The "karmanaut is PHOY" Pastebin file, now with 100% fewer IP addresses revealed
pastie.org/3416127Posted Feb 19, 2012, 8:18 PM UTC
Posted Feb 19, 2012, 8:18 PM UTC
Can someone explain the significance of this?
The significance of what?
... that karmanaut is PHOY. Why is this news?
In big subreddits, policy changes are done by votes. He gets two votes.
Sometimes three. And that's all that he's admitted to. Safe to say there are more.
I suspect that PACG is his as well. I could be wrong, however, it would be consistent as his path here is the same as PHOY.
Why is any of this news?
I suppose it's common knowledge that he lives in North Carolina, but don't people also know where he works? For anyone who's curious as to why culturalelitist would remove the IP addresses, it's because a quick search with the address would reveal his place of work.
Do you remember this mess with Laurelai? Here's a tidy little summary wrote up. Apparently personal information is personal information in the eyes of the admins no matter how public it is.
So let me throw out a little theory.
If a news article in a small town gets released with arrest records or someone added to the sex offender list and it gets posted to Reddit... even though possibly thousands (or more) people now know this information, this breaks the reddit rules?
That's my understanding...and I think it's a good policy. Unless the user posts the information themselves I don't see how real life personal info is even relevant to the conversations on reddit.
What about information posted to /r/politics of what a politician says? Can't that also be removed at the request of the user?
Was karmanaut/phoy unemployed there for a while, or has it all been a lie!!?
P.s. I'm not really mad.
A few years ago, I remember karmanaut 'quit' reddit to go to Duke Law school. I think I even remember krispykrackers visiting him and posting a picture. Then about a year later, he came back. Not sure what his school/employment status is now.
[deleted]
Karmanaut made another account (ProbablyHittingOnYou) so he could moderate other bigger subreddits as there is a rule that states if you are mod of a subreddit with over 100,000 users you can't mod other subreddits .... I think.
there is a rule that states if you are mod of a subreddit with over 100,000 users you can't mod other subreddits .... I think.
I assure you there's not. Anywhere.
I think he is simply confused with qgyh2's new recruitment policy for new mods. I've heard he isn't accepting anyone as a new mod of a 100k+ subreddit if they already mod a subreddit with 100k+ users.
It's smart, yes, because the mods will be able to devote more time solely to that subreddit, but it also greatly benefits the existing "power moderators" who mod multiple default subreddits, ensuring that power stays consolidated in their hands.
I kind of think some of them should be removed. I mean, what if they all just agreed to? Highly unlikely, but what if that was just part of becoming a default mod? Having to publicly agree not to take on too many Mod jobs. There'd be no way to enforce it of course but it's an interesting thought.
Eh. It seems more like Karmanaut made another account to avoid his downvote brigade. Lots of users do the same thing. The problem was, Karmanaut was already mod of multiple subreddits, so he kept modding as Karmanaut and started modding as PHOY.
What rule is that? When did that happen? That is not a rule for reddit as a whole. Especially considering when PHOY was made (months ago).
It's seriously frustrating that this paste site parses the single-quotes in the contractions and tries to syntax-highlight the text... ಠ_ಠ
[deleted]
The whole thing feels so political. "Power user" and celebrity PHOY being Karmanaut feels like the Donald Trump election rumors, or if there was a superhero whose alter ego was the president.
I don't think this needed a new post.
I would just like to take an aside and thank those of you continually contributing to and elaborating on this whole thing.
I still have no fucking clue what's going on, and that does not really bother me because it's highly entertaining. Carry on, pip pip tally ho!
Some googling brings up this four-week old conversation that is apparently taken from the #IAmA mod chat.
Scroll down to the bottom for some relevant lulz.
Edit:
I'm just going to paste all the evidence of karmanaut's sockpuppetry here, because it's hilarious, and for the popcorn. I don't pick sides; I'm just here for the drama.
There are tons of threads where both karmanaut and ProbablyHittingOnYou are there to reap the delicious karma, essentially in a private circlejerk, but I've chosen to focus on threads where they (he) interact with each other (himself).
Ooh, nice find! The rest is worth reading too, especially since it provides some context for this previous dustup that BEP and karmanaut had.
Check this out. Nothing beats a little in-the-third-person self-pleasure.
Oh my god, that is too precious.
Here he is conceding an accolade. To himself. But not himself.
Hey, I reformatted that second conversation you found here.
It's definitely worth a read.
Thanks! That makes it much clearer.
Is there any indication of who posted the pastie in the first place (i.e. from whose perspective exactly it is that we're reading the conversation)?
Looks like it was Andrew to me.
How did you find that pastebin, you just used google?
Yep, Google.
I've always dreamed of being bonus. Thanks, sushi^3
I read a paper on you!
you'll always be a grandpa to me. :')
This is beautiful. Thank you.
How fucking weird is this part of the conversation? He's also a mod, so he knows why [deleted] was added as a mod. Why would even respond to that?