Intuit spent $9 million on lobbying to make it annoying to do your taxes
republicreport.org/2012/corruption-taxes-five...Posted Apr 15, 2012, 10:31 PM UTC
Posted Apr 15, 2012, 10:31 PM UTC
It is so aggravating doing taxes from forms that the IRS already has copies of. The IRS already has everything it needs to figure the taxes of most 1040 EZ filers, why doesn't it just go ahead and do it?
And one more time - what Intuit is doing is legalized bribery, it is rent-seeking, it is using the government to legislate market manipulation. It is the opposite of a free market.
The lobbying system is more like legalized extortion for congress. I' too lazy to look for the articles now, but for the most part it's congressmen hitting up the lobbyists for money.
It's not necessarily as simple as Congressmen extorting businesses. It's just as often businesses saying "support our causes and we'll give you a nice little pittance, and if you don't, well I sure hope you don't like facing a well funded opponent".
Except the congressmen are the ones who are usually calling for the money.
This is accurate. Source.
I know what you are talking about - there have been a number of articles written about this comment: "We imagine lobbyists stalking the halls of Congress, trying to influence lawmakers with cash. But often, it's the other way around: Members of Congress stalk lobbyists, looking for contributions."
Last year when Dick Lugar said he supported ending sugar subsidies, my first thought was that it was odd for a farm state Senator to support ending subsidies that kept corn syrup competitive with sugar. But if you read his statement as a thinly veiled threat to corn farmers to cough up more campaign money for Dick Lugar, or else, it makes sense.
To be fair, this article failed to present any evidence that this is what Intuit is lobbying for.
The current tax system has the added bonus of basically making you incriminate yourself, and threatens you with legal penalties if you don't.
Whereas in European countries for instance, they basically just mail you a bill, AFAIK. Since, just like the IRS, they already know what you owe.
(Anything about claiming deductions, I have no idea, I just know they at least mail you the initial bill that says "this is what we think you owe us".)
I expect that they include the deductions that are likely not to change year to year (children, loan interest) and require you to add any others you would like to request.
And one more time - what ______ is doing is legalized bribery, it is rent-seeking, it is using the government to legislate market manipulation. It is the opposite of a free market.
fill in the blank with every lobbyist, corporation, and privately funded interest group. legislation goes to the highest bidder, the only real vote is money.
You know what a wise man said - "When buying and selling are controlled by legislation, the first things to be bought and sold are legislators."
He also said "Giving money and power to government is like giving whiskey and car keys to teenage boys."
I wouldn't want the government to write tax software, I'm certain it would suck.
Also, our tax code is stupidly complicated, if the government did start to pre populate returns, I could see the outcry from citizens who just sign and return it, then get audited when they didn't report something. People would bitch it was the governments fault.
<i>I wouldn't want the government to write tax software, I'm certain it would suck.</i>
Thirty-plus years of open-source software produced by government agencies strongly suggests otherwise. The quality of work they produce compares favorably with that from academia, industry, non-profit, and independent efforts.
I wouldn't want the government to write tax software, I'm certain it would suck.
How do you think returns are processed now? By hand with an abacus?
Really smart piece. Lobbying is best investment in America: millions lead to billions.
It's a huge ROI, and from Intuit's perspective it makes sense. However, from the perspective of the good of the public this is another line on the long list of helpful improvements that gets prevented by "capitalism".
Bitch please, this isn't capitalism here, crony capitalism =/= capitalism.
hence the mock quotation marks
"No True Scotsman"
Am I the only one slightly bothered by everyone saying "capitalism" when they really mean "free market?"
Please. Crony capitalism is just capitalism in practice.
The exact same thing happens with communist governments. We could try and blame it on some political view, but greed transcends the little names we make up for our systems.
You've got it all wrong my man. The belief that you can have a massive and intrusive state and capitalism is a myth.
It's the state that needs the free market to produce wealth and then tax to survive, not the other way around.
I thought the title said "Inuit" and I had to read for a while before I realized it wasn't Eskimos who were trying to make taxes difficult.
