Hey guys, first post ever so I thought I would pop my post cherry on Wicked_edge. I need your suggestions about a double blade razor. Details inside.

Ok, so I'm between three razors at the moment, I have started using bar soap and a boar bush recently and noticed the shaving improvements. And now I would like to upgrade my gillette mach 3 into one of the following, please help me decide. http://www.amazon.com/Merkur-Model-180-Handled-Safety/dp/B000NL0T1G/ref=pd_sim_hpc_1 http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B003LW4L2W/ref=olp_product_details?ie=UTF8&me=&seller= http://www.amazon.com/Parker-99R-Handle-HEAVYWEIGHT-Butterfly/dp/B003NTHWLU/ref=pd_sim_hpc_41

Thanks in advance for all of your help!

Posted Apr 6, 2012, 4:13 AM UTC

811
EnixDark•

I think you picked out the top three razors known for all around quality for the ~$30 price. I might be wrong, but I'm pretty sure at this point, it comes down to which one you think looks the best.

That said, I'd go with the Edwin Jagger, but it's sold out on Amazon, so I'd either buy it elsewhere, or go with the Merkur. Really, only reason is because I've heard the least about the Parker, but you'd be totally fine with any of them.

5
lostwriter•

I would agree about the EJ. It was my first and I loved it from day one. I got my wife a Parker (Lady G remake) and it shaves nice, bit its not in the same ballpark quality-wise.

I wanted a Merkur Futur at first, but am glad I got the EJ. It just fit my hands perfect and is beautiful.

6
LongUsername37c, EJ89L, Krona, Proraso fan•

I love my EJ, but I was using a Schick Krona before and have never used a Merkur or Parker.

2
dEvilJinWeber DLC, Parker Silvertip badger•

Everyone here is just going to tell you what they like the best out of the list. That being said, id say the Merkur; thats what i started with. Top two razors are highly praised here on W_E but ive noticed people tend to lean towards the Edwin Jagger. I myself ended up choosing the Merkur because i didnt like the handle on the Edwin.

Best of luck with your choice, im sure with good technique, you will enjoy any of the above.

4
TheGobiasIndustries•

I picked the Merkur because of the handle as well. I have pretty large hands, so the extended handle is a nice feature.

1
SpacebrotherFenris (Merkur 37C)•

One additional word on top of the people suggesting the Edwin Jagger, if you don't like the chrome handled model you can get the same razor head with other types of handle (lined, faux ivory, faux ebony, barley patterned). The head is identical on all EJ89 models so you'll still get the same feel.

The BL suffic indicates that it comes with 5 Derby blades, which in my book aren't the greatest, but what may not work for me may work better for you.

4
LeisureguyGourmet Shaver•

I would say the Edwin Jagger without a doubt. Better quality than the Parker (and, IMO, than the Merkur) and a very recent head design that supersedes the Merkur Classic head on the 180. Parker has quality control problems that they are always rumored to be taking care of.

The Edwin Jagger is well priced, solid, and provides a superb shave. All the new Edwin Jagger razors use the same head, so just pick a handle treatment that you like.

I've seen quite a few comments from guys who have used both the EJ and the 180 or the Parker, and almost to a man they prefer the EJ head.

Regarding blades, which you'll need, read this post.

You might also check out the reader reviews to my introductory guide to shaving to see whether you think that would be helpful.

4
allegedpineapple•

All three of these are great razors and i dont think you will be disappointed with any of them; however, one thing worthy of note is that the Parker 99r is a little larger and heavier than your other two choices. You may find it easier to learn the basics of this type of shaving with a more maneuverable EJ or model 180. If you want a twist-to-open razor though, the parker is not a bad choice.

2
[deleted]•

The ivory handle is ever so slightly grippier than the chrome one.

2
bennettj1087Merkur 180•

Many of the people here will lean toward the EJ as a first razor. Not knowing that at the time, I went with the Merkur Model 180 and have not been disappointed, but I don't have anything to compare to either.

I think you'll be pleased with whichever one you buy.

2
cixelsydGillette NEW•

I'm surprised no one has brought up the handle size in this discussion. I started with a Merkur Classic (with the short handle) and thought that I would hate the traditional short handle, but found just the opposite. It provides really precise control and [I think] it prevents me from getting to grippy and applying too much pressure. I've been traveling some lately with carry-ons, so unfortunately reverting to the old Mach 3 for overnight trips, and it's handle even feels huge, although the razor itself ridiculously light.

2