r/ainbow•
[deleted]

So I'm just wondering- is this a safe space for cissexism and transphobia?

I'm one of those 'over sensitive trannies' who's really fucking sick of all the crap us trans people get. Just wondering if I should bother subscribing to this community.

Posted Jan 16, 2012, 9:07 PM UTC

13105
Lykus42•

It depends. If you've already decided that this isn't the place and this is a backhanded, passive-aggressive way of accusing us of being transphobes and/or cissexists, then nice try.

If, however, you're wondering and being cautious (which is completely understandable) then no, this subreddit is not intended to be a safe harbor for discrimination. That said, the goal of this community is to allow the subscribers to self-moderate to prevent moderation abuse. I completely get why r/lgbt is doing what it's doing, but I personally feel that it is more destructive than constructive.

Tagging transphobes or homophobes or whatever else with bright red, un-delete-able flair with custom CSS is harmful because actual bigots won't care and will actually strengthen their position in the face of opposition, while people whose comments have been misinterpreted, either through ignorance on their part or poor timing with someone's need to vent, will feel unwelcome and alienated when their intentions may have been to foster deeper understanding and become an ally or to be a closer ally.

The unfortunate truth is that a lot of people won't understand exactly what it is like to be LGBT because they are not LGBT. As someone who only falls under the "G," I have no idea what it is like to be LBT or the many varieties of intersex, genderqueer, etc. As a consequence, attempts to learn more may cause me to accidentally ask questions that are offensive, because I have no way of knowing that they are offensive. It is completely unfair to expect me to know a group well enough to prevent misunderstanding when I have had limited interaction with that group, and what interactions I have had are limited to being yelled at for reasons I don't understand and haven't had the chance to ask about because I don't like being yelled at.

I get it. LGBT people of all kinds have been shafted by society. We have every right to be angry and in many cases it is the best option to take. However, we are all diplomats for our communities and we need to rationally and sensibly judge what the best course of action is for the community, not what will make use feel emotionally better in the moment. When Rick Perry made that atrocious "Strong" ad, anger was the right choice. When someone genuinely wants to understand something about gay men and mistakenly assumes that "gay men want to be women," a gentler touch is probably preferred.

78
simonask•

I wish I could upvote you a thousand times.

9
BigPeteB•

this subreddit is not intended to be a safe harbor for discrimination

Can you clarify what you mean by that? I feel like there's a subtly in the wording that I'm not sure I get.

5
wickershins•

A lot of the times when people are extremely touchy, something that can be a mere misinterpretation of a piece of information can actually seem like discrimination or otherwise harmful, offensive language. I'm not Lykus42, nor am I another mod, but I know that the problem with the LGBT subreddit was that they would rather plant the red text on people as opposed to listening and educating.

There shouldn't be tolerance towards violent language against our community just as much as it shouldn't exist towards people who might not be up-to-date on some issues.

edited because i can't spell

25
InequilibriumA whole mess of queerness•

A lot of the times when people are extremely touchy, something that can be a mere misinterpretation of a piece of information can actually seem like discrimination or otherwise harmful, offensive language.

And this is why I left r/lgbt, summed up in one sentence.

Mind you, it's not JUST trans people, everyone there is guilty of it at times. I had one pretty bad incident with a gay guy who seemed to just want to use me as a scapegoat for his anger. People are way too on edge and intent on victimising themselves.

16
Waldo_Jeffers•

I wish I could stamp your comment on the foreheads of about 20% of the membership of LGBT as a forewarning to others. sigh :)

5
[deleted]•

Using red flair! No, I kid. Don't do that.

12
chibikiba•

It is in reference to the idea of free speech and this subreddit's reliance on the voting systems instead of censorship.

If anyone has come here with the idea that all opposing views will be rapidly removed by mods then they should probably search elsewhere.

14
notacrook•

Beautifully said.

