MIL filmed my daughter crying. And I crazy for wanting it deleted?

Discussion

We were all riding together in her van with my daughter (1) and MIL in the middle row and me in the back. Daughter was tired and starting to cry. She does this pitiful lost puppy kind of cry when she is sleepy. I understand that it may be cute or endearing, but when MIL pulled out her phone to record I saw red. I wouldn’t want a camera in my face while sleepy and upset. MIL giggles and says “I’ll have to show this to her when she’s older!”. I didn’t want to cause a scene and upset babe more so I just unbuckled and moved myself between them to calm babe so she couldn’t record more.

We are back home and babe is sleeping, but it’s bothering me that she recorded my child while crying. It doesn’t sit right and I want to ask for her to delete it. I normally get along very well with her and she would do as I ask even if she gets a little hurt by it, so I’m not too worried about that. I just want to know if I’m over reacting. MIL doesn’t get to see babe much and loves to document everything so she has things to remember by. Anyone have advice? Would you be okay with it?

Posted Aug 8, 2021, 7:35 PM UTC

1024
wilksonator•

A different opinion, but ….I wouldn’t care. It might be different if it bothered your child, but it sounds like it didn’t and just another moment in their childhood to capture.

Its so hard to remember these moments, months, years and even weeks later, it all goes so fast and even if its a bad moment…well, thats also a special memory you might want to remember. ( And seriously it is so unrealistic to pretend that childhood and growing up is all smiles and adventures that we see on fb feeds…a lot of it is crying and pains and as a parent ( or grandparent) I want to remember it all).

I think asking it her to delete is a bit much. Its already captured, why take that memory away from her and also create a rift between the two of you.

If you are really bothered, I would ask that she not video when child is upset next time,…but I would be conscious about how much of your request is about protecting the child ( fair enough) and how much of it falls into I dont like it because of my own reasons. Yes you might not like it and the child is your daughter but I always try to remember that the child is also her granddaughter….unless she is hurting the child ( and she is not, actually the opposite , it sounds like it is coming from a warm and caring place), I would think that it is her right, within the scope of her relationship to the child, to want remember these things.

27
[deleted]•

Okay, okay. I read your post and this perspective does make me less upset for OP. It all does just go by sooo fast.

3
BriefPeach•

Her intentions were nowhere near malicious. I wouldnt get too upset about it. Now, if she was always making comments about how babe cries too much or how offers unsolicited advice, that might be a different scenario. But she already doesn't see her grandchild a lot, as you said, and already thinks the cry is kind of cute, as house said, so I would let it go.

22
foxafillion•

It appears you may be projecting your own emotions onto your baby. I totally understand why you would be upset if someone filmed you crying saying it was cute but your baby does not care. If she kept recording every time your baby cries and talking about how much the baby cries yes you should definitely address it as a problem. But if it's a cute cry and she just wants it as a memory I think it's normal and fine. My guess is your child will enjoy and find her little cry endearing when she's older. Clearly the opinions on this are quite varied but it doesn't seem worth hurting your relationship with your MIL over a video that your baby will likely never care or be bothered by it being recorded. Best of luck!

14
FrenchGrammar•

THANK YOU! I feel like I’m in crazy town, people saying it’s SO disrespectful and all, like what? I kept a “book” my little brother wrote when he was like 9 and I intend to give it to him on it’s 18th birthday because it is hilariously BAD! Is it disrespectful to laugh at his young artistic attempt?! NOOOO! People need to stop taking things so seriously all the time 😅!

3
foxafillion•

I've laughed at my own artistic attempts that my parents stored away in boxes and we took out when I was in my 30's. It's fun to see the way kids express themselves and how far we come from a baby to an adult. I think the big thing is whether or not it's malicious (I have heard horror stories about some in-laws, thankfully mine are wonderful) and it's tough to know without a very comprehensive detailed outsiders POV of what happened, but I think most people are not malicious.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2†
mzchanadelerbong•

OP should do whatever will make her comfortable because she is the mother, but honestly, there probably ARE people who find crying photos of their younger selves amusing. My mom has a few of me crying over the dumbest things, and I find them pretty hilarious knowing the silly things my own toddlers cry over now (ex. their socks not fitting on their heads at hats….).

8
FrenchGrammar•

My parents took tons of videos of us as babies/toddlers and I find it hilarious and cute when I cry! Or endearing to see my mom trying to calm baby me down! Jeez, people need to calm down, it is NOT exploitative unless it’s used for social media points. If it’s just for grandma/the family and to show it to her when she’s older, it’s cute!

4
foxafillion•

I also have seen home videos of myself as a baby and have been crying and have taken video of my own child and she happens to start crying. There's absolutely nothing exploitative about it unless I start sending it to Jimmy Kimmel's garbage TV segments. We're not all huddled around laughing at a crying child, we're empathizing with the cute baby and reminiscing about the time spent together. Kids cry all the time for a huge variety of reasons, I'm not going to pretend those times didn't exist.

