Accusations Against Islam Pertaining to Women's Rights and "Pedo Mo" | Refutation in Comments
reddit.com/gallery/om2a6gPosted Jul 17, 2021, 11:14 AM UTC
Posted Jul 17, 2021, 11:14 AM UTC
An-Nisa 92, regarding the difference in blood money for men and women. Women are considered to have half the value of a man.
Al-Baqarah 178, regarding the difference in earthly punishment against men and women.
For these examples I see no information talking about the difference in blood money. The Quran makes it clear that it is the same for every believer regardless of gender. There is no mention of difference in blood money paid or the hudud punishment severity for them.
An-Nisa 176, regarding men receiving twice the inheritance of women.
Al-Baqarah 282, regarding men's testimony having twice the value and authority of women's.
These can be explained as one bundle since they are talking about the socio-economic differences between the genders. Men have more authority in the case of testimony prioritization and general inheritance. For the first one, this is because men are more susceptible to harsher laws and women are given more leniency when it comes to judgement in society. However, this verse doesn't give the full story to the complexity of Islamic law and jurisprudence. When it comes to accusations of adultery for example, 4 witnesses are needed regardless of the gender of the adulterers, yet men receive harsher punishments. Islamic law has justice and gives nuanced contexts for its laws. Look at these articles talking about accusations of women committing adultery as well :
https://www.islamweb.net/en/article/135153/accusing-chaste-women-of-adultery
https://balagha.net/major-sins/accusing-woman-of-adultery
Women here are not given inferior rights. They are actually protected in society in many aspects in relation to how an Islamic society works. This also ties to the next point : inheritance.
Why do men get a higher share of inheritance compared to women? Because they are obligated to provide and sustain for their wives and families. On the other hand, women are NOT required to spend even a single penny for the family, and her money is actually hers only. Islamic law on inheritance is actually a very sophisticated system in itself. Based on the family situations, it becomes very lenient and there are actually more situations wherein a woman gets more depending on the factors :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RUJARcYjWoM&ab_channel=YaqeenInstitute
Al-Baqarah 229, regarding men having the upper hand in matters of separation and divorce.
Although it is part of Islam wherein a husband has higher authority in terms of divorce, this does not mean that Islam does not provide justice for women and oppresses them by not allowing them divorce permanently. Women actually have full rights for divorce in various situations:
It is important to know that Islam highly encourages and urges couples to maintain a relationship. It is a terrible thing for society to allow men or women to separate for terrible, trivial reasons, and divorce, may it be from men or women, should be something that is done as a last resort or when it involves heavy sins that annuls marriages and destroys families. There is a reason why Iddah periods exist too.
Ironically the very verse that is quoted does not even espouse a negative thing. It actually shows the divorce ethics expected of men.
Divorce may be retracted twice, then the husband must retain ˹his wife˺ with honour or separate ˹from her˺ with grace. It is not lawful for husbands to take back anything of the dowry given to their wives, unless the couple fears not being able to keep within the limits of Allah. So if you fear they will not be able to keep within the limits of Allah, there is no blame if the wife compensates the husband to obtain divorce. These are the limits set by Allah, so do not transgress them. And whoever transgresses the limits of Allah, they are the ˹true˺ wrongdoers. Al-Baqarah Verse 229
Men are obligated to treat their wives with honour and grace and properly even after a divorce and in the Iddah period. Men who are abusive deserve to be prosecuted by law. The next verse makes it even better- men are totally prohibited from marrying the same woman again after the divorce/talaq is pushed three times. This means that you, as a man, shouldn't try to even get the woman you separated from or get back to her by means of validation/emotional coercion.
Women are anything but identical and similar to men. However, they are equal to men in worth. But does equality directly constitute the exact same rights, privileges, obligations for men and women? The answer is no. Absolute equality is not the solution, and divine revelation and guidance from our Creator for the way men and women should treat each other AND be treated is key to a happy, fulfilled society. This refutation does not do justice to the broadness of Islam, but it is evident and clear based on these explanations that we Muslims support a rigid way of living in this life.
And shias believe aisha was 19 years old lmao. They don't believe she was 9 according to their sources. Your claim refutes itself
Nooo bro this person studied the Quran his whole life!!!
I believe this is false.
Someone pulled up an al-Kāfī reference a while back (I forgot the subreddit) that shows that Āisha was 9.
