"The US Federal Bureau of Investigation [FBI] has quietly released details of plans to continuously monitor the global output of Facebook, Twitter and other social networks, offering a rare glimpse into an activity that the FBI and other government agencies are reluctant to discuss publicly."

newscientist.com/blogs/onepercent/2012/01/fbi...
newscientist.com

Posted Jan 26, 2012, 11:29 AM UTC

1.9K639
AnUnknown•

WHY ARE YOU SO SURPRISED?!?! PUBLICLY AVAILABLE UP TO DATE INFORMATION THAT OFFERS A GLIMPSE INTO THE MINDS OF THEIR CONSTITUENTS IS DEFINITELY SOMETHING THE FBI AND SIMILAR AGENCIES WOULD WANT TO PARSE AND UNDERSTAND.

Nowhere are we talking about getting data that isn't already available to the public. Why is it such a big deal that the FBI went looking for contractors who could provide a method of parsing, monitoring, and searching this data? I'd be angry if they weren't investing in something like this. This is their job.

333
yodamaster103•

Seriously why the fuck do people freak out when their information they publish on a free public site is compromised. It's their own fault neither the government nor the sites themselves. Stupid people are stupid.

131
AnUnknown•

You too can protect yourself against being monitored! All you have to do is be cautious about what you post on the public internet. Easy!!

73
[deleted]•

IAMA never convicted axe murderer AMA

60
USMCsniper•

novice, i just killed like 6 people since this thread started.

come at me bro

39
SOULSTACK•

Lot of "Bad Actors" out there.

4
Oatbananor•

I am hitler reincarnated (where they will never look)

1
mikefh•

Not exactly. Link-analysis can statistically associate seemingly mundane details.

IBM has a company dedicated to this purpose...

13
postproduction•

It's actually pretty easy to do. I manage a forum with mostly women members and sometimes we'll get creeps who sign up and harass them. Almost always just from their ip address, username and email address you can find out who they are, including name and address.

From that experience I've learned to never use my real name online and never use the same username on more than one public website (not that I'm a stalker, but you never know who would use that information in ways you wouldn't want them to).

Also I google my name sometimes to see what information other websites show about me. The last time I showed up was after I finished a course, the school thought it was a good idea to list all of their graduates including email address and phone number.

Law enforcement agencies will always have ways to find out who you are and I think that's a good thing, with a court order of course, unless you're on some kind of encrypted connection. But you shouldn't make it easy for just anyone.

15
syzygote•
6
AnUnknown•

So can private investigators.

-1
sardonic•

Negative, the best thing to do if you don't want to be "monitored" on the internet is not to use it, or use services like Tor. Governments are actively using DPI and faked/hacked SSL certificates to get even "private" information off your accounts. Other data is being saved all over the place, they may not be able to "access" that info yet, but the mere creation allows for that capacity in the future.

4
ephekt•

Negative, the best thing to do if you don't want to be "monitored" on the internet is not to use it, or use services like Tor.

If you're really this paranoid, using Tor without gpg or the like is a dumb idea.

Simply controlling what info you post to public spaces should suffice for most people. I mean, unless you're engaged in criminal activity, you're probably more worried about id theft than govt snooping.

People like to flatter themselves, but the reality is that few of us are interesting enough for anyone to care about.

Governments are actively using DPI

At least in the US, DPI isn't being done at your local ISP or POP for this purpose. After over a decade in the ISP field I've yet to see these conspiracy boxes at IX's/transit level either.

and faked/hacked SSL certificates to get even "private" information off your accounts.

I'm not sure what kind of attack you're actually referencing here...? The govt is performing SSL-MITM... or in bed with the CAs?

With sources like FB etc at least, the govt probably doesn't need to "hack" anything. The DoJ can simply pressure the company into compliance.

5
NeoPlatonist•

We are all criminals!

1
rabblerabble2000•

A lot more difficult than it would seem for some people though. I did a brief stint working as a private investigator, and part of my job was tracking down bail jumpers...you'd be incredibly surprised how many of them have either open facebook pages or will accept any friend request as long as it comes from a semi-attractive woman. Made my job incredibly easy when they'd post something about where they were going to be etc.

4
CrazedToCraze•

What if I want to tell people my credit card number? I think the pattern of numbers is really pretty and should be appreciated by everyone.

3
tekgnosis•

Your financial institution holds the copyright on the string of numbers that comprise your credit card number. Copyright infringement is a crime!

5
[deleted]•

smith vs. maryland

actual opinion

  • This Court consistently has held that a person has no legitimate expectation of privacy in information he [442 U.S. 735, 744] voluntarily turns over to third parties.

  • '...This Court has held repeatedly that the Fourth Amendment does not prohibit the obtaining of information revealed to a third party and conveyed by him to Government authorities, even if the information is revealed on the assumption that it will be used only for a limited purpose and the confidence placed in the third party will not be betrayed.'

  • We [442 U.S. 735, 745] are not inclined to hold that a different constitutional result is required because the telephone company has decided to automate.

2
[deleted]•

Be careful what you say in public. Yes.....

1
Kensin•

You're still being monitored. That's like saying "Sure, the police will come around to your home every 3 weeks for 'inspection' but you can protect yourself by not leaving illegal things in your house!" or "Sure the government is wiretapping your phone but you can protect yourself by not speaking out against the government and watching what you say!"

I'm 100% behind you that people need to be careful what they are posting to the internet, but you are being monitored and the increased monitoring of US citizens is a valid concern.

1
AnUnknown•

No, it's not the same, and here's why.

Your house is your property. You have a reasonable expectation of privacy within your house. Per the US Constitution, police just can't come around every 3 weeks for "inspection." A telephone conversation is a private conversation, you have a reasonable expectation of privacy there too.

Posting something - anything - within the public sphere, you do not have a reasonable expectation of privacy. If anyone can see what you put up, of course the police can too.

1
feureau•

That, or use VPNs, TORs, and layers of encryption and post with a random set of usernames that is not related to any of your personal account so the FBI ca

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

28
NeoPlatonist•

1984 had me worried about the Thought police.

I should have listend to Radiohead, the real problem is the Karma police.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
talkstomuch•

It's not a problem that the information is available, it's a problem when your tax money is spent to watch over people. If you go the same route, why don't we put a FBI agent in every pub listening on people's conversations, just in case they're terrorists. Moreover it's is a totalitarian tactic. In East Germany special police spread rumours that they have a file for every citizen and they will crack down on the enemies of the state. To keep everyone on their toes.

24
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
PhantomPhun•

Because YOU are going to fuck the freak out when:

  1. They are analyzing the public info against their own intelligence gathering and the of others and readily deriving information that was never intended for their eyes, use, or storage.

  2. Over zealous prosecutors or just plain out of control employees at some link in the intel chain decides to use YOUR information against you out of spite, jealousy or a million other motivators.

Good luck with that.

14
Oatbananor•

some abuse is one thing , proliferation of information on everyone into some central databases that eventually fall in to the wrong hands means death of civilization as we know it very soon.

social structures that are very legalistic , rigid , employ and use the results of aggressive surveillance almost always give rise to sociopathic leadership in the end , scientology , just about any fascist state on this planet , various companies , schools , so forth. the remedy has always been turning into a greater power to purge the evil , often along with the organization. what happens if the entire planet becomes a rigid hopeless police state over 100 years or so? we definitely have the technology to 'accidentally' do it , what will be the greater power? religious people claim god , others might find hope in some meteor. The fbi blackmailing some facebook kid with his nude photos is small change.

1
echosofverture•

And people wonder why I mostly stay off of facebook.

9
unguru•

I've been clean for over 5 months. the withdrawal sypmtoms are minimal now.

9
[deleted]•

2 months free myself. It's such a relief not having to anxiously wonder why everyone else's perfectly manicured virtual life is so much more glamorous than mine. It's basically heroin, with brief highs punctuated by extended lows.

2
echosofverture•

I recall reading a few months back that your facebook posts can appear on a credit/background check regardless if the profile is private. Do people really think setting your profile as private will be able to stop the alphabet agencies from viewing it?

1
JudoTrip•

What information would you have on FB that you'd be worried about the FBI seeing?

I don't think staying off FB really gives you any advantages, especially if you were already on there.

1
OldFartDave•

I never saw the point of it.

1
Solkre•

Compromised isn't even a good term. Accessed or Viewed. None of this stuff is hidden from anyone.

8
[deleted]•

Because people are hypocritical fools?

5
MAC_TRUCK_HITS_BABY•

Because it forces them to realize that the shit they put on Facebook is actually fucking public. People think Facebook is some kind of private bubble. Well, it isn't kids.

5
[deleted]•

Nobody thinks that, they think, rightfully, that the government shouldn't completely exploit their personal information for gain.

6
[deleted]•

Yeah, everyone should just assume that the US government is now a Big Brother-esque all-seeing eye that can indefinitely detain anyone for typing a key-word like "occupy" too many times on the internet over the course of a few months.

/sarcasm

2
bh28630•

The reason rational people are appalled when they learn their activities are monitored is because such 24/7 surveillance was implemented under the innocent guise of social networking. The data gathered has always been for sale. What you do online is how Google and Facebook make money. The sole new wrinkle is openly stating what they have been doing all along - providing data to government agencies. You don't need a subpoena when you already have full access.

