pop_fest420•

This is genius. Drop new legislation on April Fools and no one will question it.

588
Jungle2266•

This is the UK. We're going to lie back and let them fuck us hard anyways, regardless of date's, just like we always do. Protests are one thing we do not do well with

194
this_sort_of_thing•

Protests happen, there's been huge massive protests in this country for as long as I can remember. The real issue is the indifference, the government will sit and watch and allow it all to happen...then they will go back to doing whatever they want once its all died down, protests doesn't affect anything and it never will.

The Western world allows protests to happen but never does anything in response, it's a devious tactic really. But probably the best way of dealing with dissent, ever.

103
[deleted]•

[deleted]

114
the_opinion•

...somewhere, deep in the bowels of GCHQ, a little light blinked red...

79
[deleted]•

But I don't like consequences! I have a job and a degree I need to think about.

Can't I just make 10 minute long rants on youtube and say I am "raising awareness" like that actually means anything?

15
hipsterdysplasia•

"There are certain things, certain activities, that transparently require doing. What's more, there are people who recognize the necessity to do them, and who can do them, and are even willing to do those things. The only challenge in the situation is that these necessary things are unbearably horrible and repugnant things to do.

"(We do it for)...survival. Survival of humanity, and of millions of endangered species. A chance for humanity to work its way out...But, there's not any government in the world that can stand up publicly, and say coldly and openly, that the eight billion people on this collapsing planet are at least four billion people too many.

"We never aim to exterminate any ethnic group; we simply work consistently to lower global birthrates and raise global death rates...taking steps to increase the global death rate doesn't make death into murder. An epidemic isn't genocide, its just another epidemic...Instead of saving thousands of harmful human lives through public-health measures like clean water and sewers, why not train doctors to do elaborate costly measures, like neural brain scans?...A fad here, a twist there, a brief delay in shipping to some hard-hit famine site, or a celebrity scandal to chase off news coverage of some lethal outbreak. The current muddled semi-legal situation with drugs, that was a work of genius. A great source of finance for anybody's underground, and people who shoot up heroin are extremely reckless and credulous.

"The whole military policy of "structure hits" was based on destroying enemy infrastructure - avoiding the political embarrassment of battlefield deaths so that the enemy populace died of apparently natural causes. It was Luddism write large - the first deliberate policy of natural Luddism."

And this is, of course, a double-edged sword that can equally be applied to the structures of the oppressors.

But I am absolutely in favor of the soon-emerging depopulation agenda.

Part of the problem is that the government is trying to maintain order with decreasing power projection capacity, increasing population, increasingly empowered population and decreasing popular legitimacy.

All told, a powder keg.

2
Rogain•

just because of you... because I read your post... I, I am on the list. damn you man. btw Che in "Gorilla Warfare" was an advocate for peaceful protest. Up to the point where throwing shoes into the gears takes over... oh and bullets. Cheers

2
wherethebaby•

Easier said then done no?

1
englad•

threatening violence is against the law though.

0
[deleted]•

If you want to change this system target the resources of the common man, take away his convenient access to food, healthcare, and police.

Move everyone to Detroit?

0
YouDontKnowTheTruth•

I organized one of biggest protests against ACTA in Poland just a few months ago, we literally owned all major cities for a few nights, the government said sorry, nobody will ever say "ACTA" out loud in public here.

Just go outside and start doing something for fuck's sake.

TL;DR you must be retarted if you believe massive protests change nothing. They do. You probably have no fucking idea what a massive protest is.

31
this_sort_of_thing•

Well in this country they don't. Most of the Western world adopts a policy of freedom with indifference. Let the poor people protest, it's not illegal, free speech blah blah blah.... they'll let it happen but won't do anything about it, and that's the easiest way of dealing with dissent.

Start using violence and you legitimise their cause, if they use violence they de-legitimise their cause.

5
soiherduliekmudkips•

I like you. You give me hope. Well done for organising what you did and congratulations on your victory.

Two things.

The largest protests in UK history achieved nothing. Iraq and the Student Fees. Completely ignored. Massive protests. I was present at the largest in UK history. So i do have a fucking idea. Thanks.

Secondly this.

Poland != UK

3
chkris•

I think the protests happened after ACTA was signed, right ?
The protests were huge. Two thumbs up!
ACTA needed ratification, which is an additional approval after it has been signed, and it's because of the huge protests that the European Parliament decided to freeze the ratification.
They were going to refer ACTA to the European Court of Justice for guidance and the hope was that was the final nail in the coffin but guess what happened next :
It's back. Last week, the EU Parliament voted and rejected the plan to sent ACTA to the European Court of Justice. 21 votes for the rejection, 5 in favor of sending it, 2 abstaining. So, 18 % wants the Court to review it.
Wait a second ... during the protests 50 % of all parliament members were against ACTA, now only 18 % , what happened ??
This just goes to show that you should never ever believe a politician!
Do protests help ? Absolutely but politicians screw you over when you're not looking.

2
Islandre•

In Britain they historically don't do much unless the fuel supply is disrupted. There are a few notable exceptions.

1
holohedron•

We all complain that they don't do anything in response to protests, but to play devil's advocate, it is a tricky balance because if the government backed down and changed their policy every time there was a protest the EDL would already be running the country.

I'm not saying the way they handle and respond to large peaceful protests is right, but I suppose there has to be something akin to the standard 'We don't negotiate with hostage takers' policy thatWwestern countries employ.

2
this_sort_of_thing•

The 'we don't negotiate with hostage' policy applies with violent protesters. With peaceful protesters it's just 'ok' and that's it, everyone goes home. It's a lose lose situation either way.

1
icecoldtrashcan•

It'll be just like the student protests. Despite overwhelming opposition, the government essentially ignored them (barely even responded to the concerns of the students). Exactly the same will happen here. I expect there to be protests, but I expect the government to not give a shit.

2
Tayschrenn•

"Che's death meant a lot to me and countless like me at the time, he was a role model, albeit an impossible one for us bourgeois romantics insofar as he went and did what revolutionaries were meant to do—fought and died for his beliefs."

Christopher Hitchens on Che Guevara

1
[deleted]•

then they will go back to doing whatever they want once its all died down, protests doesn't affect anything and it never will.

See Also: Occupy Wall Street

1
poiro•

It doesn't matter anyway, you can have large completely legal protests but if the government refuses to change anything then what's the use? People always complain about public apathy in politics but considering how little control we actually have, all that having interest can do is make you more pissed off.

42
fknrat•

upvoted for sad but true

9
nomis789•

Up voted for truth

0
MrHerpDerp•

Interesting example of paradox inherent in the system. And the more interesting and entertaining you make politics, the worse it gets.

8
the_opinion•

Yep. Remember what an utter failure the poll tax riots were.

2
Theamazinghanna•

You could vote for another government. You still have a democracy, of sorts.

2
gngf123•

FPTP kind of gets in the way of that, unfortunately.

Elections in this country are like flipping a 2-headed coin.

2
diablo_man•

just saying, the 2nd amendment in america was made for when the government stops listening to the people.

1
The_Bravinator•

The government in the US isn't listening to the people, and I don't see many people stepping up to take on that kind of a force with a handgun.

2
[deleted]•

In fairness, last time Labour tried this bullshit, it got shot down in flames. ID Cards have also been scrapped. RIPA passed in the height of FUD/panic of "OMGTERRORISTSEVERYWHERE!!!" but I doubt it would pass now. This will hopefully get shredded in the Commons and then obliterated in the Lords.

25
steviesteveo12•

It seems like an attempt to ask for too much, then when you get shot down you can ask for slightly less and it looks like a compromise.

11
Dreggz•

Overton window in action ಠ_ಠ

2
ChollaIsNotDildo•

Good thing the LibDems are in the coalition to restrain the Tories from excesses like these.

