Help me get over 'The Song Of Achilles'

Review

You know when you read a book so good, that you almost never want to touch another one again in fear of tainting the whole book-reading experience? That's exactly how I feel after finishing TSOA - Madeline Miller has set the standard so high for me within romance, that I quite literally haven't read anything else since the past few days haha.

I cannot describe how beautifully put-together TSOA was. I'm someone who's always insisted that Patroclus and Achilles were soulmates within The Illiad - if not lovers of a sexual kind (despite all the technicalities with Greek wording etc) because why else would they ask to have their ashes mingled together if they were just best friends/brother-in-arms? So reading this sincere, and heartbreaking adaption of The Illiad just broke me in the best way possible. I'd expected it to be from Achilles' point of view, since he was the 'hero' and all, but it was rather through the gentle voice of Patroclus who portrayed Achilles in a way that made me feel as if I knew him personally. I felt as if I was there in Ancient Greece, with the pair - throughout the years as they aged, and then finally in >!the last few years spent at Troy. !<The way their friendship blossoms slowly into something more - from two shy children who are best friends to two weary men (cough, one man and one demi-god) having to face societal roles, I can't do it justice with a mere description. Actually, by the end of it, I felt as if I knew the both of them personally, so when >!Patroclus is killed and becomes a spirit, and sees Achilles sobbing over his dead body and mourning in a sense of grief that lasts until he dies himself!< - my tears were extreme lol. >!The last paragraph in the book had me crying for an entire ten minutes, !<which probably isn't surprising.

I've read just about every other re-adaption of The Illiad, mostly just historicals detailing the love between Paris and Helen - and Ransom, which was about Hector's father, so I already knew how it would end, but tell me why I was lowkey expecting a HEA where they >!return to Greece and spend their lives together!< :/ I've clearly read too many contemporary romances.

Anyways, that's enough of my ramble, though I could go on for days about the masterful literacy and expression within the book. Does anyone know of any other fantasies or similar genres in M/M? I've heard of the Captive Prince trilogy, but I think my heart needs to rest for a bit before I go about shattering it again with feels lool.

And to anyone who hasn't read the book yet, definitely give it a look-over - it was most likely the best book I've read this year, maybe even my favorite ever. I was someone who only read sports romances or contemporary within M/M just because I could relate to them more, but TSOH changed the game for me :) I'll be checking myself into a rehabilitation centre for book withdrawal soon lol

Posted Jul 14, 2021, 10:31 AM UTC · edited

2523
TheTinyGM•

Captive prince is a good series in similar vein, as you noted, though the first book has tons of trigger warnings, beware. However, unlike SOA, it does have >!happy ending, they both survive and stay together.!<

For something less heart-wrenching but with similar "feel", I recommend Something Human by A.J. Demas. It takes place in pseudo-Ancient Rome, main heroes meet on battlefield as enemies and save each other lives.

Another rec would be Lord of the White Hell by Ginn Hale. This one is not inspired by anything Greek, but it has strong two main characters we watch grow and fall in love with each other. Its amazing fantasy series.

Lastly, its not a book but a video game, but if you want the continuation and resolution of Patroclus and Achilles' story, I heartily recommend game Hades. You play as son of Hades, god of Underworld, and you meet both of their shades there and you can help them. >!And reunite them in afterlife!<

13
laibamustafa•

I was putting off captive prince for a long long time and a few days earlier i tried reading it but I couldn't get pass through even 3rd chap. Does it get any good and if it does, when??? I didn't feel any connection between main characters. I guess it was too early to make any judgements but I couldn't read it. I do want to read it and like it.

2
Myomamama•

The 1st book is "enemies", the 2nd book is "to" and the 3rd book is "lovers". They hated each other's guts so much any connection wouldn't be there in the beginning as it shouldn't be. The end game definitely paid off though. I love Captive Prince more than The Song Of Achilles TBH. The 2nd book's my favourite.

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ddissimulationOP"I am made of memories."•

Apparently it gets much better in the second book - which is why I haven't started the trilogy yet as I just don't have the patience rn to sit through the long chapters before it gets 'good' haha. When the author said it was slow burn, they definitely weren't joking around.

3
laibamustafa•

Haha same Then i guess I'll give it a pass. I just wanted to know the hype about these books. The word rape was used so much it was making me uncomfortable so i just quit it .

3
TheTinyGM•

Hmm, capri is not a series for everyone.

But the point of the first book is that there is no connection between characters - you as a reader are supposed to read the first story and think "how the fuck do these two end up together?" and "i absolutely hate Laurent". Because Captive prince isn't just enemies to lovers in sense of progression of relationship between two main characters, but also between the reader and said character(s). You are meant to hate the guy and then slowly learn to love him, just as the main character does.

The connection happens in second book. And its slow burn.

3
Sam_Wilde•

It does get better. I’ve read the trilogy twice and I truly believe it is the best enemies to lovers story I’ve ever read. I do remember reading the first one and being kind of…embarrassed? I don’t know. I wasn’t sure what to think of it. But it was short and the people who love it are rabid about it (and rightly so), so I kept reading. I’m really glad I didn’t give up, because it’s really great.