2
yodamaster103•

A while back when the changed the like system for pages and stuff and a bunch o friends got pissed but they didn't realize it was so they could tailor make ads specifically target towards you based on the pages you like

1
waffleninja•

Actually governments should act on the will of the people. If people do not want the government monitoring their social media, the government should not.

2
NeoPlatonist•

A lot of people are pretty trusting of others until they've been given reason to suspect otherwise. A lot of people aren't lawyers and don't understand the Terms of Service crap they sign. A lot of people don't suspect they are being spied on constantly.

1
rbevans•

Stupid people are stupid

Sums it up pretty good. Don't want folks knowing your business don't make it public on the internet.

-1
[deleted]•

It actually sums it up horribly.

Its like saying:

If you don't want to be robbed, then don't ever leave your door unlocked, even once, because the thieves (government) are now religiously going door to door turning every knob until they find one that opens.

7
rbevans•

That's what thieves do. Last month at our community meeting with the local Police. They told us they've arrested folks who go from house to house and only break into houses where doors have been left unlocked.

3
DropsTheMic•

"Big government is evil! My rights are trampled! It shouldn't have power over anything. Except the things I don't like or understand. It should control those things." -America-

-1
lud1120•

The problem is why so many people don't think before they speak and write down their thoughts straight into the Internet.

We can find many potential murderers, and "terrorist" plots as well.
People need to be careful of what they say in the public.

17
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
MetaphorAve•

I'm really curious how something like this works. Is Reddit required by law to provide the IP of dfhncfgjnf since he made a public threat against the president? That's even if someone were to report it. I have no clue.

4
GeorgeForemanGrillz•

War driving to a public wifi + MAC spoofing + ssh tunnels through various compromised servers overseas + Tor + throwaway account would make it nearly impossible to track down. I think dfhncfgjnf was trying to make a point that there are many ways to stay anonymous on the internet.

7
howisthisnottaken•

Google Alerts offers this service. You can set an alert for assassinate site:reddit.com. The secret service probably knows because they have this filter and if they are motivated, which may be possible, someone can easily run down the info.

If you ever wondered how the relevant novelty accounts show up in threads it's the same path. i.e. violentacrez site:reddit.com

6
chakalakasp•

Yes they are, and yes it has happened before. It's happened over at FARK, too. It is extremely unwise (not to mention in extremely poor taste) to make jokes about such things. It won't seem so funny when you get a knock at the door from two polite people in suits.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
howisthisnottaken•

Actually the secret service investigates these. Obviously you are cool enough to create a throwaway for these purposes and covered your tracks so you know this.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
brownpanther•

Don't pretend you haven't glanced at your door every 15 seconds since you posted this...

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

What in the HELL? I need to be censoring myself in public? Perfectly good people have nothing to worry about? Yeah.. the smart terrorists and criminals don't use social media to plan their shit.. this is not about monitoring those threats... power to you if you believe it is. I better be careful what I'm saying... fuck...

1
lud1120•

Well one don't need to write about how they'd want to kill someone or make a bomb.

1
[deleted]•

Exactly my point. :) People doing those horrible things aren't so stupid as to arrange their plots in public. If anything this makes us all suspect.. that's the message I'm getting here.. we are all suspect..

1
jisted•

I can understand why the FBI would want a "PROFILING" program that utilizes all the major social sites. But stopping terrorists WILL NOT be what it's used for.

16
[deleted]•

the FBI does a significant amount of work investigating money laundering, drug and human trafficking, cybertheft, and so on. It isn't just terrorism.

7
eran76•

The FBI investigates criminals suspected of those crimes, not the crimes themselves. If they have a suspect, then utilizing the available information on FB only makes sense. But to treat the internet like an information dragnet is putting the horse before the cart. This is a colossal fishing expedition, not a targeting investigation into specific criminal activity. Any criminal stupid enough to post details of their misdeeds online will be caught eventually, so this isn't going to really help catch anyone committing major crimes. It will however place all citizens (not to mentioned non-US users) under 24hr surveillance. Welcome to the Police state.

4
[deleted]•

FYI: they've been tracking your cell phone calls for years. Does that make you uncomfortable?

2
dustout•

Think of all the piracy this will stop! Huzzah!

0
GeorgeForemanGrillz•

Because I'm sure the FBI has foiled many terrorist plots from the data they have collected from social networks because you know the criminal enterprises and terror organizations are always discussing their plans on Facebook.

The problem is that they are wasting my tax money to pay some asshole contractor who uses outsourced Java developers to add another wasteful line item in the federal budget.

15
Craptain•

It isn't all bad. A coworker at the company I work for invented this application that can filter and classify tweets, based on keywords, location and whatnot. Then it would group and display the relevant tweets on a map and in augmented reality. It was first used on festivals, so that the public could see what others around them were commenting on. They were brainstorming other uses for it, and decided to pitch it to the police. The pitch was that if something unusual (like maybe a fire) happened at something like a big sports event, people would most likely be twittering about it, and the application would pick up on that. It would be useful for the police so they could respond earlier. The police was interested so they decided to run a test.

The test went pretty well. They covered this open-air exhibit. Nothing really went wrong at the event, but there was an accident elsewhere and people at the event started tweeting about the emergency vehicles they saw going past, worried if something bad had happened at the exhibit. The official police channel then twittered that all was fine, it was this-and-this elsewhere. People subsequently retweeted the police message and everyone calmed down. I'm not saying they averted a big panic, but it's an example of this kind of technology being used by the government for good things.

6
AnUnknown•

Hey now, some criminals are stupid. Sign on to Facebook from your phone, contact list gets uploaded, connections are made to other members of your group, heuristic analysis can be performed to identify commonalities and work from there.

The FBI actively monitors all other forms of media. We know this and are okay with this. Suddenly "social" media becomes the next big thing and we don't want any authorities to continue with keeping tabs on media?

2
GeorgeForemanGrillz•

You can set your privacy settings so that your phone doesn't show on your profile. If the FBI were to mine publicly available information they wouldn't be getting as many phone numbers as you would think.

1
AnUnknown•

How anyone can think putting their personal telephone number (especially a landline) on Facebook is a good idea is beyond me.

1
GeorgeForemanGrillz•

Also, the FBI would be violating the Facebook Developer agreement if they started mining the data using the Graph API and making offline copies of it. They would need permission from Facebook which I am sure they will not have a problem muscling their way into getting.

Facebook has promised users that they would never provide their information to a third party without a court order. If the FBI stores the data that I store on Facebook then they would be in violation of the DMCA.

2
diogenesbarrel•

This is their job.

Maybe in N Korea. The taxpayer doesn't give them money to snoop on him. A Govt agency should NEVER gather data about someone unless he's officially a suspect in a well defined criminal case such as a murder case. Making citizen files by default is what the totalitarian regimes do.

Gathering data about everybody is KGB 2.0 and shows clear intentions of controlling the people.

10
flippant•

I'm as against the police state as anyone else, but this is just silly. This is like saying a beat cop should keep their eyes closed until someone reports a crime. How DARE they observe all those innocent citizens going about their daily lives in public?

Personally, I'd consider the FBI naive and negligent if they didn't make use this data because I know I'd be the first to criticize them when some twitter-organized crime went unnoticed by them.

And just to address your straw man, I don't think this plan involves making files about every citizen. I doubt they plan to archive and collate this data on every user. That would be a massive waste of resources. I believe this plan is limited to real-time or near-real-time parsing and filtering very much analogous to a beat cop walking the streets and being aware of the environment around him. Yes, they'll store the bits they flag as interesting, but that's a lot different than building some universal social media file on everyone. Internet startups are already doing that for them. I love a good conspiracy theory, but I don't see how having people read what you CHOOSE to write on social media equates to controlling the people. Please elaborate so I can add that to my evil overlord plans.

26
diogenesbarrel•

Personally, I'd consider the FBI naive and negligent if they didn't make use this data

People like you are the ones that enable the totalitarian regimes. My country was a Socialist/Pact of Warsaw one until 1990 and I tell you the Govt shouldn't gather data by default on the citizens. this leaves room for a lot of later abuse.

We called people that helped them "informants" and they were merely reporting what the target said in public, that's still evil. The Govt has no business with what I say, think or do unless I commit a crime.

Facebook is the biggest informat on the planet.

3
drc500free•

The FBI actually can't hold this data if it's not for an investigation; they can look at it in real time, but they can't archive it to go data mining for suspicious activity over time unless they already have an investigation open on a specific person.

This is a federal restriction that doesn't generally apply to states. When they do start an investigation, they can often find a state-level agency or a private organization that has archived the data. That's part of the reason that state-federal fusion centers are popular.

It's a little strange that the government doesn't have the same right as a private citizen for investigating people, but at least it's some check on what they know. But it's not like private data aggregators aren't doing the exact same thing for much less noble purposes than fighting crime.

5
neodiogenes•

You have a point. However what Poland did not have (before 1990) was a Constitution that actually protected the rights of its citizens, which meant that anyone even accused of certain crimes (including free speech, which here is not criminal) could be detained, prosecuted, sentenced, and punished by secret police who never had to answer to the public.