[0], I swear
I got about halfway through the article before I figured that out. I kept thinking "I seriously don't understand why this benefits the Inuit. It seems too passive-aggressive to be some sort of revenge plot for the plight of their ancestors."
And then I felt stupid
I felt stupid until I came here and found you guys, now I feel much better about myself.
The white man took our land.
Now we take his patience.
I kept thinking its because as I recall from a documentary they do these events every year where they shower gifts at each other tribe, and they try to outdo each other to extreme levels - and they wanted all that to be tax-free.
same xD Would have made a really interesting article if it was.
I'm at a [5] and this is EXACTLY what I thought.
HEY EVERYBODY LOOK THIS GUY SMOKES WEED!
joke's on them, I pirate turbotax
Joke's on you, they have your data if you efiled
That's why you don't with pirated versions
what "data"
either way I printed out and mailed it
Although the Free File Alliance has kept the federal government from being a direct competitor to Intuit’s tax offerings,
I like how it's "free markets" until the government looks at offering a more competitive service/product than it's all "OMG, this is going to be the death of us! We need to lobby to protect our profits at the expense of taxpayers!" These are the same people who probably call government "inefficient". Well, if government is so "inefficient", why do you feel threatened by government wanting to be more competitive? This is exactly why the Public Option for healthcare was removed too.
It's a sick joke.
Agreed.
I'd like us to end all Corporate Welfare (subsidies, tax credits, deductions, etc). Corporate welfare is anti free-markets and capitalism and personally, the only money a corporation should receive is the money consumers spend on their services/products.
then america would become rediculoulsy uncompetitive at attracting business and corporations to invest/start/headquarter/whatever here though.
You don't need to bribe someone to set up a business. The chance of profiting from an idea is motivation enough.
Ahh, the mythical 'free market'. Religion for angry white kids...
It's still Capitalism. Yawn.
Conservatives really just get a bunch of stiffs to get up there and talk about the "Free Market", while doing everything they can to prevent it and maintain their interests.
It works cause most of the public just isn't smart/cynical enough to understand.
Yeah because Democrat-heavy industries and unions don't spend millions to net them billions...and then claim they're poor, hard working stiffs.
Hypocrisy is ripe on both sides when we have trillion dollar federal budgets. Greed takes over and people get wide-eyed with free government money.
A Free Market, as described by ideologues on the right, would never work in principle anyway (as far as Capitalism is concerned). Even if all governments were abolished overnight, there would be a subset of people (the wealthy and powerful) that would immediately seek to create another body that acted just like any other government. Well, it'd actually be worse because it would most-likely be a highly authoritarian and hierarchical government.. the exact same way a Corporation is structured.
You're exactly right.
What they really want is a regulation-free market.
The free market is only good if it's going to earn me money. If it's not, then clearly Big Government is the problem. And socialists. And possibly women.
-- The right's platform
Or maybe it could be the fact that the government would have too much money to design, update, implement, and maintain this service and it would most likely be an inferior product to what is already available.
If it would be such an inferior product, why lobby to make sure government doesn't do it?
Indicates more about Intuit's product weakness don't you think? If the company doesn't even have faith in it's own product that it can stand up to competition from government - why would someone want to invest into the company?
As I said in another post. Lobbying resembles extortion more than it does bribery. Also, there is nothing to say that the lobbying effort was to prevent the government from creating an alternative. Especially when you consider the amount of laws and regulations regarding taxes.
"Here’s a chart of Intuit’s lobbying expenditures in Congress, courtesy of Open Secrets. I suspect that some of that nine million dollars of lobbying by that company since 2008 has gone to making it more annoying for you and me to file our taxes."
Intuit spent $9 million on ALL LOBBYING during that time frame for all of their business. This article is complete speculation by the author and very misleading in the title of this thread. Intuit is a multi billion dollar company and like most companies their size they spend money on lobbyists. No exactly newsworthy.
Ok, i've made a petition for this at White House petitions. Please sign it so that it's at least on record!
yeah! this one will change everything!
