triggerhappymidgetOP•

I have no idea what happened. Didn't hit anything or go off a curb or something. I was just going around 20mph and the next thing I know I was over the handlebars and on the ground. Landed on my shoulder and then skidded on my face for a while. I have minor whiplash, took a few chunks from my shoulder and knuckles, and my face is a swollen mess of bruises and road rash but no broken bones or torn muscles. Hopefully the whiplash heals up in a few weeks.

106
another_mind•

Get checked for a concussion! No joke!

87

Accidents tend to make your brain forget stuff that happened before/during accidents to protect itself.

That doesn’t looks like a carbon failure, this looks like a hard impact. It doesn’t fail like that on both sides simultaneously without heavy force.

34
austinmilesColorado, USA (Viathon G1)•

Don’t these catastrophic defects typically tend to delaminates and splinter when they explode rather than this relatively clean break?

Not that it couldn’t happen this way. I’m actually just curious

3
Little_NaCl-y•

Glad you're okay(ish). Incredible reminder that what are near average speeds can do a lot of damage if you go off.

8
0LD0G•

Glad your okay! Make sure you get properly examined, and have a good recovery!

6
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
NxPat•

You might do well to report your incident to the CPSC. https://www.saferproducts.gov/IncidentReporting
It is a sure way to get the attention you need from Scott with the government overseeing their actions.

25+ years in bike manufacturing, that is not a “normal” fracture incident.

https://www.cpsc.gov/search?site=cpsc_site&output=xml_no_dtd&getfields=*&tlen=120&client=ek_drupal_01&proxystylesheet=ek_drupal_01&filter=p&query=scott+bikes

This is a very long list of recalls by Scott with a number of fork related incidents.

71
triggerhappymidgetOP•

Thanks. I was wondering how to get Scott's attention since I'm way outside any warranty period and don't have a big enough social media presence to get them to notice me.

21
Trepidati0n•

That kind of failure is something they tend to take care of regardless of warranty. Sorta a “oh shit” for them.

23
Mistafishy125•

It’s probably less “oh shit” more “well, it’s cheaper than litigation”

25
orangenegative•

It happened in this instance, but the damage was done in a previous crash.

6
MakeMeOolong•

Scott is a very serious Swiss brand and trust me, they don't take this kind of stuff lightly in Switzerland. Of course if they could avoid to be sued that would be a bonus, but even without it they would pay attention.

2
igotsaquestiontoo•

i went to that page and noticed that scott was frequently a person's name and the item didn't even have bikes in the summary. so i tried with "scott bikes" and the list shortened to 40. even then, there were a lot of not scott bikes entries.

i skimmed and i saw at most 5 or 6 legitimate scott bikes recalls. one of which is a recall of a 2014 model. others looked like a recall for a mtb fork made by fox and potentially used on several brands of bikes. all in all, it doesn't seem that bad in regards to scott.

5
MakeMeOolong•

I was about to say the same. No idea what u/NxPat was trying to suggest with their vague and weird accusation.

3
NxPat•

I think if you check the link, it is specific to Scott Bikes. The query itself on this page shows: query=scott+bikes

1
MakeMeOolong•

I think, if you check the results, that close to zero of those are actually linked to a Scott bike, as u/igotsaquestiontoo explained.

1
SpeckbieberGermany (Canyon Neuron 2018)•

The front fell off D:

41
Ruslan124•

I laugh every time I think of that. As a side note I used to be a navigator for BP Shipping which of course was the company that owned the ship referenced in the sketch.

For those not familiar with the reference

https://youtu.be/3m5qxZm_JqM

It's very funny.

37
unpersonanongrata•

That is the funniest thing I’ve seen in quite a while. Thanks for sharing.

9
Ruslan124•

You are welcome.

6
run421•

Well the front fell off!

7
OneMorePenguin•

Cardboard's out.

6
Brewfintunafisk•

No cardboard derivatives.

2
Cakebeforedeath•

These are great, remind me of the "George Parr" interviews: https://youtu.be/nYC0P_NBLZw

2
bennywilly93•

That’s awesome hahaha

1
Cakebeforedeath•

These are great, reminds me of the "George Parr" interviews: https://youtu.be/nYC0P_NBLZw

0
Cakebeforedeath•

These are great, reminds me of the "George Parr" interviews: https://youtu.be/nYC0P_NBLZw

0
Cakebeforedeath•

These are great, reminds me of the "George Parr" interviews: https://youtu.be/nYC0P_NBLZw

-1
tripleaardvark2•

That's not very typical, I'd like to make that point.

10
Ruslan124•

I hear that in my head very clearly LOL.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
tchunk•

I'm very happy Clarke and Dawe became a meme. Every one of their sketches were like this. RIP JC

6
Likemike437•

A wave hit it

2
Nolberto78•

First thing, that's not a carbon failure. It's an impact of some sort. I guess if you wanted to look for every possible cause or try to replicate it you could jam a length of rebar between the spokes at 20mph but even then I can't see it shearing both blades at the thickest point simultaneously.

Warranty wouldn't touch it. There is no reason for a straight bladed fork to fail at that point. In an impact it would also be protected by the wheel as it's below the level of the rim. If someone presented that to me and said guess how it happened I would say it was on a roof mounted bike rack, you forgot and drove into your garage.

