spacealienz

u/spacealienz





r/Trotskyism•

Edit: doh, sorry for the typo, too late now.

I'm reading People's Republic of Walmart and it talks about how Trotsky wanted the "full militarization of labor" but Lenin thought Trotsky "went too far" and "He felt that the trade unions needed to maintain their important function as sectional representation of workers". Is this accurate?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trade-union_debate_(Russia)

See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leon_Trotsky section "Trade union debate (1920-21)"

Smaller, more radical factions like the Workers' Opposition (headed by Alexander Shlyapnikov)

I thought Trotsky was the leader of the Workers opposition. Goddamn this shit is maddeningly confusing.

165

r/Trotskyism•

Even though the party claimed to represent the working class, most of its membership, and particularly its leadership, including Lenin himself, came from the educated classes.

So my understanding is that the workers' opposition pressured Lenin to make the party more representative of its supposed base by opening the gates of the party to bring more proles into the vanguard.

Trotsky opposed this.

Together with the theory of socialism in one country, there was put into circulation by the bureaucracy a theory that in Bolshevism the Central Committee is everything and the party nothing. This second theory was in any case realized with more success than the first. Availing itself

199