Fitting username.
Does anyone know what happened to that petition that demanded a condescending answer? Did it ever get enough signatures?
[deleted]
Tax software is no substitute for a tax accountant.
[deleted]
In the area of tax preparation, software can easily substitute for an accountant, because when I give an accountant that worksheet with all of my financial information, they simply enter that data into software.
No they dont, actually. It's a lot more complicated than just entering the numbers into a program.
I have, in the past, hired multiple CPAs from large companies, and started doing my own taxes years ago after realizing that I could do them just as well with the right software.
Who says you are doing them just as well? Most people I meet who do their own tax returns (not counting people with just a w-2 and some simple deductions) have them all screwed up but dont know enough to understand that. How many times did you do your own taxes and get audited by the IRS? If you havent been audited, how do you know that your taxes are correct? The truth is that you probably dont know. Just because you filed your taxes and the IRS didnt send you a notice of deficiency doesnt mean you did a good job on your taxes.
There is nothing esoteric about the rules of income and deductions.
Of course there is. Do you think people spend years in school learning the intricacies of tax law because they dont know about the existence of tax software?
Tax preparers exist because most people have no interest in educating themselves about the field of accounting, or don't have the time.
You just said there was nothing esoteric about tax law, and that anyone could just use a $50 program. Now you are saying that people dont have the time or inclination to spend learning about taxes. Which is it? You seem to have confused yourself here!
[deleted]
If your financial life is simple enough, it doesn't take more than 5-10 minutes to fill out the 1040EZ.
If your financial life isn't that simple, I really don't trust the IRS to figure out my taxes for me - given that they can't even explain their own rules at least 20% of the time.
This is the real reason so many Americans want a flat tax - they just want to be able to understand the tax code.
That lack of understanding is precisely why they shouldn't be arguing in favor of a flat tax; it is demonstrably regressive on lower and middle-income earners.
Easy to see why. Doing taxes with regular paper forms is a pain, doing it online with TurboTax is a breeze and Intuit doesn't want anyone to cut into their business. Pretty slimy but understandable that they would do it.
and I thought people came first =)
I figured the reason why my state, Illinois, has a decent web site to file taxes for free while the federal government does not was that lobbyists from tax prep firms kept people in congress happily bribed.
They don't have to pay anything. That is the joke.
The US government does not work on making a simple tax system for anyone who makes a decent living.
You all want to stick it to the man, and the politicians want to assure us that - as long as we donate enough money to their campaigns - we wil continue getting tax breaks. What do you get? What do we get. A system where, no matter what I do, I am always suspect of committing a crime even though I pay a guy to help me follow the tax code.
I like Hong Kong a lot these days. They have a simple tax system that I - as an individual - can follow. I don't mind some taxes, I just hate the silly fucking game that has to be played so that I can pay a fair share but no more.
Find someone who owns a small business that employs more than 10 people how easy the tax system in the US is. Ask - are you able to understand your own taxes? Are you sure that you will not be audited every year that you pay your tax by either the state or the federal government?
Is this the world that we want to craft for ourselves and others?
I own a business. I don't fear audits. It shows my CPA is doing his job.
Intuit is a piece of shit company all around. Their Quickbooks software already costs around $150 (on amazon...higher other places), but then they make you subscribe to services if you want to do any sort of actual kind of accounting - ie. if you want payroll for 5 employees, it's $390 plus tax A YEAR. On top of that, after the 3rd year, it tells you that you need to upgrade to the latest version of the software in order to run those subscriptions. Hell, even attaching files to an invoice on your own computer requires a subscription.
On top of that, on amazon, they have a whole team of damage control commenting on negative comments and many of the 5 star comments look very generic as if they were cut and paste from a script.
Yeah fuck companies that do shit like this with their products.
I've used http://www.taxact.com/ for the past few years and it's free to prepare and eFile fed return. eFiling state return is a nominal fee (!$17).
I haven't tried this myself, but I think you can go through the process up to the point of filing, so you can even prepare all of the forms, save the PDFs, print them out, and then snail mail them in for free.