It's a difference that makes all the difference. Any criminal caught in this way (publicly posting data of their criminal activity on public websites) has the right to an attorney and the full protection of the law against the use of any information obtained illegally.

You might hyperbolically claim this is the first step on the road to totalitarianism. But as others have pointed out, it's actually nothing new. When Law enforcement is preventative more than it is punitive, then it's doing its job right.

2
flippant•

Ad hominem aside, you make a good point and you've given me something to think about.

Where do you draw the line between the police watching what you do in public in real life (e.g. the cop on the beat) and what you do in public on the internet (e.g. reading your facebook)? Is it a matter of scale? Pervasiveness? Or are you against any proactive use of investigation and believe LEOs should restrict themselves to reaction? Given your experience, what's your opinion?

2
2crz4u•

Popular Science had some interesting write-ups on how utilizing large data sets you can locate key points of control and crime detection.

2
videogamechamp•

This is like saying a beat cop should keep their eyes closed until someone reports a crime. How DARE they observe all those innocent citizens going about their daily lives in public?

It's more like allowing hundreds of cops to continuously monitor you day and night, waiting for you to commit a crime. I'm not against a cop watching me walk to the store, and I'm not against a cop looking at my Facebook page to see if the guy I robbed that store with is my friend. What I am against is the systematic collecting and storing of that information. If I were to do that, I would be arrested for stalking. I don't trust my government that much.

2
[deleted]•

Gathering data about everybody is KGB 2.0 and shows clear intentions of controlling the people.

Oh, come on. So the agencies responsible for tracking down criminal activity should ignore information that is being made freely available?

9
diogenesbarrel•

Exactly. Those agencies have no right to treat everybody as a potential criminal, that's what the Nazis/Communists did.

1
[deleted]•

Well...we all are potential criminals, and it is the agencies' responsibility to help prevent crime and well as investigate it. I'm not saying they need to dig through every bit of private information we have, but is running algorithms on public sharing sites to look for suspicious material so heinous?

And I'd say the Nazis and Communists were a bit different, as they targeted entire groups of people not based on criminality but on their race and/or beliefs.

1
mexicodoug•

If you never break any laws or transgress social norms you must have the most boring life ever.

Most of us are outlaws or transgressors by nature, and with government monitoring of everybody it means that whenever anybody powerful is out to get me or you or any individual they can simply call up the records and nail us for something, whether illegal or socially unacceptable.

0
[deleted]•

It's always fun to break laws, until of course someone else's doing so somehow fucks with your own life, well-being, or source of income. Then all of a sudden it's "WHY AREN'T THERE MORE LAWS TO PREVENT THIS SHIT? WHERE ARE THE POLICE WHEN I NEED THEM??" And so on. So yeah, there needs to be a balance in there somewhere.

2
rabblerabble2000•

Prosecution and Intelligence operations are two very different things. The FBI has the mandate for Intelligence Gathering in country. This is just open source Intelligence gathering.

1
serrimo•

There are plenty of private companies that are mining the same sources as well.

This is certainly legal.

6
mexicodoug•

Just because something is legal doesn't necessarily make it right, just as because something is illegal doesn't necessarily make it wrong.

1
silent_13•

Couldn’t agree more. The cynic in me worries that this is the program they want you to know about. Right now the FBI is likely trying to build a way to get data that is not publicly available from these sites as well.

5
AnUnknown•

Oh I'm sure they've got (or are looking to get) just as much information from non-public sources on these sites. Of course, being US sites hosted in the US on a US TLD, you can't genuinely expect to be all that far from the all-seeing-eye.

1
chowderbags•

Yeah, I mean it's like this time when I went to the beach and started photographing all the women there. Can you believe that they actually got angry at that, when they're clearly in public spaces? I mean, if they didn't want to be photographed, they shouldn't be out in public!

5
[deleted]•

I don't get the surprise, at all. If the information is freely available, then it can have algorithms applied to it to mine information from it.

People have to realise that.

I'd be very interested to see what they can find out tho. /geek moment

4
Law_Student•

There's a difference between protecting people and a police state. Even if a police state would result in fewer crimes, we still don't accept it. You have to do the full cost/benefit analysis before crying 'think of the children' and going with what turns out to be the bad choice when it is thoroughly considered.

4
AnUnknown•

Monitoring public social networks is akin to monitoring newspapers and radio stations, only its more efficient thanks to today's technology. It's not about spying as much as it is knowing what's going on.

Spying would be getting nonpublic information, hacking accounts, running dummy accounts (which we all know happens as it is, but that's not being talked about here), etc. Parsing publicly available information is merely making good use of technological tools.

*edit I'd also like to add that a police state, by definition, results in more crimes. Perhaps fewer heinous crimes, or crimes with a high social cost; but more crimes overall.

4
[deleted]•

a police state, by definition, results in more crimes.

I don't think that's contained anywhere in the definition of a police state.

1
another_user_name•

Violations of fundamental rights should be consider crimes.

1
Law_Student•

Do you know what stalking is?

Collecting all publicly available information on everyone regardless of suspicion of a crime is like stalking. It's as if a police officer was following every member of the public, taking notes on where they went, who they talked to, what they ate at restaurants.

Just because it is public doesn't mean we accept the compilation of that information into databases. Observing one public fact incidentally, like a stranger in public would, and systematically compiling them all to build a picture of someone are two very different things.

1
AnUnknown•

You should learn to accept it. You do so with every EULA you sign.

It's creepy, sure; but wrong?

If wrong, then it should be illegal, right?

At which point? How much of your life can be gleaned simply from access to your Google services? Is that wrong? Think about how much money you've saved from providing your own e-mail service, the time saved for the ease of finding pretty much anything; is it worth it?

I get that it's uncomfortable to think about just how easily databases based off of public information scrapers can be built. Between Facebook, various levels of public information in the government sphere, and the ease of social engineering, it's not that hard - if you're determined - to "dox" somebody. It's pretty reasonable to be scared of that.

So, what? Now you're not going to use Google? Turn off Steam, refuse to sign up for Xbox Live, and bar yourself from the official smartphone marketplaces?

You really don't have much in the way of options. Either you accept that information you publish is going to get compiled into a database, or you don't publish information - simple. That's one of the interesting aspects of the new privacy bill I read (and subsequently cannot find) about being introduced somewhere else in Reddit the other day. One of the key tenets was forcing opt-out and delete-all-data options to users. I'd argue that that's the way to go for users to maintain some semblance of control over information they publicize. Of course, that doesn't necessarily prevent any third party bots that had scraped the user data before being removed from retaining that information - but one step at a time.

1
[deleted]•

Question:

In this case, if your privacy settings are turned to the maximum on FB, do the things you post still count as public information? What I mean by that is, if you need to be my 'friend' to read what I post or even see my profile, can this new proposed technology still glean information from it?

Just honestly curious.

4
koreth•

No, this technology won't see any posts that some random stranger who visits your Facebook profile wouldn't be able to see. If you only post friends-only, they won't be able to read any of that stuff unless you're being investigated specifically (in which case they could get a court order or whatever.)

2
[deleted]•

Thanks for the context. I suspected this would be the case, but I needed verification from an internet stranger to convince me. Because internet strangers are always right.

1
AnUnknown•

I can't say that with any certainty, I'm no expert. I would assume, though, that no they wouldn't be gleaning information that requires "friend" permissions.

Of course, that's why they set up innocent looking dummy accounts and try to convince people to friend them.

1
City_Zoo•

Even if you have friends lists to maintain privacy, if only one of those people on the list has the public setting on - your posts between you and them are splattered all over everywhere for anyone to see. The term 'Facebook Privacy List' is a contradiction in and of itself.

1
[deleted]•

Understood. I'm certainly not counting on FB to keep my information private, I try to do that myself. Mainly by not posting anything I wouldn't want anyone else to read on FB.

I was just curious how far the 'publicly available' label really applied and whether it meant that this new technology would allow the FBI of DoJ to actively bypass so-called 'security settings.'

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
lordcorbran•

The fact that they're only starting this now says something about the effectiveness of the FBI. I hope the they enjoy reading about what beers I like and my opinions on new video game releases.

3
swander42•

You really think it will end there?

3
AnUnknown•

No, I'm not that naive.

I just think the outrage should be saved for "when it doesn't end there."

1
[deleted]•

if we aren't outraged until then, we'll have no chance of doing anything about it (but like we really can at this point either)

1
AnUnknown•

They would've said the same thing about DMCA and look what happened to SOPA!

1
rabblerabble2000•

Why do you guys always go straight to conspiracy with this shit? They've been collecting information like this for decades...it's nothing new. If things worked the way you guys seem to think they do, we'd be living in a dictatorship by now.

-source: My grandfather was an FBI agent.

1
swander42•

If you wait until it happens, it is too late. I don't like data mining at all, but I am in agreement that if you don't want your data out there, then don't put it out there publicly. But you would be naive to think that they will only be going after publicly available information. I don't mean to sound paranoid, but our government is obviously starting to realize the internet has the potential to make things difficult for them. Without social media, the Occupy Movement wouldn't have really existed. There was almost zero media coverage during Occupy or about SOPA, you can bet they were behind that. Controlling the mass media used to work when trying to keep the masses calm. But they can't really control the internet, or at least not yet..So this is a nice runner up to let them target civil disobedience online before it becomes widespread in RL. Again, I hate to sound paranoid, but the evidence really is kind of mounting up.

