I hope questions are acceptable here, because this has been a mystery to me
I would like to know how careful hackers are caught. I first became curious following the arrests of members of lulzsec.
If someone uses hijacked/public wifi to access a vpn through tor, and changes their mac address, how are they caught? All I have come up suggests that they either access accounts without the protection that they created/accessed with (thereby correlating ip's) or they get loose lips on IRC.
Is it fair to say that a hacker using public wifi, TOR, a VPN with a spoofed MAC is undetectable if they maintain silence and don't access any accounts?
Posted Nov 16, 2011, 8:11 AM UTC
I generally don't answer questions like these but I'll bite this time, since I'm waiting on scans to finish.
Rule #1 If you don't own the network (ie: You didn't build it or you don't administer it), you don't know what kind of traffic monitoring or mirroring devices are sitting in the middle and all of that can and will be logged to remote devices which store the data for a very very long time. This can include VPN services, shell providers and TOR.
Talking about TOR, there was a vulnerability recently where a user can be de-anonymized. The question that remains now is, how many users have been de-anonymized before this vulnerability was found and patched and what other vulnerabilities are within the system that we aren't aware of yet
Link: http://www.reddit.com/r/netsec/comments/ls1ed/critical_tor_vulnerability_attackers_can/ and https://blog.torproject.org/blog/tor-02234-released-security-patches
Rule #2 Talking about your hacks, generally not a very good idea. I don't think there needs to be anything said about this issue.
Rule #3 Spoofing the MAC address of another device on the network has nothing to do with what happens OUTside of the network but everything to do with what happens INside the local network. Since the MAC address field of the ethernet frame gets changed at every single hop. The only thing that remains constant is the source and destination IP address.
edit1: To answer your question, no, there can be safeguards in place to detect MAC spoofing, arp poisoning with a plethora of monitoring tools and devices that can very quickly alert an administrator based on different parameters.
edit2: MAC addresses on network cards are burnt-in (ie: It's fixed, you cannot change it) but what you CAN do is to have your system report a different MAC address while on the network.
Thank you for your reply.
As you have said you generally don't like answering these types of questions, I will understand if you elect to leave this follow up question unanswered, but I shall ask all the same.
How was it that it took as long as it did to catch the members of lulzsec, and how has the remaining member maintained anonymity?
Also, incidentally, why do you generally not answer these types of questions? I only ask because I greatly appreciate the efforts you and the others have put forward to help educate, and I would like to make sure I do my part to make it as enjoyable for you as it will be for me.
Trying to resolve issues like this legally isn't really as simple as going "ENHANCE! ZOOM! and WE HAVE OUR GUY!" but it does requires extensive time and collaborative efforts between different LEA in the event the arrest is conducted overseas.
Technically speaking, it's really like trying to fix a jigsaw puzzle but the catch is, you have no idea what the puzzle looks like, neither do you know the number of pieces. So there, in a nutshell, that is really what makes it annoying as hell to get such people arrested.
I don't really follow Lulzsec so I'm not sure who's the remaining member or what the situation is, apart from them going around and dumping db's and exploiting LFI/RFI vulnerabilities in poorly secured web applications.
I generally not tend to answer these kind of questions mostly because it ends in either circle jerk or drifting massively offtopic but since this was a fresh post, I figured I'll comment on it. :)
The analogy of the jigsaw puzzle is very much what I expected it to be like. I have always been curious, as all my reading has left me wondering "how do you actually find these guys to arrest them?"
I followed the LulzSec saga with great interest as they attacked some pretty high profile targets, and remained undeterred for quite a while.
I understand your aversions, and thank you for answering my questions anyway :) I'm really excited about this sub and appreciate setting a standard of quality.
I thought they were "officially" six members, and only three or four have "officially" been arrested? (Three or four because there was at least one news report saying "Kayla" was actually two people, both of whom have been arrested, but it wasn't really clear . . .) Though I think it's likely that anyone seemingly not arrested actually was, and is now working for LE . . .
Also just tossing an idea out there -- just because it takes a long time to arrest someone doesn't mean LE isn't onto them. Maybe the person is under surveillance and LE is waiting to see what other useful information they can gather by leaving the person free.
Fair enough, and I suspected as much as well, as its a fairly common practice in every other aspect of law enforcement. Its not enough to know who they are, you need a solid case as well. Here in lies my question, however, is how they were identified. I am to believe that fellow hackers turned them in, though I wonder if they had not mixed personal and criminal activities and maintained silence how they would have been found...
Maybe they wouldn't have been. In that Dark Market book, there was at least one "king pin" carder who was never caught. They're not even sure if the king pin (whose name I forget) was one person or many, because he/she/they hid their tracks so well. Also any LE agency has to prioritize its resources, so probably many small-time hackers don't get caught, only because LE has more important things to focus on.
Very good answer. I couldn't have said it better myself. But there is just one thing that stood out in the question which I didn't see in your answer which is the following: Just to clarify, you can spoof a MAC address which modifies what the operating system reports your MAC address is but you can not "change" your actual MAC address because it is permanent by design.
Which is true. I'll edit my post to better reflect it. Thanks for picking that up.