2
synspark:D•

Just wondering if I should bother subscribing to this community.

that depends. are you open to honest and frank discussion about issues without shutting people down or immediately labeling them as transphobic when they may not understand or agree with what you're saying? if you are, then by all means, stay.
if you're comforted by using the "wall of transphobia" to cut off people trying to ask questions or have proper discussion, then you may not make a lot of friends here.

37
Waldo_Jeffers•

Hear, hear. I don't like watching people derail conversations because their sensibilities got offended. We're dealing with LGBT here, a complicated issues that really depends on nuanced speech and people actually listening to each other's experience, even if they're telling us something we don't necessarily like to hear. (Heh. I did an oral history project for a gay men's health clinic once. Telling the truth about what I overheard there would get me pilloried SO FAST on r/lgbt it's not funny. :) )

And while I'm being honest, GREAT BIG RED WARNING KLAXONS go off at an introductory post like the OP's, walking in and basically announcing an expectation that she'll be offended and need to stamp off in a huff someday. Because I have known so damn many people in various freak communities* who really do seem to turn every damn trivial matter of identity into grounds for offense, even from members of their own tribe who aren't quite as dogmatically pure as them.

Everyone's welcome here, but... I do look forward to some presences less than others. It has nothing to do with sexual orientation, and everything to do with the fact that having suffered transphobia does not justify reciprocal rudeness to random innocent people. I am already rather braced to be told that it does, somehow, because that's a mentality I keep seeing in the LGBT community -- and it shames and saddens me that we can't deal with dissent a little better than that.

MissJess has the same chance as everybody else to prove me wrong -- displaying a sense of humor and an ability to deal with a little provocation would go a long way to convince me. And I do look forward to seeing her in a better mood someday. Until then, meh, not gonna go out of my way to reassure her, because I can't guarantee I won't go flaming her someday. That's the cost of free speech, people lose their tempers and say nasty things sometimes, and I've always thought the important thing is how you behave AFTER the fight.

(* Litmus test for prudes: if you can't figure out that I'm using "freak community" in a loving, self-deprecating way because I belong to it, your tolerance for humor really is too low for the Internet and there's no hope for you.)

34
InequilibriumA whole mess of queerness•

Pretty much everything you've described is what r/lgbt feels like at the moment.

Heterosexism and cissexism are not acceptable, and I see the LGBT community as one not bound by them the way most of society seems to be. But when people start interpreting comments that do NOT have any harmful intent as transphobic, it becomes impossible to have a real conversation.

18
Waldo_Jeffers•

Yes, yes, yes. Thank you.

Listen, people, I'm not making some kind of trojan horse argument to let homophobia run rampant here. I'm drawing on my own experience in a whole bunch of different "alt" communities ranging from BDSM munches to underground newspapers to what's going on right now with Occupy Seattle's militant wing.

If a society lasts long enough in isolation or under pressure, it'll start to develop orthodoxies. And orthodoxies mean oppression, because there's always someone who feels threatened when that orthodoxy is threatened. And communities like ours, that have been the underdogs for centuries, tend to walk around this with naive belief that because we have generally been the victims in the past, we will generally be the victims in the future -- and thus we're not capable of being the oppressor by definition.

Which is bullshit.

And I have seen that attitude wreck so many damn communities, as people start getting silenced, slandered, exiled, and dehumanized... in the name of an ideology which set out to combat those things and make life suck a little less. And it's usually the people on the next fence, the people who threaten the next duality, who get the worst shit out of the deal. (Look at all the radiant love certain parts of the feminist community have shown to TG people. :p ) And those victims never seem to fucking learn how to break the cycle-- when it becomes their turn to enforce dogma and dole out punishments, they do it just as eagerly and self-righteously as the last bunch.

Here's how it always goes. Take it as prophecy if you like:

Step zero, some prejudiced assholes wander into a community, doing genuine harm.

Step one, people there get into the habit of looking for harmful things. This inevitably leads to them finding some.

Step two, this becomes routine. The community starts attacking things that merely resemble the thing that harmed them. (e.g., well-meaning people asking obtuse questions, or damn near any other member of the out group).