1
AnUnknown•

Of course they're gonna try. It's in their best interests to try. It only makes sense, as a current holder of this sort of power, to do anything you can to maintain it. That goes for the Government just as much as it does the MPAA and RIAA.

I find it interesting to hear the argument that the Occupy movement wouldn't have existed without the internet, specifically because of the Vietnam war protests they mimicked (in some ways).

1
tuprmdrpm•

Facebook - which gives you the opportunity to filter your information amongst different groups - is not public in the same way a park or street is (or if it is it does a damn good job of making sure it doesn't appear that way on the surface - I, as a user, cannot access private profiles for example). What I say on Facebook should stay on Facebook for the viewing pleasure of my designated groups(as well as the company itself) but I do not buy into the idea that it's ok to collect my personal information that can be traced back to me as an individual. I hate the idea of everything on the internet somehow becoming public just because you post it; that should not be the case no matter what vulnerabilities electronic, connected machines have.

You make it sound as if giving information to a third party automatically makes it available for everyone.

3
AnUnknown•

By default, your Facebook profile and its contents are publicly available. As in, anybody can see what's on your wall, what photos you've uploaded, who your friends are, etc.

You do have the power to change these settings to be more secure, however most people do not.

OP is talking about government organizations scraping this publicly available data for their own use.

If you are using Facebook and can't be responsible enough to concern yourself with the safety and security of your private information then that's your own doing.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
AnUnknown•

I have a friend who has her entire profile public, including all of her photos, and had her profile pic as her tattooed tits. No face, no nothing; just boobs. Framed perfectly to have no nipple and thus not run afoul of decency policies. All publicly available.

It's pretty common.

Stupid, but common.

2
Oatbananor•

the park is private to those who visit it at a given time.

facebook is public for everyone forever.

1
omarqazi•

Exactly. Imagine how fucking stupid the FBI would look if the day before an attack, the attacker posted his plans publicly on Facebook or Twitter.

As long as its just public data, it's alright. We just have to watch closely to make sure they don't eventually start expanding into collecting private data.

3
AnUnknown•

Precisely.

Again, though, that raises the question of who the actual evil is, the one asking the question or the one giving the answer? If Facebook, as an example, is complicit and allows private data to be scraped (as opposed to being forced to allow such things), then Facebook is the 'evil,' not the enforcement.

1
Enlightenment777•

If you want to fill up their collection bucket and force them to waste time looking at all of your emails / twits / comments, then put keywords in everything that you write.

Back in the day, people use to add lots of crazy keywords to their emails and usenet posts, just for this purpose.

2
AnUnknown•

I wanted to come up with some witty reply chocked full of words like TERRORIST, BOMB, HEROIN and JIHAD, but I'm not that witty. So instead, have a BLAST.

6
Enlightenment777•

agree and upvoted you, so does that mean they examined this comment?

1
Enlightenment777•

I'm sure your comment is going to BOMB, lolz

1
[deleted]•

I've assumed this was happening ever since they announced Twitter feeds will be running through the Library of Congress.

I mean, really? They need to capture historic tweets? Yeah right.

2
Supertrinko•

I've taken my family tree back as far as I can (1663), how I would have loved it if they had twitter back then, one little tweet that said "Miss my dad [insert name here]".

Information from an average guy, finding use hundreds of years later.

2
[deleted]•

Oh, I completely agree! I'm just saying I seriously doubt the motivations of the government here.

Plus, there's the flip side. Do you really want to see pictures of your then-13-year-old grandmother acting like a total skank?

2
Supertrinko•

Agreed, I have no interest in the promiscuity of my grandparents. However, I would absolutely want it if it were a picture of my 16th century ancestors, simply because it told me what they looked like.

And in 1000 years time, almost every little tweet you post will tell your descendants something about you.


Yes you're right, the motives of the people who want to collect this data however, are suspect.

1
heliosdiem•

This is an awesome concept. I concur.

1
[deleted]•

Yeah I really don't understand why people are freaking out so much. This is more of a big picture app than a "John Smith just bragged about speeding on the highway!!" app. It's so that if suddenly thousands of people in Iran start tweeting or updating their facebook about an event they're tuned in quickly.

2
[deleted]•

You've read 1984, right?

2
bongilante•

For real STOP PUTTING ILLEGAL SHIT ON THE INTERNET ESPECIALLY IF YOU CAN IDENTIFIED BY SAID ILLEGAL SHIT. Frankly I'm surprised they weren't already.

2
zombiphylax•

Not only that, but they have a list of your acquaintances.

1
bsilver•

Since when is the government interested in what their constituents want? Last I knew the closest they came to this was having outraged or unbalanced constituents contact them. They have no interest in seeking opinions or input...

1
AnUnknown•

Gotta stamp out those OWS hippies before they're able to do something crazy like take over a downtown park again, duh.

2
Code_For_Food•

If any non-private information that you shared with anyone is fair game for the government to collect, store, and analyze, you won't mind agents questioning your friends, co-workers, and family to make sure you're not up to anything.

1
AnUnknown•

If I'm under investigation then no, I don't mind agents questioning my friends, co-workers, and family. Isn't that what police are employed to do, investigate?

3
Code_For_Food•

Way to focus. If you're under active investigation, you're minding or not minding is irrelevant. However, we're discussing an article that is about the FBI using constant monitoring to look for things to investigate.

So, once again, are you still comfortable with having government agents question your friends, family, co-workers, etc, to make sure you're NOT up to something?

1
AnUnknown•

Is that what they're doing?

Or are they reading things that I've posted to a publicly available portal?

Very different.

1
CactusA•

I completely agree with you. In my country it was big news that the government was planning on doing this when they tried it. And it was met with such backlash that they had to back down. Because storing and analyzing large pools of data about citizens is a big fucking deal and it doesn't matter if it is public already.

Also this: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rI8INgw0xq0

1
xopitseleh•

So many up upvotes.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mitttheserialkiller•

Because following people around, reading their emails, facebook and twitter postings, bank accounts, etc. is something a secret police of a repressive government would do. Not America, where the agencies should be busy fighting real crime, not treating Occupy protesters or PETA as terrorists, for example.

1
AnUnknown•

Emails are private. Reading those without a warrant would be a breach of law.

Facebook posts are (usually) public. Reading those (public posts) without a warrant is A-OK.

Private Facebook posts are private. Reading those without a warrant (or an invitation) is a breach of the law.

Twitter posts are (usually) public. Reading those (public posts) without a warrant is A-OK.

Bank accounts are private. Examining those without a warrant would be a breach of law.

Do you see the difference?

1
mitttheserialkiller•

Breach of law? Not a chance. Especially when you're dealing with the NSA, CIA, or military.

1
AnUnknown•

What are you saying? That it's impossible for the NSA, CIA or military to break the law?

Derp.

1
Sumgi•

I work as a federal contractor and I can tell you that this has already existed for at least a couple years. DoD and the Intellegence community primarily wanted it to find relationships, A talks to B and B talks to C who then talks to D etc.. Not really concerned with what people say, just who they say it to. Here you can see that Greenplum started developing their Federal practice in 2009. My current client who is Federal is deploying the same product and the Federal Reserve has implemented it as well for the purpose of analyzing mortgage data.

1
AnUnknown•

But I only just learned about it now, OUTRAGE!!!!!

1
socialtangent•

Anyone with a keyboard and an Internet connection can read what you post publicly to Facebook, Twitter, Reddit, any social site. It's not just the FBI who has this ability. Anyone can.

1
AnUnknown•

And that's precisely the point. ANYONE can get at this data. Why are we acting so shocked when members of the US Government and/or enforcement are considered part of the "Anyone" group?

1
Oatbananor•

the first problem is that people just throw shit for the entire earth to permanently know about as if they were in a classroom or something.

privacy isn't just your thoughts vs the world , if you share something with 5 people and 6 people know about it , your privacy is degraded. there should be more education on the matter esp for kids.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
dustout•

Your view that the government should be watching everything we do is why we can't have nice things... like freedom.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
AnUnknown•

My view is that it is in the Government's best interests to watch as much as they can. And that scraping and collating publicly available information - be it from newspapers or social media sites - is well within the scope of what is legal for a government to do.

That's precisely the reason documents like the Constitution exist, to protect the people against the best interests of the government, as they aren't necessarily going to be the same as one another.

Nothing about scraping and sorting publicly available data runs afoul of the constitution.

1
ramp_tram•

Nowhere are we talking about getting data that isn't already available to the public.

Except in the case of a locked down Facebook account or a private twitter account.

-9
AnUnknown•

And where in the article or in the source document of said article does it say anything about monitoring the contents of a "locked down" Facebook account or a private twitter account? It doesn't, because it specifically says it is looking to scrape publicly available information.

9
ramp_tram•

"The US Federal Bureau of Investigation [FBI] has quietly released details of plans to continuously monitor the global output of Facebook, Twitter and other social networks

There you go. Work on that reading comprehension.

