MLB Power Rankings: After going 6-2 and outscoring opponents 43-27, the Blue Jays move up from #11 to... #14
mlb.com/news/mlb-power-rankings-after-week-18Posted Aug 9, 2021, 9:00 PM UTC
Posted Aug 9, 2021, 9:00 PM UTC
Shows you how pointless these power rankings are
I’m still not sure exactly what they’re supposed to tell us
Which team harnesses the most power
Originally they were created to keep track of the hottest teams as they go through runs and cold streaks. Now it's budget Vegas odds for some reason.
If you want the actual true talent best team (as in, like, actually the best, not "will win the most games this year", and it's probably best to get current record out of your mind for this), the best method is probably the following:
Go to FanGraphs.
Click on "2021 Projected Standings" (not 2021 Playoff Odds, those are the actual in-context win total projections, we want a context-neutral measuring of roster-strength).
Look at the "2021 Projected Rest of Season" tab.
Sort by "W%", this is how many games FanGraphs would expect this team to win based purely on the strength of their roster (as measured by total projected WAR for the team using FanGraphs' Depth Charts projections) and nothing else.
The top ten that result from this are as follows:
Dodgers
Yankees
Blue Jays
Astros
Padres
White Sox
Red Sox
Mets
Brewers
Athletics
The easy critique here is "where r the giants lol" but the more nuanced critique I'd like to give of these projections is that they tend to underestimate the vulnerability of injury-prone rosters, as the playing-time projections done for this are set by human beings who tend to give fairly optimistic guesses about how much playing-time an injury-prone player will get. For that reason it seems high on the Red Sox, who are going to depend a lot on Chris Sale being his stable pre-injury self down the stretch.
It's also worth noting that if you want to get mad at anything in particular with these rankings, you can click on the teams themselves and see precisely who is generating the projected WAR. If you're a Giants fan mad about them not putting some damn respect on Donovan Solano's name, go right ahead, just know that it's Solano they're low on and not Kris Bryant.
Wait you’re telling me the Rays roster isn’t the best in baseball? 60 million can’t buy you shit these days I’ll tell you
Rays not a top ten team confirmed. Now get out and let the real AL East winner ascend. (Not the Yankees because fuck them)
So just as bad a list of teams as MLB Power Ranking.
Two other things to note is one that the Rest of Season win % is not a true barometer of talent as it is accounting for strength of schedule. A team with a harder remaining schedule and more talent can have a lower expected winning % than a less talented team with an easier schedule. Second is that these projections are going to take a LOT longer to stabilize and account for adjustments than your average power rankings. ZIPs is looking at the last 2.5 years of production for these players, not this season. This means it doesn't think guys like Ruf, Wade, Estrada, Webb and just about any of the bullpen are major league contributors. It also doesn't consider much if any of the improvements by any of the old core as long term sustainable.
Another system FG has on their playoff odds page is using season to date stats for their protection model and evaluating ros winning % that way. Though that still is punishing teams with harder schedules.
Top 10 by that metric is
Astros
Dodgers
Blue Jays
Brewers
Rays
White Sox
Giants
Braves
Reds
A's
The Giants have the hardest strength of schedule with their average opponent's projected winning % of .531 and the Reds the easiest at .468
Reds get to play Pirates while Padres get roughed up by Giants and Dodgers 🙃 it probably doesn’t matter anyway because we play to opponents level.
How come I don't see Mariners on your list?
All power rankings are for is to lead to discussion. And here we are.
They don't have any impact on anything. So of course they're pointless
Budget vegas odds.
atleast mlb.com ones
[deleted]
It’s the border tax, Blue Jays automatically lose 25%
Highest score wins, right?
Nope, we had to hold the best record in baseball for 2/3rds of the season before they let us have spot 1.
Flair up
lol, I got downvoted when he had no flair
What a bunch of hosers
You realize that these weekly rankings mean absolutely nothing, right?
It could mean the difference between the Meineke Car Care Bowl and the Sugar Bowl.
The MLB Power Rankings are produced by big brain mathematics, do not question them
The Jays are pretty easily better than the Mets, Phils, and Reds
Well the teams that moved ahead of them are the reds, phillies and Yankees. Yankees have been tearing shit up since the deadline, added more talent than the jays, just took 3 from the Mariners and have a better record. Reds are on a 5 game winning streak, have a better record. Phillies are on a 8 game win streak and just took over first place in their division. Jays should be ahead of the Mets tho, and maybe Cincy because they played the pirates.
The jays are 10-2 in their last 12 and the red sox are 2-9 in their last 11(3-10 in their last 13, there was a dher and i don't know how to most clearly display that). The red sox moved down 2 and the jays moved down 3.
yeah -- idk why the power rankings are so low on the jays. personally, my hot take is that the jays are the second best team in the al east. the jays have had a great run differential throughout the season, shored up the bullpen and got key arms back which is primarily why you guys were losing the games, and have very good starting rotations + batting lineups.
Yeah this is a good take. But as Jays fan, you're missing that our team is still very young and makes mistakes at critical times. Before Springer bailed us out on Sunday, we made a couple of very bad baserunning mistakes which should have cost us the game.
Also it's practically impossible for us to have a winning record at the Trop. That place seems to give every Blue Jay nightmares no matter what era.
Yeah and the Red Sox still have the 7th best record in the league
record doesn't appear to matter though, because the mets are ahead of the blue jays
It’s not my power rankings lol. Mets shouldn’t be that high. I wouldn’t have the Sox above the jays either, but being 3 games ahead of the jays I get why they are.
Even entering tonight, the Blue Jays were ahead (.5454 vs .5446) in the standings over the Reds.
AND the Mets are two spots above the Braves after losing a series to them at home and in complete free fall.
Rankings are dumb.
I think it was just last week(?) where the Giants won series against the Dodgers and the Astros( the other 2 best records in the league at the time) and went from 1st to second
And the Nats moved up a spot
Most of the teams we're chasing for the division & wild card are also red-hot, so this isn't much of a surprise.
Its almost as if 1/3 of the league never cared for 2021, and 1/3 of the league traded all their good players 10 days ago to the other 1/3 of the league left.
Blue Jays finally started playing actual home games at home (Toronto). Seems these power rankings fail to factor that in. Also.. they only lost 2 in the last 12 games (so the win streak goes back more than this..)
Remember, the writers are the same people who vote for the HoF
The A's moved down after going 8-2 last 10 games too lol.
I think their excuse is that the A's only faced the angels and rangers so they don't actually have good wins against good teams, so they're not real weighted wins like everyone else?
Meanwhile the dodgers lost to the Angels and we stayed top 2
Correction, you and the A’s played the Salt Lake Bees.
Edit: plus Ohtani
Now you get the Jays for 4 games, one of which is a Jays home game. We do good with the double headers because We can't lose in the 8-9th innings like we usually do.
The Brewers are missing a ton of their pitching to Covid, including Hader, and we just lost two games that we would have won with him, yet we moved up? Definitely disagree with their analysis there
Dodgers took 2 of 3.
We also played the Padres in that span.
[deleted]
I thought the same thing
You could also say the same for the Jays, their last stretch of games was against Cleveland, KC, and the ice-cold Red Sox
I think their excuse is red sox yankees = $$$ and jays A's less $$$
[deleted]
I think it's that you got a player suspended.