breadguy69325
u/breadguy69325
I finished this a couple days ago and enjoyed it for the most part, but was not really blown away. I suppose I had my expectations high since it won a Hugo and saw credible reviewers call it genre-redefining, a masterpiece, mind-blowing, etc etc. but it didn't really live up to any of that for me.
I liked the main cast well enough, but the plot didn't really have me gripped. The stakes felt weak because I don't really know anything about Lsel or it's people, and I didn't feel much tension for Mahit since she walked away from every life threatening situation (multiple targeted assassination attempts) with no more than a bruise.
The political aspects are really were this book fell apart for
In my opinion it's gotta be Caul Shivers. Despite only having one POV book, he's in every other installment aside from The Blade Itself and consistently one of the most influential characters in the whole series.
They refuse to mention the names of certain characters in context (eg. Jezal in Best Served Cold, Logen and Carlot dan Eider in Red Country) as if they'd be a spoiler.
Also, sidenote about the series in general, it's so frustrating that Logen won't just explain to anyone he cares about that he goes mindlessly berserk in combat and it's dangerous to be near him. Just simply communicate man, it's not that hard.
Anyway, Red Country was great and I'm pumped to read Sharp Ends and finally get on to the second main trilogy
I've already read Gentleman Bastards and Rook & Rose and they're fantastic. Looking for some more likable and skilled con artists
and if I have to read another Gawyn POV chapter I'm going tiqqvvfncoawhrvfjxlvag+$+#(-iskdlaanajNDHKSLAHjjdid
I need a scene of every single established character thoroughly reacting to the Eithan reveal. This is the most important thing in the world to me right now
metal working is cool as hell, and I think would be interesting in a fantasy setting (especially if it's related to a magic system in some way).
was wondering if anybody had any recommendations
This is a quote from Soulsmith when Lindon and Yerin attempt to steal a bunch of scales from the sand vipers:
Lindon had been blind. In Sacred Valley, once a person reached Jade, they could use their spirit to sense things they couldn’t possibly see or hear. They couldn't sense a person's level of advancement without personally witnessing their sacred arts. Somehow, it hadn’t occurred to him that sacred artists on the outside could.
if this true then how did the jades in Bloodline determine everybody's advancement level by scanning their spirit
What's everyone's favorite potential Chekhov's Gun?
For me it's the original Heart of Twin Stars manual (and it's author/author's pure madra opponent), and Seisha's brown hair (and potentially it's link to the missing 4th clan from Sacred Valley)
For those who don't know, Chekhov's Gun is a writing concept that states that all elements introduced in a story should serve a narrative function. It usually refers to a seemingly innocuous detail that ends up playing a much larger role later in the story.
Couldn't put it down all day today, sheesh. Easily one of my favorite series of all time, wonderful character work and such a believable, unique world with so much life to it. Each city feels like a character in itself. Plot was engaging all the way through, even the slow bits were incredible fun, and the between chapter interlude format was nice to keep the pace in check.
Anyway, if Sabetha doesn't come back and join the crew for real next book I will literally cry and shit and moan and pass out and scream and throw up and
Kaladin and Shallan ended up revealing their surgebinding to each other in the chasms in WoR? I know Kaladin had lost Syl by this point but he still could have told Shallan
Would it be theoretically possible to create a forging of a soul making someone into an Invested entity? For instance, could Shai have created a soul forging of herself into a Elantrian? Or even a worldhopper with other forms of investiture like breaths?
Are there any good fantasy books/series where the protags are a clandestine group whos sole goal is to prevent/stop wars, like using sabotage, assassination, manipulation, etc.
Bonus points if one of the major parties is an imperial nation attempting conquest
