Rule update

Moderator message

Hey everyone,

We will be rolling out some new rule changes on this subreddit. These rule changes can be read below, and will be added to the current rule list.

Rule 1.

Users must remain respectful of their opponents in all posts and comments.

Hot takes or low-effort comments may be removed, as well as off-topic and trolling comments. Slurs are not allowed.

Users must use the labels pro-life and pro-choice unless a specific user self-identifies as something else. This also goes for pronouns and gender identity.

Following the Debate Guidance Pyramid is highly recommended. Levels 1-3 are the desired quality of debate.

Clarifications: As of now, general statements towards either side will be treated the same as statements pertaining to the individual. Comments that attack the people in a movement will be considered personal attacks, and will be removed. An example of this can be "Pro-choicers are devoid of compassion", or "Pro-lifers are stupid". This is an attack on the group, not the argument.

Additionally, hot takes about the other side and low-effort comments that are disruptive in nature can be subject to removal as well.

Comments that show a refusal to debate will also be considered low-effort.

​

Rule 2

All posts must be on-topic to the abortion debate. Low effort posts and hot-takes about either side will be removed.

Every post must have a subject to kick off the debate. Posts that don't may be removed. The poster should be available that same day to respond to comments.

Clarification: There is a minor change in the requirements. Instead of a thesis we will now require all posts to have a subject to debate. Posts are still expected to be high-effort.

​

Rule 3 

It is required to back up a positive claim. Either give a source and show how it proves your point, or by making an argument. Accusing a user of a logical fallacy is a positive claim and needs to be backed up.

Comments that break this rule will not be removed. Instead, the user may be warned, and banned for repeat offenses.

It is up to you to argue whether a source is reliable or not. However, it is required of a user to show where their claim is proven when given a source

Clarifications: Minor change to reflect that mods are not responsible for judging the validity of sources given.

​

Rule 5

The following guidelines apply to post flairs. We highly encourage users to let the top level comments come from users with these specific views. Posts with no flair are "General debate" for all users.

Question for pro-life - All top level posts should be answered by a flaired pro-life user.

Question for pro-choice - All top level posts should be answered by a flaired pro-choice user.

New to the debate - Flair for those who are new to the debate.

Clarifications: A brand new flair called “New to the debate” will be added. This is meant for posts by people who aren't as familiar with the abortion debate and wish to know more about the debate. Low effort posts are not allowed for any of those flairs

We will be removing the information request from the list of flairs. This is a place to debate, not to request information.

​

Weekly debating thread:

Per demand we are introducing an additional weekly post; the weekly abortion debate thread. This thread is meant for smaller debate topics that do not warrant a post. This post will be pinned on top of the subreddit to be more visible, along with the weekly meta post.

Posted Feb 5, 2022, 7:29 PM UTC

10143
Odds_and_Weekends•

As of now, general statements towards either side will be treated the same as statements pertaining to the individual. Comments that attack the people in a movement will be considered personal attacks, and will be removed.

Y'all 'bout to be busy

20
Oishiio42pro-choice, here to argue my position•

Users must remain respectful of their opponents in all posts and comments.

Comments that attack the people in a movement will be considered personal attacks, and will be removed.

What counts as being disrespectful and what counts as an attack? My general experience with a lot of pro-lifers is that anything that doesn't give them maximum benefit of the doubt and/or assume their positions is inherently morally virtuous is perceived as disrespectful. And it's quite frequent that they'll take offense to just literal observations. This is getting a too "safe-space" in here. Aren't the respective subs better for that kind of thing? I'm not interested in coddling prolifers feelings.

Saying "pro-lifers are stupid" is obvious, but I (as well as a lot of other people) make quite a lot of generalizations. What crosses into "attack" Because we're dealing with ideologies and political movements, not just standalone individuals - the context of the broader ideology matters.

Ideas are not identities. If someone holds their ideas so close to their identity that they can't handle their ideology being criticized, then they aren't equipped for debate.