Either way it sucks as that was a dream bike of mine and now there's one less.

13
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
supersonicturtle•

Huh..so if the wheel came unclipped and fell off, could that do it?

You'd defs notice the wheel rubbing against the brakes for a bit before then though.

2
four4beats•

Have you had any crashes in the past?

I recently ran my bike into a guardrail when I lost control descending - I was breaking but was likely still traveling 12-15 mph. I’ve been worried about my carbon wheels and fork even though there’s no visible or audible signs of damage. Seeing OP’s fork scares the crap out of me.

7
chrrsfursnpurrs•

This type of failure is really unusual, the forks are some of the most reinforced parts of the bike.

However, what does happen is the junction of the fork to its steering tube gets compromised. If you haven’t taken your fork out and checked that area, I’d strongly advise to do so.

11
TheBklynGuy•

I hit a depression in the ground hard just yesterday, causing the bike to jump up. Thanks to the OPs post im about to check my bike carefully. Hope OP has a swift recovery and miles upon miles of great riding ahead.

1
mrmischiefboy•

Just gonna throw it out there that, " I was JRA and the fork snapped for no reason!" is not a thing. Maybe the OP didn't see the pothole/brick/wombat that they hit but it wasn't nothing. I mean, how do you even get on and start rolling on a fork that fragile? Impossible. Take it to you LBS and see what they say. Probably something like, "...uh-huh... Bummer, man".

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
dubyakayBombtrack Audax 2016•

wombat

Oddly specific. Could the wombat have moved on after such an impact?

1
mrmischiefboy•

Yes, wombats are cute and very durable.

1
pedalsgaloreColorado, USA (BMC Teammachine SLR01)•

Dang. What happened?

5
madeindavidRibble CX SL EE•

How’s that posible?

5
[deleted]•

Wow! Once my wife was riding home from a friend's house during a storm and hit a small bump and her front wheel flew off. She made out much better than you it seems though. Good luck with the recovery.

4
MoltenCorgi9•

And people say steel is too heavy lol.

4†
triggerhappymidgetOP•

Yeah, I'm gonna go back to riding my Surly for a while, ha.

13
illdoitlatermum•

Steel is real

7
jayxdirty•

Yeah your better off buying a steal or aluminum bike than a cheap carbon bike. That’s not new news

-10
triggerhappymidgetOP•

This wasn't a cheap carbon bike. It's an old carbon bike, but I've had it for almost ten years and new, it was not cheap. (MSRP was over $5k.)

12
Narwen189•

Holy fuck, that's terrifying. Hope recovery goes smoothly as possible.

4
0LD0G•

The sound of your face on the floor milliseconds later?

3
angiebanangie92056•

What brand/ model

2
triggerhappymidgetOP•

Scott Addict. I THINK it's around an '09 because the paint job matches the TdF Columbia-Highroad team bikes from that time period.

6
angiebanangie92056•

Check if there’s any info on recalls on your bike. Did you get injured? Not a lawyer but document injuries

10
BicyclesOnMain•

So you bought it used I'm guessing? I think a lot of the bad rep carbon gets is from a picture with no context, I've seen plenty of bent steel forks as well. This has to be from previous crash damage.

2
triggerhappymidgetOP•

I bought the bike used in 2012. I have never had an accident on this bike, and I highly doubt it took almost ten years and 50,000+ miles for something to happen due to hypothetical previous crash damage.

8
BicyclesOnMain•

Understood, but why do you think it randomly failed after 10 years and 50k miles? I don't follow your logic. It could be a flaw or crash damage, but I don't see how time and miles disproves one but not the other.

1
Convicted__Vapist•

>>laughs in chromoly

2†
BicyclesOnMain•

Trust me that fails too.

6
pine4links•

Like this? Without obvious rust?

3
Convicted__Vapist•

nuh uh

1
liamemsa1998 GT Lightning Titanium•

Your collarbone shattering in the middle of a ride?

2
[deleted]•

I didn't hear anything.

https://imgur.com/a/ISwKw9N

2
supersonicturtle•

How'd yours happen?

1
[deleted]•

I was riding alone on a country road, paying attention, then I was flipping over the bar and landing on my face, neck, and shoulder. After research and talking to a bike lawyer and a pro racer I can't blame the frame manufacturer. The pro told me he once saw a squirrel do that to a fork. I think the pump came loose, bounced into the front wheel, and sheared the fork.

2
supersonicturtle•

WELL THEN, I now have a million more reasons to brake for squirrels other than basic human decency.

The pump shearing the fork makes a ton of sense. Thank you for sharing.

1
[deleted]•

The pump shearing the fork makes a ton of sense.

Well, yes, but it makes me look stupid!

2
HardlyThereAtAll•

I'll tell you what I'm impressed by: this guy didn't let the fork breakage end his ride. For me, a breaking fork would have been the end of the ride. But for him, it was just the middle.

Respect.

2
NNYCanoeTroutSki•

HOLY SHIT!!

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
HarlemPaul🇺🇸 (Airborne Valkyrie, Van Dessel Country Road Bob)•

Feel better soon. What brand fork?

1
triggerhappymidgetOP•

Scott Addict.

1