r/AusFinance•
Temby

ETF tax confusion

Tax

Edit: Solved, I was an idiot and the vast majority of the tax is for distributions/dividends, not fund rebalancing. Thank you everyone.

Original post:

In February, I bought $1,996 of ACDC. In April I bought another $10,470. Total cost, $12,466.

Now the confusing part. My ETF tax statement is telling me that my "Total current year capital gains" for last FY is $875. That's a whopping 7% of the gross value of an asset I owned for 2 months (and a small amount for 4). As of 30-June the price had moved very little (in fact it was 1% down) and no dividends had been paid.

I understand that ETF capital gains are based on the fund selling the underlying assets to rebalance, but it seems like I'm paying significant CGT despite having no gain anywhere on paper.

If there is CGT then there must be corresponding profit somewhere. But I assume that profit was already factored into the price when I bought in, therefore it seems like I'm being lumped with a tax bill for profit I will never receive. Would I have had to pay the same amount if I had owned the asset for the full year? Or if I had bought on June 29?

I created a ShareSight account and imported my trade history, and it's giving me the same figure. So I'm not insisting it's wrong, rather I'm looking to understand how it's possible that I'm paying tax when from my perspective there was never a gain (either unrealised or realised) and never will be.

I plan to talk to an accountant but hoping someone here will have some insight and that it might help others in the same situation.

Posted Aug 14, 2021, 6:07 AM UTC · edited

111
wtfisthis888•

This has already been talked at length in this sub. Basically your distribution is a result of capital gains the fund has incurred as a result of its mandated “equal weighted” structure with its holdings. It is rebalanced four times a year. You will be liable for any CGT based on units you hold past the ex-dividend date. Btw this happened with alot of different ETFs, not just ACDC. eg. I got stung and liable for tax with the 17% distribution for IHVV

5
TembyOP•

Thanks, I apologise for the repost. I've read several ETF tax posts but hadn't come across this specifically. 17%, ouch...

Did you end up getting that back via a dividend later, or is it the case that we should be careful to time ETF buying after a weighting event? (If the timing of those is available). Or does the price auto-adjust like it does after an ex-dividend date anyway so it makes little difference?

1
ghostdunks•

I understand that ETF capital gains are based on the fund selling the underlying assets to rebalance, but it seems like I'm paying significant CGT despite having no gain anywhere on paper.

What were your distributions for the year? I’m guessing that’s where you would have seen at least some of the capitals gains reported in your annual tax statement. So maybe no gain on paper, but reflected as income distributions instead.

4
TembyOP•

I see, I was paid a distribution this financial year (21-22) that was $10 less than the CGT amount for last financial year (20-21).

Sorry if it's a silly question, but won't I also get taxed on this year's distribution independently, like a standard dividend, essentially tax that twice?

1
ghostdunks•

No that distribution will be made up of different components of income, some will be franked dividends, some will be foreign income, others will be capital gains, etc. it’ll be taxed as each type of income once.

Distributions from etfs are treated different from dividends paid from shares(assessed in financial year it’s paid). Just go off the annual tax statement you receive for the etf from the share registry(computershare or link market) that’ll tell you which tax year it should be assigned to.

3
42bottles•

Distributions are taxed in the year they were earned by the fund not the year they were distributed to you. So most likely those distributions you talked about are for the 20/21 FY not the 21/22 FY despite receiving the money in the 21/22FY.

2

, but it seems like I'm paying significant CGT despite having no gain anywhere on paper.

The capital gain is built into the distributions you received, so yes, you do have a gain "on paper".

It's all a flow on of the structure you have invested in, be8ng a trust that has to distribute all of its earnings, including capital gains it makes.

Have a look at the price of the units, they take a significant drop whenever a distribution is paid, so that's another area you can see where your gain is coming from.

3
TembyOP•

Yep I see the drop on 30-June was which was ex date. I think I understand now, thank you!

1
iced_maggot•

Typically every quarter you will get a distribution. As long as you buy before the dividend date you will get this distribution even if you buy only a day before. Note that when you receive the payment is inconsequential for tax purposes, the money can hit your account after June 30 but the distribution will likely still count towards the previous FY.

The distribution is you getting the profit which seems to be where you are whetting confused. There are two categories of capital gains you need to be concerned with a) capital gains incurred by the fund that are distributed to you usually quarterly b) capitals gains you incur directly by buying units and then selling at a profit.

2
TembyOP•

It looks like ACDC is only paid distributions yearly, but the ex date was 30 Jun 2021 which explains why it was counted towards last year's tax, but the payment was only received this FY. Thank you for the reply!

1
HockeyMonkey_19•

High fees, high turnover leading to tax inefficiency generally makes these thematic ETFs a poor choice. That is unless you can pick which ones have high returns and then subsequently get out before their performance reverts.

Broad market cap ETFs on the other hand have low fees, low turnover, are very tax efficient and don’t require market timing, suitable for a long term hold.

1