Step three, taboos about the harmful thing are put into place, and breaking the taboo becomes redefined as willful harm. A group consensus is reached, and even just entering the community not knowing this consensus is grounds for punishment, ridicule, and exclusion.

Step four, questioning the taboo becomes grounds for punishment too.

Step five, congratulations, you've created an oppressive community out of a liberating one. Now go out there, do some purges, defend your newfound ideological purity, and enjoy your paranoia!

Sound familiar at all? IMHO, it explains everything from Stalinism to people who get really pissy if you like the wrong kind of music. :)

105
InequilibriumA whole mess of queerness•

That summary is perfect. And also helps me to understand r/SRS as what happens when you cram all of those oppressed communities into a single concentrated pocket of anger.

I've gotten quite a bit of hate from people in a couple of communities (including one of the ones you mentioned), despite never saying anything to anyone that had the intention of being personal, or negative, or attacking anyone in any way. Yet I get met with hatred and attacks anyway. People let their paranoia drive them into taking everything as a personal affront.

Edit: The part that stands out the most to me is "attacking things that merely resemble the thing that harmed them", because combining that with the fact that questioning any taboo is forbidden ends up hurting a lot of innocent people. And stifling all intellectual discussion. I love discussing and debating topics of gender and sexuality. It pisses me off that I can't do so on r/lgbt.

28
[deleted]•

This is an excellent explanation, I'm submitting it to r/bestof.

9
Murrabbit•

Step three, taboos about the harmful thing are put into place, and breaking the taboo becomes redefined as willful harm. A group consensus is reached, and even just entering the community not knowing this consensus is grounds for punishment, ridicule, and exclusion.

Haha oh goodness yes. Try heading into one of the femenist subreddits and asking what the big [TRIGGER WARNING] tags in every title are all about, and watch the downvotes come and very angry comments flow in.

3
HoverHell•

Are there cases where it doesn't happen / gets averted? (or, better yet, hypotheses on difference / why didn't)

1
callouskittygirly boy•

OMG, have you read The True Believer?

1
[deleted]•

Well, seeing as this ain't r/lgbt, tell us what you overheard!

5
Waldo_Jeffers•

snicker Good point. :) Seriously, I'm bound by confidentiality, but I can say that... erg... I saw a lot of stereotypes "confirmed" (scare-quotes intentional) at that place -- drug abuse and terrifyingly unsafe sex practices, mostly. LOTS of meth exchange, lots of older men talking perfectly calmly about shockingly exploitative and emotionless relationships with younger (but legal) men, people letting some fairly unpleasant things happen to their, um, digestive tracts... (Are you sure there's no speech code here? Because I'm pretty sure I'm gonna have to start using words like "prolapse" and "reddish-pink" if I go on any further. :p )

To be honest, it was exactly the sort of stuff that the 700 Club trots out when they want to make us all look like horrible debauched people. And here it was, documented first-hand in one interview file after another, every godawful stereotype you really only expect to see in a Jack Chick tract. And I mean... what the fuck do you even do when you encounter that sort of stuff? How do you process it? Do you get angry at the people who do it, even though they're probably just the victims of trauma and alienation themselves? Do you get angry at the people who bring it to light, and hope to just bury it? Do you ignore it and say it's none of your business?

Well, in my case, I decided all this risky behavior was the consequence of hundreds of years of being crammed into the closet. You really can't devote a lot of time to creating healthy ways of doing things, if you're constantly being oppressed for doing them at all. And the more free we've gotten to be ourselves in this culture, the healthier our sexuality's been. But it's still a little disturbing to see all this yucky stuff persist in our past and present, even though I know we're no more degenerate on average than any other batch of humans. :)

10
[deleted]•

LOTS of meth exchange, lots of older men talking perfectly calmly about shockingly exploitative and emotionless relationships with younger (but legal) men, people letting some fairly unpleasant things happen to their, um, digestive tracts... (Are you sure there's no speech code here? Because I'm pretty sure I'm gonna have to start using words like "prolapse" and "reddish-pink" if I go on any further. :p )

Heh, what does it say about me that that just sounds like your average Saturday night in Collingwood? :P

I take the admittedly unpopular attitude that people should take whatever level of risk they're comfortable with, so long as they're aware of the possible consequences. If that means they're a cumdump for 25 men in a sauna, I'm cool with that even though I'd never do it myself.

