r/chess•
Marilynkira

Checkmate in 500

META

Can mods do something about the checkmate in whatever the number of moves is posts? If i wanted to do puzzles I'll do them on whatever platform I'm using. These posts are getting out of hand. I honestly unfollowed r/chess just because my front page is full of these posts.

Posted Sep 24, 2021, 10:12 PM UTC

37399
porn_on_cfb__4 Team Nepo :nepo: •

it's obvious karma whoring... ppl just pull up their 800-level bullet games, scroll back 2 moves from the checkmate, and spam the "mate in 2 puzzles". it's always queen sac/smothered mates stuff too.

if you give people an opportunity they'll take it. Rules don't allow people sharing checkmates bcuz "low effort", but scroll back two moves? Now it's a "puzzle"! And not low-effort anymore!

187
zerbikit •

There are posts like that but usually they are not particularly popular. If you don't want to see them filtering by hot avoids most posts like that. That being said, it is kinda stupid that the mods are so trigger happy but the instant you make it a "puzzle" you can post whatever.

24
ASilverRook2000 Lichess and Chess.com•

And there’s not even a rule that “puzzles” must have an actual solution, so sometimes some 800 elo player posts something which is totally wrong and freaks out on anyone in the comments who tells them that their “solution” is false.

24
theyouman88 •

I have a separate account subbed for chess just for when I want to solve puzzles, is that not what we're doing here?

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

12

My excitement of finding a smothered mate for the first time ever with 0.1 seconds remaining in a bullet game has now been smothered.

6
[deleted]•

Especially when those puzzles are dubbed “THE MOST INSANE PUZZLE YOU’LL EVER SEE, FOUND IT MYSELF. SO SATISFYING”.

9
CoconutOperative•

And they love seeking validation too with the “I missed this earlier in my game but find the +9 winning move for black” or they give some other stories for you to read.

3
ning72100 fide | 2500 lichess•

puzzles should only be the ones where there's a clear best move available (other moves do not win or make the win difficult). I don't care about a mate in 2 when you're up two rooks and two queens.

180
Rotsike6•

Most of the time, yes. But there's some beautiful mate-in-three's out there when there's a billion other mate-in-fours. Like the one where white has a king on e1, a rook on f1 and h1 and a pawn on g3, while the black king is on g2. Mate in three.

31
pinks85•

That's a nice one and took a while to solve 🙂 although 99% of positions like this are composed, I'd say that's a different category than "tactical puzzles" from real games

5
sian_half•

If you’re on chess.com with 0.3s on the clock with no increment, being up 2 rooks and a queen dont help if you cannot premove a mate in 2

1†
ning72100 fide | 2500 lichess•

lol, just lol.

15
sian_half•

yeah i know it's dumb but that's the only scenario i can think of that you need mate in 2 and 3 won't do lol

-3
Mountain-Appeal89882450 lichess rapid•

And the mate in 2 takes 5 min to find while the mate in 3 takes 10 sec

13
Centurion902•

Maybe we could just have a day of the week for puzzles?

100
sophialepley•

Or a thread

26
johnstocktonshorts•

yes this would be great

12
The_Boar_Shark•

Thank you, I can't see why there isn't a seperate subreddit specifically for puzzles (especially since the majority of puzzles here aren't all that special or interesting) while this one is for news and advice.

82
[deleted]•

[deleted]

23
yourfriendkyle•

Because it’s boring

24
buddaaaa NM :Verified_Master: •

almost like the constant puzzle spam makes this subreddit more boring

42
SuperSpeedyCrazyCow 2400 lichess noob•

Why don't you post content you like and upvote it and ignore the ones you don't?

People on this sub are so dramatic acting like it's some huge amounts of posts. I hang out in new all the time and I never feel like its an issue to just scroll past them.

-19
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
elementzer01•

Easy answer. Chess news, chess facts, chess questions

16
Mustangorino00•

You mean r/ChessPuzzles?

9
rogozhin5 Team Carlsen :carlsen: •

Fully agree. This sub gets absolutely spammed with them I have to hide them all just so I can scan for real posts. There should just be a subreddit called r/chesspuzzles. Mods could even hack together their own vision bot to remove them from here automatically. But of course they won't.

40
yourfriendkyle•

There’s legit no reason to share 75% of all puzzles shared.

16
city-of-starsgive me 1. e4 or give me death•

The problem is there's no objective standard for what makes a puzzle 'good'. You "know it when you see it", essentially, but in order to create a subreddit rule and enforce it something more objective than that is needed otherwise there would be a lot of complaints. You'll see some excellent and well-made compositions get posted here as well, and we don't want to throw out the baby with the bathwater.