$17 is not "nominal".
With those standards, CBruce should work for Ticketmaster.
If anything you give a shit about costs only two digits, you're nobody.
lol
I also assumed Itrcola to be poor.
So it's slightly cheaper than turbo tax? Free federal and $30 state.
Turbo tax is more than $30 for state. I just did my friends last night.
Hmm you're right it's $40 now. Also it's more if you have them take it out of your refund.
I printed out and mailed in forms rather than paying $20 to efile in CA.
At $0.05 per page and $1.50 in postage, that's < $5.
Shit, I dunno why anyone pays these guys for the state taxes. Both states I've lived in have had their own online stuff for free. Hell, even the local taxes did too.
Tax Slayer was also $17 for me.
Just a note: Check with your state to see if they offer a free way to file state taxes. PA has ETIDES. Log in, punch in your return, submit. Free unless you owe.
is there no demand so ludicrous that it can't be bought from our government?
How do the people who say "Keep taxes complicated and hard to do! Here's 9 million dollars." feel good about themselves? Have they really done worthy things with their time on the planet?
I read this as "Inuit". Heh
Ah... Capitalism.
So it should cost you money to do your taxes easily? Only in America...
How awesome would it be if the IRS could mail you a letter every year on January 1st... it listed every piece of your data they had collected in the previous tax year (W-2, 1099's, 401-K contributions etc). Based off of this data, the IRS could also give you a pre-populated 1040. If they estimate that you are owed a refund, they would also include a check in this letter. If you cash this check, this automatically files your pre-populated 1040 for the previous year. Of course this would not work for everyone, people with a much more complicated tax situation could opt out. But 90% of the people in the country, it would be huge convenience.
We have this in Australia.
You go and download a program from the tax office web site (which has all the tax changes for that year). You run it, stick in your TFN (Tax file number - equivalent of SSN) and go for it.
You can select to download any data they have on you (from employer payments, bank interest etc.) and it does its magic.
You can also add deductions and other stuff, and when you're done, you click submit, and in a couple of weeks, you have a transfer to you bank account with your return.
It has never taken me more than 20 mins to do my taxes. And I never spent a cent on software to do it.
Yeah, I bet doctors treat you when you visit their office too. We all know anything vaguely positive is socialism, ergo the end of humanity.
Social democratic nations are only pretending things are positive so they can lure more to join their evil ways. When all the world is socialistic the second coming of Marx and Engels is at hand. They shall come to judge both the billed and the paid!
But I heard their video games are censored... so it evens out.
They're also $100, seriously wtf is up with that?
In the United States you can walk into any Emergency Room in the country and you will be treated by a Doctor. It doesn't matter if you have identification, money, insurance, or anything else. You will be treated. You may have a shit bill afterwards.
Not if you have cancer.
Strictly speaking, they are only required to stabilize you before discharge, per EMTALA. Many life threatening conditions are not treated because the patient is stable, according to the legal definition.
That sounds like work. In Norway I get a letter in the mail detailing my income, how much income tax I paid over the last year, and if I owe, or are owed, anything. If I do not disagree with the government estimate I can do nothing and it just goes through on default. If I am owed anything I get that transferred to my account in June. The additional documentation and papers that come with the tax forms are for any alternations you feel should be made.
I know a lot of different people that tend towards paying more taxes than they need. First it avoids getting a potentially massive bill in the mail at the beginning of the year, and it gives them a nice additional payment at the start of summer.
The easiest way to save money IMO. Here in Finland we get the refund in December, conveniently right before xmas.
In Norway December is a half-tax month. I think the idea was to give people more money for the holidays, though some do not get the extra money until January if their pay date is the 1th. Never the less I've yet to hear anyone complain too much about that.
It's a half truth, people still do that here but when you do you're giving up the use of your money in an interest free loan. Saving it off and investing it is generally the better option.
Only problem is the government gains interest on that money throughout the year instead of you (assuming you are good at financial planning and investments).
yeah, if you have a normal job, everything it's a matter of clicking "update" than submit if you like the summary.