11
ksrm•

So goes the theory anyway.

9
mrpizzaboxman•

Are you joking?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Theamazinghanna•

I hope you're right.

3
[deleted]•

Me too doll, me too.

1
OminousHippo•

That's why you protest sober (coffee and cigs wont hurt you, at least not today) and then rage face when it's party time. Nixon loved jailing hippies for possession of drugs instead of having to listen to their protests, I'm sure you guys have been doing the same at least as long.

23
permanomad•

Hanging on in quiet desperation is the English way.

2
OminousHippo•

Sadly a lot of people were on too much LSD to remember the lessons in their music :(

2
robreddity•

dates

5
Jungle2266•

I was going to edit that but you all know what I mean

2
biskino•

Actually we had one of the biggest protests in the history of the planet right here in the UK on the eve of parliamentary vote on whether to go to Iraq with the US. 750,000 to 1m marched against the war that pretty much opened up this whole rotten can of worms.

2
soiherduliekmudkips•

That was a great moment for democracy in action. Middle Britain eventually woke from its slumber and protesting this Bullshit War went mainstream.

Ruined only by the governments complete disregard for the will of the people.

1
[deleted]•

Ya its easy with murdoch's henchmen programming people into the ultimate state of lethargy. Turning people against each other while making sure they are concerned with frivolous topics that ignore that fact that the people are getting raped... In the asshole... With a condom, rubbing alcohol as lube, and sand as an extra fuck you.

2
goobervision•

A link to Charlie Gilmour who vandalised the most symbolically significant war memorial and then jumped on the front of the future kings car being an idiot and not really protesting against anything? It's bit like the millionaires kids from the riots (against poverty).

1
Jungle2266•

My point being, after all the students protests about University costs, that is the only thing that people can remember about it and heard nothing since.

1
Angstweevil•

I'm not sure. This one would get me on the streets.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
stanfan114•

Did the UK just decide "hey, if Murdock can do it for decades, let's legalize electronic spying and do it ourselves!"?

1
[deleted]•

They should make the protest into a queue...

1
Methedras•

Considering most people in the UK would be protestants (random out of my head fake figure, could be very wrong) that is highly ironic. :D

-10
Tetzel•

I think most people in the uk are now atheist, though it may be Christian slightly in the lead still.

4
Jungle2266•

I'd say we are mainly Christian still. It's just we don't bang on about it all the time, have anti gay marches, tie it heavily into our legal system and the atheists don't feel the need to shout out and prove how clever they are as an atheist like other countries do.

3
LargeTuna06•

False. Christian (Anglican, Roman Catholic, Presbyterian, Methodist) 71.6% https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/uk.html

3
Methedras•

Good point. I would consider myself catholic only from a societal point of view but I'm from NI and thats a whole 'nuther kettle of fish altogether. Still consider myself an athiest. Might be difficult explaining to anyone outside of NI/Ireland/UK though.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

14
perfectlyskin•

And what has been its effect since then? April Fools Day legislation..

2
Solivaga•

Everyone's too concerned with the Pasty Tax, that and stockpiling petrol in jam jars in the airing cupboard

1
TheMightyAdzilla•

Don't be silly, you store it in a small container then pour it into a larger container kept in a room with no ventilation by candlelight...

3
rach2K•

This is blatantly an April fool's joke, although it says a lot about the state of government that people seem ready to believe it.

1
The_Bravinator•

It would be beyond stupid to make an April Fool's joke out of something that could start widespread protests or riots.

2
rach2K•

Oh god. They really think they can do this.

2
The_Bravinator•

Apparently. :/ The question is, will they be able to get away with it? I hope not, especially if the public come out in force against it, but the public don't always get listened to, as we've seen in the past.

2
thisnamestoolong•

But this is an April Fools Joke? Right? Please?

*crickets

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
macutchi•

Fuck this , Fuck the government, Fuck the church, Fuck god, Fuck chav's and benefit whore's, Fuck England , Fuck the poo-lice, Fuck being mid 30's, no job and no future, Fuck Renting because the banks wont lend, Fuck toff's running my country, Fuck facebook, twitter and all the rest of those advertising trolls, LOVE PEOPLE JUST BECAUSE YOU CAN! Fuck war, Fuck the pope and his billions, Fuck controlled substances, Fuck I.E.D's, Fuck putin, Fuck sky Fuck murdoch (not A-TEAM) Fuck lazy billionaires Fuck the gutter press Fuck "the apprentice" Fuck it all, fuck it all................................................................

-1
geoffacakes•

Not sure if April fool or just downright scary!!

461
Thisisyoureading•

I am hoping it is April Fools, but I suspect not.

178
Azradesh•

It isn't.

135
krugmanisapuppet•

(ominous silence)

dear ISPs, courts, and police, please ignore the deranged cult members in Parliament. sincerely, the world.

65
[deleted]•

[deleted]

32
vicegrip•

Interestingly, the Canadian Conservative government is actively pushing forward legislation to do the same thing.

In Canada, "the warrantless-spying-act" is widely unpopular. Yet the government appears to want to ignore public opinion and further resorts to wild arguments to validate its attack of civil rights and privacy. Vic Toews, the Public Safety Minister, went as far as to say that "if you didn't support the government, you supported the child pornographers".

One wonders at the source of this impetus to perform all this additional surveillance.

19
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0

Wow... At least our government tries to hide the fact they are doing this.

11
the_opinion•

Our government already do this. This bill just aims to make the process simpler for them.

5
revolting_blob•

I don't know whether to upvote or downvote you :(

2
1Ender•

Wow, i'm actually really shocked about this, i was for sure it was a April fools joke until i saw it on two separate websites.

2
phanboy•
7
SarahC•
4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
Thisisyoureading•

Actually it isn't a fake, sorry to burst your imagination. It is an archive news article from the BBC's old site (you can find even older versions that are so early internetish it is embarrassing) Until the BBC News redesign onto word press it did not allow comments on their articles whatsoever, unless they were a specific 'debate' article which was based around comments of their users.

2
tweek17•

I doubt this sort of legislation would pass in the Lords.

56
maxq333•

The Home Office says the move is key to tackling crime and terrorism

Bring terrorism into it = automatic pass.

67
[deleted]•

This has been tried before with the same excuse and scrapped. Many times.

29
geoffacakes•

I,m suprised i havn't heard "But think of the children" yet!!

19
kneel_armstrong•

Terrorists are the new children.

18
soiherduliekmudkips•

That comes out when the gloves are off.

5
epsy•

Save our terrorists!

2
sybau•

Harper tried that in Canada with his surveillance bill and it worked terribly... UK cons probably learned from their Canadian counterparts mistakes.

1
el_poderoso•

It's the UK, not America.

15†
pib712•

The counter-terrorism card is played all the time here in the UK. It's used to justify

  • putting CCTV everywhere (even ones with speakers attached, ordering people to leave the area)
  • monitoring phone calls
  • indefinite detention policies
  • ID cards
  • proposals for invasive security measures at airports and even train stations (though luckily we've got nothing approaching the TSA here).

Not all of these policies have taken off, but one of the attitudes that's grown in government over the past ten years is that more fear is better, that more information on people's movements and actions is better, and that anyone who raises objections must have something to hide.

72
pjflameboy•

doesn't matter anybody who is against it will be on the side of the child pornographers thats how it goes nowadays

3
filioqueclause•

That didn't work in 2006 for 90 day detention, though. The Lords kicked it out despite Blair's repeated use of the t word.

8
the_opinion•

Nope. That gambit has failed in the past

2
Angstweevil•

The Home Office says the move is key to tackling crime and terrorism and threats to children.

There you go, the perfect trifecta

2
[deleted]•

In the USA, not UK. Politicians here rarely play the terrorist card.

1
suntzusartofarse•

Politicians here rarely play the terrorist card.