Being into a lot of the stuff you're probably referring to Chick Tract stuff, (but not meth, ew) I'd encourage people to take an attitude of "Is everyone involved a consenting adult? Carry on!".

2
AspelMtFtM•

As a freak, I take offense to being lumped in with those freaks.

0
scoooot•

The flip side of this, is shutting people down for talking about transphobia by immediately claiming to have been labeled a transphobe when not.

2
ebcubeClinically cynical•

If by safe space you mean a space where you can't get offended at everyone else's privileges, as it seems by the tone of your post, then, sure! You can go now.

As if you should bother subscribing to this community, well, I don't know. If you feel comfortable with the current climate of r/lgbt, I don't think you'll gain anything by subscribing here as well. If you're looking for a place that feels more like a community and less like a war, try subscribing.

I, for one, will use my precious, precious downvotes against anyone who tries to spread transphobia (I'm not actually sure what cissexism is supposed to mean, though I assume it's the trans* related version of heterosexism: in that case, I'm against that as well) in this subreddit (or anywhere else, really.

But, seriously, if you're looking for a reason to get offended, I don't care if you're straight, gay, trans, or a little kitten covered in glitter: leave. That is not what r/gaymers is about, and even less what I hope this subreddit is about.

TL;DR: If you plan on screaming "OMG SO TRANSPHOBIC" as if being trans meant you are a holy cow, this place is not for you. On the other hand, if you like reasonable discussion on LGBT issues, by all means join us!

TL;DR2: Just subscribe to try. If you feel offended, you can always unsubscribe.

25
clearlyordarkly•

I'm a little kitten covered in glitter and i take offence to this comment.

7
ebcubeClinically cynical•

OMG SO KITTENPHOBIC

I kid, i kid. Kittens are welcome too. But be careful, I'm allergic to adorableness.

8
joeycastillo30,male,gay');DROP TABLE flair;•

I've already responded to your question here but I feel as though I can add one more thing:

There's something of a dichotomy between a "safe" space and a "free" space. We certainly want to strive for both; but in this community, creating a space for free discussion is the primary goal. That is to say, if someone posts something homophobic that threatens the safety of the space, we're going to err on the side of leaving it up and allowing the community to downvote it below threshold, rather than remove it ourselves. The effect is the same — most readers don't need to see it — but the means of getting there are more in line with the goal of open discussion.

I do not think that this policy creates a safe space for cissexism and transphobia; it relies on the community to police for these things, and so far in our fifteen-hour history I think it's done a pretty good job of it. And in cases where it doesn't, there are tools for dealing with the problem that don't involve banning, branding, berating and disrespect.

tl;dr: there may be crap, but it will be downvoted in short order if we have a highly supportive community, which I think we do.

18
zahlman...wat•

There's something of a dichotomy between a "safe" space and a "free" space.

I'm not entirely sure I agree. I've said for a long time that unprotected unrestricted speech is not the most free speech; you effectively can't speak freely if you fear being shouted down by the jerk next to you.

Maybe this notion makes more sense to me due to being Canadian.

Edit a whole month later when this was linked somewhere else: whoa, I totally typed the wrong word there!

5
BigPeteB•

There's something of a dichotomy between a "safe" space and a "free" space.

Pretty sure this is insightful and that I agree with it, but can you elaborate on this just for clarity to everyone?

4
[deleted]•

It's like the old adage, the most secure computer is one that's turned off and not connected to anything. The objective is to find a balance between protecting people from bigotry (the computer that's turned off) and allowing people to discuss things with no content filtration (the computer running an unpatched copy of Windows 2003 with no antivirus).

