What is the point of medium range SAMs?

Question

First of all; sorry if this comes off as a stupid question. I guess the obvious answer is to shoot down medium altitude aircraft, but this raises to me even more questions than it answers.

Is mid altitude flight even worth it?

My understanding is that low and high alltitude flight correspond to different tactics of aerial warfare. High level flight seeks to make aircraft hard to shoot down by outranging all but the biggest and most expensive missiles and if in combination with stealth possibly also outranging surface radars as well. Low level flight on the other hand seeks to shield aircraft from being shot down by hiding under the radar horizon, often helped by following the countours of hilly/mountainous terrain.

In this regard, wouldn't mid level flight put you both within reach of long range SAMs while also within line of sight of short range SAMs?

For a doctrinal standpoint, this means short and long range SAMs must be used differently. The long ranged SAM systems can focus entirely on the air battle, coordinating only with themselves as an integrated network, and with the air force (which it is often part of). The short range SAM units however has to be close to wherever local air defense is needed, often tagging along with ground units as they move. This means they must coordinate with ground forces and also be (more) prepared to face penetrating eneymy ground forces, and paratroopers etc.

Where does medium SAMs fit into this?

From a technical standpoint couldn't medium range missiles be put on both the smaller APC sized and larger vehicles already in use with short range air defense/anti air artillery, as well as be included as smaller/cheaper missiles in whatever truck-borne long range sam batteries you already have?

The US plans to equip stinger missiles on Stryker vehicles as its future SHORAD system. Surely though a Stryker could haul a small radar, and missiles weighing more than 10-20 kg? Even more so some armies use autocannon systems such as Oerlikon GDF weighing several tons as short range air defense. I wouldn't think bringing along a few extra vehicle chassis carrying radars and missile launchers instead of guns would alter tactical mobility or logistical footprint too much.

I know that medium altitude is considered a sweet spot for recon drones and CAS aircraft in COIN type conflicts. My understanding is that this is done to put them just outside the range of gunfire and MANPADS of a poorly equipped enemy. But it seems like it should be pretty easy to deal with for a well equipped mechanized force.

Bringing cheap attritable drones into the discussion opens another can of worms. "What if the missile is more expensive than the drone it shoots down?". I don't intend this to be a discussion about the ultimate answer to Nagorno Karabakh type loitering munition drone warfare, or whether that's a thing. I'm sure people can point to fancy tech such as lasers and fuzed/guided AAA all day long. In the realm of missiles however I dont see why mid level flight would make drones inherently more effective than either higher or lower level. What advantages are there?

If you can answer any of the questions posed I'd be very happy. If you instead can point to mistakes in my reasoning or my premises and provide correct knowledge instead, I'd be even happier.

Also this is my first question here. I aprecaite it alot if you take time to answer, but feel free as well to also give tips/critique on the way I formulated the question, formatting etc? EDIT: Spelling error.

Posted Jul 7, 2021, 3:25 PM UTC · edited

6734
pnzsaurkrautwerfer•

The point of HIMAD is something that can reasonably engage high performance targets at standoff range, but do so from a battery or platform that's a lot more agile than a theater or other long range scaled system.

Like a sniper rifle is cool but its the wrong answer for a lot of engagement ranges. The HIMAD option is sort of the assault rifle option, more burden but more capable than the pistol of SHORAD but less capable but less burden than long range systems.

58
LightlikebeforeOP•

If I understand you correctly, your point is that it makes sense to distinguish between hi-and-medium range SAM systems primarily used to defend against enemy combat jets, as they are still light enough to be reasonably mobile, versus even longer range SAMs used to shoot down jets even further away but also to shoot down sattelites, and ICBMs mid flight, as they aren't really mobile enough to be used with the same flexibility as the former.

Would it be correct then to say that you can mix high and medium range SAMs with eachother to let them operate as part of the same AD network (or even the same battery). Assuming the high range SAM is mobile enough to be put on a somewhatbrefular truck chassis or trailer?

