Drama in /r/MetaPorn between SFWPorn mod kjoneslol and RES creator honestbleeps.
reddit.com/r/MetaPorn/comments/obn75/a_new_ye...Posted Feb 6, 2012, 6:09 AM UTC
Posted Feb 6, 2012, 6:09 AM UTC
[deleted]
hi. I was just alerted to the existence of this thread.... eesh... I didn't expect to be uh... showcased here...
to be perfectly honest, I think I lost my cool and turned into a bit of a dick.. not that it might not've been justified... but I think I need to do a better job of not getting visibly frustrated with people who are being jerks.
DON'T SWEAT IT, BUDDY! YOU SEEMED, TO ME AT LEAST, TO KEEP IT TOGETHER PRETTY WELL.
can i meet you in real life
To me, it seemed like you were being perfectly reasonable, calm, and level-headed. You didn't really come across as a dick at all.
Kjoneslol, on the other hand.....
I think you handled it amazingly well. The other guy became quite mad though.
Honestbleeps is the man!
[deleted]
Oh man, this is awesome. These kinds of arguments are the meat and potatoes of my drama diet.
Though, it would be nice (and beneficial for everyone) if the two groups could get together and work something out but that, unfortunately, will probably never happen (at least not anytime soon).
This is just a pile of bullshit though. "I'm a mod. I'd love it if we could work together. But we can't." Someone's not feeling too optimistic about their own free will I guess.
And /metaporn AND /pornoverlords? Are they going to start a /pornilluminati next? Sheesh.
I'm not saying we can't I'm just saying it's not very likely considering we haven't already. Also, all the subreddits I moderate work with RES so I have been trying on my end.
Is it just me or are the mods of this "SFWporn network" totally full of themselves? I mean, I like looking at pictures and subscribe to a few of them but their CSS is annoying, the names of their reddits are annoying (the porn meme is so old. Why do they feel the need to keep it going?) and the mods constant trolling to enforce standards makes me think they take their hobby as being a mod too seriously (like its their job, and that they're getting paid for it.)
Also, I'm sick of CSS heavy mods acting like their shitty CSS overload is more appealing than RES. Leave HonestBleeps alone!
Hey, I'm one of the newer moderators of the SFW Porn Network. I don't think I'm full of myself (though I'm a bit biased) and none of the others strike me that way. Sure, sometimes we show our bad side, but in general, everyone in the SFWPorn network are really nice and cool people. I came late to this, and kjoneslol's comments are deleted, but from what I can tell, I don't agree with him on this. Please don't assume that one moderator's rash comments represent the whole network.
The names of their reddits are annoying (the porn meme is so old. Why do they feel the need to keep it going?)
Once you make a few subreddits in a small network with a decent following, and then you dislike the name, what are you gonna do? You don't simply start a "CoolPics" network, and redirect the people in r/earthporn to r/CoolPicsOfEarth. So, if we were dissatisfied with the name, there's not much we could do. And we don't "feel the need to keep it going" because we are kinda stuck with it.
the mods constant trolling to enforce standards
I'm not sure what you're trying to say with "trolling" but let's put that aside. Our ruleset is kinda strict and always has been. We enforce it so that the rules are followed, and everything runs smoothly.
Also I'm sick of CSS heavy mods acting like their shitty CSS overload is more appealing than RES
I definitely don't think that way. I do like the CSS we have, but I still think people should use RES to turn off CSS they don't like. I don't like how so some reddits block that option, but we don't do that.
Man that SRS meme is so old. Why do they keep it going?!?
SRS is short for Sister Ray Says. An old username I had when I was a rabid Velvet Underground fan.
Man that is really unfortunate.
Why? I love Shit Reddit Says.
How long has Hitlarious been alerting people to our presence?
Couple of weeks at least. Also does SRS and worstof's advertisement, so helpful!
For anyone who's curious why honestbleeps is replying to a 24 day old comment, over here kjoneslol said that he never said he didn't like RES, which of course he did say in the parent of the comment linked here. It seems kjoneslol likes to make strictly false statements that should have an asterisk or 'almost' put in there like
Moderators can do whatever they want. They have complete control over their subreddits
As we have learned, things like changing post titles and user names without the user's permission, simulating reddit being down, or banning users which have never even posted in your subreddit are not allowed.