21
cairnival•

If you don't like them downvote them. If they're still showing up then you're outnumberd by people who want to see them. That's how every subreddit works.

18
notconquered•

It's not that simple though. When subreddits grow in size, lower-effort posts tend to rise to the top. So one of the jobs of mods, if they so desire, is to put rules in place to keep the subreddit content meet certain criteria.

25
BitBroken•

Then why are memes banned?

19
clfcrw•

Most likely, because the mods want this to be a 'serious' subreddit where people come that want to learn.

Puzzles are traditional chess content that people do for fun to learn.

7
RajjSinghh•

And also how spammable they are. If people are mad at low effort spam puzzles, imagine how they would react to r/anarchychess content being spammed and upvoted here too

1
ghost-train•

Yeah same thought here. Getting well out of hand now as you say. Thanks for being one of the first to speak up on it.

15
braamdepace•

I don’t mind the puzzles, but it’s annoying when they say stuff like “mate in 2 and queen sacrificed” I’m like well you reduced the options so much it’s not even a puzzle. If people really hate them that much though maybe only make them postable on a certain day or two during the week

14
atopixMOD♚♟️♞♝♜♛•

We've already had debates on whether or not to continue to allow puzzles.

The biggest one since the current moderation team (or the majority at least) has been in place: https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/l712ci/unpopular_opinion_this_sub_would_be_substantively/

But the counter-argument has nearly twice the support: https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/l7t5t8/unpopular_opinion_this_subreddit_would_be/

Unfortunately both posts have been deleted by their authors, but you can still see the discussions each sprung.

5 months ago someone even complained about the joke rules we had instituted for the most recent April's fools (not realizing what the date was): https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/mi2ddh/unpopular_opinion_the_new_changes_in_this_sub_are/

And then you have other posts similar to the one we are in: https://www.reddit.com/r/chess/comments/llhkcr/i_think_this_has_been_mentioned_before_but/

Which are less than 70% upvoted and without universal (or a strong majority) support.

If a clear majority really didn't want puzzles anymore, we would seriously consider not allowing them anymore. But a LOT of people clearly still want puzzles in this subreddit.

14
[deleted]•

I would like to propose something: how about we create a poll regarding this matter and pin it to top of the subreddit for a week. Then no one can complain about it and it will be easier to see which side do most of the people fall on.

We did a similar thing for birthday posts, let's do for this one as well.

7
atopix♚♟️♞♝♜♛•

Yeah, it's a possibility. Except the birthday posts issue was a more clear cut case, in this one some people would prefer some form of a compromise and there could be many variables to any version of a compromise.

But we'll consider doing that.

5
Mutte23 Team Carlsen :carlsen: •

Yeah, let's vote again.

1†
clfcrw•

Yeah! Lets vote until we have a result that fits your point of view. /s

-1†
MrLegilimensf3 Nimzos all day.•

Pretty much.

3
IcollectSTDs•

Co-sign

13
CatRelocator •

we should just collectively downvote it if we dont like it

12
SuperSpeedyCrazyCow 2400 lichess noob•

Get over it. I've never seen a hobby subreddit so obnoxious and pretentious. Im talking about OP but also the other people in this thread.

We already have memes banned, pictures of chess sets banned, sure let's remove puzzles too. Why not. I say we ban everything. Only thing that is allowed is 500 page essays on opening theory.

11†
MrLegilimensf3 Nimzos all day.•

current top 20 posts as I type this: 7/20. That's not really "full of these posts". 35%

10†
MarilynkiraOP•

35% is 25% more than what it should be.

9†
MrLegilimensf3 Nimzos all day.•

Ah yes thank you for that, I see right there on the sidebar it says 10% as u/Marilynkira demands. Sorry i missed that.

10
rogozhin5 Team Carlsen :carlsen: •

35% is too much. Poll the subreddit. Do your job.

-8
MrLegilimensf3 Nimzos all day.•

Submit other shit. Our job isn't overmoderating.

16
yourfriendkyle•

That’s cause only the good ones get upvoted. The rest are pointless but for some reason I still see them a lot

3
DenseLocation•

It's not a perfect solution (you can't do it with every app) but on desktop + most Reddit mobile apps you can filter by flair. I set mine to filter all puzzles except the advanced ones about six months ago. Took about five minutes.

7
throwawaytrol71341913 FIDE•

Is there a way i could do it on Boost For Reddit?

1
Gfyacns•

There used to be more options for reporting posts but there were some changes to the sub moderation and the content quality has gotten even worse as a result.

