Forging Investiture (Emperor's Soul)
Would it be theoretically possible to create a forging of a soul making someone into an Invested entity? For instance, could Shai have created a soul forging of herself into a Elantrian? Or even a worldhopper with other forms of investiture like breaths?
Posted Sep 21, 2021, 2:36 PM UTC
168
There's a WoB that it's possible but would be very difficult and require a lot of investiture.
https://wob.coppermind.net/events/361/#e11253
This is something that's always confused me with elantris/emperors soul. Since soul stamps and aons draw directly from the Dor, rather than using something like stormlight or metals, shouldn't they be able to use as much power as they like? There's no indication in emperors soul that Shai has any investiture to use as fuel right? She just makes the stamp and it works, and anyone can make and use the stamps too, they don't need to be invested themselves. Couldn't you just use a soul stamp that would make someone into an allomancer the stamp would just draw as much power as it needs from the Dor?
I'm probably just forgetting some detail but if I'm not this is very confusing
We don't have the full clarity of it. But all forgers seem to have some kind of investiture to work with. Maybe it's like they connect to the Dor but the hose is of a certain size so they can only pull so much. She never tries to do anything outside her ability in terms of requiring too much investiture, but there's probably ways to boost her ability to do things like turn someone into a mistborn, or give them more breaths.
I'm not so clear on that. I thought Forgers still had to be someone from MaiPon, just like Elantrians are from Arelon, and so on. Is it literally just knowing how to make one?
Note that metals are also just a key - an Allomancer is getting Investiture directly from Preservation, the metal isn't invested. (Stormlight, on the other hand, literally is Investiture in gaseous form.) So soulstamps/aons actually are a lot like metals - they're keys that unlock some investiture and then direct it.
I don't think you're forgetting that detail, we probably just don't know that detail yet. That's the thing with Brandon's stories - we see the world from the characters' point of view, so if something is unknown to them it's also unknown to us. Raoden certainly doesn't know the limits of the powers of Aons, he barely learned Aons 101. Shai knows a lot about soulstamps, but is clearly more concerned with finesse and skill than raw power - quite possible that whatever limits there are on total investiture available via Forgery, she hasn't run up against them.
So I think it falls to the readers to figure these things out, if we're interested in them! Aons and Forgery both use shapes to direct the flow of Investiture from the Dor to do things. ...but that doesn't seem like it would mean that they have literally unlimited investiture. You probably can't just "draw the right Aon to basically become a Shard", or "carve the right soulstamp and Forge the whole planet into a raisin". There's probably something that makes that impossible. We just don't know for sure what it is yet.
Thinking about it right now, and putting on my aluminum foil hat, it might be geography. I think we know that power of Aons depends on distance from Elantris. But perhaps that's more general - the investiture available to a Selish shape-based magic depends on the distance between the magic and the special geographical location. So there's some specific point in MaiPon where forgery is most effective, and it goes down from there, just like Aons are most effective in Elantris. So what's the eventual limit on Aon/Soulstamp power? Might be the physical size of the Aon/Soulstamp! It is literally impossible for, say, a 6-inch soulstamp to have an "average distance from the center of MaiPon" less than 3 inches. Which might set an upper limit on how powerful a soulstamp could be - since the shape is important, maybe you can't just arbitrarily shrink the soulstamp down. Or maybe it's the other way around - Elantris is not a single point, it's a whole city, so it's not possible to be "closer to all of Elantris" than "half the size of the city". ...maybe that's why the giant Aon the size of the city is so powerful, able to affect all Elantrians - because it's literally covering the entire geographical nexus of power, thus minimizing the "distance" between the Aon and Elantris?
Anyway, just random theories, don't know whether that's true precisely. But I do think the answer has something to do with geography and distance.
[deleted]
Unclear. The way characters in TES talk about it, anyone can learn to, don't even have to be from MaiPon (Shai speaks about generally just anyone can, and Ashravan expresses surprise they used a MaiPon Forger instead of their resealers... who are Forgers). But Brandon's explicitly said before that not everyone from MaiPon can use it (the questioner specified MaiPon, so it's unclear if other people can or not). So it's not clear if there's just a stage they don't know about or what.
Forging someone to be an Elantrian would be relatively easy. Making someone an Allomancer would be a lot harder, because she would need to Connect them to a completely different Shard, and different Investiture. Theoretically, it might be possible, but practically it'd be incredibly hard.
It's not a matter of power, it's a matter of cosmere physics, Investiture, etc.
The comment I was replying to literally has link to Brandon saying it would take a lot of investiture (power) to do it, and it would be easier to break a bond with a spren than make someone an allomancer, the former requiring probably a larger manipulation of connection than the latter
I know, I read it. I'm saying sure you can brute force it, but you also need a lot of knowledge and maybe some funky abilities. It says it needs a lot of power and is beyond Shai's abilities after all.