Edit: guys stop upvoting me if I can’t verify this
I have no strong knowledge about shia beliefs, but many shias on tiktok have said what I said. So I'm gonna shut up because it's clearly a subject out of my current area of knowledge
Same
As an ex-Shia, I can confirm that the classical belief was 9 years. Both Sunni and Shia schools started saying 19 years in the past couple of centuries in response to Western scrutiny.
Shia believe Aisha may Allah be pleased with her murdered the prophet, they are lost in conjecture and devilish works
When do they believe that?
This is in their books, where they insult and propagate against sunnis, where they also mention narrations of things like flying elephants over the holy mosque.
To any shia reading this, please, repent, your battle is not with enemies of Allah but with the messenger of Allah. Please look into who you are insulting, Abu Bakr al Sedeeq & Umar peace be upon them both would never harm any of the believers, they are blessed in the Quran as every fellow of the prophet.
Why don't they put the differences set to men?
Men have to do many things women aren't demanded to. And if explained fully and with evidence it could refute every single piece of "evidence" taken out od context of the whole quran
Bruh already from the first argument we can see how their minds work. Pornography and today’s society have rewired their brains so hard that they associate having 4 spouses to some sex orgy fantasy, while that is far far from the truth. 99% of them don’t even know why this is allowed and how this can be of benefit.
Glad to see that the sub has returned to former glory.
Remind me! 1 hour
I will be messaging you in 1 hour on 2021-07-17 13:40:21 UTC to remind you of this link
CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.
^(Parent commenter can ) ^(delete this message to hide from others.)
| ^(Info) | ^(Custom) | ^(Your Reminders) | ^(Feedback) |
|---|
join the discord server! https://discord.gg/wuVb5qRrRW
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
Let us start with the pedophile accusation against Muhammad PBUH. This has been done for a wickedly huge number of times now and this video essentially summarizes and explains the marriage in great detail superbly :
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZH8L3XiVrXw&ab_channel=FullMetalTheist
The marriage is not pedophilia, nor is it abuse. Anyone who disagrees is eventually deemed hypocritical, baseless, and has no legs to stand on upon further inspection. Case closed.
An-Nisa 3, regarding men having the right to marry 4 women while women can not have more than 1 spouse.
When Islam sent down laws pertaining to polygamy, polygyny specifically speaking, it is important to note that polygyny is not an Islamically-endowed practice in the world. 90% of all human civilizations, even ones which have had no contact to each other for most of history, practiced polygyny i.e. one man married to multiple wives. This has been done primarily in situations wherein high-value men are capable of sustaining a family of more than one woman. This was overwhelmingly the norm in pre-modern societies especially considering the fact that for most of history, establishing large and strong families were important and beneficial. This could not have been possible with polyandry, where a woman marries multiple men.
Here are two materials talking about the topic deeply, containing a religious, scientific, and societal view and how polyandry, on the other hand, is not suited for society.
https://www.instagram.com/p/CNssJi9nGZu/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=faomB9e9Qyo&ab_channel=AliDawah
An-Nisa 34, regarding women's obedience to men and the right to beat them.
As constituted in Islamic thought, we ideologically conform to the preservation of societal values enforced in the Quran, and one core aspect of it is family. We adhere to gender archetypes and roles in Islam, wherein a husband and wife are each given their respective rights over each other and obligations for a family structure. Wives are obligated to be obedient to their husbands, because these assigned roles help preserve social cohesion. People might think, at first glance, that it is oppressive, but this view becomes erroneous when you realize the male side in a family has its obligations as well. Men are divinely obligated to provide for their wives and family, whereas women aren't. They are put under clear rules when they operate in and out of the home. Women who are rebellious and arrogant are not healthy for themselves, their families, and society as a whole, the same way that men who are effeminate, lazy, slothful, and egoistic are. This is why Islam constituted not only rights, but also obligations and a way of living. Don’t dismiss the fact that men should treat their wives with dignity, and by nature women are submissive and attracted to men who can provide for them and know how to lead. Would a healthy minded man allow his wife to go out without him knowing, let her do whatever she wants without restrictions, and if he has protective jealousy he is deemed as “toxic”?
The wife-striking verse has also been explained countless times :
https://islamqa.info/en/answers/41199/hitting-ones-wife
https://islamqa.info/en/answers/164216/did-the-prophet-blessings-and-peace-of-allah-be-upon-him-ever-hit-his-wife-aaishah-may-allah-be-pleased-with-her
Beep. Boop. I'm a robot. Here's a copy of
###Quran
Was I a good bot? | info | More Books
Based
You have done a great service brother, May Allah bless you.