State v McDaniel

Raised by Nelson today:

State v. McDaniel, 777 N.W.2d 739 (MN Supreme Court 2010)

Prosecutors must avoid inflaming the jury’s passions and prejudices against defendants. Although a prosecutor can argue that a particular defense has no merit, a prosecutor may not belittle the defense , either in the abstract or by suggesting that the defense was raised because it was the only defense that might succeed.

Blackwell called the defences arguments stories, fabricated facts, halloween stories, suggested defence was saying Floyd could wake and lay waste to the city etc etc

In your opinion did Nelson have a point when he raised his concerns or was Blackwell acting appropriately?

Posted Apr 20, 2021, 4:13 AM UTC · edited

1737
Loading comments…