Lightlikebefore

u/Lightlikebefore


r/WarCollege•

I am curious whether articulated trucks are feasible for use as logistics vehicles. Compared to rigid trucks they have obvious drawbacks, such as increased cost, weight and maintenance requirements. At the same time, they also offer substantially better off-road mobility.

Hence, while very unlikely to completely replace rigids, they could perhaps find a niche in 'the last leg of the journey', offering forward logistics to especially remote or hard-to-get-to units. Potentially, that means artillery batteries or armored formations get to operate longer away from major roads, and an overall increased ability to sustain operations in extremely austere enviroments, etc.

Has any military eve

237

The Italians are seemingly very succesfull in turning the Otomelara 76mm into a CIWS system, but what about the 127mm?

Its large caliber gives it a decent range of

-30km for conventional shells,

-70km for unguided Volcano shells (I'm assuming enabled by aerodynamic lift/gliding), and

-100km + for the guided version.

While these numbers are for indirect fire, I'm guessing it could still deliver effective direct fire in ranges up to about 10km depending on altitude, outperforming even some missile based systems. Low accuracy at such ranges is likely a problem but could be partially offset by fuzed exploding ammo.

Thoughts, anyone?

Bonus question; the IR seaking Volcano shell is primaril

83

r/WarCollege•

First of all, let me preface that different militaries do it differently so I fully understand the premises can be challenged. Still it is my understanding that most western brigade-centered armies often have one batallion sized recon unit at the brigade level (in the US known as cavalry troop).

How do they differ from the manoeuvre batallions? Whether wheeled or tracked, the recon units often have both vehicle and dismounted elements. If the brigade is a heavy type with tanks, the recon unit often have tanks of their own, and just like the maneuvre battalions, the recon unit sometimes also have their own support elements with mortars, ATGMs etc.

It seems the recon unit perform a very wide

2110

Multinational acquisition programs have a pretty bad reputation. They are typically associated with bureaucratic bloat, design and production choices made on political and diplomatic grounds, leading to delays, cost overruns, and design compromises.

The best example of the above is arguably the Eurofighter program, where France did much better by dropping out and just doing a whole plane by themselves.

Are there any examples the opposite happened? Programs that in the end resulted in a system that is likely (and demonstrably?) better than what one participant would have produced alone?

916

r/CredibleDefense•

Multinational acquisition programs have a pretty bad reputation. They are typically associated with bureaucratic bloat, design and production choices made on political and diplomatic grounds, leading to delays, cost overruns, and design compromises.

The best example of the above is arguably the Eurofighter program, where France did much better by dropping out and just doing a whole plane by themselves.

Are there any examples the opposite happened? Programs that in the end resulted in a system that is likely (and demonstrably?) better than what one participant would have produced alone?

7258

r/WarCollege•

Reading about aerospace design you can often read about how newer(ish) aircraft are designed intentionally to be unstable in order to improve maneuverability among other things. However the word stability can mean very different things in different disciplines. Even within an engineering setting, a physicist and a numerician might use the word very differently, thus its not clear to me excactly what is meant.

Please lets consider three different situations.

  1. A system where something is in rest and its exact position/configuration lets it continue to stay at rest. Ex. a ball lying still on top of a hill. Without anything to secure the ball where it to be slightly moved, this would typic
713

r/CredibleDefense•

I posted this first in r/WarCollege but am posting it here as well. First of all; sorry if this comes off as a stupid question. I guess the obvious answer is to shoot down medium altitude aircraft, but this raises to me even more questions than it answers.

Is mid altitude flight even worth it?

My understanding is that low and high alltitude flight correspond to different tactics of aerial warfare. High level flight seeks to make aircraft hard to shoot down by outranging all but the biggest and most expensive missiles and if in combination with stealth possibly also outranging surface radars as well. Low level flight on the other hand seeks to shield aircraft from being shot down by hiding

29

r/WarCollege•

First of all; sorry if this comes off as a stupid question. I guess the obvious answer is to shoot down medium altitude aircraft, but this raises to me even more questions than it answers.

Is mid altitude flight even worth it?

My understanding is that low and high alltitude flight correspond to different tactics of aerial warfare. High level flight seeks to make aircraft hard to shoot down by outranging all but the biggest and most expensive missiles and if in combination with stealth possibly also outranging surface radars as well. Low level flight on the other hand seeks to shield aircraft from being shot down by hiding under the radar horizon, often helped by following the countours of

6734

You've reached the end of this feed.