2
ddissimulationOP"I am made of memories."•

Were you sent down from the heavens for the perfect game recommendation of Hades? Have an award, kind stranger. I've added all to my reading list - thank you :)

2
TheTinyGM•

Thanks! Hope you enjoy Hades, its truly a divine game.

2
PenelopeSummerCompulsive Editor•

Sorry for the two month late comment, but what’s the steam level on Something Human?

1
TheTinyGM•

Hm, is there some objective char for that, haha? Its been some time since I have read it, so I don't remember all the details, but the book is mostly plot and has about two or three sex scenes? They are explicit (aka cocks mentioned) but its nothing extra spicy.

2
PenelopeSummerCompulsive Editor•

Thanks so much!

1
[deleted]•

I literally came here to talk about Hades (been playing for a while now), but you beat me to it, lol. Why does it feel like Supergiant devs read The Song of Achilles and decided to take the matters into their own hands? xD

1
laibamustafa•

I feel you TSOA set my bar so high for romance books. I couldn't literally read anything for one whole week after finishing it first time so i re-read TSOA and when i say that i cried buckets I'm not exaggerating. I cried second time the same if not more. It's heart wrenchingly beautiful. And now I'm planning to re read third time. I love this book so much.

5
ddissimulationOP"I am made of memories."•

It was especially the small things that struck my nerve, such Patroclus' tender friendship with Briseis, or how each of the opposing characters such as Agamemnon and Thetis were described in such a way that made your blood boil whenever they appeared. I loved how Patroclus narrated each event in his bashful manner as well.
I really wish I could read it for the first time again - I wasn't expecting much, thinking it'd be similar to the movie 'Troy' (2004) where Patroclus was just Achilles' cousin/best friend. The movie left me heavily disappointed, and not just because I wanted to see Brad Pitt in some man-on-man action lol

4
laibamustafa•

I really love Patroclus he was such a gentle soul i was hooked from the very first page because of his heartfelt narration. I was mad at Achilles sometimes he was just so arrogant but i understand that was his nature and necessary to drive the plot, but my heart break for Patroclus every time. It was my first time reading anything on Greek mythology. I was interested in greek mythology for quite a long time but didn't know where to start and I'm happy that I read this without any prior knowledge. I literally dove into this book without any warning and believe me at the end i was HEARTBROKEN i was still hoping that somehow they would live. Thank God i didn't watch movie otherwise it'd have ruin my experience.

3
ddissimulationOP"I am made of memories."•

What really had me in a whole crying sob-fest was when Achilles' mother, Thetis, >!who's hated Patroclus since day one (bc she's a wicked and homophobic asshole) finally reunited their souls together after Patroclus' spirit spent days hovering over Achilles' grave and describing his desperate love for Achilles to her.!<
It made my heart ache, because by the time she did come around which is all Achilles and Patroclus wanted - it was too late. Also! I loved Chiron! The time the two spent with Chiron were some of my favourite scenes, ahhh they were so good and comforting.

4
laibamustafa•

I wasn't expecting her to unite them it was such a plot twist for me but i was sobbing mess at that time i just wanted anyone to unite them but i absolutely didn't expect her. It was good that she did it though. And yes those scenes were so good and comforting. This whole book is comforting in a twisted way.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
ddissimulationOP"I am made of memories."•

If I could recommend anything, it'd be to get the physical copy when you do read it! Embarrassing to admit and I'll probably never confess to this again, but I literally held my Kindle close to my heart for ages after finishing it :') It's one of those books you can re-read again and again to appreciate the beauty in passages you may have missed before, and overall just one that would feel much better in paper.

Let me know how it goes when you do read it someday, I hope you love it :)

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
GertieFlyyyy•

Axios by Jaclyn Osborn (and the sequel, Eryx) are similar and will also hurt you bad. The story is beautiful and has stuck with me for years.

Axios is told from the POV of Axios, a young Spartan boy. It follows him through his life, from the agoge to adulthood as a soldier. He is infatuated with his friend Eryx, with whom he has a sometimes tumultuous relationship. It's a beautiful love story and the recent sequel, Eryx, tells the same storyfrom Eryx's POV. There's also a fantastic audiobook to go with it.

Edit: While "Axios" will break your heart and hurt you deeply, "Eryx" will heal you again.

2
ddissimulationOP"I am made of memories."•

Axios by Jaclyn Osborn

Thanks, amazing person :) I'm hoping it's not too much of a shadow of Patroclus and Achilles though, and that they have different personalities. I remember reading something else set in Troy and it was basically Achilles and Patroclus all over again except they were Trojan and had different names lol.
But this sounds really good, I'll check it out!

3
PenelopeSummerCompulsive Editor•

Did you ever end up trying it? Did you like it?

1
chgommromancefan•

TSOA is definitely literary fiction as opposed to genre fiction (most MM Romance) so it's more in line with At Swim Two Boys, or Swimming in the Dark, or Maurice, or Giovanni's Room--and Maurice is the only HEA here--and there is new novel, Alec, that is a sequel to Maurice.

1