-22
AnUnknown•

The bureau's wish list calls for the system to be able to automatically search "publicly available" material from Facebook, Twitter and other social media sites for keywords relating to terrorism, surveillance operations, online crime and other FBI missions

There you go. Work on that reading comprehension.

18
Crane_Collapse•

.. which they have no access to. Christ, people here can be dumber than dogshit.

4
ramp_tram•

"The US Federal Bureau of Investigation [FBI] has quietly released details of plans to continuously monitor the global output of Facebook, Twitter and other social networks,

Just like the other guy who replied to me, you need to brush up on your reading comprehension skills.

-5
AnUnknown•

Dumber than dogshit, indeed.

4
Humanstein•

Are you actually stupid?

3
Gaffit•

Honestly, I assumed they were doing this crap already.

My big concern here is that whole "Protest is a mild form of social terrorism" thing the FBI decided on a couple years ago. If something like this is used to stop actual terrorists, awesome. If this is used to preemptively stop constitutionally protected protest, then yeah...

267
acertainpointofview•

So who wants to start placing bets on which type of 'terrorism' this type of monitoring will be used on first?

Haven't seen or heard of many bombings in America lately... plenty of protesting though.

98
fillerpma•
51
idk42•

And the fact that the PATRIOT Act is used against non-terrorists and routinely abused and further, there is a secret interpretation of the PATRIOT Act as vaguely explained by recent reddit-hero Senator Wyden.

So basically, we aren't even allowed to know what the law is, although the law doesn't seem to matter either. Business as usual.

13
Blappelgydol•

As is terrorists go around posting their plans on facebook.com for all their friends to read. Wake up, people!

23
NeoPlatonist•

Oh! The Oslo bomber had a facebook account, therefore all terrorists use facebook. Sounds logical.

2
upton-ogood•

I don't think this is just about Facebook. It's about you -- yes, you. If you're on Reddit, disseminating information and encouraging direct action, you are probably the kind of person the FBI wants to monitor.

It's hard to imagine the FBI being so interested in what people post on Facebook and Twitter but not being interested in what people post on Reddit -- especially given the role that Reddit and Redditors play not only in disseminating information, but also in encouraging and organizing actions. Things like widely disseminating information regarding police brutality (e.g. Lt. John Pike, the causally pepper-spraying cop) or child abuse (e.g. Judge William Adams) to such an extent that it forces corporate media coverage as well as an official response, disseminating a targeted person's information (e.g. name, rank/title/position, contact information, superior's/supervisor's contact information, official's contact information -- as well as sometimes posting a targeted person's personal information -- etc.), and encouraging other Redditors to take some form of direct action (e.g. calling and officially complaining or demanding a targeted person's resignation/termination, threatening a boycott, etc.) tend to catch the attention of the FBI. Things like threatening and organizing a boycott that forces GoDaddy to change its stance on SOPA within the span of a day or so, or providing much of the fuel for last week's SOPA blackout (not just participating in the blackout, but providing a forum for the blackout itself to be discussed, encouraged, planned, and to gain momentum and support) also tend to catch the attention of the FBI. And things like providing at least one staging ground for organizing a large, popular, grassroots social movement (i.e. OWS), disseminating information about it and keeping people informed about it even as it's being ignored by corporate media, forcing it into the public debate and then keeping it there, and significantly altering Americans' class consciousness is definitely something that's going to catch the attention of the FBI.

And it's not that the FBI doesn't monitor what people say and do on social networks already; I'm sure they do. It's that their current methods are apparently not quite up to snuff for what they want. If you read their Request for Information, it looks like the application the FBI wants is specifically geared towards gathering real time intelligence on breaking events as they unfold. Users have to be able to create, define, and select search parameters/keywords on the fly and create and disseminate spot reports for their superiors about "threats/incidents." This is not so much about trying to ferret out a handful of terrorists secretly plotting to carry out some nefarious plan as it is about trying to monitor the public in order to be ready to respond to large-scale actions and demonstrations.

2
frankle•

I would like to say that's because they're doing their jobs, but I honestly don't know. I'd love to hear about foiled terrorist plots, but I don't think they'd tell, do you? Then again, this being an election year, now is as good a time as any to start talking about it.

11
[deleted]•

They would absolutely tell you. They LOVE to hype up potential terrorist attacks, and then pat themselves on the back for how they "foiled it". Just look at this September when there was NOTHING but coverage on the "expected terrorist attack" that everyone got from a "reliable source" etc. etc. They spent three days talking about how tight security will be because there was such an "imminent threat". Then nothing happened and they gave themselves a victory because maybe it was the tightened security that scared the terrorists off.

So yeah if there was ever a threat/failed attempt they would love to tell us about it. It helps the government justify all of their civil liberty violations - i.e. reminding the public why NDAA, Patriot Act, and Guantanomo are all still "necessary".

32
GigglesMcFuckCunt•

...all paid for by your hard earned tax dollars!

3
anothershittyUN•

that's not completely true. for my job, we get "privileged" information about TSA "events" around the country, and much of it would make them look great. they don't release it, though, because it's security sensitive.

1
darkscream•

It's called "Security Theatre" and it's pretty much all the US government-media complex is about these days.

1
beetlejuice02•

You can find them all at the NEFA Foundation site.

7
acertainpointofview•

upvote for the NEFA Foundation suggestion. There is some data here.

1
Stingwolf•

I'd love to hear about foiled terrorist plots, but I don't think they'd tell, do you?

They would be falling over themselves to tell the public about foiled terrorist plots. It keeps the money flowing into their departments. They don't tell because there's nothing to tell, not because it's some secret.

4
acertainpointofview•

This is a pretty good point and something I considered when making that comment. If we could see some sort of progress that plots are being foiled all the time, I think it would go a long way to reassuring the American people that these steps are indeed necessary. As long as they obfuscate any success that these sacrifices to our civil liberties have gained for America under the guise of national security, Americans will question and eventually resist the authority of the government if it continues to attempt to erode away at our freedoms. A police state is a win for the terrorists, and all that.

3
titsffs•

I for one don't think these type of terrorist "missions" happen very often and I am surprised that people would actually think that it does.. scare tactics gogo

8
[deleted]•

had a friend that worked for the FERDBEYE they have always monitored this kind of thing and kept active files - scans of news articles all sorts of things since forever - if its been out there they have it

1
kiwifuel•

I agree. There are plenty of bad guys out there. The whole point of terrorism is to... "terrorize". If people don't find out about failed attempts, it defeats the purpose of commit an act in the first place.

Also, in my own opinion, a majority of funds from Islamic extremists is going into the war in Afghanistan to fight troops.

Have you heard of the drone bombings along the Afghan/Pakistan border? Those aren't good people. Just saying.

-1
Blappelgydol•

You actually believe this is about terrorism? Brainwashed much?

13
[deleted]•

What does this have anything to do with monitoring Americans' social media postings? There's a war going on - they are bad people - that doesn't excuse watching what citizens are doing.

10
klafka•

How terrible of them. Killing our robotic death machines!

2
88leo•

Though I think that publicizing failed attempts by known groups could possibly destroy those groups credibility and hurt their recruiting.

1
Sequoioideae•

This shits just gonna be used to battle protests before they pickup. How long until they start censoring? America saw how powerful social networking was in the Arab spring revolts, now they are preemptively attempting to stop it from happening in the US.

1
JGPH•

Haven't you heard? Protesters are the new bombers.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
acertainpointofview•

No, but to be fair I don't visit many prisons often.

It is interesting to note however that The Press Freedom Index has recently downgraded the United States to 47th from a position of 20th this year as a direct result of the incarceration of [journalists] (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/01/25/press-freedom-occupy-wall-street-us-arrests_n_1230825.html_) who were covering the OWS protests. I'm sure plenty of protestors were as well.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
MeowMule•

You mean like the man from Occupy Portland who used a molotov cocktail in Portland's World Trade Center then hid in their camp?

Edit: Before you downvote, I was responding to the comment that the person hadn't seen many of the bombings in America--only protesting--not making a statement about discrediting the Occupy movement. I understand people generally react badly when a fact goes against their preconceived emotional biases, but this did happen, and provides a counter example to OP of this particular comments suggestion. I am a supporter of the Occupy movement, but not a blind supporter--like most people tend to be.

0
mitttheserialkiller•

Sounds like some lone crazy lunatic goes to cause trouble, what does that have to do with the Occupy movement?

0
MeowMule•

I never said it had to do with the Occupy Movement in the sense you are suggesting. If you weren't so quick to read only what you wanted to following your emotional bias, as critical thinkers avoid doing, you'd see I was responding to the comment that the person hadn't seen many of the bombings in America--only protesting. This person bombed a American building, and was part of a protest. That is what I responding to--not a statement about the Occupy Movement in general.

Also, the whole "lone crazy lunatic" really takes away the responsibility of the society and environmental factors that produce those "lone crazy lunatics", you should read Murakami's Underground: The Tokyo Gas Attack and the Japanese Psyche if you'd like a better insight into this.

