Why is my simple syrup coming out cloudy?

Syrup

Trying to make a rich simple syrup and the result keeps coming out with those cloudy streaks. Am I screwing something up or is it just the sugar not fully dissolving? I'm doing two parts sugar to 1 part water over gentle heat stirring occasionally.

Update: Third time seems to be the charm! Thoroughly cleaned the pan, gave the mixture a little more heat and more time until I saw tiny bubbles, and the result looks much better!

Posted Jul 18, 2021, 3:15 PM UTC · edited

5531
WichitorianButcher & Sommelier•
  1. What kind of sugar are you using?

  2. are you certain the pan was very clean and had no residual oil on it? It’s hard to tell really from the picture but to me it kind of looks like there’s something besides just sugar and water in that pan? Maybe something accidentally fell in your sugar?

  3. I usually add a splash more water when making rich that 2:1 like maybe a tablespoon than cook it slightly longer to dissolve the sugar crystals cause if you don’t get them all sometimes they can fall out of solution and your simple doesn’t last a long.

30
SnailShellsOP•

Using some cheap granulated sugar I got at the store. The pan is actually brand new and this is the first thing it's been used for. I'll try your suggestion to add a little more water, and maybe I'll try a different sugar or pan too.

12
WichitorianButcher & Sommelier•

Oh that could be it too! Some pan come with a coating on them to keep them nice in the store. Throw that simple out, scrub the pan down and start again.

35
SnailShellsOP•

Will do! I'm tired of using store bought simple syrup so I want to get this right haha

16
WichitorianButcher & Sommelier•

Good for you! It’s super easy and I’m sure you’ll get it. In the future think about switching out your sugars too, for cocktails I make both 1:1 simple and 2:1 rich with demerera sugar and it really lends a richer & more complex flavor profile to basically whatever you make. Turbinado is also good. You could try making it with the C&H brown sugars, I never have but I bet that would be interesting as well.

I hope it came out ok!

6
GustoGaiden•

You should *always* wash new cookware with warm soapy water before using them. Most pans come off the factory line with a residue of releasing agent: A lubricating chemical used to make sure the metal pan doesn't stick to the machinery that makes it. It's usually (hopefully) non-toxic and harmless, but it's not something that's tasty or desirable to eat in any way. Most companies do not completely wash the residue off, because it helps give the pan the appealing shiny look of new cookware.

The same goes for new plastic, silverware, and glassware, by the way. You should be able to tell a before and after difference by the way that water beads on the item. The residue usually give it a hydrophobic effect.

6
SnailShellsOP•

Good call. I usually try to, but more as a passing thought than anything (quick rinse with some soap and cool water). I'm definitely gonna be more thorough next time.

2
bw2082•

Don’t think it is mixed enough. Those streaks are caused by difference in density.

24
notnowbutnever•

This was my first thought. Something’s not finished. Like it isn’t dissolved maybe?

11
b0yheaven•

what temp are you using? that is a lot of sugar for the syrup, water could be evaping before dissolving sugar. you could try a 1.5 to 1 ratio and still wind up with a pretty hefty syrup.

7
Phuffe•

I do a 2:1 ratio syrup all the time so i dont think thats the problem. Either it has been cooking for to short of a time or something was in the pan before i think.

8
b0yheaven•

soap res?

2
Phuffe•

Honestly hard to say what it was if the problem was residue. Maybe just try to clean it better next time and see if that fixes it. Otherwise i cook up water so it is hot but not boiling then add sugar and lower the temp. And keep on stirring until it is done.

Works for me.

2
SnailShellsOP•

ahhh I added both components to a cold pan then heated. I'm going to try heating the water first then adding sugar and see if that makes it come out a little more appealing.

5
Gunner253•

Looks like slight crystalization. When it cooled did it get worse? Try using more water and a lower temp so it doesn't boil. If the pan isn't perfectly clean those bubbles will stick to the sides and create streaks. If more water was cooked out it would continue to crystalize.

5
Stands_w_Fist•

Those are just sit bubbles. Stir vigorously and then pour into a container and let cool

3
alyxmj•

It's not cooked enough. Syrup is not just about dissolving it, you also need to remove all the water you put in. Simple syrups are done just after a slight boil - indicating that you've hit 212F and the water is boiling off.

1†

Someone need to stop downvoting correct answers. Boil it, OP. Just for a few seconds at least. You’re making syrup. It has to be boiled.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mtocrat•

If you have a high speed blender I can also recommend that.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
shutyercakeholesam•

I thought simple syrup was equal parts sugar to water? Or am I mistaken? Anyway, clean pan and then swish some white vinegar around it and rinse and dry it. It might help get the coating off the new pan.

0
1nquiringMinds•

Rich Simple is 2:1

1
aspiring_outlaw•

Simple syrup is a 1:1 sugar to water syrup. You are using a 2:1 that is oversaturated. The clouds are the undissolved sugar.

0
mtocrat•

OP got it right. 2:1 is called a rich simple.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1†