As Promised, My Post: Hi-Rez on PS Cross-Progression is Weird (Long Read)
(To be clear, this is most directly in response to: "SoNy SaYs nO!" And if you fall into the group that cares deeply about your split progress and purchases, this is for you.)
Anyone who knows me, knows that I mostly hang out around and specialize in leaks and rumors of releases, but as a person also around gaming in general, I'm going to go over my thoughts on this with the information I have on me.
(Quotes will be placed and sources linked for context. Not necessary to read due to most not being one-topic articles, and instead, interviews. Also, linking does not mean I agree with every wording in a link, like said website, or anything like that, just for sources :)
_______________
Being honest, a lot of the lack of understanding around things like crossplay-purchase-progression comes from a lack of curiosity and exposure to some of the situations and questions in years earlier. Some people definitely were curious. Most really were not. And also, I say people not being used to interacting with companies, as seen with this most recent part.
Because come now, this last part is actually really easy. There is a last statement, that holds true until further notice.
It's one of the reasons you have seen people, including myself obviously, say that, "It could happen whenever, there is not a default 'No' being handed out." Beyond just looking over at Hi-Rez's other game, Rogue Company, to see this....as of 2019, here is Sony's rule on console-to-console connection.
"That cross-play is now available to any developer that wishes to implement it in their game."
First covered in a Wired article interview with Jim Ryan. Should be the last paragraph:
https://www.wired.com/story/playstation-now-updates
IGN covered this as well. Right at the start:
https://www.ign.com/articles/2019/10/02/ps4-cross-play-exits-beta-now-a-full-feature-for-developers
----------------------
Any complaints seen from devs/pubs from after Sony's console-to-console crossplay was in effect, as maybe some have seen and remember, was due to dev/pub confusion. The moment connections happened, was not for everyone. It was a beta. That is the beta that is being referred to in the articles.
The quote above, as well as those articles linked, are from afterwards, after the beta ended.
As said before, that is Sony's last statement on the matter, and yeah, it holds true. Since then, devs/pubs that have the expertise and desire to set things up with the features they want, have done so. No others have been running into an issue that is some blatant and standard, "No, you can't."
I would add, in my personal browsing, how players respond in their words about cross- implementations only varies in one place. The Non-RC part of the Hi-Rez playerbase. Weird how one game over, what players believe the console-to-console landscape looks like, let alone what seemingly everywhere else thinks, is hugely different.
Anyways, yes....cross-progression, and cross-purchase, are included in Sony's statement, as the terms are so tightly grouped with one another, and they were also featured in said beta.
So, one might ask, "Ok, you've known this, and have been saying it, why are you making a post suddenly? Is it just to be more descriptive and reduce others having to repeat themselves?"
Well, sure. But that's not why. It's because I learned something new the other day. It's about cross-progression, and cross-purchase.
Like I said, I've known them to be tightly grouped, as do a lot of people, but it wasn't until I was looking for the "...cross-play is now available to any..." quote that I stumbled across an article....I remembered seeing, but hadn't read every part of.
In it, it's the first time that I can recall hearing a head of one of the console manufacturers, defining cross-play, cross-progression, and cross-purchase. None other than Shawn Layden, former CEO of Sony Interactive being interviewed, while he was still the CEO.
"We got to that determination a lot faster than you read about it on the internet or heard people talk about it. It’s just that, and I’ve used this phrase a couple times, it’s not just like flipping a switch. And then people online said, “Of course it is!” No, of course it isn’t. When we did turn it on, light it up, we wanted to make sure we had thought out all the different ramifications of cross-play, cross-purchase, cross-progress, Those are all three very discreet aspects ++of what cross-play is++, and there are decisions you make in provisioning those different pieces of it that if you make it quick and hasty, and the wrong decision, you can put yourself in a corner really fast, and that prevents scalability over time and the ability to bring people in in a secure and safe way.
We got to that place in Fortnite and it seems to be going reasonably well, from what I can tell."