Well, they do, I can remember Brown and 'Jack Boots' Jacqui Smith using that excuse to bring in 28 and then 48 days detention without charge, that and 'OMG! paedophiles!'.

It's just no-one really buys in to the bullshit.

18
the_opinion•

True. Because, unlike the USA - and this is not a dig - the people of Britain have lived with the threat of terrorism for decades. The terrorism card generally has little effect as a result.

2
maxq333•

I'm from the UK. It is an obvious pass card even if it rarely gets used. Think it makes it sound even more serious cos it rarely gets used tbh.

1
[deleted]•

yes because the usa doesn't have naked body scanners and indefinite detention in guantanamo bay

1
Kinkykat•

It is true, sadly is has nothing at all to do with that, anyone with any sense would be using a VPN and encrypting all the things!

1
SlapTheSalami•

its not America

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
Clbull•

Then they could just pass it again in 12 months.

3
Bigdave28•

The lords no longer have teeth. Please correct me if I'm wrong (and I hope that I am) but as I understand it the lords can only slow things down these days not stop them.

1
Giant_Badonkadonk•

As far as I'm aware they can still stop legislation, though usually they just demand certain aspects are changed rather than just binning it. It usually works like this; parliament propose some legislation and if it passes then house of lords look at it, if they then find parts which they do not agree with then they pass it back to parliament who then renegotiate the legislation with what the house of lords decided in mind. With this system I don't see why the house of lords can't just demand that they change it so much that it effectively becomes a much less severe piece of legislation.

Though this is all just hypothetical as this legislation hasn't even been proposed yet so still has to go through every political hoop, and I am more than confident it won't go anywhere. Something almost exactly the same as it has already been tried in the past and it failed miserably.

3
ProfoundlyDeaf•

Please stop calling the House of Commons Parliament. Parliament is the Crown, the Commons and the Lords together.

2
talking_to_myself•

The Lords can't hold it up in parliament forever.

1
gabbeelva•

A similar directive is already in effect here in Sweden where I live, and guess when it was implemented? 01/04/2009>

It passed here in sweden, why not in the UK?

1
EVILFISH2•

proud western freedoms

28
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

15
InactiveUser•

"Glass half full"...

Pfft~

4
Yarcofin•

Probably not an April Fools joke as just recently someone here was sent to jail for racist comments they wrote on Twitter, the kinds of stuff thousands of kids are spouting on Xbox live every day. During the London Riots plenty of people were calling for the government to have access to your Facebook account, etc. or to BLOCK THE SITES ENTIRELY in times of emergencies.

11
jlt6666•

Funny, wasn't the government criticizing Arab countries for doing the same during the Arab sppring?

10
The_Bravinator•

The US government was criticizing those countries for aggressively suppressing protests during the same period that police here were regularly injuring peaceful Occupy protesters. The scale was obviously much different, but it does go to show that governments, on the whole, are sadly prone to hypocrisy.

2
Insomn•

NIMBYism, Not In My Back Yard.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
the_opinion•

The spaghetti tree joke was in 1957.

8
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
TheAmazingOctopus•

This better be an April Fool's Day joke.

2
geoffacakes•

I don't think it is. :(

1
WaitThisIsntDigg•

absurdity and reality might soon not be so different.

2
BigassJohnBKK•

Has to be a joke - by the UK gov itself, since it's being reported on multiple respectable news sites. ROFL that queenie sure has a sense of humor!

Next thing Obama will announce it's legal to assassinate US citizens anywhere in the world for being terrorist suspects without any due process!

funny, not

2
jonkrav•

I don't see how this is any different then sticking cameras inside everyones home and invading their privacy. This is kind of fucked up.

246
WhoShotJR•
29
17_irons•

I fully expected that link to go to an excerpt from 1984. All I could say was... HOLY SHIT. Really, I just commented to save this link though. This needs upvotes.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
jkkaplan•

Imagine all those jobs it'll create to watch all the cameras. Destroying privacy = job creation.

5
Lilday•

That is actually a good idea in the context of that article.

Problem families. Families who are prone to committing crime and generally fucking shit up. If they live in a council house at least - then don't the council have the right to survey their activity within that property?

1
nomis789•

And here's the key point, use any sort of website that can access your webcam? This legislation will let them see that.

22
KamehamehaWave•

Pretty sure you pulled that out of your ass. According to the article, the legislation doesn't allow the contents of messages to be seen without a warrant, just the senders and recipients. Similarly, I think that it would monitor which URLs you visit.

15
nomis789•

The "real time" monitoring allowed with use of warrant would make it a possibility

9
[deleted]•

nobody ever abused their government-given powers before, right? Can you imagine how much people are salivating over this right now? You literally can access the browsing history and email correspondence of anyone you want, if you can get away with it.

I assure you people are already thinking about how to do it.

3
KamehamehaWave•

That has nothing to do with anything I said, but sure, I agree, it's a bad proposal.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
trackerbishop•

the us is already working toward using your tvs with webcams to spy

3
freakwent•

Because there aren't any cameras, that's one difference.

-9
soiherduliekmudkips•

Theres webcameras. /s

3
the_opinion•

Turn it off.

1
[deleted]•

Because they will require a warrant to monitor what you're doing. The proposals are for them to merely see who you're talking with and how long for without a warrant. That's like police sat in a car outside your house looking through the windows. Police are already allowed to do this.

-19
moooo566•

Except this time, I don't have curtains I can just open and close. This is more like them getting an itemised copy of every phone bill, bank statement and receipt I ever get.

22
Frankeh•

Except this time, I don't have curtains I can just open and close.

Sure you do. 1024 bit encryption.

3
the_opinion•

Bit hysterical. In what way is it them getting an itemised copy of all that? As mentioned in the post you just replied to obtaining this information will require a warrant.

I'm concerned that our civil liberties are being eroded, and this bill is another nail in the coffin, but am I actually personally concerned that I personally will be affected directly by this bill? No. Beyond my tax affairs, the gub'mint has no interest in what I'm doing. There's no reason why they'd want to get a warrant to look into my browsing and email, and I'm not arrogant enough to think I do anything important enough to put me on their radar. This only makes it a simpler process for them to do something they can already do, that I am in no danger of falling foul of.

I know people who have, genuinely, been put under government surveillance, phones tapped, followed everywhere by shady men and what-have-you. Guess what? Nothing happened to them. Every time this shit comes up, people freak out as if they're going to suddenly be un-personed by men in a black Mercedes, just because they looked at some porn on the Internet.

Fight the bill. Write to your MP, and your MEP. Stand up for your rights. But don't get hysterical and paranoid, nobody's looking at you.

-2
ZombieWomble•

Bit hysterical. In what way is it them getting an itemised copy of all that? As mentioned in the post you just replied to obtaining this information will require a warrant.

Actually, that's not quite true. A warrant is required to obtain contents of the e-mails, phone-calls, and so forth. But getting a list of websites visited, e-mails received and phone calls made would be possible without a warrant under this bill - or, at least, that appears to be the current implication.

That has staggering implications for privicy - if things can be analysed without a warrant, well, why don't you just analyse them as a matter of course? And, if you're doing that for terrorism, why not track it for other signs of inappropriate behaviour too? Processing requirements may be an issue, but leaving privicy in the hands of Moore's Law is not something I'm very happy about.

4
coned88•

derp

-3
[deleted]•

Anyone could get curtains. It's called TOR, vpn, etc. This type of legislation will encourage people to become more secure, another plus point I think. Also police do currently have powers to request text message records etc with a warrant, they same as they will have under the proposed legislation.

-15
dddoug•

That's where the analogy falls short. My parents can understand the functions in curtains and can install and operate them but tor, vpn etc are beyond many peoples technical abilities and understanding.

18
ctindel•

Since when is tor secure from the government?

