Workers' Opposition be opposed to the trade unions?

Edit: doh, sorry for the typo, too late now.

I'm reading People's Republic of Walmart and it talks about how Trotsky wanted the "full militarization of labor" but Lenin thought Trotsky "went too far" and "He felt that the trade unions needed to maintain their important function as sectional representation of workers". Is this accurate?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trade-union_debate_(Russia)

See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leon_Trotsky section "Trade union debate (1920-21)"

Smaller, more radical factions like the Workers' Opposition (headed by Alexander Shlyapnikov)

I thought Trotsky was the leader of the Workers opposition. Goddamn this shit is maddeningly confusing.

Posted Mar 26, 2021, 7:19 PM UTC · edited

165
CheffeBigNoNo•

It is important to understand to context of this. These were the early days of the Soviet republic, still going through the civil war, and different factions in the party had different ideas on how to hang on in the face of an extremely unfavorable situation. No one was proposing ideal solutions at the time; rather, the idea was to find a way to ward off the imperialist invaders and survive long enough for the revolution in Germany to come to the Russian revolution's aid.

In this context, Trotsky thought - and he was eventually vindicated in this - that War Communism was going for too long and was becoming untenable. He argued strongly for NEP-like measures, which the party would adopt later. Having failed to convince the party of the necessity of such measures, Trotsky suggested taking a different approach to the trade unions. It was not his default position, and was framed purely as a measure to survive longer under War Communism.

Was Trotsky's position wrong? Probably. But to paint as Trotsky having some deep desire to tie trade unions to the state, as opposed to scrambling to mitigate a line that the party itself would later recognize as a mistake, is to strongly misrepresent his position.

35
Bet-Inside•

he was for worker soviets, or worker councils, not really a big union guy. similar to unions, but more democratic in nature. it’s a little confusing, but that’s what i’ve come to understand as far as his position on trade unions.

6
TheHopper1999•

I think this something to be said about Trotsky, he essentially had two periods of though, his civil war thought and everything else. His civil war thought is in a sense shaped by the conditions of Russia at the time.

4
The-Evil-Chicken•

Most non-electoral socialists apart from Anarcho-Syndicalists are differing levels of disapproving about unions. Most tend to the view that they are still participating in Capitalism, so they can't completely introduce Socialism/Communism. Some actually see them as defending Capitalism, as they, and other welfare policies prevent the worst of Capitalism and therefore make it more feasable than it would be unregulated.

I personally am torn, as they generally improve living conditions, but they are also sometimes very mingled with bosses/companies and harm less fortunate businesses by for example upsetting wages. For example someone employed as a delivery man/woman has it more difficult to unionize and raise wages than a clerk. So it can increase inequality.

1