Sometimes people are just ignorant of the issues surrounding the T in LGBT, or really have no idea what it's like. (I'm only in the G camp, though I've been good friends with some Ts.) There's a rough line to hew between ignorance and malice, and with all the categorizations of trolling on the Internet, it's often impossible to tell the difference between concern and concern trolling. The perception (as I can gather) is that r/lgbt swung way too far to one side, and that this is an attempt to bring things back to a happier medium.

It's important to keep in mind, particularly for the Ls and Gs (and somewhat less so for the Bs) that the sort of socially-accepted and implicit discrimination against Ts that is embedded in the world largely doesn't exist anymore for L G and B, so it's easy to feel like you're on a high horse if you're L G or B, but the gulf between LGB-discrimination and T-discrimination is I think much larger than many of us give it credit.

So I suspect that's the real issue. The word "queer" has been reclaimed, and the word "faggot" is well on its way. The same is absolutely not true for e.g. "tranny," but if you're an allegedly thick-skinned user of a fully reclaimed word, I guess you can see how one might get confused.

12
TwistTurtleGetting a grip so you don't have to•

Well I'm not a mod, obviously, but I don't plan on tolerating any form of discrimination. So for as long as I'm welcome here, no, this isn't a safe space for that sort of hatred.

I think the general point of this subreddit is to be able to discuss anything involving sexuality without the ridiculous hivemind, 'Agree with everything we say or GTFO' mentality of r/lgbt

16
[deleted]•

Hate is hate my friend and I don't think being hurt by people's hatred makes you over sensitive. I won't be standing for any prejudice but constructive discussion is always fun :)

14
Murrabbit•

constructive discussion is always fun

Right on, and that's certainly the line that the /r/lgbt mods crossed. Branding someone who disagrees with you, or says something you take offense at with bold red text for everyone to see is not an act which fosters constructive dialogue. It's petty and abusive.

6
Waldo_Jeffers•

Yes, even the highly sarcastic, unnecessarily rude, and and presumptuously confrontational are welcome here, but please feel free not to subscribe anyhow.

I walked in late to this whole mess. I don't know who's been giving transpeople crap on LGBT, but it probably ain't me, so in the spirit of free and open discussion... I understand why you're angry, but could I ask you to check that hostility at the door please?

Unless this place has become a haven for virulent transphobia somehow, I'm really not sure why you're directing this at us, or why you think generating more hurt from the hurt you've already suffered is going to make anybody's life any easier.

Basic good manners and benefit of the doubt apply to those of us who have suffered from prejudice, just as they do to everybody else, especially when you're addressing a community of people that probably largely sympathizes with you in the first place. I... just don't get this post. I apologize if I misread it and you're genuinely asking for reassurance instead of being passive-aggressive.

13
lifeinneon•

A lot of the criticism that led to this sub's creation involved full throated defending of transphobic trolling.

I would expect a great deal of caution over motives.

0
ApplegateApplegate•

Hey random trans dude here, the waters fine (or at least I think it is, I don't mind the occasional chilly plunge). Yes there will be a couple people who straight up don't like us, and that isn't going to stop. There's more than enough awesome people who just want to post cool vids and news though. This is a clean slate, and people seem much more willing to work with each other than I have seen since I subscribed to LGBT, even before the big debacle (given I am also not that old on Reddit). That's my two cents.

11
Gehbstemmer•

I'm all about giving the benefit of the doubt, but the way you loaded this question makes me think that you almost want to dislike this new subreddit.

10
ducttapeearth•

What I'm wondering is is this a space space for homophobia? My gripe with r/lgbt was the subtle internalized homophobia that was always present. Will I see talk about "those kinds of gays"? Will I see gripes about queers who are out and proud about who they are? Will I see as much homophobia from bi people as I do biphobia from gay people? Or should I just learn to accept gays who are self loathing?

9
BigPeteB•

I certainly don't claim to speak for everyone, but...

  • What do you mean by "safe space"? Do you want to be safe from being harassed by cissexism and transphobia? Or do you want to be safe to complain about cissexism and transphobia? Or do you want to be safe to have civil, productive discussions about cissexism and transphobia?