But you can claim insane bonuses for kids, childcare etc... so worth checking out in any case.
Which made me think, could I just pirate a program like TurboTax?
Which made me think of how dumb of an idea that is. No way am I giving my SSN, and basically every form of ID possible to a program ripped open and modified by some random team online.
There's a bunch of websites that will do your federal taxes for free if you're under a certain income. You'll have to pay $5 or $7 or something for your state return though. The IRS website has a list of them.
Many states will let you do the state return on their DOR website for free. I delete the state return from the tax prep sites and file only the (free) federal one, then go to the state site to do that return.
Bonus: I just did my Illinois one last night, and TurboTax had missed my Illinois earned income credit but the state site picked it up, so my bill was about half of what I originally though.
Turbotax and whatever H&R block is calling their software these days are both web based. So no, you won't be pirating them.
EDIT: thought I should elaborate, when you "install" their software it literally just puts a link on your desktop to their website, once you're there when you register you give them your key and it changes what pages you see based on what you paid for. You also have the option to upgrade to the more expensive software at any point in the process and they bill you at the end.
Apparently you can pirate and file with the TurboTax premiere addition, on TPB. But I wouldn't ever actually try that.
Yeah, so this is not true. H&R's software is client based.
If you're on the 1040EZ, there's a free version of turbotax.
Privacy proof software.
Assuming it was a release from a trusted group, I'd be more worried about a possibly overlooked portion of the copy protection phoing home. If I were Intuit, I would protect it with seemingly complex DRM, but include a few "mistakes" that allow it to easily be broken.
Hopefully this would distract the crackers from the real DRM which would covertly phone home with the user's personal information, and send a harshly worded invoice to any nonregistered users.
I believe that New Zealand has a similar system.
Wait, wait. So you can download any data on a person just by putting in your TFN/ ID Number? That seems... dangerous.
Other than that, Australia is sounding better and better.
Yeah, well you're not supposed to give your TFN out randomly. But there are also some other questions you have to verify (name, dob, maybe passport number?) that should all match up.
So just a TFN doesn't get you anywhere.
If you have someones TFN and d.o.b and full name, then someone doing their taxes for them is the least of their worries.
Also, a TFN is not used for ID purposes, so you can't do anything with just a TFN number (like open a bank account), without accompanying ID (passport, drivers license, birth cert etc.)
That makes so much more sense than for the government to collect data and then play "gotcha" and assign penalties when honest people forget to include something they should have.
They have been pretty good in the past. I got a letter from the IRS a few weeks ago saying I missed a 1099 from Google, which Google never sent me and I had forgotten about it. They recalculated my taxes based on the missing income and gave me a few weeks to pay it without a penalty. If I fail to pay the $1k by April 18th I owe a whopping $32 in interest.
With that said, I've always wondered why the IRS doesn't send you what you owe if they have all the information anyhow.
I hope I'm not the only one wondering what you could have done for Google that you:
1.) Forgot about
2.) Had to pay $1000 in taxes on.
Ran a website with Google AdSense ads, and earned around $4000 in the course of the year from ad clicks? Probably not even that much; the income would also be subject to self-employment tax, so it's gonna be his marginal rate plus another 15% or so.
You worked for Google? Doing what?
probably ad revenue
[deleted]
In Finland that is approximately what we get.
Except for the following things:
January 1st is actually early April.
Instead of a cheque I get a direct deposit to my bank account.
If there are any changes, I can file them online and send any needed receipts and other paperwork later.
Most deductions are given automatically. So that most people just have to check the summary. No other action is necessary for about 70% of tax payers.
That's basically how it works in Sweden (although you don't get a check with your tax forms, instead you approve it (which you can do through SMS or on the net) and then they transfer the money directly to your bank account). Your forms don't add upp? Fix it on the net also!
To pull this off the IRS would probably have to restructure all their systems, which would take a transitional budget increase.
And we all know that the non-National Security budget increase request box is actually a paper shredder. People already don't like the IRS, imagine campaigning for them getting a bigger budget...