I don't think you realise how ironic it is that the view that these actions are simply committed by lone crazy lunatics is, considering it is justification used by "the 1%" as the Occupy Movement would call them, to take away responsibility from the factors in society that produces them. In fact, I'd think Occupiers themselves would point this out, the same way the Occupiers in Portland pointed out that the complaint about the mentally ill homeless gathering at their camp raised awareness about the problem of homelessness and lack of quality mental health care in Portland and greater America.

Edit: Oh, and also the fact that people in the Occupy camp did not report this guy, though they knew before hand his plan.

2
yes_thats_right•

It was used during the London riots to preempt future breakouts. It was also used successfully to charge at least one person with inciting riots.

I am in favour of what happened here, although it does seem to lurk dangerously close to a grey area.

-1
tekgnosis•

Various agencies have similar things, the FBI started with Carnivore and the NSA help run the Echelon network.

22
[deleted]•

Don't forget Magic Lantern.

11
tekgnosis•

Oops, looks like I just did :p Jokes aside I was just throwing out some of the better known examples to confirm what Gaffit said.

4
[deleted]•

No doubt. I was just throwing out a keyword to help an agent have a laugh this morning.

8
Clumpy•

To be honest, the level of white noise here probably protects any individual person who doesn't already know that what they're saying and doing is going to put them on the government's radar. I just feel really sorry for the poor guy whose circumstantial physical evidence and Facebook posts will coincide to make him a suspect when he shouldn't be. This is why we're supposed to have due process, and I don't really trust our "throw them all into Gitmo and let God sort them out" government to use this information wisely.

20
Blappelgydol•

Even so. People will always make empty threats. People will always say they're gonna do stuff even if they're not gonna do it. This type of scanning and prevention is very wrong.

12
Richard_Ramsbottom•

Yup. A DMV gets bombed and the FBI combs its archive so it can round up everyone who posted "ugh I hate the DMV, I wish it would just explode" as terror suspects.

6
mexicodoug•

The info is far more likely to be used by somebody with influence to target somebody they don't like. Martin Luther King Jr. is probably the most famous innocent target of the FBI. After years of surveillance they couldn't get anything more damning on him than his sexual dalliances, so they used that info against him.

If somebody with clout decides that you or I should be targetted they can use the FBI to pull up all the info on our internet activity in an organized manner and sift through it in order to attack or blackmail us.

There is no doubt that given the tool, it will be used.

"Terrorism" is just a word used to fool us now that they can't scare us with "communism," the real game is the same one it's always been: maintenance and increase of power and control by those who already are powerful.

Our only defense is a more equitable distribution of power; specifically, more democracy in the political sphere and more equitable wealth distribution in the economic sphere.

2

This is your receipt, this is my receipt for your receipt, and this your receipt for my receipt for your receipt for Mr Buttle.

2
Clumpy•

One of my friends is going to school to become a military interrogator. Despite being very patriotic, he's actually a school of the "build a rapport and mutual understanding" school of interrogation. Still, I like to tell him that as soon as he graduates they're going to tell him: "Congratulations! Here's your diploma. And here's your baby mask."

2
[deleted]•

It seems to me any halfway competent terrorist wouldn't use words that would be on a terrorist keyword list. On facebook. It would identify a bunch of gamers though.

14
[deleted]•

And redditors lol.

3
Mumberthrax•

I don't think it is intended to be used against real terrorists, but against potential homegrown ones. Have you been putting up anti-TSA comments or pro-OWS videos? You may not be trained to be a terrorist, but you'll be on their radar in case you start becoming more bold.

2
lalilulelo09•

CS fans are screwed

1
newtotheinterpoops•

Also honestly: even if terrorism on the scale of 9/11 happened every year or so, it falls into the background noise compared to so many other causes of fatalities and (financial) loss. The only thing that makes it special is that it's scarier because it's tangible and immediately televised in full intensity. Oh, and also because it's something we feel isn't under our control, unlike a lot of the other dangers that we also can't control well.

Basically, there's very little potential benefit to society from this vs. the costs, especially when the costs include a huge budget that could have reduced fatalities and (financial) losses much more significantly in both the short and long term.

11
evemarketbot•

I'm not so sure its negligibility in terms of lives and cost matters that much. Terrorism is more about the threat of being murdered if you don't act/live/vote a certain way.

With that in mind, it's kind of sick how our government hypes up all its actions as being crucial to preventing attacks. Threatening that someone else will murder you if you don't do as you're told is almost as bad.

1
newtotheinterpoops•

That's exactly it. Terrorism is only effective if you feel terrified of it. The government constantly reminding us of the dangers of terrorism has the exact same effect as terrorism itself, except the cost of engaging in multiple wars is much higher and most of the fatalities are citizens of [not America]. I'm sort of going on a tangent here, but by pissing off entire countries, we're pretty well shooting ourselves in the foot by nurturing a future wave of terrorism in an effort to fight terrorism in the short term.

1
evemarketbot•

assuming that fighting terrorism is actually the main thing they're trying to do.

1
[deleted]•

Couldn't agree more. I'm no expert but I'm pretty sure terrorists don't post their plans or any useful information on the internet...

However, I know for a fact that people who are planning protests or civil disobedience frequently use social media to publicize the event. Search terms will quickly go from "terrorism" to "protest". And I would say that anyone who is Muslim can expect their profiles to be red flagged.

8
Mumberthrax•

Protestors scare me - you could say I'm terrified of them, I suppose. This is America and I have the right to not be terrified, the right to feel free and safe. These terrorists are scaring me and my friends and family, so they need to be stopped. I don't like some of the stuff the government has to do to stop terrorists, but if it means my loved ones are safe then sometimes you have to accept that. I know that God will keep the good people safe from danger, so I'm pretty sure the only terrorists who are punished will be the ones who refuse to be saved.

/s

1
[deleted]•

Protestors scare you? What's wrong with you hahaha

2
Mumberthrax•

I wasn't being serious. :p

1
R34C7•

Anyone with a slight grasp of power threatened with losing it will reach for whatever tools have been left at their disposal. The only way to protect our rights is to fight governments having such tools at their disposal.

4
beetlejuice02•

I don't know if Facebook was directly involved, but by monitoring social networking sites the FBI has stopped a lot of terrorist plans. Summeries of the cases with links to actuals docs are all listed on the NEFA Foundation sites. There has been a lot more than the media covered. For instance there was a second shooting attempt on the army base by fanatical soldier that had the shooting a while back. Can't think of all the details off the top of my head. Not saying this kind of monitoring can't or won't be abused, but it has been ussed to prevent terrorist attacks. This type of electronic monitoring is probably the most sited method of catching on to these people.

4
Blappelgydol•

Today, eveything that the government doesn't like is called terrorism. It's a word meant to go hand in hand with their views. It's a word that enables them to become a police state. It's a word that should be used as little as possible. Today everyone is calling everyone a terrorist and that's a VERY dangerous thing to do.

6
beetlejuice02•

I didn't say it couldn't be abused. I said it has been used to prevent very REAL and VIOLENT terrorist attacks against American citizens and is one of the primary methods used to prevent these attacks. All the information is out there. But I guess that isn't even a factor in your thinking process, since you just glossed right over it. These prevented attacks weren't just an arbitrary viewpoint of terrorism for not agreeing with the government. They were planned, coordinated, trained, and equiped attacks aimed at KILLING American civilians on American soil. But I guess your right and the FBI shouldn't have anything to do with this or shouldn't be pressing their viewpoints on these people.

3
Blappelgydol•

How do you know that these so-called very real and violent terrorist attacks are actually that: real?

1
TROLOLERT•

I prevented an attack against you, just now. I can produce documents to prove it.

You'd better obey my ridiculous, unconstitutional demands from now on... It's for your own safety.

0
88leo•

A single person motivated to shoot at people isn't necessarily a terrorist. Yet, you sheepishly followed the talking points and said it was a terrorist attack prevented instead of just the pre-crime police preventing a murder.

-1
NeoPlatonist•

Nice try, FBI agent.

0
beetlejuice02•

I rest my case.

2
[deleted]•

My thoughts exactly... They probably want to go after Anonymous and 'hacktivist' groups mostly.

2
NeoPlatonist•

The police-state doesn't need to get rid of the constitution, they simply have to continually redefine it in such a way that its 'protections' become meaningless. With each erosion, the population becomes more accustomed to their shackles. Millions have already been conditioned to submit to TSA pat downs.

The water simply needs to be turned up a bit higher to completely boil the frog.

2
TruthHammer•

Yep, Chomsky 101.

Too bad he already had his 2 or 3 AMAs years ago and I doubt he would come back to Reddit in it's current state.

2
JGPH•

They are, through AT&T. The difference is that the AT&T setup monitors all unfiltered internet traffic, even that which bounces through but otherwise has neither an American origin or destination. This is another waste of American taxpayer money from a different government branch which could be accomplished by adding filters onto the NSA's existing infrastructure at AT&T for much cheaper. Note also, this "monitoring only American traffic" s bullshit. On the Internet, there are no political boundaries.

2
A_User•

I blocked all of facebook's servers in my hosts file long ago.

The FBI might not have been doing it on any great scale until now, but I guarantee that the CIA has been doing it for years.