3
moooo566•

I already have curtains. Almost every home in the country has curtains. I do not have TOR, vpn or anything. While I know that this exists, I daresay there are plenty who don't. Everyone knows how to use curtains.

No-one reads the letters that are sent to my door. As far as I can tell (and correct me if I'm wrong) this gives them the power to see not only who I am communicating with, but also what I say, any pictures or links that I send them and indeed monitor more or less anything I send to anyone through the internet. Not everyone who wants to hide things does it because they want to do something illegal. For every message about plotting a robbery or a bombing, there are probably hundreds of thousands of messages hiding nothing more than sexts and the like.

This allows them to do it on a whim without having to go through the courts, which I am unhappy about in any event. To have any group of people reading through what is effectively a comprehensive rundown of much of what I do, whether or not I have anything private for other reasons or downright illegal, horrifies me. This makes it far, far easier for them. And that, in my opinion, is wrong.

3
Detry•

As long as you have nothing to hide? AMIRITE!?

Privacy is so two-thousand-and-late.

2
woocheese•

I think it will encourage terrorists, pedophiles, pirates, online drug dealers and hackers to operate more securely. (Not comparing those people to each other though!!)

Sure this could allow for the highlighting of people that are in constant communication with known terrorists but it will also be an invasion of privacy. A privacy that we as the people of Britain deserve to have. Being free to communicate without the feeling of a secret police opening your mail is something people here are generally all proud to have.

If someone wants to bomb buildings where I live they are going to do it weather GCHQ is monitoring the number of emails they have sent to some terror cell or not.

2
thebassethound•

Another reason to start voting Pirate Party.

199
OneClassyBloke•

I'm already a member.

38
robreddity•

I'm not only a member, I bought the company!

12
WaitThisIsntDigg•

nice try Romney.

14
MrHerpDerp•

buying companies

1
Thjoth•

Spatula City, we sell spatulas....and that's all!

1
abw•

Unfortunately the Pirate Party is already dead in the water. As much as I approve of their motives and manifesto, they're a one issue party with a name that implies they endorse criminal activity (I'm not saying that they do necessarily endorse it, just that it sounds like they do). The vast majority of sensible, middle England voters will avoid it like the plague.

I wish it wasn't the case, but politics these days is all about marketing and the Pirate Party have missed the boat.

That said, I fully support the PP for doing what they're doing. But I fear that the best they can do is raise awareness over these issues and perhaps persuade other parties that this is a popular agenda that they should embrace.

EDIT: I should clarify that I was talking specifically about the UK.

16
SwampySoccerField•

And yet the PP did amazingly well in Germany these past elections. Its a new party, is growing steadily, and continually being a naysayer just hampers the growth potential. If you really care, then be active.

But I fear that the best they can do is raise awareness over these issues and perhaps persuade other parties that this is a popular agenda that they should embrace.

Wouldn't that be an improvement alone?

20
Shivalli•

Yes but, unlike the UK (which uses FPTP), Germany is a democracy.

3
abw•

I certainly don't dispute the points you're making. I should have been more clear in stating that I was talking about the UK specifically. I think Germany and also some of the Scandinavian countries are leading the way here and I wish we were following their example. But right now we have far too many middle-class, middle-aged "safe" voters who read the Daily Mail and believe whatever it tells them. The Pirate Party doesn't stand a chance against that kind of institutionalised conservatism.

2
SwampySoccerField•

Can't disagree with you there. The UK is a mess in a crapshoot.

1
deleated•

I think people are intelligent enough to understand the entirely positive connotations of the name Pirate Party.

6
[deleted]•
2
abw•

I wish I had your optimism. The people we're talking about here are the kind that believe whatever the Daily Mail tells them to believe.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

Sorry but I make a living selling software to clients who want to buy it so why should I support a party who wants to make it so that it is legal to take the work I do and use it for free?

1
Joakal•

It's hard to find a Pirate Party in the world that wants to abolish Copyright. Here's PPUK's policy on copyright: http://www.pirateparty.org.uk/policies/uk-2011/copyrights-patents/

tl;dr: Copyright policy is more than about licensing intellectual property.

As for why they're named 'pirate': http://www.pirateparty.org.uk/blog/2010/may/4/whats-name/

Here's a wiki article that briefly mentions it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pirate_party#History

2
soiherduliekmudkips•

I'll only vote for them if we get a piratebay.se mirror, on a raspberry pi aerial drone above every street. Is this in their campaign manifesto yet?

0
talking_to_myself•

My neighbour's unsecured wi-fi has never looked so tempting...

164
bilwis•

Joke's on you when they arrest all your neighbors and you don't have any internet left!

171
crystalsucks•

The government came and took my internet.

27
randomsnark•

They came for my neighbour, and I said nothing, because seriously, fuck that guy.

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

This cannot be done at ISP level, it's impossible. If it goes through, it'll be done at the level of the mail provider/social network.

13
Virtblue•

It can and already is done in the USA, Carnivore was introduced in 1998 and has mostly been upgraded now but the same program is still in effect.

9
[deleted]•

Not the same thing. It targets specific users first off, and it's a simple packet sniffer so it can't look at the contents of SSL'd traffic.

3
nevesis•

Uh, it most certainly can and will be done at the ISP level. Actually; it will be done at the backbone level (British Telecom), just as it is in the US (AT&T).

7
[deleted]•

Those systems are useless if the packets are encrypted.

1
nevesis•

Unless the CAs provide the government root certificates for MitM ... which is far easier than installing software on every Exchange/Sendmail server in the UK.

7
Magzy•

Tell me why/how a VPN won't circumvent this

1
Jetboy01•

A VPN will obfuscate your movements somewhat, but you will have to refrain from using any services within the country or you'll just be monitored at the service providers end and make yourself look suspicious.

Using TOR will help, but you'll still leave a paper trail with any service providers you use. If at any point that paper trail can be matched to you, then it's game over and you'll be monitored just like anyone else.

1
freakwent•

Don't ISPs provide email in Britain?

2
[deleted]•

Yes, but you don't have to use it. Most people don't.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
freakwent•

Lots of people do in Australia... YYMV I guess.

1
[deleted]•

They did in the 90's.

2
canireddit•

So they expect Facebook and Google to just hand over the keys then?

2
[deleted]•

Basically, yes. Countries like the UEA do this already so it won't be too hard for Google et al. to just let the UK in on it too.

Next step, internet censorship. Oh, wait.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
squatly•

Just in time for the annual summer riots!

155
Solivaga•

which is the perfect way to devalue dissenting voices - let's smash stuff up on May day and thus enable the casual dismissal of naysayers as idiot radicals

24
Bobzer•

Well to be fair it's not like dissenting voices make a difference anyway.

2
Thisisyoureading•

Surely this is a very big issue?

147
F_A_F•

Front page of BBC News so yes....it is a big issue.

110
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-11
morphintime•

I guess I'm still the only one that finds this line fucking gross.

-14
WindSandStars•

An article on how Gary Oldman lost his script to the new Batman film was "front page" last week. The BBC is a joke.

-14
feeblemuffin•

what, the BBC is a joke? it's probably the best news organisation in the world. compared to american "news" that focuses on stating how great america is, constant patriotism, and weird/stupid newsreaders. this perfectly sums up american news, i still can't believe they actually air this nonsense!? american's seem so over dramatic and strange!

5
moodyfloyd•

american media is a joke. i use bbc and al jazeera english

1
andrewtheart•

Fox New's patheticness is well known. But thanks for educating us on that.

For the most part, the rest of the American mainstream news is OK

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
soiherduliekmudkips•

More like an attempt to bring into line the reality of what already happens illegally with a means to do it in a more transparent and legal way. GB is already a surveillance state, thats the big issue.