1
Darth-Hokie•

She probably meant no harm, but this kind of thing bothers me too. It's the "I'll show her this when she's older" part that gets me. There are pictures of me crying as a child, and they have been posted on social media by my mom and aunt. I'm in my 30s. I don't find it amusing now either.

13
rollupolly84•

My uncle would threaten to take pictures of me crying as a threat and say if I didn’t stop he’d take the pic and show me when I was older, implying I would be embarrassed. He did end up taking a picture once when I was like maybe 3 or 4. He did show it to me when I was older…I am not embarrassed. Well, I’m embarrassed for him. As an adult I know that’s more about his inability to deal with a crying chil than a problem with me crying.

It doesn’t sound like your MIL has bad intentions but if you guys get along and it bothers you, then I feel like you should at least ask her not to again. Even delete it if you would feel better because of it.

3
[deleted]•

I HATE THIS SO MUCH!! Why does anyone think this is cute or funny 🤦🏻‍♀️

3
hyrmes165•

I agree. My parents have a picture of me crying in my crib and looking right into the camera from when I was one. As a mom now, I can’t imagine seeing my young toddler crying and picking up the camera. I haven’t said anything but I find it weird and disturbing, not cute.

2
Luckyducks•

Yup. Its like using someone else's emotions for entertainment. You would never do it to an adult so why do it to a kid? Its one thing to catch your own kid crying because you were already filming but to pull out a camera instead of trying to soothe a kid is odd to me.

1
Becks_786•

My son is 3 now and I actually wish I had some videos of him crying as a baby. I don’t remember what his cry sounded like at all, and the one video I do have of him starting to cry is so adorable, I wish it was longer. It might seem weird to record such a thing now, but you honestly may wish you had it later.

I’m also glad I took pictures when he went to the ER or when he wasn’t feeling good. Taking a picture or video isn’t invasive or bothersome to a baby, and you may find you want to see and remember those things, and not just the happy times.

12
mightylittlebitty•

On the other hand, I had captured LO in the middle of a breakdown about a month ago in the car. It wasn’t until later in the day I realized she was uncomfortable bc she was hot and tired in the carseat.

I recently stumbled upon the video on my phone and it broke my heart to see her in pain like that. Ugh. Awful. I wish I could delete the memory.

1
shiftmax•

I personally wouldn’t mind it. but that’s just because my mother we lost all my siblings and our photos in a house fire and literally have 0 pictured videos or anything except for ones that other people have taken. idk also my mother in law and my mother have thousands of videos of my son probably lol. Your feelings are valid and if you want them deleted you should tell her

9
sed2017•

Aww she’s just enjoying being a grandma. If it makes you feel uncomfortable just politely ask her to delete it…

9
adventurelyfe•

I’d ask her to delete it if you’re uncomfortable with it. Your baby is a human and deserves respect, just like any other human.

5
lilbkbb•

This would rub me the wrong way for 2 reasons:

1: if my baby starts to cry, I want the first reaction of the people nearby (ie MIL) to be to like, help. Not gawk and take photos

2: I think it is a little invasive to take photos of someone without their permission when they are not at their best (and babies obviously can’t give permission, so in their absence usually parents are the ones to make the call). So I would be mildly annoyed about this from that perspective

However, up to you to weigh the pros and cons of asking MIL to delete. Only you know the calculus there about costs and benefits.

4
[deleted]•

Oh man, I’d be super upset too. If it’s that important to you, just try to kindly let her know and politely ask her to delete it. I have a hard time not losing my cool, but calmness really does help in this situation. Poor bebe!

4

If it were me I’d kindly ask her to delete it

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3†
October_13th•

I’ve told my in-laws multiple times that we don’t take photos/videos when baby is upset. I’ve had to be the “bad guy” and remind them sternly but IDGAF. I told them my rule for photos is: if you wouldn’t want someone taking a photo or video of you doing that, then don’t take one of him. So for me, we don’t allow photos when baby is messy, unclothed, fussy/sad/angry, or any other moment that isn’t smiley and cute. It’s a bit harsh, but I’m just trying to respect my baby’s privacy. Photos are forever and once they get spread around there isn’t anything you can do about it. So I’m strict.

1†
make-cake•

I would care due to the fact it’s disrespectful for baby. Adults wouldn’t like it. I don’t think you were projecting your emotions, your point of view sounds like you were seeing your baby as a whole person and you are advocating for her.

Culturally people don’t give babies enough credit and respect or see them as competent. But I’m a fan of RIE.

I would let it slide but also I don’t think it would be unreasonable to ask her to delete it.

You could also take the perspective that It’s okay that she’s not happy in every video or photo, that this moments exist and it’s real. That would help me a bit but i would plan to be ready to say something next time- like that’s not respectful to baby or something.

1†