So I'm just wondering- is this a safe space for cissexism and transphobia?
I'm one of those 'over sensitive trannies' who's really fucking sick of all the crap us trans people get. Just wondering if I should bother subscribing to this community.
Posted Jan 16, 2012, 9:07 PM UTC
It depends. If you've already decided that this isn't the place and this is a backhanded, passive-aggressive way of accusing us of being transphobes and/or cissexists, then nice try.
If, however, you're wondering and being cautious (which is completely understandable) then no, this subreddit is not intended to be a safe harbor for discrimination. That said, the goal of this community is to allow the subscribers to self-moderate to prevent moderation abuse. I completely get why r/lgbt is doing what it's doing, but I personally feel that it is more destructive than constructive.
Tagging transphobes or homophobes or whatever else with bright red, un-delete-able flair with custom CSS is harmful because actual bigots won't care and will actually strengthen their position in the face of opposition, while people whose comments have been misinterpreted, either through ignorance on their part or poor timing with someone's need to vent, will feel unwelcome and alienated when their intentions may have been to foster deeper understanding and become an ally or to be a closer ally.
The unfortunate truth is that a lot of people won't understand exactly what it is like to be LGBT because they are not LGBT. As someone who only falls under the "G," I have no idea what it is like to be LBT or the many varieties of intersex, genderqueer, etc. As a consequence, attempts to learn more may cause me to accidentally ask questions that are offensive, because I have no way of knowing that they are offensive. It is completely unfair to expect me to know a group well enough to prevent misunderstanding when I have had limited interaction with that group, and what interactions I have had are limited to being yelled at for reasons I don't understand and haven't had the chance to ask about because I don't like being yelled at.
I get it. LGBT people of all kinds have been shafted by society. We have every right to be angry and in many cases it is the best option to take. However, we are all diplomats for our communities and we need to rationally and sensibly judge what the best course of action is for the community, not what will make use feel emotionally better in the moment. When Rick Perry made that atrocious "Strong" ad, anger was the right choice. When someone genuinely wants to understand something about gay men and mistakenly assumes that "gay men want to be women," a gentler touch is probably preferred.
I wish I could upvote you a thousand times.
Can you clarify what you mean by that? I feel like there's a subtly in the wording that I'm not sure I get.
A lot of the times when people are extremely touchy, something that can be a mere misinterpretation of a piece of information can actually seem like discrimination or otherwise harmful, offensive language. I'm not Lykus42, nor am I another mod, but I know that the problem with the LGBT subreddit was that they would rather plant the red text on people as opposed to listening and educating.
There shouldn't be tolerance towards violent language against our community just as much as it shouldn't exist towards people who might not be up-to-date on some issues.
edited because i can't spell
And this is why I left r/lgbt, summed up in one sentence.
Mind you, it's not JUST trans people, everyone there is guilty of it at times. I had one pretty bad incident with a gay guy who seemed to just want to use me as a scapegoat for his anger. People are way too on edge and intent on victimising themselves.
I wish I could stamp your comment on the foreheads of about 20% of the membership of LGBT as a forewarning to others. sigh :)
Using red flair! No, I kid. Don't do that.
It is in reference to the idea of free speech and this subreddit's reliance on the voting systems instead of censorship.
If anyone has come here with the idea that all opposing views will be rapidly removed by mods then they should probably search elsewhere.
Beautifully said.