60
DownvoteAttractor•

Everytime a government tries to do this sort of stuff, it makes the demand for cryptosystems greater. The only people will be affected by this are ordinary Joes. Real crims (terrorists, corporates etc) will put up defences, and people who have nothing to hide except their private lives will not use cryptosystems.

51
soiherduliekmudkips•

They have more surgical methods to try and control the big fish, this is not about catching serious organised criminals and terrorists. This is all about average Joe and expanding their eye on him, thin end of the wedge stuff.

32
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
DownvoteAttractor•

Um, yes, that's my point, I think?

3
[deleted]•

They have been doing this for a while, just not openly. Hence all the faf about refusing to let the "intercept evidence" be used in open court and about secret trials. If they let it be used in court they would have to admit that they store everything you do online for at least a year already.

13
[deleted]•

It depends on what you mean by that.

ISPs store your web history for at least six months by law, but I don't see how the government would itself be able to store "everything you do online", especially communications, because it's difficult. Doing it at ISP level is impossible, not least because social networks and e-mail systems all use SSL these days, so they'd have to get every e-mail provider and social network and ISP to manually send them copies of their info illegally. Not too likely.

1
soiherduliekmudkips•

social networks and e-mail systems all use SSL these days

"You are trying to send unencrypted information across a page that is encrypted, this means that anyone could be able to read it. Do you want to continue anyway?

Please check this box if you do not want to see this warning again."

But seriously though. If what 'he meant by that' was just whats in the article, then intercept evidence is already simply visited URL's and emails in contact with. Which is seen with or without encryption of the content of email, or the pages content.

1
[deleted]•

Well, with SSL you can still see the website you're going to but not the specific page you're viewing or any information going through the site (if it's done properly, which it is with major social networks). For e-mail, you can see the e-mail provider but not the account you're using or the person you're talking to unless you get that information from the provider.

1
irishchris1•

yes this should be huge!

3
TwistTurtle•

Does it concern the X-Factor or some other bullshit reality show? No? Then it's not a big issue for the British public.

God I fucking hate my country.

2
joelthelion•

If it can push the adoption of encryption for email and http, I'm all for it.

0
Toenails100•

The liberal conservatives will hate it, the majority of liberal democrats will despise is and Labour will vote against it because they vote against everything.

I really can't see how this will get though the HoC let alone the HoL.

97
toodrunktoocare•

I agree. Everyone is acting like it's already law but it's just a proposal and it has been defeated before. The ISP's are already saying it's expensive and ultimately unworkable, the free-speech advocates are up in arms and, as you rightly said, the liberal MP's won't stand any of it. Hopefully it's doomed before it begins... However, just incase it's not, what we should all be doing now is thinking of how we can help ensure this gets blocked, not bemoaning how our rights are going to get raped again.

60
acabftp•

This is what I thought when the NHS bill was proposed...

33
Clbull•

Remember when they blocked the report assessing the risks of this legislation from the public?

Yeah, that's a really good way to reassure the public that "Your NHS will not get butt-raped."

15
[deleted]•

Ohh..glowing optimism lives on in some.

1
Bigdave28•

Yes this

-1
montret•

And I don't think its April fools: 1 April 2012 Last updated at 12:17. This is after 12.00 and they've not owned up.

the majority of liberal democrats will despise it

Planet earth calling Mars!

"But the enviroment DUDE! The enviroment!"

"But Schools DUDE! Schools!"

"But public walkways DUDE! public walkways!"

"But Racism DUDE! Racism!"

"But Brussels DUDE! Brussels!"

"But Government Unity DUDE! Government Unity!"

"But the middle east (Israel) DUDE! the middle east (Israel)!"

"But the pipe smoking nudists won't mind DUDE! The pipe smoking nudists won't mind!"

Actual quote from an Ian (!!!!) who posted a comment to the BBC website:

Ian 45 Minutes ago

We are happy to post everything on Facebook for all to read, we are happy for Google to know everything we view. Google have been reading our emails for years. Yet we wont let the government do so in the interests of security. Why do we trust Google, Facebook and the News of the World so much but not our elected government. I am not for this change at all, but we need to put it into perspective

BECAUSE I'VE NEVER USED FACEBOOK OR TWITTER OR GMAIL YOU FUCKING PIPE SMOKING NUDIST LIBIAN!!!

8
Heaney555•

You use google.

11
Retro_virus•

But what can Google do? Target advertisements at you, sell your browsing habits on to marketing companies. A government can lock you up in a damp basement and waterboard you for googling 'terrorism'.

26
f0rk123•

If you actually read the news story, that isn't what this legislation wants to do. The intelligence agency has to ask for an individuals details with a warrant.

-5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
soiherduliekmudkips•

Its my default and only search engine. Though using chrome means i assume i might as well be.

1
lightsaberon•

Interesting that he completely ignores the crucial aspect called choice.

10
NotFromReddit•

Sure we let Google and Facebook know a few things. But at least we still have the option to do things in private. Also, Google and Facebook can't arrest you.

6
soiherduliekmudkips•

Ian is a proud patriotic citizen of the great nation of Googleania. He has nothing to fear.

1
Rhythm23•

As with a lot of the elements being pushed by the ConLib coalition (NHS privatisation, university charges) this is a proposal that Labour started but backed off from. Public opposition stopped this last time but post 9/11 and 7/7 I'm not so sure the nebulous "public" would be against this so much any more :-/

7
Virtblue•

The last time Labour pushed this was post 9/11 and 7/7, the Tories abhorred it and so did the lib dems.

2
uat2d•

And even if it passed (which it certainly won't), it would be incompatible with EU law.

4
el_muchacho•

I really doubt this is a problem in a country where the Police has been proven to spy some citizens for the benefit of Rupert Murdoch. Also, the french president (right wing) is all for something like that too. From flawed democracies, we're fast becoming fascist democracies.

7
Vibster•

When has that ever stopped us?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Virtblue•

UK very regularly ignores the rulings of the EU court of human rights see the DNA database for an example of that.

1
naich•

This isn't some private member's bill. This is "legislation, due to be announced soon". Unless there is a significant rebellion in the ConDem ranks, it will become law.

3
Clbull•

It will get through. You seem to be forgetting that:

  • Unless it's a very touchy matter of great personal debate (i.e. abortion), generally politicians will follow their masters in terms of distributing their vote. The Conservative Party will undoubtedly want it in, the Liberal Democrats will have to follow their masters and the Labour Party will oppose it. And regardless of what one says, Labour have a smaller proportion of MPs.

  • Britain is in bed with the United States, who are trying to pass similarly restrictive legislation. Just look at ACTA, SOPA and PCIP.

  • The Liberal Democrats broke a fucking electoral pledge. Do you really trust these morons with keeping their word? That's like trusting Mark Zuckerberg with your privacy.

Put it this way, at the rate the government is going, I can see our ISPs condemned to invading peoples' privacy. They already fucked us over on tuition fees and the NHS.

If this does pass, I will NOT be happy. I'm already pissed off at the previous government for sneaking out the Digital Economy Act.

1
StonedPhysicist•

The Liberal Democrats broke a fucking electoral pledge. Do you really trust these morons with keeping their word? That's like trusting Mark Zuckerberg with your privacy.

People seem willing to trust Labour and the Tories, who haven't exactly been paragons of truth and honour.

1
Solivaga•

Scattered back-benchers from all parties will oppose it - but by and large the front bench will support it, and it will pass. We don't have the American concept of sanctity of freedom of speech. We don't have American levels of political activism, we already have more CCTV cameras per person than any other country in the world, and with a choice between the Lib Dems, Labour and the Tories we effectively have no mainstream distinction in political parties.

-2
dirtyliberals•

liberal conservatives

Oxymoron?

Edit: wtf is with the downvotes, fuck you all too.

-7
Bear4188•

liberal and conservative are only opposites in the twisted definition of American politics.