17
BwanaAzunguPro-choice•

What counts as being disrespectful and what counts as an attack?

I've been trying to get clarification on that since Tokyo...

Apparently: if the mod in question feels it's uncivil, it's an attack and/or disrespectful.

8
Catseye_NebulaPro-abortion•

My general experience with a lot of pro-lifers is that anything that doesn't give them maximum benefit of the doubt and/or assume their positions is inherently morally virtuous is perceived as disrespectful.

Agreed. This is a huge thing I experience when talking to PLers too. For instance, they get offended to see their views compared with rape even though they literally redefine consent so that it can be nonconsensual, and advocate to use women's reproductive systems against their will.

They also get offended when we refuse to take their claim that they "are not misogynist," "don't want to control women" or "are not forcing birth" at face value, despite reams and reams of evidence and observed behavior to the contrary.

In my experience PLers absolutely expect to walk into every conversation being afforded the moral high ground as a matter of course, and some have got quite angry with me for refusing to cede them that ground.

I could see this rule being weaponized in contexts of, for instance, a PCer not immediately capitulating and agreeing with a PLer who insists that they are not forcing anyone to give birth.

8
Oishiio42pro-choice, here to argue my position•

I could see this rule being weaponized in contexts of, for instance, a PCer not immediately capitulating and agreeing with a PLer who insists that they are not forcing anyone to give birth.

This is my concern too.

7
kinereranti-killing innocent humans•

I don't think it's fair to call not being maligned in the worst and most uncharitable way possible "expecting to be afforded the moral high ground".

-4
Catseye_NebulaPro-abortion•

^^^ prime example

8
AritheseOPPC Mod•

Generally anything that shifts the focus from the debate to the user. The disrespectful part has been in effect for months and the only change really is the personal attacks also including general comments.

Of course being pro-choice there are beliefs of pro-life movements being inherently X. This is not counted. And the same can be said for pro-life mods towards the pro-choice side. Where eg. The belief is we are inherently sexist.

I haven’t seen many reports pertaining to disrespect. However the addition of refusal to debate will crack down on a lot of troublesome comments.

6
kinereranti-killing innocent humans•

Can you give examples of things you think are unfairly perceived as disrespectful?

1
Oishiio42pro-choice, here to argue my position•

For example, when we point out that PL wants to force pregnant women to give birth, it's met as if this is an attack on character (either the individual, or the whole group). In actuality, this is just an observation of your stated goals, we just don't bother to dress it up in some pseudo-moralistic way, or adhere to the mental gymnastics required to claim it's not forcing.

12
Oneofakind1977Gestational Slavery Abolitionist•

This!!! ⬆️

5
kinereranti-killing innocent humans•

I personally don't have a problem with that. But I rarely see that said. Usually it's "PLers want to rape women". If I'm being charitable maybe it's not something you believe/say, but this seems like a motte-and-bailey situation to me.

-1
Oishiio42pro-choice, here to argue my position•

It's not wrong to compare PL to rapists either. It's a bit much to say "you just want to rape women" explicitly and without any other context, sure. But when PL try to redefine consent to be non-consentual, or they try to say consent isn't important at all, it's a valid criticism to say it's a similar mindset a rapist has. It's also valid to critique pro-life goals as subjecting women to medical rape, and it's also valid to point out how pro-life policy can incentivize rape (if there are no rape exceptions). Most of the time when I do one of these criticisms, at least one person will get very offended that I'm insinuating they are in any way similar to a rapist, and will feel disrespected.

PC are compared to murderers all the time. PL compare women (which most of us PC are on this sub) to murderers, criminals or even just objects all the time.

And while I can totally get behind there being a line drawn from what contributes to a conversation and what doesn't, I have a hard time accepting the very vague guideline of "civil and respectful" when it comes to entire groups, because the group isn't an identity - pro-life/prochoice are ideologies and ideologies are not inherently worth respect. I do not respect the PL ideology (and you don't respect PC ideology), that's why we're here.