You don't even have to be correct about where the puzzle is from apparently, just insert a famous player's name into the title

6
KingKonghonk•

Ouch, I feel attacked. Don't worry that mistake won't happen again lol

0
ProfessorDave3D•

Please don’t down vote me just for saying what I like. But it seems like there’s usually about one, maybe two puzzles per day?

Whatever the number is, it seems good to me.

6
[deleted]•

But it seems like there’s usually about one, maybe two puzzles per day?

Sort by new and you're in for a big treat. But there was unusually large number of puzzles yesterday on top of the page as well.

3
ScalarWeapon•

There's a lot more than that.

When I look at like the newest 50, it's usually at least half puzzles

3
ProfessorDave3D•

Yeah, I guess I have a particular view because I don’t actually go straight to read the articles on the chess subreddit. They are mixed in with articles from all my subscribed subreddits, so from my point of view, I’m reading a variety of subject lines, and mixed in with them, there will sometimes be one or two chessboard images telling me there’s a little puzzle I could solve this morning.

My needs would be met just fine with an r/chesspuzzles subreddit, as someone mentioned in this thread.

2
JurijFedorov Team Carlsen :carlsen: •

It's a chess subreddit. If you kill puzzles it will just become a chess news subreddit which would be super boring and pointless. It's extremely cool that there is one single subreddit where you can interact with a lot of the posts.

6
ChairmanUzamaoki•

it will just become a chess news subreddit which would be super boring and pointless.

Says who? I am extremely interested in chess news and discussion. I've been following games and players for years. There are billion dollar TV syndicates dedicated to sports discussion, why can't chess have a small forum for it?

However, I am not in favor of removing puzzles from this sub. I would like to see more news but i think to ban puzzles is dumb.

5
SuperSpeedyCrazyCow 2400 lichess noob•

His point isn't that chess news is boring and bad.

He's saying a sub thats ONLY news is boring and bad

3
ChairmanUzamaoki•

I disagree. I would probably be a lot more active in this sub if it was just chess news. I'm not in favor of removing puzzles, but it wouldn't be boring to talk about positions and modern players as opposed to "Mate in 3 (you'll never guess what piece you have to sac)" posts.

I would love an active sub that was all discussions about the game and not copy and pasted puzzles.

3
SuperSpeedyCrazyCow 2400 lichess noob•

Yes but that's you. If you just sort by top that's not how the community feels.

Why is it so hard for people to just engage in the things they enjoy and let other people enjoy the rest?

I dont care about 99% of the puzzles posted here usually because they are too easy for me. So I just scroll past them.

I dont think its a great idea to keep splitting off parts of this sub into more and more sections of other subreddits. Theres barely any posts as it is. And if you feel like there isn't enough of the content you enjoy, go find some and post it.

2
JurijFedorov Team Carlsen :carlsen: •

Says who? I am extremely interested in chess news and discussion. I've been following games and players for years. There are billion dollar TV syndicates dedicated to sports discussion, why can't chess have a small forum for it?

I'm not saying this is a bad thing. I'm saying that this is competing with chess news sites and even sites where people can comment and make their own posts on the news sites. Plus you have chess forums without images. Hence boring because it's nothing new. Reddit has an image feature that makes it a bit unique in this aspect. So it becomes new and fun. Not that it's better. It's just a different thing.

2
SirVyve•

While we're at it, let's ban discussion of board states, too. This sub should not be newcomer friendly; I don't want anyone below a GM rating tainting my pure subreddit. The only thing that should be on this subreddit is chess news and drama.

5†
[deleted]•

The only thing that should be on this subreddit is chess news and drama

There shouldn't be any of this drama bs, all it attracts are hivemind and frankly trash twitch noobs. Remove all low effort/easy puzzles, and a honest suggestion from me is that you have to be at least 1500 FIDE to comment here. Will remove the regular trash we see from the twitch noobs here

-2†
Justinwc•

Can't tell if sarcasm

11
SirVyve•

SmORC PogChamp Kappa OMEGALUL

Fuck, I cringed just writing that

4
burned_pixel Team Carlsen :carlsen: •

Yup. It's annoying as fuck. I don't mind the actually interesting and educational ones, but those are few and far between.

5
clfcrw•

Seriously, what kind of content DO you like? And if it's so overwhelmingly specific make you're own subreddit.

Puzzles are an important, traditional and serious part of chess. If you don't like a specific puzzle you are free to down-vote it. Like I do.

Among the many average puzzles you can find here I found some that are extremely insightful and fun.

If you want people to curate good puzzles for you support a chess magazine by buying one.

4