The judge just told the jury that he expects defence to be finished this week, potentially taking Friday off

in your opinion, does this indicate that defence is confident? Or that defence has very little to offer in terms of counter-arguments?

Posted Apr 12, 2021, 10:05 PM UTC

714
geyges•

which means Nelson anticipates only 3 days to give his presentation, and that's with allowing prosecution to cross.

I hope nobody expects Nelson to BTFO state really quick and call it a day.

He's going to keep doing what he was doing this whole time. Sow doubt. I don't expect to learn anything new. I think at the end he'll make a point that "Hey we got a drug addict doing criminal things, and we got a cop doing his job, so plz acquit"

9
dollarsandcents101•

Defense doesn't plan to parade half the PD and a hodge podge of medical experts saying different things in front of the jury. They will be concise - strong use of force expert witness (Barry Brodd) explaining why what Chauvin did was reasonable, and strong medical team (The Forensic Panel) explaining a unified cause of death theory. These are the two main issues at play and they will be targeted. Nelson will also provide the full timeline (e.g. starting at Floyd initially being arrested, even before) through to aspects of the investigation (he may try to impeach Baker through calling HCAO/FBI/DOJ witnesses), and doesn't need a bunch more witnesses to fill in the gaps

Nelson also has more than enough from his cross-examinations of the prosecution's witnesses to craft reasonable doubt points during closing arguments, so doesn't need much more.

7
whosadooza•

The defense is going to do anything but present a unified theory to Floyd's death or Chauvin's use of force.Their narratives of the 2 conflict severely and I think cross examination will be very rough on those discrepancies.

They say at the same time that Chauvin did not know Floyd was having a health crisis or had taken drugs so he didn't have a "depraved mind," but also that his continued use of force was necessary, not excessive or negligent, because a man having a health crisis or on drugs could be dangerous. They have the defenses for the 3 charges pitted against each other.

8
dollarsandcents101•

They've well established that Chauvin isn't a medical expert - he doesn't necessarily need to know contemporaneously why Floyd died, so what he was thinking while using force versus what was actually happening to Floyd don't need to be in line.

Main arguments will be that Chauvin was concerned about excited delirium (they can prove that through the bodycam footage) whereas Floyd was dying from what they will contend is a previously established cardiac arrhythmia.

1†
whosadooza•

No one believes Chauvin knew how Floyd was dying. People believe Chauvin knew that he was dying.

Even if Floyd was just already dying of a breathing failure for any reason and Chauvin then knelt on Floyd's neck and back restricting his breathing, he contributed to that death. No one is fool enough to believe otherwise and no doctor is going to suggest otherwise

The question is why did Chauvin do that and the defense doesn't make sense as a whole. They address each charge at different times using contradictory reasons, but they're pitting the contradictory defenses against each other. It's hard to say what that will mean for their reasonableness or even credibility.

8
Bregvist•

You and u/dollarsandcents101 are making good arguments and are civil to each other, what is this, an alternate reality reddit?

Anyway, defense's job seems easier, they don't absolutely have to present a coherent theory, just possibilities, and it only has to work for one juror.

2
[deleted]•

So have you been giving Nelson fellatio for long or just recently?

5
[deleted]•

Wow this comment really has not aged well. The defense witnesses today were terrible.

At times I thought I was watching the prosecution not the defense.

1

does this run the risk of deliberations beginning and ending on Friday? Or would the jury just do nothing on Friday and begin deliberating Monday?

3
stumpy2121OP•

the judge said he will likely delay final arguments because he doesn't want to sequester jurors over the weekend/he wants council to have sufficient time to formulate their arguments

6

ok so closing arguments first thing Monday and then deliberation begins. I like that schedule.

3
dragonfliesloveme•

Nelson’s cheeks looked a little plumper to me today; think he might be doing some stress eating.

And who could blame him, really. But yeah I think he has no hope of an acquittal here.

-8
stumpy2121OP•

Yeah im pretty sure an aquittal is out of the question. Hung jury or which charges will stick is still up in the air as far as i can see

3