Tsukishiro's plans would've made more sense if he had nothing to do with the White Room. *Year 2 Spoilers*

SpoilerDiscussion

If Ayanokoji's father had simply hired some criminal/corrupt individual named Tsukishiro to expel a student and gave him resources to work with, the plan in Y2V4 would make perfect sense.

A hired thug coming up with the plan to jump Kiyo in a secluded place would be about what you'd expect. (Wasn't it literally hosen's plan in Y2V1?)

Thinking back to his introduction in Year 1 Volume 10 where Tsukishiro attacked Kiyo and Sakayanagi on the rooftop trying to make Kiyo get caught fighting the principal on the cameras, he always acted more like a hired thug than a secret agent.

And in the end, it currently is rather strange that Tsukishiro isn't very invested in expelling Kiyo considering his boss should be very displeased, but it wouldn't be all that weird if he was just some random shady guy being paid to do a job.

Also narratively, having Kiyo defeat the principal is weird because that's the greatest threat he could possibly face. What's the white room student gonna do that the principal of the school couldn't do? It's like he fought the final boss half way through the game.

Posted Oct 4, 2021, 12:48 AM UTC

1410
Rhymar:kikyo5: The Best Girl in ANHS :kikyo10:•

Tsukishiro already stated himself that he has nothing to do with the White Room, and that working for Ayanopapa to expel Kiyotaka is just another job to him.

13
JokingkinBest girls:chiaki3::hiyori4::honami24::ichika4::tsubasa6:•

What volume? I swear my memory is pretty shit cause I don't remember this part.

4
Rhymar:kikyo5: The Best Girl in ANHS :kikyo10:•

It was during Kiyo's conversation with him while he was being stalked by Matsushita

3
NTRconnoisseur•

No explanation in the novel on why he did it like that, even Ayanokoji ask him why he didn't go with more radical method since what he shows was not up to par. So just take it as is, there's a high chance he will come back later during the school festival so he will go all out at the time since he was an outsider now

4
vimboy2005•

well its possible he will return back, the reason for not expelling kiyo was kind of foreshadowed in vol 11.5, when he says wr metthod is both stupid and terrifying, hinting that he does not like it, but tsuki is not stupid enough to directly confront ayanopapa, so he is doing it in a roundabout way by not expelling kiyo but also 'trying' to do so.

3

thats another interesting theory about theory about tsukishiro would nice if that also happened in the later volumes.

1

what do u think about the theory that tsukishiro was a father figure to ichika to free her from wr? (thats why he lacks proper motivation to fully expel kiyotaka in 2-4)

1
NTRconnoisseur•

A bit far fetched, becoz they only have little time to mingle with each other to establish a proper connection. Tsukishiro only got about a year to prepare wr student before enrolling them, so I don't think he bother to care about them in that short period of time. Also Ichika turning into defector was miscalculation from WR side so it didn't align well with your theory. Although she received punishment already from Shiba, it was a bit light compared to what Ayanokoji father has done to Ayanokoji butler so maybe there's something there like she will receive more severe punishment in the future. Or WR simply cut ties with her just like that

1

ah i think u failed to understand that im only pointing out tsukishiro’s possible reason he was not fully serious in expelling ayanokouji.

having 1 year of preparation would be enough to add ichika as possible candidate to be enrolled in anhs to help her defect from wr to have her freedom. Given that he really had plans to do so.

Wr is not tsukishiro wherein he was just a single henchman of his father. Im not even talking about shiba giving punishment to her when that punishment was even too light to be considered as one from matsuo’s case. The point here is that given tsukishiro a much severe punishment by ordering shiba to do so, the connection between tsukishiro and ichika is still not far fetched.

1
AutoModeratorMOD•

FOR WHERE/HOW TO READ/BUY THE LN/MANGA OR TRANSLATION STATUS, PLEASE CHECK THE SUBREDDIT'S GUIDE. YOUR POST WILL BE REMOVED IF IT IS ABOUT THOSE CONCERNS.

Please don't forget to appropriately flair your post and mark as spoiler or/and OC (for original contents like fanarts/fanfics) if necessary. Check the wiki on how to add a link flair!

If you have already done so you can disregard this message!

Thank you for your submission to r/ClassroomOfTheElite!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1