9
BunnyGirl1983•

For rule 1, can we call someone else's position on abortion "stupid" or "hyprocritital" for example or is that still considering as attacking part of the movement/the individual person?

9
AritheseOPPC Mod•

Criticising someone’s movement is still very much okay. Just not anything hat can be considered a personal attack.

8
BunnyGirl1983•

Good because I recently posted a comment where I called the "pro life" people who make exceptions "hypocritical". However I didn't tag any individuals in the post or single anybody out with that statement. I do try to avoid name calling individual people though, not an easy thing to do but I understand that would break this rule and possibly get me a ban from this sub.

7

I think you meant hypocritical not hypothetical

6
BunnyGirl1983•

Woops, yes I did. I will correct that now, thanks for letting me know!

6
Murky-Arm-126Pro reproductive autonomy •

It is unclear to me how a comment that an argument is stupid is consistent with the first sentence of Rule 1:

Users must remain respectful of their opponents in all posts and comments.

3
AritheseOPPC Mod•

Being respectful does not mean you cannot criticise someone's movement. One's argument can still be commented on.

7
Murky-Arm-126Pro reproductive autonomy •

Being respectful does not mean you cannot criticise someone's movement.

I would consider it disrespectful to state the above is a stupid response to this comment:

It is unclear to me how a comment that an argument is stupid is consistent with the first sentence of Rule 1.

0
BunnyGirl1983•

Because I am not directly insulting a particular individual by calling an argument that they are making "stupid" or "hypocritical". There's a difference between saying "Using X as an argument is stupid/Your argument is stupid" and saying "YOU are stupid". Smart people can still make stupid arguments.

4
Murky-Arm-126Pro reproductive autonomy •

Because I am not directly insulting a particular individual by calling an argument that they are making "stupid" or "hypocritical".

I would make a distinction between the terms stupid and hypocritical. Hypocritical provides something constructive, stupid is a catchall pejorative.

1
svsvalenzuelaPro-choice•

What constitutes a hot take? I may be guilty of this I'm not certain. Sometimes, I am a goofy ass clown.

6
AritheseOPPC Mod•

A hot take is generally seen as a provocative opinion about the other side that does not show an openness to debate (Usually without evidence). It would also make it clearer if we look at the purpose of this sub, being a neutral ground for a debate.

9
svsvalenzuelaPro-choice•

So if I say something jackassy and am willing to debate it, is that cool?

4
AritheseOPPC Mod•

Note that it’s also hard to judge it without context but no, generally this would’ve already fallen under rule 1.

6
svsvalenzuelaPro-choice•

Examples. Do these count? I do not want to break the rules and get banned but like I said, I am a clown.

4
BwanaAzunguPro-choice•

Every post must have a subject to kick off the debate. Posts that don't may be removed. The poster should be available that same day to respond to comments.

Clarification: There is a minor change in the requirements. Instead of a thesis we will now require all posts to have a subject to debate. Posts are still expected to be high-effort.

What's the point of this change?

3
AritheseOPPC Mod•

To better reflect the flairs; a question does not have to contain a thesis.

6
BwanaAzunguPro-choice•

Sure, but why don't other posts need a thesis?

How do you think debates are gonna go?

3
AritheseOPPC Mod•

A subject to debate would encompass this. Requiring high effort posts would already get rid of non-questions that have no actual thesis to argue.

3
greyjazzPro-choice•

I'm really happy with the change to Rule 2!

3
AutoModeratorMOD•

Welcome to r/Abortiondebate! Don't be a jerk (even if someone else is being a jerk to you first). It's not constructive and we may ban you for it. Check out the Debate Guidance Pyramid to understand acceptable debate levels.

Attack the argument, not the person making it.

Message the moderators if your comments are being restricted by a timer.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
MomodoespoliticsPro-life•

In regards to what is now rule 3, using current law as a source shouldn't be considered adequate. The whole point of this subreddit is debating whether or not abortion should be legal, so citing current law is just a circular argument of "it should be legal because it is legal". It only serves to kill debate because a self-justifying claim is impossible to go against.