5
Toenails100•

There is a wing of the Conservative party that tends to be very Liberal on civil rights and other issues. Im thinking people like David Davis, the LBGTories and other similar groups.

3
dirtyliberals•

You mean libertarians?

1
Toenails100•

That might be close enough but Liberal Conservatism is a valid ideology. In Europe Liberal has a different meaning to what people in the USA would define as Liberal and as such the two are more compatible.

Edit: additionally there are areas like environmentalism and the welfare state in which Liberal Conservatives differ from Libertarians.

6
ardbeg•

Yeah. Fuck this. Fucking fuck it.

93
InactiveUser•

Fuck yeah! This is fucking fucked, those fucking fuckers.

32
RedMushtoom•

It's fucking fucked-up, I fucking tell you! Only a fucking fuck-wit would fucking think this is a good fucking idea. What the fuck is wrong with those fuck? Don't they fucking understand the fucking societal fucking consequences of what they're fucking doing? Fuck!

-4
jibbist•

CUNTS

27
gmfthelp•

recorded!

1
right2exist•

I honestly don't see a problem with it. Do you know how many billions of emails are sent per day? Just because they can look at your email doesn't mean they are going to unless you give them reason to suspect you. Why should you worry anyway unless you've got something illegal to hide anyway...

-2
nascentt•

How sweet and naive. You don't think everything's going to be automated scanned, and recorded? Any time in the future the government want, they can just fish through your stuff and use it against you.

2
schueaj•

Dammit Britain, 1984 is not an instruction manual!

77
teknic111•

I've seen this comment before.

28
Timmmmbob•

Woa, this is such an original comment!

9
[deleted]•

Britain is increadibly 1984, there are ANPR cameras situated on sides of roads for no god damn reason than to log that you passed that camera at that time....

2
chickenswithaxes•

emails will be written in Newspeak

1
imthebossofme•

Well it looks like all my traffic will be going through an offshore VPN provider from now on then.

75
EquanimousMind•
43
soiherduliekmudkips•

Anyone who trusted HMA to not be cop-friendly is a dumbass. Lulzsec were dumbasses. Cheap though, fast, and never had a problem with torrenting.

4
imthebossofme•

Was the very page I visited a few hours ago to pick a provider :)

3
EquanimousMind•

Its become the standard response against the 'graduated response' in the US; but works just as well against most of Hollywood's schemes around the world. They really are just wasting time and money. They don't realize the capacity for the internet to evolve.

3
Wanderlustfull•

Who'd you pick?

1
imthebossofme•

I haven't committed yet but it's a toss up between btguard and ipredator.

I also plan on picking up a cheap VPS to use as an SSH jumpbox, lowendbox should help me find a suitable one for next to nothing.

2
frixionburne•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Happy_Gaming•

While that is a prudent step, TOR should be sufficant to ensure privacy browsing.

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

46
soiherduliekmudkips•

I'm an average joe who doesn't stand out from the majority mould in anyway, and i support this message.

Its great to live in a free country.

8
Taedirk•

Which country?

1
[deleted]•

You mean TOR which was developed for the US Military?

4
[deleted]•

TOR is but a syllable or two away from torrorist. Must be contained with a huge trawler net.

4
sanph•

you forgot pedophile

2
Rhyotion•

Sometimes business needs to be private, why else would those in power try and black-box every damn thing they do?

Edit: you need a competitive edge in business these days, or you risk getting sold out to someone less than worthy of your love-drenched wonder product. Apparently alot of techology firms here are being spyed on by chinese techs, one major firm being Intel. Personally, it frightens me to think that China, in all their horrible human rights violations has blue prints that americans have worked hard on, not for money, but for love, and china goes and makes a crap carbon copy, example: look at their cities they construct so haphazardly, how childish of them!

yep, fallacies everywhere.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

TOR is slow as fuck though. At least for me.

45
soiherduliekmudkips•

Reddit should organise an International Tor Day annually. If reddit can attract 10,000's of users to participate as relays (edit: no need to be the risky exit node, just be relays) for just one day that would show how useable/fast it could be. Problem with tor is not enough relays.

Edit: MAY DAY. May 1st. International Tor Day. Lets do this chaps. Join /r/Torday for info.

45
[deleted]•

The thing with being a relay is that you don't know what people are going on through your relay. They could be going on highly illegal stuff.

12
[deleted]•

May 1st will likely be a bit of an issue due to the heat of May Day strikes (last I heard this was still going to happen), but I really do like your idea of an International Tor Day.

3
Happy_Gaming•

Check out Operation Electronic Leviathan they are trying to promote awareness of privacy options for Canada who has similar laws in the works

2
[deleted]•

If my internet connection didn't have caps, I'd gladly be a relay node.

1
sadthatthisisneeded•

Just verified this using the Tails LiveUSB linux distro, connected to tor within seconds and browsing reddit with it. Not even that slow. Maybe 50% of normal speed. Really not a lot to trade in exchange for immunity from the massive loss of privacy the internet is facing these days.

Edit: After having just visited Redditor, the .onion version of reddit, i have to clarify that. Onions are slow as fuck. The surface web is 50% as fast. Which is by far what most of us would use it for. The Onions are <20% it seems...

2
[deleted]•

You could put up a non-exit relay, others will be encouraged to useTOR because it's faster. Then, they in turn may start relaying. Walla, faster TOR for everyone!

1
chakalakasp•

Tor is not for privacy. Tor is for anonymity. There is a big difference. Tor is very much not private.

15
[deleted]•

Interested in using Tor but not sure what you mean. Would you be able to explain?

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
soiherduliekmudkips•

So if you want to talk about your radical views on tibetan freedom, you're OK.

If you want to plan where when and with whom you'll paint "free tibet" near tianenmen square. Welcome to the party van.

Thats the general jist of it.

2
redcoat•

Sorry, being dumb. Can you elaborate?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Should-I-Stay•

Yes. You need end-to-end encryption + anonymity to be truly private. Also consider where the other "end" is. If it's someone who will, decrypt, archive, then answer requests from government, it still isn't private.

1
[deleted]•

Of course it is not, neither is the internet.

You are as private as you make yourself on Tor.

1
mjbat7•

Indeed, but not for file sharing

7
Happy_Gaming•

no you need i2p for that

9
mjbat7•

Hmm, that looks promising for when the Internet is reigned in in my own country, thanks for the heads up!

7
jderm1•

I had the Vidalia bundle but now Torbutton doesn't work with the newest Firefox. I was going to download the Tor Browser Bundle instead but do I need to uninstall the previous bundle first?

2
chromiselda•

TOR browsing is banned on a lot of private trackers.

1
soiherduliekmudkips•

Welcome to the list.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
bilwis•

ILLEGAL ALL THE TRAFFIC!

-5
zgzgzg•

FYI, your provider can monitor your traffic at the source (meaning, right out of your computer) watch what you type and read.

before going to the TOR node or VPN server your data goes to your internet provider's computers: they read it all.

good luck.

only one solution : get off the internet and talk to people IRL

-11
imthebossofme•

Nope. The traffic that leaves your home (i.e. trusted) network/computer is encrypted, save for some added headers including src & dest IPs.

If you can't trust the security of your home network or personal computer, you should assume you're already compromised.

6
zgzgzg•

can there be backdoors in our internet boxes planted there by those who cant to monitor traffic? in this case, are we fucked?

-2
soiherduliekmudkips•

YES BURN THE INTERNET BOXES ITS THE ONLY WAY QUICKLY NOW THEY'RE NEARLY HERE

3
robreddity•

For the love of god, WHO'S WATCHING OUR INTERNET BOXES?

2
imthebossofme•

It's not impossible, but it's highly improbable.

If you're that concerned about the privacy of your data (as I am) you should test your home network to ensure nothing is misconfigured or that there are any open ports/active services which shouldn't be there.

