Constant upload packet loss, even after techs visited on site

Closed

Hello,

For the past several days I've been suffering from constant packet loss. The intensity of the packet loss is variable but the presence is constant. Upon reaching out to support, the first agent I spoke with reset my modem and detected decreasing packet loss on my modem and so we concluded. Unfortunately my problem persisted into the next day so I reached out to support again. The second agent ran through similar troubleshooting steps and after the problem persisted and scheduled a tech visit. The techs came out and decreased my downstream power levels. I tested for packet loss before they left with packetlosstest.com in the interest of time (which may have been a mistake and I more than likely should have committed to a trace route). The online test showed no packet loss, but soon after the techs left the packet loss returned.

First I want to say that although the problem has not been resolved, all of the comcast support agents (including the techs) were extremely sincere and did a wonderful job. I'm very frustrated with this problem but the quality of customer support has been extremely high. To be honest, I haven't considered switching ISP's predominately because of how wonderful customer support has been.

My configuration: during the day I'm the only person at my apartment. I strictly use cat 6 ethernet cables for all connections; no wifi is used. My modem is an XB7 (the CGM4331COM model). I have the modem in bridge mode connected to an Edge Router X solely for the edge router's QoS features (to reduce buffer bloat). I've had this same setup for months and the packet loss has only recently started to be a problem. Further, if I configure the edge router as a switch or disable bridge mode on the modem and connect it directly to my PC, the packet loss persists. This leads me to believe that my configuration of the edge router is not the source of the problem.

I test for packet loss using WinMTR. I've taken a screen shot of my signal levels as detected by the XB7: https://i.imgur.com/rIuwHiw.png

A high correctable codewords count is usual, and occasionally I also see uncorrectable codewords. For upstream power levels, typically the indices 1 and 2 are both above 49 dBmV, but do not exceed 50 dBmV. Is this acceptable? I've read that upstream power levels should be fine so long as they do not exceed 55 dBmV, but I have also read that comcast's modems occasionally under-report upstream power levels (though this is hearsay and I don't have much confidence in it).

Ultimately I'd like to resolve the issue but a starting point that I'd be over the moon with is if we can pin down the source of the problem as something internal to my network or something out of my control. I hesitate to start tinkering with things on my end for fear of breaking something, and I hesitate to schedule another tech visit and wind up with a charge after they see nothing wrong.

Thanks

Posted Jun 19, 2021, 8:19 PM UTC · edited · locked

52
AutoModeratorMOD•

We have made changes to keep employees safe so response and call times may be longer than usual. For immediate assistance, check out the Xfinity Assistant. You can also use Xfinity MyAccount (Web|iOS|Android) and xFi app (iOS|Android) for product and account support.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
CCAnnaH:xfinity: Community Specialist•

Hi u/NihilHS, thanks for reaching out through Reddit. I am sorry to hear about your ongoing internet troubles and packet loss. It certainly sounds like we have dropped the ball. I do have to say, I am glad you have not had any negative customer support. I do want to make sure we get this fixed up for you ASAP. You have reached the right team. I will need to gather some personal information to help. Please send us a modmail with your full name, account holders name (if different), and service address as it appears on the bill. We look forward to hearing from you!

1