1
MasculineCompassionPro-choice•

It depends on context, though. Citing bodily autonomy to justify abortion being legal is not circular reasoning. Citing the fact that it is legal is.

8
AritheseOPPC Mod•

This is up to the users to debate, not us.

If someone uses current law to justify said law then this is very easy to disprove.

6
MomodoespoliticsPro-life•

Easy to disprove, but unfortunately the people who cite it don't see it that way. Just a whole load of "the law agrees with me" and a refusal to make further arguments

2
AritheseOPPC Mod•

Which, depending on context, can be refusal to debate.

10
kinereranti-killing innocent humans•

The whole point of this subreddit is debating whether or not abortion should be legal, so citing current law is just a circular argument of "it should be legal because it is legal".

Exactly, I have no idea how such a simple concept eludes so many.

1
BwanaAzunguPro-choice•

u/Arithese I couldn't reply to the other comment for some reason

We have explained this in the rule change. Bringing up mod action to get the opponent to comply is weaponising the rules.

How is bringing up mod action to get the opponent to comply, weaponising the rules?

Seems like a warning to me.

I cannot enforce rules; I cannot possibly use them as a weapon. So I'm warning them that rules will be enforced.

There is a clear difference between "Rule 3 says X" and "Do X or get banned".

What's the difference, then? I'm honestly not in the mood for these games.

Please don't weaponise the rules going further.

I cannot promise this: I cannot distinguish between what you call weaponising and warning.

Until the difference between these two is made clear, I'll confuse them again. It's clear to you, so it should be easy to explain.

Edit: funny that nobody has been able to explain the difference

1†
jaytea86MOD•

If you're using the rules to threaten, that's weaponizing them.

If you're using them to inform, that's cool.

3
BwanaAzunguPro-choice•

How can I use the rules to threaten? I'm not a mod.

2
jaytea86MOD•

You can threaten to contact or report to the mods etc. We really rather you not do this, and if it's got to that point, just report and we'll deal with it.

However the main reason we came up with the whole weaponization thing is because of abuse of rule 3, that's really what it's aimed towards.

2
BwanaAzunguPro-choice•

You can threaten to contact or report to the mods etc. We really rather you not do this, and if it's got to that point, just report and we'll deal with it.

I would just report them, and inform them they've been reported instead. At best, this example is "weaponising the report button".

But this doesn't really explain how users can "weaponise rule 3". Only mods can enforce rules, so only mods can weaponise rules; users can only point out they exist, and report violations.

However the main reason we came up with the whole weaponization thing is because of abuse of rule 3, that's really what it's aimed towards.

Could you give an example, or point to one? I don't understand how rules even can be weaponised, apart from mods abusing rules for personal reasons.

Rule 3 exist so people actually back up the claims they make, correct?

Edit: perhaps you mean this? Setting up a strawman, then demanding proof for the strawman they themself set up. That would be "weaponising rule 3".

4
kinereranti-killing innocent humans•

Sounds great! However, I think rule 3 is still a problem. Why does it only apply to positive claims? This allows for situations where a person makes a claim, and then places the burden of proof on others to disprove it (instead of proving the claim). A real example:

PC: Rape isn't inherently life-threatening.

PL: It is.

PC: Prove it.

There also seems to be disagreement within the mods, since one mod said that this claim doesn't need to be proven, while E: two said it does.

Suggestion: If you make a claim, you have to back it up.

-4
Desu13Pro Good Faith Debating•

Since you're so incredibly obsessed about this and won't shut up about it, here is the legal definition of rape. Notice how it does NOT say that it is life threatening. It states:

(3) threatening or placing that other person in fear that any person will be subjected to death, grievous bodily harm, or kidnapping;

Notice the ORs. It does not say "subject to death AND [...]. It says OR

So again, even though the burden of proof was ON YOU, I still did the work for you. Stop being lazy, stop debating in bad faith, and stop projecting YOUR rule breaking onto me: rape is not a life threat is a negative claim. YOU have the burden of proof to prove that rape is automatically a life threat.