Gameinformer. Second to last paragraph:
https://www.gameinformer.com/interview/2019/02/11/shawn-layden-on-playstation-and-the-future
----------------------
Yes, it's one thing to associate the terms cross-play, cross-purchase, and cross-progression together, but it's another to hear one of the console heads talk about it, and how connected the features are. Not even from a developer/publisher. Someone at the highest level. Which, if you think about it, makes sense. Someone all the way up there in charge of a lot of things, including okaying things and making implementations available, would have even less of a reason to think of these features in a completely separate fashion. Coding the different functions is not his job.
I hadn't seen this before. What else haven't I seen?
A developer/publisher being blocked from only one or two of the three crosses-. Does that even make sense?
There are cases where a game does not have all three implemented, but it's been down to a personal decision. Not, some sort of "block" out there.
Famous example being Overwatch.
"While cross play will be coming to Overwatch, Blizzard states that cross progression will not be available for the time being. However, Game Director Aaron Keller states in a developer update video that the team is 'excited to bring cross-progression to the game' at a later date.
As cross play will be in beta on launch, Blizzard states that it will continue to monitor the game’s balance as well as player feedback."
They would love to add both, but due to the cross-play being a mere beta at that time, and possibly a focus on OW2, they are purposely not implementing both features simultaneously.
https://www.playstationlifestyle.net/2021/06/10/overwatch-cross-play/
_______________
Now.....
The topic at hand in this community, is Paladins.
From what I'm seeing, you really don't need to look over at Hi-Rez's other game, Sony's last statement on the matter, or even every other dev and their games. If a game has crossplay......there shouldn't even be much conversation with Sony required for the rest, if anything really.
It's not just players who think of these features as being almost one. It's the heads themselves that talk about it like a bundle.
I don't think Hi-Rez's silence is a good look here. There's no way you don't see your players asking for and about it, and them putting this on Sony time and time again. This really comes across a certain way, and you know what I mean.
Honestly.....if Sony weren't so large and actually paying attention to this, I don't think they would be at all pleased about this lack of clarity. Lack of anything.
Could there be some situation here? Sure, but I really, really doubt that. Any actual situation, dare I say cruel, would have an actual statement out there, would it not? "Where's all that bravado," from before? That's what I'm thinking of. You all remember that don't you? Let me remind you again**, now, we're talking years of silence. Years.** With no end in sight. Notice this different behavior?
TL;DR - There is nothing at all pointing to them being blocked. There is a ton that Hi-Rez is just being silent and taking their time. I find it extremely hard to believe, (1.) after Sony's last statement back in 2019, (2.) that one of your games -not even the most consistent one either- is allowed everything, (3.) and your others only a piece somehow, (4.) while no other games are running into this situation, (5.) and you're just years silent about what you would certainly call unfair or targeted treatment. Why would I believe this? Why would I believe you're blocked?
Let's be honest, Hi-Rez simply adding a system way late, after years of complaints, and after implementing it in one of their other games, is nothing new. Just look at their rough matchmaking history, and Rogue Company desperately and quickly trying to use an improved, yet familiar system. Funny. Long-standing, non-system related things? Sure. What about bugs then? The blatant ones. At least on PlayStation Smite, there has been this N64 model bug for how long now? Juuuust sitting there. Which you would imagine has to look pretty bad when trying to advertise new, shiny things, to new players......
The silence sort of feels like a game to me, and it bothers me personally. To cut this long read, short, I have something to do. I know some people. I don't believe I'm off in all of this, as it is from pure statements, and what years of time has already shown, but again, I know some people :)
Bye.
Posted Jan 4, 2022, 4:55 AM UTC
u/Ai_of_the_Deep
I remember you had asked. This is literally the most comprehensive thing you'll find. A long read though.
I fully understand this and im grateful youbposted about it. Since is definately not a no and is a matter of when. My hopes are still there. Thsnk you again this brings me hope for other games too