My ISP provided router sits infront of my own router, which is the gateway of my network. Any data that leaves my gateway should be encrypted if it's sensitive, that way I don't really have to worry about swapping out ISP provided routers or their config, as any sensitive data they see should be encrypted.

I order to ensure the integrity and confidentiality of data you must ensure that you trust the source, destination and method of transport. If you can't trust any of the above you can't in all honesty say you're secure.

Basically anything outside of your home network should be untrusted (i.e. the internet).

1
Krenair•

They can't see what you type or read, only what your internet connection sends/receives. Even that is useless if it's encrypted by Tor.

3
zgzgzg•
  1. do you really believe that the people/powers who want to monitor stuff can't hack TOR encryption?

  2. what about the internet boxes

doesn't your provider has access to your router/internet box? can they install a backdoor in it? can there be a backdoor in your internet box ? what about backdoors IN windows/macosx?

im just asking if it's possible technically. if yes, tell me.

then after that, it's CONSPIRACY Theories of course and therefore insanity, right? no need to talk about it.

just asking

-4
soiherduliekmudkips•

The best conspiracy theories are theories. You're at best making wild hypotheses without sufficient prior research into the facts of the technologies you're describing.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Krenair•

doesn't your provider has access to your router/internet box? can they install a backdoor in it? can there be a backdoor in your internet box ? what about backdoors IN windows/macosx?

No. Don't think so. Even if they did it, it wouldn't effect Tor's encryption. As for backdoors in Windows/Mac OS X that's a non-issue because I don't use either for anything I consider private, just gaming and wikipedia anti-vandalism.

1
robreddity•

I can't decide if you are more wrong than imbecile, or more imbecile than wrong.

3
soiherduliekmudkips•

Nope, its encrypted before leaving the network card on the computer. If your computer is verifiably uncompromised its airtight. Even if there are other devices on your network that are compromised they cant penetrate that tunnel to snoop (i.e the internet "box").

1
Kman1121•

I'd rather be free than safe.

65
Luke273•

"Any society that would give up a little liberty to gain a little security will deserve neither and lose both." - Benjamin Franklin

42
hahainternet•

Which is clearly utter nonsense, and is trotted out as a quote far too often with no backing. I'd rather strike an acceptable balance between free and safe. I don't want people free to kick the shit out of others for no reason, for example.

1
sanph•

You don't understand the context or point if you think Ben was talking about being free to kick the shit out of others for no reason.

12
VorpalAuroch•

Which is clearly utter nonsense, and is trotted out as a quote far too often with no backing.

Please provide an example of a case where this was wrong. Basic physical-harm laws and anything up to shouting "Fire!" in a crowded theater don't count, obviously.

1
hahainternet•

Sorry it took me so long to reply, but are you genuinely saying "Give me a list of places where security is more important than liberty, but exclude all of the places we accept security is more important than liberty"?

The point I was making is that there is a fine line, and it is not a hard and fast rule. I gave up owning many classes of firearms in order to reduce the ability of criminals to access guns. America now murders more people with knives per capita, than we murder.

1
el_muchacho•

Actually, when I know that I no longer have any privacy, that someone can know everything about me unless I keep it to myself, I don't feel any safer nor freer.

11
hakkzpets•

This is what bothers me. I'm a lot more afraid of future governments than any "terror" threats.

2
douchebag_investor•

This isn't about your saftety. It's about the safety of the ruling class when the peasants revolt.

3
judgej2•

There is always going to be a compromise. It is all about setting the limits and draw the lines.

2
[deleted]•

I'd rather not paint the world in such black and whites. Modern society is a compromise between the two. If you want to be entirely free fuck off to Sealand. I want to live alongside citizens who recognise the need for giving up some freedoms in order to live a life of relative safety.

-12
matamou•

I want to live alongside citizens who recognise the need for giving up some freedoms in order to live a life of relative safety.

Oh how naive you are.

7
[deleted]•

Me naive? Perhaps you can enlighten me on how a society could function without the police?

-10
acabftp•

Excuse me, I thought you didn't want to paint the world in black and white? So now the choice is between having no police, or a government with the ability to monitor everything?

9
MELSU•

Are you fucking serious. Do you really think that if the government has access to everyone's computer files you will be safer? Hypothetically,If they are looking into someone's files that means they are most likely investigating a crime that already happened. Therefore, your "safety" is probably unsalvageable at that point anyways.

As of late, governments do not make decisions for the good of their people, but merely for self preservation.

5
[deleted]•

Governments have always worked this way. The advantage of a democracy is that what is necessary for self preservation more often than not is good for the people. I don't see how you can't see the massive flaw in your argument. It's like saying murder laws don't make us any safer because if the police are investigating a murder it has already happened. These laws deter others from commiting crimes. Also, the government would only have access with a warrant.

-2
el_muchacho•

Except that when democracy is eroding the most basic principles and foundations, it's a victory for the enemies of democracy.

1
Aiskhulos•

Murder laws don't make us safer, with the possible exception of serial murderers, who are in the minority. Murder laws don't deter people from committing murder. If someone really wants to murder you, they will. For the most part, murder laws (and many other laws) are only there so that we can punish people after the fact.

1
Kman1121•

Wrong. To most if human history, there was what we today call terrorism and there was government. After the rebellions of early US history for instance, the US was still safe, but no less free.

1
[deleted]•

Brit myself. We have such a good society, most tolerant nation towards LGBT, NHS, pretty good welfare system (even though it does get abused), then some arsebandit goes "HURR DURR LETS HAVE A LOOK AT PEOPLE'S EMAILS"

FUCK IT WE'LL DO IT LIVE.

28
Lykii•

You can shame people for responding to Nigerian prince emails. Think of the ratings for a new show: Britain's Funniest Emails. Soon to be an American Primetime program, based on the British smash hit.

5
cjcolt•

Most tolerant nation towards LGBT doesn't let same sex couples get married, eh?

Hope that sentence was an April Fool's Day Joke.

3
[deleted]•

Presumably that was a typo for mostly, as any country has it's hold out of homophobes and other assorted bigots.

Still, if the tories suppoort gay marriage then it's just a matter of time until it's passed. Civil partnerships are legally identical anyway, so we're basically there already.

1
[deleted]•

Civil partnerships which are marriage in all but name, and gay marriage is about to be introduced. Where do you suggest is more tolerant of homosexuals and transexuals?

1
006ajnin•

It's hard to know what metric you'd propose concerning gays and transsexuals in particular, but with respect to tolerance of minority groups in general (including LGBTs) the answer is Canada. And we've had nationwide marriage equality since 2005 (and civil unions in many areas prior to that).

1
cjcolt•

Countries where they can get married.

Netherlands, Spain, Sweden, Canada, Norway, Portugal, South Africa, and certain States in the US.

Anyway when I was in Scotland I constantly heard people saying there were gonna go outside and light up a fag or two.

Needless to say I was pretty offended

0
[deleted]•

Sweden, where transexuals must be sterilised by law? (Unlike the UK.)

The US where there are no laws against discrimination on the basis of sexual orientation? (Unlike the UK.)

Portugal where homosexual couples are barred from adopting children? (Unlike the UK.)

Canada, where only the North Western Territories have explicit anti-discrimination laws for sexual and gender identity? (Unlike the UK.)

Anyway, as mentioned, by 2015 gay marriage will be officially recognised throughout the UK.

1
mrchunks•

They can get married in all but name.

1
[deleted]•

carrier pigeons?

1
[deleted]•

They would require a warrant to do this. Are you also against wire taps?

-7
woocheese•

Without a warrant is the whole point, the idea here is that a warrant won't be necessary.

8
[deleted]•

Did you read the article? It specifically states a warrant would be required to read people's emails.

2†
woocheese•

But not to see the number of emails sent to x person over x time.

3
[deleted]•

No it isn t, read the fucking article.