The fact that you've always refused to back up your claim proves that you knew your claim was wrong and that you were skirting the rules.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/10/920

10
Wheel_of_Logicmorally pro-life, legally agnostic•

Interesting take on so-called 'negative claims' and the burden of proof they may entail.

Here's one for you: abortion is not moral.

Now, I do not need to back up this claim at all, as it is a negative claim. Further, not only do you now have to argue against it, you have to "prove" your position is correct.

PLers, we can now lean back and enjoy; our work is done, as we only need to assert a negative claim and be done. Noice.

Further, for whatever you say, I will respond with 'you are not correct'. That, according to your logic, is a negative claim and requires not justification. That will throw the burden of proof right back at you for whatever you say!

Please, you have to see this is a silly way to conduct a debate?

1†
BwanaAzunguPro-choice•

PLers, we can now lean back and enjoy; our work is done, as we only need to assert a negative claim and be done. Noice.

Further, for whatever you say, I will respond with 'you are not correct'. That, according to your logic, is a negative claim and requires not justification. That will throw the burden of proof right back at you for whatever you say!

Thank you for admitting you do not care at all about debating, and will not engage in good faith debate unless the rules will force you to.

Why on earth are you even on this sub...

Please, you have to see this is a silly way to conduct a debate?

Yes, this comment is silly indeed

12
kinereranti-killing innocent humans•

The problem here is that, like what happened to me, we're in a situation where mods don't demand that the initial claim is proven, but they will demand that anyone who disagrees with the claim disproves it. Certainly someone who cares about "good faith debating" can see why that's problematic?

1
Wheel_of_Logicmorally pro-life, legally agnostic•

Why on earth are you even on this sub...

I am here for some actual debate, not for pro-choicers to dress up their claims to truth in a 'negative manner' as a way to avoid their burden of proof.

Again, you are completely missing the point of my comment big time. This reasoning I provided was a reductio ad absurdum of my interlocutor's view.

1
Desu13Pro Good Faith Debating•

You are lacking the context of our interaction; thus, your comparison is absurd.

You are free to think that abortion is not moral. But if you state this as if it's an objective fact, then you would need to back this up because this can be re-worded to mean the exact same thing, but turn it into a positive claim.

Secondly, "life threatening" is subjective. So while you may think rape is life threatening, someone else may not view it as such.

Additionally, I have tried to find the statistics of being raped AND murdered, but I can't find any statistics on that. So the default position would be rape doesn't lead to murder.

However, that's obviously wrong, as we hear on the news all the time of some unfortunate person being raped and killed. So obviously, SOME rape leads to death; but unless we have statistics, we can't determine what our chances are of being killed during a rape. I would venture to assume that your chances of being killed during a rape is far less than your chances of dying from childbirth.

According to this article, 652,676 woman were raped in 2019 in the US. Compared to around 700 woman dying from childbirth in the US.

Going by those statistics, it appears as though you are far likely to die in childbirth, than you are to die from rape. So it seems to be quite hypocritical of PL'ers to claim that childbirth is generally safe and that there's no need to fear for your life, yet, they turn around and claim that rape is a legitimate life-threat.

Further, for whatever you say, I will respond with 'you are not correct'.

According to these new rule changes (as the OP states), this would be against the rules.

Please, you have to see this is a silly way to conduct a debate?

Yep. Considering you're missing the context, you have no idea what you're talking about.

5
Wheel_of_Logicmorally pro-life, legally agnostic•

"But if you state this as if it's an objective fact, then you would need to back this up because this can be re-worded to mean the exact same thing, but turn it into a positive claim."
I see you have edited this first paragraph from what it was before. And I fully agree: it should be backed up. Likewise, however, the claim that 'rape is not inherently life threatening' can be turned into a positive claim. Here's two exaples. (i) Life in inherently life-unthreatening, or (ii) it is not the case (claim to truth) that rape is life threatening.