7
pnzsaurkrautwerfer•

HIMAD and the Theater level SAMs tend to be linked through Integrated Air Defense Systems networks, so shared sensors and targeting.

In theory it's basically a layered defense, with SHORAD providing very point defense on the front line, HIMAD reaching out farther and higher, but still within sounds of the guns, and then the theater system covering high altitude long range threats.

The issue with the "big" systems is the radars, launchers, and management systems are all big, so a battery might be dozens of vehicles, often with a 20-30 minute setup time. A HIMAD is less agile than a SHORAD, but it tends to be within the range of much fewer parts, and faster standup/tear down.

Air Defense is changing a lot with the proliferation of unmanned systems, as the traditional paradigm is no longer as valid (or if I smoked 2/4 SU-25s, that element is aborting and leaving. If I kill 4/4 UASes, but they get warheads on targets, that might still be a lose for the air defender). With that said, the "middle" option is still quite valid for covering things that a small missile can't reach, or a big missile is much too much for.

26
LightlikebeforeOP•

In theory it's basically a layered defense, with SHORAD providing very point defense on the front line, HIMAD reaching out farther and higher, but still within sounds of the guns, and then the theater system covering high altitude long range threats.

Hmm, I might be confused by the name HIMAD, as it implies that it's supposed to be also be up to high range, whereas it in relation to the other two is mid-tier. What ranges do you consider HIMAD to include. Are we talking patriot batteries, S300, S400? Would you consider HIMAD to be US Army's version of medium range SAMs, if such labels make sense.

The issue with the "big" systems is the radars, launchers, and management systems are all big, so a battery might be dozens of vehicles, often with a 20-30 minute setup time.

I see, thank you.

Air Defense is changing a lot with the proliferation of unmanned systems, as the traditional paradigm is no longer as valid

Yeah, so I guess we will see new types of air defense tech and organizations in coming years possibly complicating the picture.

With that said, the "middle" option is still quite valid for covering things that a small missile can't reach, or a big missile is much too much for.

I suppose the heart of my question really lies in where the distinction between short and mid, and mid and high should be made. Weapons are fielded to do specific missions or deal with specific threats; eg. stingers need to be light enough to be carried by a man, S-300 needs to be big enough to deal with fighter jets at the maximum practical operating altitude of a turbofan engine etc. For the US' case I guess what I'm looking for is kinda the altitude range the patriot were designed to intercept within, and the technical or doctrinal reason it say wasn't designed to be higher/lower.

Is it then that the patriot in its current form is considered large enough to deal with jet aircraft as well as short and medium balistic missile, yet has a more manageable setup and shutdown time compared to the THAAD, letting it more easily operate under threat of an enemy DEAD campaign?

3
AmericanNewt8•

The canonical example would be the S-300 HIMAD, Buk mid-level, and Tor SHORADs. The US doesn't field anything aside from HIMAD [Patriot] and SHORAD [Stinger].

16
[deleted]•

Is it then that the patriot in its current form is considered large enough to deal with jet aircraft as well as short and medium balistic missile, yet has a more manageable setup and shutdown time compared to the THAAD, letting it more easily operate under threat of an enemy DEAD campaign?

THAAD is a dedicated ABM with no capability against air-breathing targets at all. It's a compliment to Patriot, not in any way a replacement.

10
polarisdelta•

Regarding the specific question about the US choice to use the Stinger, the Stinger and Stryker exist and are paid for. A new missile or a new gun would be a procurement cycle which there might not be money in the purse for at the moment. So it's not necessarily that the US Army doesn't see the need for a weapon in between Patriot battery and a Stinger pod but it's more apt to say that they see other, more urgent needs for those same resources.

30
LightlikebeforeOP•

Yes, that makes sense to me. Im assuming a part of its reasoning is also the perception that enemy mid alltitude air strikes is a problem that can be solved by other means eg. its own fighter jets.

