Decided to pick up GoT for the 4th time and im trying to make sense of something that truly is unimportant
So, this is genuinely unimportant and I'm not sure there's an answer I'll find satisfactory, since the only one I can think of is ehhh.
In the catspaw chapter, after Summer rearranges his vocal cords, Cat just sits there laughing. Understandable. But when she's found, Robb, Luwin, Hallis and half the damn Winterfell guards show up. Why?
After the fire, Robb heads back to the room and hears the hysterical laughing and then runs off to round everyone up/hears her through the window? That's the only thing I can think of, but I don't know why he wouldn't just finish coming up the stairs and see what's going on himself. Nobody knew about the danger that had been dealt with already. But props to them for the flex, I guess.
Yea, that's it, really. What signaled them to know something was wrong, because manic laughter doesn't hit me as, there's immediate danger let's GO people.
Posted May 16, 2021, 4:23 AM UTC
I think GRRM is capable of making some errors or having the “little things” not line up especially in the first book where he’s not facing the massive enormous reveal details threading together, but I’ll also assume it’s a tie in to the beginning of Winterfell essentially being left with no guards. Ned has taken all the good guards with him and Winterfell has a pretty small garrison remaining- I don’t think 100/200 men burst in, but rather 15/30 or even 7/15 based on the fact that Winterfell is never described as having a massive guard in the first place.
It looks like we’re more curious about WHY these guards showed up though and so I looked at where they were and what changed when Robb and the guards leave the room vs return:
Jon and Tyrion both reference that Bran is located in his sickroom, where Catelyn has had a bed brought and which is outside her quarters in the Great Keep. We can presume that the sickroom is closest to the person who can care for him the best- Maester Lewyn.
As far as the sickroom itself, the chapter tells us that with the door open, loud sounds travel, as they do when the shutters are open. But Catelyn closes the shutters, suggesting the alarm was possibly raised from within.
No mention of his traveling outside to do so.
My guess is to his quarters just up or downstairs in this tall tower.
So basically the room isn’t super insulated to sounds. And therefore everyone in the tower is alerted that something is up.
And tons of sound can pass in and out of the room to the outdoors.
A library full of books is burning so we can assume this is a pretty serious fire that will take some time to put out.
Robb left worrying about his mother’s sanity and maybe the closing of the shutter is something he immediately noticed once he was distracted from the fire.
We know he didn’t close the door behind him, because that’s how Summer got in, and we know sound travels at least to the staircase.
There’s no mention of how much time has passed before:
My guess is that Maester Luwin was located somewhere close by in his own chambers and was paying attention to the fire, possibly looking out a window. Reading through it this carefully, I’m kind of creeped out at how silently the whole episode unfolds- the catspaw is clearly trying to be silent and get away quickly, but he doesn’t even really threaten Catelyn until she tries to scream for help. Instead he actually tried to tell her it’s for Bran’s own good because he’s not even interested in her, who wasn’t s’posed to be there. I doubt he wants to kill a crippled lordling AND the lady of the House. But some piercing hectic sounds do happen and it seems likely that Luwin heard them and called for help- a man his age couldn’t do much alone but he could raise the alarm and he’s one of the first responders which indicates he was standing by waiting for help? Possibly Robb was keeping an eye on his mom and Luwin was able to quickly raise the alarm with her first scream?
Anyway that’s my head canon now because the sheer silence of the entire scene is extra creepy and it makes sense that Luwin would desperately signal for help and Robb would leave some men to fight the fire and the rest to rush back to the new emergency.
Also I guess it’s possible that there was evidence of arson in the library, or that Septon Chayle was injured or suspicious. The actual only word we have that the catspaw set the fire is Catelyn saying so after having slept for four days... no one disputes her but it’s possible they were suspicious earlier on. It does make sense that the catspaw didn’t see Catelyn leave because he was busy sneaking back from the library.
I adore you for getting so entirely thorough and deep, detailed and invested in what was just me being half asleep at work scratching my head at this chapter. Here, have your gold and eat it, too!
Haha, that’s what I do 😆 I hope it gives your curious mind something to latch on to. And thanks for the the gold!! 🤩 mmmm gold 🤩
I've been up for almost 21 hours and the sleep before that was 36. I'm just picking apart everything in these early chapters. Like brans dream before we wakes up. It's part literal, part symbolic. I was thinking the dragons by asshai could be actual dragons that people just aren't around, or danys eggs(if they really came from there, thats what were told right?) to hatch in the future. I hope the eggs are the 3 stolen from Dragonstone, and I think it would be cool if there's wild dragons off living free that people just don't live near or travel to. If that is the case, it isn't important and has no value to the events taking place. I just think it would be neat
I love getting into those modes because you see how very very carefully GRRM crafted these books, how “real” the world is. And you do start to catch things that really make you scratch your head or even leap onto Reddit to make a post! This is one of my catches I’m most “proud” of hahaha