2
[deleted]•

NDAA then monitoring your face book status -> easy way to abduct people - just an algorithm that parses status with a correlative database on thoughts from terrorists. streamline convictions

1
maplethorpe•

Thanks for your terrifying perspective :) Reminds me of the movie Brazil.

1
[deleted]•

thought crime - 1984 dude paranoia isn't necessary but the technology is all lined up to be abused, all it takes is one despot . . .

1
dvfree•

If something like this is used to stop actual terrorists, awesome.

The question I would ask is what percentage of the traffic belongs to terrorists and what percentage to protected speech? At what point do the ends not justify the means?

1
[deleted]•

They're probably afraid people will use social media to participate in a widespread anti-government civil-disobedience type of protest. Like if everyone pledges to stop paying their income taxes if enough people get "on board" with the idea.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
m0deth•

Oh, like to be used for coordinated suppression of legal protest? Naw, that wouldn't happen, they're just going for the "bad guys"....wake up please, I'll even buy the first cup of Joe.

1
Fyzzle•

What kind of shitty terrorist is going to tweet about it publicly?

1
DisregardMyPants•

My big concern here is that whole "Protest is a mild form of social terrorism" thing the FBI decided on a couple years ago. If something like this is used to stop actual terrorists, awesome. If this is used to preemptively stop constitutionally protected protest, then yeah...

How many actual terrorists do you think are on Facebook?

1
BokononHelpUs•

Agreed. This is actually an extremely logical move, in my opinion. It makes sense that, if you are in the business of gathering intelligence, you should just go looking in a place where people volunteer this information for all to see. I understand the concern that people might not understand that what they post on the internet isn't just viewed by their friends, but most of us understand that this is not the case by now. This is nothing compared to the NDAA and the Patriot Act that strip constitutional freedoms from citizens of the United States. The (sad) fact is that internet privacy, in fact privacy of any kind, is not a protected constitutional right. If the FBI were to use this information to halt non-violent protesting (which, as you've said, is a constitutional right), then that would be extremely alarming. The fact that no one here would put it past the agencies of the Federal Government to do something of that very nature is what should be focused on. The real crisis here is not that people will see your tweets and Facebook posts without your knowledge, it is that we have a government who is knowingly working in direct opposition to the will of its citizens, and that these citizens now have to live in fear that their government is working against them.

1
newloaf•

Did you know there aren't any 'actual terrorists' in the United States? At least not foreign born ones.

0
mexicodoug•

The reality is that anybody who wants to kill a bunch of innocent civilians can figure out how to do it quite easily, unless they are a complete moron. Fortunately, the vast majority of people who want to kill a bunch of innocent civilians are complete morons.

1
ActuallyMike•

FBI: Well we've learned that Becky is single again, and OMG she looks sOOOOOOO cute in that bikini!

93
[deleted]•

[deleted]

46
ToAGasChamberGo•

Mission successful, her relationship status set to "It's Complicated"

7
ADifferentMachine•

It's okay. They just want to protect our freedoms from the terrorists.

38
roadbuzz•

Damn terrorists! Forcing our great government to spy on us.

17
[deleted]•

[deleted]

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
Overlay•

The FBI isn't some real-life CTU. Domestic criminals are just as much of a priority. Monitoring social media would be extremely efficient, and I'm not sure why it took them so long to do this.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

37
blackstar9000•

It isn't really spying if you volunteered that information.

15
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
[deleted]•

Who does Facebook sell your information to?

1
FenderJazzbass•
1
NeoPlatonist•

The Stasi would be impressed.

2
AddisonH•

Yeah, hopefully they can't actu

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
pvk8336•

saw it on a YouTube video, must be true

10
NeoPlatonist•

Immediately dismissed something because I'm so smurt and Youtubes is dumb.

-1
Cid420•

I'm hoping it's just a joke. It's like when I called bullshit on some redditor for making fun of a guy because he "learned something new on YouTube". It's like, really dude, in this day and age, I'd be more surprised if there was someone who hasn't learned something new from YouTube.

(not implying video linked above is legit)

1
FenderJazzbass•

Is anonymity is a superpower ?

2
pnettle•

Christ almighty. Its fucking sad if you genuinely believe that huge ass stretch of a connection they made somehow gives them magic access. And that no facebook employee has come forward blowing the lid off it? In this day and age, they wouldn't get away with it.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
pnettle•

So in your mind the NSA and CIA are the same thing?

Also again, you did nothing to convince me that an employee at facebook would not have found the CIA hooks and blew it open in a big story. Especially given the massively tenuous link to the CIA.

Facebook has fucktons of privacy and data concerns, but most of that scare originates facebook itself and not some magical shadowy conspiracy with the CIA.

0
mix0•

everyone knows about room 641A and frankly, I would be surprised if they WEREN'T already doing that shit, it's their job.

but saying the CIA owns Facebook is fucking retarded and you should just go back to r/conspiracy

0
dickbucket•

TL;DR of the video: rich people are evil.

1
BokononHelpUs•

And then the NSA spies on the FBI and CIA! I know, I've played Splinter Cell.

2
paolog•

All 7 billion of us? Wow.

1
[deleted]•

I'd be more concerned about the backdoors the NSA has.

23
brownpanther•

Ever wonder why the NSA gets little attention, and the FBI (domestic law enforcement program) and CIA (international intelligence program) do. Because the NSA ( security and asset protection program) does most of the dirty work they don't want you to know about.

9
AddisonH•

That's it! I just recently realized this the other day while on my Windows boot. I was running netstat and noticed a few IPs that shouldn't have been there. I ran a quick WHOIS. Turns out tha

4
nubbin99•

Tango down.

3
mexicodoug•

The NSA does the dirty work of collecting intelligence and using it to maintain and expand international corporate power, but the FBI and CIA, in addition to collecting intelligence, carry out operations, many of which, like the FBI's COINTELPRO and the CIA's Phoenix Program, have been extremely dirty indeed.

Edit: I tried googling NSA security and asset protection program and didn't get any useful info. If you can disprove my statement above I'd be much obliged if you'd provide a reputable link to the info.

2
NeoPlatonist•

The NSA was practically unknown for quite some time, then its activities and existence became a bit publicized. Who knows what agency took their place as the blackops intel org.

0
Boveus•

How do you "quietly" announce something? If people are that worried about other people reading what they post on the internet they shouldn't post it to begin with...

It's not like law enforcement looking at twitter and facebook is a huge deal anyway. Everyone already has the capability of doing exactly what the FBI wants to do... Just take a look at these sites:

Facebook- http://openstatussearch.com/ http://youropenbook.org/

Twitter- http://tweetscan.com/ http://tweepz.com/

The bigger issue, at least for me, is that there are already resources out there doing the exact thing the FBI wants to contract someone out for. This is a waste of public resources.

As far as their "peering into the future" idea... take a look at https://recordedfuture.com/ it does that too.

20
ramp_tram•

Quiet announcements happen all the time. You issue a statement, but don't play it as a big thing.

4

'Take out the trash day'.

You want it to have been announced should anyone ask you about it in the future (or accuse you of trying to hide it). Then you wait for a busy time in the news cycle and bury it.

3
will7•

Ignore this comment.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
forgetfuljones•

Glad you get chuckles.

Of course people are concerned, when they hear things like 'you are all going on 365/24/7 surveillance of one form or another.'

It's one thing to investigate committed crimes, or monitor known problems, etc etc. It is quite another, in my opinion, to monitor every scrap of data about every person that you can get your mitts on. The first is a healthy act, the second is symptomatic of totalitarianism.

If I post on facebook "That's it, tomorrow I'm going into work with an uzi" after a trying day, I do NOT want my name to have flashed across someone's desk. I don't think it's reasonable.

If I get pulled aside in an airport ten years later, because my name matches one on a list, I don't want an anonymous suit telling me "well, you have made threats in the past, we're just being safe."

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
MikeOnFire•

How do you "quietly" announce something? If people are that worried about other people reading what they post on the internet they shouldn't post it to begin with...

/Thread over.

-5
toconnor•

You know it is bad when life imitates The Onion.

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
zemo•

did anyone actually read their paper? There's an implicit admission that there is a national grid of cameras. In section I.E.v, under operational capabilities:

Traffic Video - Ability to display video feeds from traffic cameras to monitor traffic patterns, obstructions, bottle necks, protestors, and flash mobs.

but honestly, the paper is amateur in its wording and structure. It's obviously written by someone with no experience managing a software project before. Some of the requirements are things that can already be done with public tools, some of the requirements are so vague they don't mean anything, and some of the requirements are literally impossible. There are functional requirements and then UI descriptors just kind of, littered about. E.g., they know they want a drop down for some thing, but they don't know what the overall UI for that thing looks like. I like this one:

Must provide a drop-down menu with pre-identified "word search" criteria.

...what the fuck does that mean? Where is this drop-down, why is it a drop-down and not, say, a scrollable list? Wait, is this a web application, or is it a desktop application? Pre-identified? What're you retarded? Don't you want to keep a history of recent searches?

Ability for the user to create new "key word(s)" searches on the "fly" for identifying and monitoring new threats as they emerge.