  • What do you mean by "overly sensitive"? When I read that it sounds rather negative, so I'm not sure what you're saying by applying that label to yourself.

I, for one, did not bother to read through all the flames and trolls that led to the creation of this group; so I'd like it if you spelled out calmly and clearly what it is you would want from this group, and then someone can tell you whether you're likely to find it here.

8
boygw•

AFAICS the point of this subreddit is to be lightly moderated and self-governing, though up and downvotes rather than mod deletions and shameflair.

In other words, there may well be inadvertently cisnormative comments that won't be deleted -- though they well be downvoted at the judgement of the community, if we feel they don't contribute.

Whether you consider that an "unsafe space" is up to you.

7
[deleted]•

i kinda like the shame flair.

-21
Waldo_Jeffers•

Well, great, we'll make sure to shame you, then...?

Oh, wait, that's not what you meant, is it. You just want other people to be shamed? The "bad" people, whom you are confident will be correctly identified and punished according to criteria very similar to yours. It was not your understanding that it might be turned on you, if you yourself said something that was deemed offensive. (And you have already said things that have genuinely offended me.) All the times you were labeled "fragile tranny," that was bad and those awful people didn't know the real you. But labeling someone "homophobic shithead" is AWESOME, good and righteous and just plain fun, and never ever applied by mistake.

Perhaps you have come to think of yourself as cast in the victim role so often, you just assume you can never -- by definition -- be the aggressor. And I sympathize if you've been hurt, I really do, even if I have a bad first impression of you and think your behavior is worthy of criticism. But the way you approached us is... not okay, no matter how disadvantaged you think you are, especially in the presence of plenty of people who have suffered in similar ways. In the immortal words of Fluttershy: "How dare you."

I'm sorry, but you did ask: my advice still settles down to "yeah, if I'm getting a good read on your personality, maybe you'd better leave until you've got a little more serene approach to life, and don't revel in doing things to others that you wouldn't want done to yourself." Do come back, with my full blessings and welcome, when that happens.

18
Communard•

All the transphobic stuff I've seen in this (and indeed any other lgbt-based subreddit) has been quickly downvoted to hell anyway, I simply don't see the need for self-appointed mods when reddit has a perfectly functional democratic and community-based system for filtering out content. I'll certainly be downvoting any transphobia I see. I don't think that trusting the community makes this a "safe space" for transphobia.

5
Erzbet•

If you scroll through the comments on this post and see what has been upvoted and what has been downvoted, you'll get a pretty good idea of what will be acceptable here and what won't.

5
chibikiba•

I want you to subscribe.

I want this sub and all of its subscribers to respect free speech.

Most of all I want both sides of this ridiculous argument to come together and handle the issue the way respectable adults are intended to.

4
Olpainless•

The problem is that the other side keeps banning us from r/lgbt or red flairing us.

-4
simonask•

trannies

THAT'S OFFENSIVE YOU BIGOT!!!!!11

… I'm kidding, of course. I think what we're trying to eliminate here is the kneejerk namecalling of people who ask legitimate questions or who have legitimate opinions that they would like to discuss without being instantly red-flaired or called a 'troll'.

3
AspelMtFtM•

Some of the crap that us trans people get isn't really about trans people.

Try not to mistake ignorance or irony as actual hate, and I think you'll do fine.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
stopthefate•

I don't care if you're transgender at all, more power to ya, but no, you should not bother joining if you actually believe yourself to be "over sensitive" (REGARDLESS of gender identity) because this is NOT r/lgbt for a reason. We do NOT tolerate whining in this sub. Only discussion.

I'm not saying you are whining, (the tone of your post comes off a bit passive aggressive though tbh) you should just really think if you get offended easily because if so, this place might not be for you.

1
[deleted]•

Do we tolerate genuine complaints? What about calling out? If we see something horribly homophobic, do we just have to wait for people to downvote it, or can we speak up?

2
Loggie•

Oh you mean... all the crap you got in r/LGBT? Cute.

-6