My Dad had a collapse flying in some trashy air yesterday
Posted Jul 25, 2021, 9:20 PM UTC
Posted Jul 25, 2021, 9:20 PM UTC
As a paraglider pilot (not powered), that looked like a pretty normal day of flying. But I joined this sub because someday I want start PPG. What I've been picking up from posts here is that PPG (or is it the pilot?) is a lot less tolerant of wings doing what I would consider just normal wing things.
In ppg we are much more loaded on the wing so collapses like this feel a lot more violent (it also takes a lot more to get this). A motorist loaded up on a C wing could get seriously turned around and lose hundreds of feet from what might be a"normal" collapse in free flight.
That makes sense. Thanks!
Came here to say this.
I was just flying in Chelan, WA. On the rowdiest day I had a 50-60% asymmetrical collapse of the left side. The wing immediately rolled left and pitched forward 90 degrees. I weight shifted right to fly straight, pumped the brake to reinflate and then had to pluck the stabilo line to release a small crevat. Back to thermaling normally in less than 3 seconds start to finish. It was one of my best moments as a pilot. Scary but knowing how to fix something that wrong is so important.
Uh yeah most PPG pilots would not feel comfortable flying around if this was normal wing things. I've been flying somewhat regularly for 2 years now and have only had a collapse like this when I attempted light acro.
Paragliding is definitely different from PPG though. I have seen a lot of paragliding videos with way worse collapses than this though. Must be a difference in wing design or load or something... definitely seems more common. Could also be that PG uses thermals for lift whereas PPG would prefer completely laminar air.
He sent me this video with the caption.
"Pretty exciting. Not so fun."
That about sums it up. Don't think he flew for very long.
[deleted]
Being someone who wants to get into paramotoring, this is the scariest thing about the sport to me. What causes collapses or folds on the wings? And correct me if I'm wrong but isn't it completely unavoidable?
Eh this was avoidable just by flying in better weather.
Also, a collapse happened but you can see in the video the wing immediately recovered.
It's an understandable concern but you can make PPG a very safe activity by flying high, in good weather, without doing acrobatics. Doing this gives your wing time to recover and makes collapses less likely in general.
Some of the biggest beginner mistakes in this sport happen before you leave the ground.
It's very difficult, and often impossible to predict, you can't see air currents, though you can learn to expect them. I haven't flown a paramotor before, I'm just into the sport, so there could be some symptoms you feel in the brakes which indicates you're going to have a collapse. My understanding is that they are usually due to turbulent conditions, or the way in which a wing is set up. For example some wings have been known to collapse when you max out the speed bar.
I think it's also somewhat common for beginner pilots to cause unnecessary collapses because they try to over control the wing, but this is why beginner wings exist, to be stable even when the pilot isn't.
This is avoidable. Shit air doesn’t just surprise you, you are right we can’t see air but we do have other tools and weather models that really lower the possibility of this happening. Plus this really was a small tip collapse, still scary to a new guy but hardly any trouble.
Oh absolutely, I didn't mean to say that paramotoring was Inherintely dangerous. In fact that's part of the reason I'm so attracted to paramotoring, it's mostly only as dangerous as you make it.
[deleted]
Lol it was my dad not me but he was fine. The wing recovered nearly immediately.
Is it possible for the lines to drop low momentarily by a quick collapse and get chopped by the propeller? which of course would mean reserve chute time and change of underwear time. Are powered hang gliders safer than powered parachutes in this respect to collapses? I guess the good thing about paramotoring is there are no distracted drivers or deer running in front of you like in motorcycling, just air.
Is it possible for the lines to drop low momentarily by a quick collapse and get chopped by the propeller?
Never heard of something like this. You’d have to fly in like a tornado because you’re guaranteed to fall faster than the parachute. Maybe if you flew directly underneath a helicopter…
That's a pretty mild collapse, slightly more brake pressure should help. Those are not uncommon collapses if flying in rowdy air, and they aren't too troublesome. It doesn't look like a pleasant PPG flying weather, so yea I'd have landed too, and I fly all kinds of shit.