If your benchmark for a negative claim is that it include the auxiliary 'not', any negative claim can be turned into a positive claim, including your own. Besides, the crucial aspect of burdens of proof is whether a CLAIM TO TRUTH is being made! 'There is x' and 'There is no x' are both claims to truth.

"Secondly, "life threatening" is subjective"
So? If 'life threatening' is subjectibe, so is 'not life threatening'.

"Additionally, I have tried to find the statistics of being raped AND murdered, but I can't find any statistics on that. So the default position would be rape doesn't lead to murder."

WRONG. The default position would be to withhold belief either ways.

"Going by those statistics, it appears as though you are far likely to die in childbirth, than you are to die from rape. "
NOT AT ALL. As you have failed to include the figures (I suppose you could not find them) on how many of these rape-victims died as a result, we have NO IDEA about the relative likelihoods.

"So it seems to be quite hypocritical of PL'ers to claim that childbirth is generally safe and that there's no need to fear for your life, yet, they turn around and claim that rape is a legitimate life-threat."
You have offered nothing but unsubstantiated conjecture. Not saying its your fault that the numbers are unavailable; but if the numbers are unavailable, while assert things that have no evidentiary basis?
BOTTOM LINE: Tagging a 'not' into your sentence does not alleviate you of your burden of proof. This is not a debatable matter.

1
Murky-Arm-126Pro reproductive autonomy •

Here's one for you: abortion is not moral.

I thought the rule was only regarding factual claims.

4
Oneofakind1977Gestational Slavery Abolitionist•

Same here. Hmm...

4
Wheel_of_Logicmorally pro-life, legally agnostic•

I consider this a factual claim.

-3
kinereranti-killing innocent humans•

I'm not interested in rehashing this debate. You were the one who made a claim (which at least two mods have thus far agreed you should've backed up), and then insisted it was on me to prove it wrong (not on you to prove it). That's my point. I think if someone makes a claim, they should prove it, and not demand others prove them wrong.

The fact that you've always refused to back up your claim

I backed it up at least three different times during our conversation, each one of which you either ignored completely or dodged. I also explained why your "proof" is, let's say lacking, and you dodged that as well.

-1
BwanaAzunguPro-choice•

Why does it only apply to positive claims?

Why wouldn't it be?

The positive claim carries the burden of proof.

PC: Rape isn't inherently life-threatening.

PL: It is.

PC: Prove it.

This is a perfectly reasonable course for this conversation to take. The PL person must prove this claim.

Suggestion: If you make a claim, you have to back it up.

Nonsense. Do you not understand the burden of proof?

9
kinereranti-killing innocent humans•

Why wouldn't it be?

I just explained it. People can make claims without substantiating them, and place the burden on proof on others to prove them wrong. You're also ignoring what I hope would've been an incredibly obvious fact: it's trivial to write positive claims as "negative claims".

Nonsense. Do you not understand the burden of proof?

It's clear that you don't. So if I said "abortion shouldn't be legal", I don't have to prove it? Come on. I think you're just being contrarian for the sake of it.

2
AritheseOPPC Mod•

Non-existence is most often impossible to prove, which is why.

Also, that claim would need to be substantiated by the initial person.

6
kinereranti-killing innocent humans•

I understand, but here you agree that negative claims should be substantiated. So because there are disagreements within the mods, I would suggest that you guys clarify the rule and come up with a mutual understanding of how to enforce it.

0
AritheseOPPC Mod•

The claim above is not a negative claim.

We are indeed discussing it, but for now the rule stands as it is.

5
kinereranti-killing innocent humans•

That's good, but I would suggest that if you're not going to change the rules, at the very least you should clarify what a negative/positive statement is. Some users like u/Desu13 and u/BwanaAzungu seem confused about this.

1