I love the SFWPorn Network, and from what I hear kjoneslol does a lot of good work with it, but he is really shooting himself in the foot here.
[deleted]
When was he trying to turn them off? He just said that he didn't like RES, and then acted rude when honestbleeps came in. He just wanted to fix the submit button.
I'm sort of torn. kjoneslol seems to want to and not want to make an effort and he brings up a good point with this:
You wouldn't call a game developer to ask for help trying to get a third party mod to work so why would you do that here?
If a moderator makes style changes to a subreddit and they work perfectly fine on default Reddit, they shouldn't have to cater to the third party. It would be beneficial and kind for them to do so, but that's a headache they shouldn't have to anticipate.
kjoneslol could benefit from working with honestbleeps for the sake of the users and honestbleeps should continue his effort to streamline RES into the standard Reddit experience.
Kind of arguable, isn't it? The moderator's custom CSS can be thought of as third-party to reddit itself, just as RES is third-party to reddit.
imo, Reddit should just hire honestbleeps outright anyway.
A mod's CSS isn't really the same. RES works outside of the system to implement changes to the system. A mod's CSS works within the system to make changes to the system. A mod has to write CSS that doesn't break the experience of their subreddit. honestbleeps has to write CSS that doesn't break the Reddit experience, which includes custom subreddit CSS.
I hear people say that a lot about people who develop browser extensions for websites and I honestly don't think it's that simple. Someone working for Reddit probably spends their time addressing bug issues and working to optimize the Reddit experience and make it as uniform as possible. If RES slows your Reddit experience down, you can just uninstall it. You can't uninstall baked in Reddit features. They could allow people to turn off features, but that comes with the risk of creating an uneven experience. Like in video games, you can turn off fancy sounds and graphics, but the mechanics are never touched.
for the record:
If RES's feature set were built in to reddit (which it probably won't be, ever), it wouldn't slow down peoples' experience.
RES causes slowdown for people with slower computers because it's doing a metric crapton of DOM manipulation via Javascript, which isn't the fastest operation in the world. (DOM manipulation isn't fast... javascript these days actually is!)
If these features were baked into RES, there would be no client side DOM manipulation and thus no slowdown -- Reddit would just serve up most of these enhancements in the HTML.
Yes, this is the crux of the "argument", lying and whatnot aside.
Sometimes I think it would've been better if reddit had never allowed custom subreddit CSS.
I don't agree. Most subs work very well with RES and improve the quality of the sub. RES has also gotten so big, I would say that it's a mod's responsibility to make their CSS work with it.
Sometimes I think it would've been better if reddit had never allowed custom subreddit CSS.
In case you are unaware, you can go into your preferences and turn off custom subreddit CSS sitewide.
RES simply allows you to do it on a reddit by reddit basis, rather than having to choose all or nothing.
hi there.. bleeps here... got pointed to this thread by someone... I just want to say a couple of things:
First and foremost: I never anticipated RES would get big enough that people would start bothering moderators about CSS conflicts... that's something I do feel bad / guilty about, and don't want happening... I never wanted to create more work for anyone, I just wanted to make Reddit more.. awesome... er...
That being said, I'm happy to work with anyone who wants RES to change a bit to make styling around it easier.
The only place where I hold strong/steadfast is on the notion of subreddit moderators disabling pieces of RES through CSS hacks. That I'm just not cool with, because I feel strongly that the user's browser belongs to the user, not the subreddit moderator. That, combined with the fact that Reddit itself allows me to turn off subreddit CSS anyway, implies to me that CSS isn't supposed to be used to change "functionality" .. only look and feel...
Was kjoneslol disabling certain portions of RES with "css hacks?"
I was told he was, but he doesn't seem to be now.
Regardless, that wasn't the subject of the debate we had over there... his issue (and I do understand his frustration) was that people were bothering him about his sub not looking right with RES enabled, and that was creating more work for him.. I can respect that.. it's a lot of work making complex CSS for your subreddit(s).