Fucking stupid Reddit americans and their retarded sensationalism.

-6
HugeJackass•

Except he's not American, you twat.

6
woocheese•

"it would enable intelligence officers to identify who an individual or group is in contact with, how often and for how long. They would also be able to see which websites someone had visited."

Now you go read it again you stupid xenophobic fuck!

2
rino187•

They will always take away your rights if you let them...anything can be done under the guise of to protect us from terrorism or communism or whatever the procived threat is at the time...

24
Rhyotion•

Fool me once shame on you, fool me twice, shame on me.

2
MabyLater•

does the Uk have a contest with the US to see who can ruin the internet faster?

20
the_opinion•

It's ok guise! They're only going to use this power to combat terrorism! You don't support terrorism, do you?

In all seriousness, problematic and awful as this is, in reality they're not actually going to be monitoring everything. That's logistically ludicrous. GCHQ have to ask for the information as part of specific investigations, there isn't going to be a massive team of people watching everybody's online activity, all the time. It won't affect most of us.

Oh, wait. We've heard all that before, and millions of pounds of anti-terrorism equipment was used to catch...people not putting recycling in the right bins.

17
soiherduliekmudkips•

Now they're talking about outsourcing law departments to private companies, complexifying things further so it will be harder to fight the mission creep.

2
the_opinion•

Yeh the complexifiabilitynessism has to stop.

2
soiherduliekmudkips•

I feel like that guy in Inception when he used specificity.

2
the_opinion•

Don't become a CSS developer. You'll use that word all the time.

1
TheBakedPotato•

That is a dark April Fools, BBC.

17
ApoChaos•

Conservatives: they will do anything for big business. Funny, I don't remember hearing an election pledge to fix the internet, but I do remember something about taking us out of a recession and leaving the NHS alone. Well, they seem to have completely failed; they only implement policies that repeal support, and just recently one of the upper-toffs referred to an impending fuel strike as this government's 'Thatcher-moment', likening it to the miners' strikes. How ridiculously conceited: they probably think they're saving the country with their dumb policies: 'competition' and 'choice' do not improve services when everyone needs those services; if I break my fucking leg I don't want to have a comprehensive list of hospitals' leg-mending credentials: I just want it to be able to, y'know, heal eventually. Or are they basically saying that they've thrown the country to the right as much as Thatcher's government did and that this is their expected backlash? How the fuck does everyone forget how much the country hated Thatcher's administration when she left office!? It just sears me, and I repeat something I've been saying for a while: if you voted Conservative at the last election, you are a horrible person who likely doesn't know much about the way our political system works, or, you have a lot of money and are just greedy. Which is it: stupid or greedy?

EDIT: There is a difference between being conservative, and towing the Conservative (big C) line on this. Much respect to David Davis for breaking rank. There are far more potential consequences for going against the the party line in the UK than in the US, though it would be dangerous for Cameron to censure this; Davis was almost the leader of the Tories. I would wager the only reason Davis didn't end up the leader is because of tactical voting: David Cameron is noticeably younger and could, theoretically, attract floating-voters more easily (UK politics are annoyingly sceptical of anyone with grey hair: a decent leader of the Lib Dems, Menzies Campbell, was forced to step down because he was 'too old' at the same time as John McCain ran for president; McCain is by far the senior.)

13
Islandre•

You had me until you called the plurality of voters stupid or greedy. The truth is that there was so little given away before the election on actual policy by any of the parties that we didn't have a lot to go on. Remember that think tank that said the Lib Dems had explained something like 25% of their intended cuts and the other parties even less?

The fact that the "coalition" has abandoned most of what little there was in their manifestos does make me angry. Our system of accountability does not work.

1
ApoChaos•

You are right, I'm sorry; I really should have said 'ignorant' instead of 'stupid', and there is the simple fact that with only two really viable parties a discontent public has no way to eject a government without synonymously rejecting the party. Between this article and the NHS reforms, I'm just little too angry to be impartial, especially with all Tory voters I've spoken to who didn't have an articulable (or decent) justification for leaning that way. It really doesn't help that there is practically zero education on politics here.

The ignorance thing really comes into play with regard to the fact that the Conservative party at large had never renounced the policies which landed them out of power for so long against New Labour in the first place; they honoured Thatcher and hammered in right-leaning points as opposition against a government that was already right-of-centre. The truly unpopular elements of New Labour were the right-leaning ones: the PPIs, two wars and Bush-like anti-terrorism laws; the policies that the Tories never really spoke up against as opposition were the frequent justifications used by people for why the Government should be traded in... For a more right-leaning government...?

Maybe it's just a failure of a two-party-favoured voting system. In any case, it was clear that Cameron and his Shadow-Cronies were the only ones putting a veneer of 'Change' on an otherwise, ahem, conservative party. Even then it was superficial: remember David Cameron, the environmentalist who rides around on a snow-mobile to investigate global warming? No Tory political action ever came of that PR move, and it was patently unrepresentative of the make-up of his party. As opposition it was actually useful to push that agenda onto the scene, even if it was just to boost his image. As Government, though, there is none of that. Every criticism he ever had of New Labour lacked a 'here's the approach we argue for', it was always what they were against. I used to listen to PMQs a lot, and the lack of Tory initiatives on anything really stood out after a while.

And then, in the run-up to the election, various leaders of businesses signed a petition saying they would prefer a Conservative Government. It was paraded on various news outlets like something that tells people anything; that extremely wealthy individuals would like the party that they conventionally support to win the general election. I think it was on the front page of the Sun.

Blegh. Sorry for essaying at you. <3s

TL;DR: Can politics be put in the UK's curriculum please!?

3
Islandre•

At your tldr, I'm not sure it's politics that really needs to be taught. Maybe it's just my personal bias but I feel like a better understanding of formal logic and statistics would go a long way towards changing the popular perception of politics through the lens of personality and charisma.

1
danhero•

Well said.

0
[deleted]•

Wow, just calm down now.

You know what I think makes "a horrible person who likely doesn't know much about the way our political system works"- someone that doesn't respect the democratic process and throws a tantrum because the people they want don't get elected.

I know this is the internet but stop sensationalizing everything for your own ends. Labour tried to introduce this legislation when they were in power and were stopped by the Conservative and Liberal Democrat opposition. It's not a party specific issue and was not voted in specifically by the public on any level

0
ApoChaos•

Okay, you're right, I was over-the-top. How would you feel if the only reason you were able to get any kind of higher education after 16 was because of implemented Labour policies that were some of the first to be scrapped by the Conservatives? Or how about a climate of people hating Gordon Brown for no reason other than institutionalised media bias and the fact that he wasn't a rhetoric-charisma-machine? There were many elements of complacency in New Labour towards the end, but it has, traditionally, been easier to break file for issues of conscience without fear of removal of the Whip in Labour than it is with the Conservatives (the Trident renewal vote was a good example).

Apart from all of this, no one has dished out more shit on New Labour's policies than Cameron in opposition, with no scrap or hint of what he would have done differently. That they would even consider pushing legislation that resembles a defeated New Labour bill is just blatant hypocrisy, but also points to the power of lobbyists over a government that hasn't even been in power all that long.

2
irishchris1•

The worst thing about this is that they hope it will be unopposed... and it probably will be. Fuck This Shit.

12
bilwis•

Oh, come the fuck on... Thats exactly what I feared would happen if they passed ACTA, but it looks like the fuckers don't even need that. I still hope we get spared from oppressive legislation like that here in Germany. We've had "internet surveillance" laws for some years now, but of course the police need a fucking warrant, which is to be granted only if they have "probable cause" to assume a crime which is punishable by three or more years in prison (iirc). Why is this proposed law even legal? CRUMPETS!

12
context_begone•

in Germany

it

is punishable

to be

fucking

CRUMPETS

18