...what? Why is fly in quotes? What is the definition of threat, and how can it be applied to the key word? E.g., someone adds a "key word" of "Elmo" and you want to search only for threatening occurrences of Elmo-related events? What?

woah, the FBI wants to farm public data. That's not shocking, it's their fucking job. The only thing that's surprising about this is how delusional the requirements are and how amateur the wording is. They're just going to get ripped off by a suit-wearing jackass, orating expert nonsense about the fecundity of their cloud-based enterprise hyper-scale .NET infrastructure and its endless capabilities to simultaneously do everything you've ever heard of in any sci-fi movie, television show, or Philip K Dick book. And then they ask how much it would cost to have the consultancy run their super-brain, which is required to constantly monitor all embassies and military installations world-wide (sec I.E.iii), as if there's zero possibility that the system would be compromised. So realistically, there's two outcomes to this: they spend a bunch of money and get a shitty enterprise application that over-promises and under-delivers, or they build their fantasy mega-brain and it gets compromised and used against them. Fucking. Amateurs.

11
ArseAssassin•

Going to blow up the White House.

Better update Facebook.

11
iamrunningman•

The bureau's wish list calls for the system to be able to automatically search "publicly available" material from Facebook, Twitter and other social media sites for keywords relating to terrorism, surveillance operations, online crime and other FBI missions

This is childishly simple to disable. If everyone put in these keywords at random in their posts, it would effectively flood the system with garbage and render it useless.

I am a personal fan of using phrases like "dirty bomb" , "jihad", "termination of target", etc, during routine phone calls to friends and family.

Eat my shorts, Narus, you invasive piece of shit.

7
howisthisnottaken•

The worst possible outcome of datamining is false positives. If enough people cause them then all the time is spent grabbing low hanging but false fruit and never connecting the proper dots.

5
sailorh•

Use them as slang: "This new album is a beat jihad; a dirty bomb of remixes."

4
essjay24•

flood the system with garbage

Pretty sure this is already happening.

3

Wow, another telecom surveillance company chock full of Israelis...

1
clickity-click•

...Facebook, Twitter and other social networks...

You can bet your arse reddit's on the list.

A vast majority of the "/r/askreddit" posts are a fantastic way to get people to spew intimate details about themselves past and present.

"This is my throw away account" lol.

7
blackstar9000•

You can bet your arse reddit's on the list.

Doubtful. Those social networks are useful because they routinely connect user profiles to real-world identities -- not just their own, but also those of the people and groups that they "friend" or "follow." Redditors sometimes volunteer that sort of information, but not routinely enough to make it as valuable a data set.

1
clickity-click•

Doubtful.

I disagree. There are some sick people with some twisted ways of getting their rocks off that post their fantasys on reddit and get mega upvotes for some reason. Lecter type people that the FBI would be very interested in.

I personally don't care if the FBI does this. If an individual is sketchy and insight into this person's profile and people he/she associates with helps the FBI, than more power to them in gathering as much information as possible and hopefully saving someone from serious harm.

1
DefinitelyRelephant•

There are some sick people with some twisted ways of getting their rocks off that post their fantasys on reddit and get mega upvotes for some reason. Lechter type people that the FBI would be very interested in.

Generally speaking, if you're going to use a fictional character to attempt to scare people into agreeing with your alarmist point of view, it helps to at least spell the goddamn character's name right.

It's "Lecter".

4
mexicodoug•

I recently googled my real name and on the second page clicked on a link that listed mexicodoug in the address bar. I'm sure the FBI (and other stalkers) has plenty more techniques for identifying people who use fake names on the internet.

1
blackstar9000•

That's not the point. The point is that social networking sites are of particular use to the kind of investigations that the FBI connects because they arrange people into social networks in ways that Reddit does not. Generally speaking, the FBI isn't going to be interested in one guy whose breaking the law and dropping hints about it on Reddit. There are other law enforcement agencies to deal with that. Unless you're on an murder spree spanning several states, you're likely not going to get on the FBI's radar on your own. What they want are criminal groups, and criminal groups that communicate with one another on social networking sites are basically making part of the FBI's case for them by documenting their social network via Facebook or Google+.

1
koreth•

If they find something nasty on Reddit they can get a court order to force Reddit to give up server logs to get your IP address and access history, and use that (along with whatever other information they've gathered in whatever investigation they're running) to narrow in on you. They would have to be stupid to not be monitoring Reddit.

1
blackstar9000•

If the FBI had unlimited resources, then sure, why not monitor Reddit 24/7/364? But I don't think they're out to nab individuals with this sort of surveillance. To really justify allocating resources toward tracking social networks, they have to be looking to make bigger cases, specifically cases involving criminal groups. Drug trafficking organization, white slave traders, child prostitution rings, terrorist groups -- those are the sorts of things that will justify this sort of thing to the book-keepers at the FBI, and for that sort of thing, social networking sites are simply more useful, since they function by tying people together and documenting their behavior as members of a group. Reddit does that only to a very limited extent.

Which is not to say that the FBI doesn't pay attention to Reddit, but I doubt they're putting the same resources to it that they're putting to Facebook and Twitter. Facebook's structure just doesn't lend itself to eliciting the sort of data that would be useful for the sort of investigations that would make it worthwhile.

1
mycall•

I'm sure Reddit is big enough to be targeted by the FBI too.

6
whats_that_smell•

I was head of technology for a vendor that supplies this service. There are literally hundreds of these companies, and they are hired mostly by marketers to look for instances of their (and competitor's) brands and products being mentioned. Everything you say online that isn't behind some sort of a privacy barrier ends up in the database of these vendors. If you've posted something positive or negative about any product in the last 3 years, I promise you that someone at a marketing agency has read it and put it in a report. The fact that a government agency is doing it should not be news. It's just a more efficient method of finding data than Google.

5
[deleted]•

The FBI not only has to parse for blatant explicit crime, but must also parse for code words. So who wants to write the software to parse everything everywhere for every form of words relating to crime? Plus a constantly updated dictionary complied by field agents that are codes for crimes. Is there a Kapersky algorithm for detecting crimes? :/

1
FourCounters•

Is anyone really that surprised?

4
[deleted]•

FINE! Let's fill it all up with Q's! QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQetc

4
Ouroboros_87•

Remember, they hate us for our freedom.

4
Elranzer•

"They" refers to our powers-that-be, not terrorists.

1
Ouroboros_87•
1
ransomdenton•

Then we should agree to create new slang word/phrases for the most common of activities in order to wreak havoc with their filters. Possibilities include: Eating = bombing, hitting on someone = selling some crank/exchanging mp3s, using the restroom = downloading some movies etc, etc, etc...

4
hamburgerandhotdog•

Going home to exchange mp3's and download the latest version of The Muppets right after I get done bombing the dealers I supply crank to.

2
Solkre•

I hear the FBI has technology to view the stuff I put on my lawn too! DO WE HAVE NO PRIVACY IN THE ATTENTION-WHORE-SPACE ANYMORE?

4
ZombieSocrates•

Lynch says that many people post to social media in the expectation that only their friends and followers are reading, which gives them "the sense of freedom to say what they want without worrying too much about recourse," says Lynch.

Who the hell are these clueless people? Are there really still people out there who haven't heard the horror stories of how public postings have negatively effected the employment, loan, and even relationship opportunities of numerous individuals?

4
zumzink•

I think Reddit users tend to forget that they are, as a whole, far more tech savvy than mainstream users.

Who are these clueless people? Um, how about nearly everyone I've ever met: co-workers, family, friends, strangers, people on forums, anyone on a social network. ;)

When I explain to them that what they post is potentially viewable by loan officers, interviewers, property owners -- and all of this could put them in jeopardy of losing a loan, job, or apartment -- I get dismissed as paranoid and neurotic.

Nevermind that I've been online since the early 90s and working in the industry since the mind 90s -- while their most intensive online experience is sending emails and posting FB updates about their weekend. Nevermind that I provide them with links to news articles that support my claims, everything from Slashdot to lifestyle news sources.

Worse, when they meet someone who has been DIRECTLY negatively effected by such issues (losing their job, custody battles for their children) most people just dismiss this information as "that's absurd and never going to happen to me." It's like trying to tell a teenager, that yes, they too can have a car accident, and no, they are not invincible, and please just trust our lifetime of experience on this one.

Which has partly led to my theory that the majority of internet users are the tech equivalent of adolescents, or at best teenagers:

This is something I've been thinking about a lot lately. The average person, living in the tech mainstream, hasn't had a history with the internet to understand the these kinds of privacy issues, nor do they have any comprehension of how valuable their personal information is. Nor even that their internet experience is not some insular little bubble (I equate this to the false sense of privacy people have in restaurants, as if no sound can penetrate past the boundaries of their table edge).

From their perspective, technology has always been linked to consumerism. Products and services. They don't tend to think of things in terms of information or individualism. They can't (or won't) see the big picture. To them, the internet and all its peripherals like iPhones, is kind of like TV: just merely a device for entertainment. They aren't aware they have become the product for companies like Google and Facebook.

I mean, most people weren't even socializing online prior to, say, 2006. That means they're missing the prior 15-20 years of experience to comprehend scale or growth or history. They lack the larger experience to understand the power of information.

And all of this leads to a complacency when it comes to how information is used and who is (mis)using it.

2