My issue was that he lied about trying to contact me "several times" and saying I never replied when I did in fact reply... I did make the mistake of thinking his problem was fixed, but that's kind of irrelevant at this point... My main beef is just that he lied in such a way as to paint me as unresponsive and unwilling to help while he kept trying "several times" to get help... which is an absolute falsehood.
I want moderators to know that I'm 100% willing to spend time with them to either help them update their CSS to be more RES friendly, or even change RES to make it easier for them to play nice.
I never was and never have disabled any part of RES. In fact, I have worked pretty hard to make it work with RES--even without your help. The SFWPorn Network clashes very little with RES but fixing r/kpop to work with RES was a pain in the ass but I managed.
I also never said "several times" I said I sent you "messages" so you might want to stop using quotes around that.
But game developers who's games aren't mod-friendly are often attacked for that. Just because they aren't involved in problems with individual mods doesn't mean that they aren't involved at all.
Obviously how relevant that is to this particular situation is debatable, but as a general point I disagree.
That would be true, but Reddit would be a game that's not intended to be modded.
... As would any game that was produced that wasn't mod friendly.
If a community demands modding capabilities either the service is going to have to provide it or it'll find that the community moves somewhere that will in the long run.
All I'm trying to say that it's naive to suggest that developers have nothing to do with mods working because in the end the consumer gets what the consumer wants.
I hate it when people downvote because of disagreement :/
I think it's a little ironic, since kjoneslol was defending r/apple's right to remove RES' disable stylesheet button and any mods right to do whatever the hell they want to their CSS (as r/metaporn does with removing the downvotes). I don't necessarily disagree with those statements, but the downvotes show that all your carefully crafted code can and will be ignored but the users.
I disagree with moderators removing addon code. They can meddle all they want with the code provided to them by reddit, but they shouldn't extend their reach into stuff users do themselves (for example addons or custom stylesheets).
IMHO, the priority list is as follows:
users > user addons > moderators > vanilla
So, mods are right when trying to adjust the vanilla experience, and are free to consult and compromise with addon developers, but they have no right to try and override user's addons.
It isn't about anyone's "right", because that language tends to muddy the issue. Fundamentally it's about who owns what.
Reddit serves the html. Mods can play with css to alter a great number of attributes. But the user and the browser have the final say on how to display the content served by reddit. There are some "rights" mixed up in there. We have a long-standing expectation of freedom in the browser but for the most part it is simply a matter of who owns what layers.
As HB has said in other threads they can obfuscate CSS and make it hard to change things w/ RES or disable the stylesheet but that's just a holding action. Eventually the userscript gets updated and the user wins again.
r/apple's right to remove RES' disable stylesheet button and any mods right to do whatever the hell they want to their CSS (as r/metaporn does with removing the downvotes).
Nope. Downvoting is an integral part of reddit's voting system and mods do not have the right to disable it. http://www.reddit.com/help/moderation#ArethereanyrestrictionsonwhatIcandowithmyredditsCSS
You are pretty much free to make any style modifications you would like, within reason. Some things you can't do:
Disable or tamper with site functionality (e.g., buttons)
Many subreddits remove the downvote arrow from their stylesheets, including r/metaporn and the admins haven't done anything about it.
Including r/ShitRedditSays
Did kjoneslol remove downvotes after this? Wow. Just wow.
Downvotes have been disabled in /r/MetaPorn since the subreddit was created.
Lotta good it seems to have done.
Ah, ok. Honestly didn't know, never looked at it before.
Downvotes have been disabled in r/MetaPorn since the subreddit was created.
[deleted]
TOO MUCH QUOTING
If there's drama in r/SubredditDrama it will be r/metaporn??
It will be in /r/SubredditDramaDrama
From the linked post. Bullshit. I sense the need for mods to stop pretending their subreddits are myspace pages.
YOU DON'T LIKE 99 RED BALLOONS? WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH YOU?
But seriously, who the fuck doesn't like 99 red balloons?
I liked it when it was 99 Luftballons
I liked it better when it was 99 luftballoons. It still takes a heartless monster to not like 99 red balloons.
Balloon salesmen with bulk discount deals. They lose money.
I don't. Mostly because it was on every MySpace page in high school and got played at every battle of the bands ever. Same reason I don't like ska anymore.