stumpy2121
u/stumpy2121
Raised by Nelson today:
State v. McDaniel, 777 N.W.2d 739 (MN Supreme Court 2010)
Prosecutors must avoid inflaming the jury’s passions and prejudices against defendants. Although a prosecutor can argue that a particular defense has no merit, a prosecutor may not belittle the defense , either in the abstract or by suggesting that the defense was raised because it was the only defense that might succeed.
Blackwell called the defences arguments stories, fabricated facts, halloween stories, suggested defence was saying Floyd could wake and lay waste to the city etc etc
In your opinion did Nelson have a point when he raised his concerns or was Blackwell acting appropriately?
Nelson addressed the confusion regarding 98% O2 result. He said he could make the argument that Floyd could not have died of asphyxiation if he had that result, but it would be intellectually dishonest. We saw Floyd get oxygen.
He also addressed the fact that if the prosecution can acknowledge that O2 can be changed after death by resuscitation attempts, then they have to acknowledge that carboxyhemoglobin levels can be changed too.
Pretty cool to see we weren't totally off the mark.
There has been discussion over the lack of clarification in court regarding the blood o2 being 98%.
Most here now know its likely due to cpr. I even confirmed with a family member who is in medicine ...its cpr.
But was cpr raising blood oxygen levels after death in anyones testimony?
Is there anything stopping Nelson saying:
"the states experts claimed mr floyd died of asphyxia, Dr tobin testified mr floyds blood oxygen was at healthy levels when tested, 98%. Dr baker, the only expert to touch mr floyd said he felt the struggle was too much for mr floyds heart. Dr X (cant remember who) said that if they found a body with this toxicology and without any other evidence it would be
in your opinion, does this indicate that defence is confident? Or that defence has very little to offer in terms of counter-arguments?
Theoretically chauvin should have plenty of experience testifying from previous cases and would not present the same risk as a normal defendant testifying.
If Chauvin is able to give a reasonable, plausable (not saying what he did was reasonable) explanation of his actions beat by beat that matches up with the evidence that Nelson sets up over the week, it will be hard for prosecution to chase at least one of the charges.
He's not a typical defendant, he knows how court works and i think the jury needs to hear him explain why he did what he did.
The defense has no choice but to take this gamble. Prove me wrong.
Even if we were majority Christian (which we arent), our govt should reflect all NZers and never mandate religious holidays.
This sub has some aggressive group think and I think that it would be beneficial for us all to get some self-referential memes out in order to vent some of this stress.
It seems like any simple meme that challenges the way this sub thinks gets deleted due to rule 12. I for one would love to roast this sub, and i suspect there are a lot of lurkers who would enjoy seeing some counterpoints to the groupthink. I see it in the comments all the time. I know for sure there are some stone-cold killers here who would post some fire memes
Is it time that we dim the lights and whisper "no homo" while we let off some steam?