If you don't mind me asking, is it reasonable to think that if the US faced an urgent threat, such as hypothetical drone swarms, requiring a medium range SAM, and such a missile was developed (or bought) that it could be fielded with and used similarly to the SHORAD systems now in development?

EDIT: specification

6
The3rdBert•

It largely comes down to preceived needs. Its not really there, joint air will fill that need quite well. Ballastic missles and drones defense are going to get the majority of fire procurement dollars, if the US feels the need to get something, they will quickly purchase rights to an off the shelf product and build it. Something like NASAMS, which is in use around DC, would be brought on line. There also has been lots of work showing HIMARs can be the shooter for SAMs using queuing from a networked Radar.

12
LightlikebeforeOP•

So I guess the US due to its large air force, really doesn't have all the textbook air defense system in question.

HIMARs can be the shooter for SAMs using queuing from a networked Radar.

I've never heard about that. That's pretty neat!

6
The3rdBert•

Pretty much, a fighter will be better than a ground launched SAM almost everytime if you have the numbers to ensure coverage, that is incredibly expensive to do. Most countries, buy a bit a both, becuase they dont have the numbers to do a continuous CAP.

If you think the HIMARs is cool, wait to you read about the Army testing using Paladins to shoot down cruise missiles. Decentralized networked warfare is crazy.

10
Grim1316•

The Chieftain did one of his QA's fairly recently where I actually asked him about this and it comes down to for the US army, why spend the money when you can have the USAF do it for you.

3
tobiov•

Others have answered it in more detail but I think the summary is that it's probably better to think of medium Sams as medium range not medium altitude.

They are larger and have more effective range and are more reliable than short range Sams but are more mobile, cheaper and less of a target than the big theatre Sam systems.

6
LightlikebeforeOP•

Right, thats an important distinction.

1
Taira_Mai•

(Former US Army 14E PATRIOT vet here)

The US Navy wants to - in the word of the classic 80's telephone commercial - reach out

and touch someone (in this case airplanes) far enough away that the can't shoot anti-ship missiles. Most have long rangers to the AEGIS system is designed so that it can hit aircraft far enough away to keep the ship and it's battle group safe.

The Army (formerly the Marines) had HAWK and the Army has PATRIOT.

HAWK was for the hordes of Soviet Air Force "Migs" that would have come screaming across the Iron Curtain if WWIII had happened. When the wall came down, the decision was to withdraw HAWK from the Army and the Marines.

PATRIOT inherited the point defense of the old NIKE system and is in theory mobile.

In practice it's function of anti-aircraft is secondary to it's anti-missile mission.

The Air Force or Navy would be running the show when it comes to the air battle unless the enemy starts lobbing missiles.

As many others have posted here - the Army sees SHORAD (short range air defense) and HIMAD (hi to medium AD) as more important.

Keeping runways, bases and ports clear and open is more of a priority for the Army than a medium SAM. As the US military is networked, a brigade or battalion that found itself under air attack could call upon Air Force or Navy combat air patrols to deal with what their organic air defense couldn't handle.

PATRIOT (and THAAD) would be tasked with keeping Tactical Ballistic Missiles (TBM's), cruise missiles, drones and any aircraft away from runways, bases and ports. Any "raids" of enemy aircraft, TBM's drones or cruise missiles get reported to higher headquarters. They then sick Air Force or Navy missions to make sure there isn't a repeat.

1
LightlikebeforeOP•

Right, so what I'm taking away from US Army doctrine is that they don't see dedicated or seperate medium range SAM systems to be that useful, seeing as patriot systems can do their job in a pinch. At least not important enough to be included in the current budget.

I get that the Army also worries more about missiles than jets but that seems kinda like a fortunate luxury. I wonder if some of export customers of patriot systems do expect it to contribute more to the air battle overall.

2
Taira_Mai•

The Germans do - around 2006 I was with a unit that trained with the Luftwaffe. Our senior NCO and LT said that the German air battles still focused on hordes of Russian aircraft.

1