I think we have this government distributed program in Netherlands because it is cheaper for the government.
Pre-filled in is just a bonus where they started with, but they do not have all the data yet.
Oh yeah, it would most certainly be cheaper in the long run. But US politics and business are pretty short-sighted.
It's kind of like basic competence. Actually one of Bush's campaign promises all the way back in 2000 was to do this automatically. It's mind blowing that in 2012 the IRS doesn't have it's own website, and instead goes through intermediaries.
Um, http://www.irs.gov/?
er, I meant a website where you could file your taxes online, equivalent of turbotax or H&R block
I got tax forms as late as mid-March.
In .nl, the IRS already does this.
[deleted]
Employers don't even owe you W2s or 1099s until the end of January. The IRS gets that information when you do. Then of course Congress waits until December 28th to pass the final tax code changes for the year.
Our income tax return was 18 pages this year for federal, and 12 for the state. This is without itemizing (ie no schedule A), but instead schedule C, self employment tax, some form 8889s, and a child tax credit form (could they make any of those more complicated?) We are definitely nowhere near being in the 1%.
I could live with some tax simplification.
Though if they sent checks like that, there would be so many people in jail claiming they didn't understand what it meant it wouldn't be funny.
Obama promised this!
The government would never do this because they would miss out on 4 months of an interest free loan.
Not to mention all the people that are owed a refund, but never get around to filing.
It's not even that it is a "refund" but other credits that even exceed their tax burden. I'm not dogging on EIC or other credits, but a whole slew of people with little to no income are probably not filing when they actually should.
On a similar note, my brother-in-law receives more in credits that what he pays in (due to EIC). I.e. he has 3 grand withheld and received a 6 grand check. I try to tell him to have no taxes withheld so he sees larger paychecks, and would still have a 3,000 dollar check every year.
He doesn't understand it. He likes getting the "big check" as he calls it.
I think the only common behavior that this wouldn't support is charitable donations. Even with computer assisted tax programs, this would be wonderful.
I think I've said this every year since I started filing taxes.
There's a couple problems with this. First and foremost, data collection is no where near what it needs to be for the government to successfully collect enough information to file your return. Hell even basic stuff like which parent in a separated couple is claiming the kids, gets whacked all the time in the tax world.
There are many situations too where you CAN take a deduction, but may not want to. For example, if you use an asset (like a car) for your business, you can deduct its cost from your income over several years, a process known as depreciation. However if you do this, the car is now for tax purposes considered worthless, so if you later sell it and make 3,000 dollars back, you now owe taxes on this money, and if it's enough to push your tax liability over 1000 dollars for the year, you may owe penalties on top of that. So there's no "right" or "wrong" way to do it, and leaving it to the government to just get you the best refund may come bite you in the ass later.
It would even work for GE (EDIT: and they'd probably get a cheque, too).
It would never fly Orville. You would need to expand the IRS to do this, which instantly kills the plan. And people would think that they aren't getting the best deal. Then you have the wealthy still opting out, and screwing the system.
[deleted]
Um, people strive to maximize unreported income in the current system... right now if it's unreported, it's up to your fear of being caught/honor to report it when you do your taxes...
[deleted]
You're being downvoted, but I think you're right. It's the psychology of the IRS having "tipped their hand first", so to speak. Also, under this system people might just not add the extra stuff not out of deceit, but instead out of laziness ("this is good; I don't want to take the time to reprocess it").
But if this were automated like this, it would drastically reduce filing work at the IRS, which would open up space for more legitimate enforcement work. Probably a good tradeoff--fewer paper pushers, more keeping people honest. So it might work out on balance.
That'd be an improvement, but I'd prefer if the IRS just went away. What if I felt my tax filing might incriminate me? Doesn't forcing me to file violate my 5th amendment right against self incrimination?
No, the IRS considers that a 'frivolous' argument, and using it to try and avoid filing subjects you to an additional $5000 penalty.
No. See: United States v. Sullivan 274 U.S. 259, 264 (1927).