Inner and outer skin: Do they differ by nature or only because of placement?

Question

Reading u/silversweep's question got me thinking again about what is known or unknown about the mucosal properties of inner skin vs outer skin.

We all know that for an intact penis, the inner skin [see Edit below: yes, "inner skin" is not the same as "skin" per se] is mucosal, lies atop the normally mucosal skin of the glans when the penis is flaccid. We also know that the inner skin keratinizes after circumcision and becomes seemingly identical to the normally keratinized outer skin.

In reading some anatomical and histological descriptions, it seems that the inner and outer skin are extremely similar [Edit— albeit with different names, "mucosa" and "skin"], with the main difference being the keratinized layer (epidermis) in the outer and lack thereof in the inner.

I couldn't find any information that made it clear whether outer skin is different by nature, or whether it has an epidermis primarily because it experiences different conditions (abrasion, air, no contact with the glans) from what intact or restored inner skin does.

Let's take the example of men who restore mostly outer skin, so that it folds over and plays the role that inner skin normally would have in an intact penis by covering the dekeratinized glans. Two main questions emerge for me:

  1. Does that portion of outer skin (which now acts like inner skin) fully dekeratinize?
  2. Does it differ histologically from intact inner skin (i.e., would it be distinguishable from inner skin under a microscope)?

Men with restored foreskins where outer skin is the main component that covers your glans, what would you say?

And if anyone can point to histology or anatomy that clears up these questions, that would be great.

I'm focusing on restoring my scar line to the tip of my eventual foreskin, but for those that can't, or don't want to bother growing enough inner skin to do so, it would be great to be more clear about how much it matters.

EDIT 1:

Several of you have pointed out correctly that the term "inner skin" is incorrect, and that it refers to mucosa or mucous membrane of the inner lamina of the prepuce. I've used the term "inner skin" just because it's a phrase that is common in this sub.

There appear to be two clear differences between skin and mucosa:

  1. their names, which doesn't in and of itself help us understand when or if one can behave like the other, as we know is the case at least in one direction (from mucosal intact foreskin, to keratinized, skin-like "inner skin" of a cut foreskin)
  2. the presence or not of an epidermis consisting of dead, keratinized cells

We know that mucosa of the so-called "inner skin", when exposed to air and abrasion over time, will keratinize and be structurally very close to, if not identical to, "outer skin". We know that this same tissue, which resembles "outer skin" (is it histologically identical, I wonder?) will dekeratinize and become mucosal.

What I think we don't know is whether the outer skin, in prolonged contact with the glans, will 1) fully dekeratinize and 2) be structured similarly to mucosa. Several of you have opinions about it, but I have yet to find anything either anecdotally or scientifically compelling to confirm one way or another.

Having looked through Normal and Abnormal Pupice, by Mohamed A. Baky Fahmy, a fairly comprehensive guide to the anatomy, histology, pathology, and more of the foreskin, there seems to be very little difference between the inner lamina of the prepuce ("inner skin") and the outer, other than the presence of an epidermal, keratinized layer on the outer. That's what led me to my question. Because if the mucosal inner lamina, seemingly differing only from the outer lamina because of its lack of a keratinized epidermis, can transform into what is basically skin by gaining a keratinized outer layer, then it's reasonable to wonder if its partner, the keratinized outer lamina, could similarly transform into a mucosa.

EDIT 2:

I've added some relevant info from Fahmy's book and another article in this comment.

Posted Feb 7, 2022, 11:59 PM UTC · edited

1620
m__m__7Restoring | CI-6•

I'd like to know this from a biology-restorer... They'll probably use words like histology... 😄

My layperson's undstanding is that inner skin isn't 'skin' as such, because it's mucosal like the insides of your cheeks. Inner skin on us when keratinized is a different texture to outer skin. I'd like to know more too.

KoT 👊

5
resensingOPRestoring | RCI - 4•

Yes, I've used the term "inner skin" just because it's a phrase that is common in this sub. I recognize that the so-called inner skin is actually mucosal. Yet when it keratinizes, it's pretty much identical to so-called outer skin.

4
goimghooded20Restoring | RCI - 8•

I can’t scientifically answer your questions but I can tell you what I have personally experienced. Before my inner skin dekeratinized it felt pretty much the same as outer skin running a finger over it. Now that my inner skin has dekeratinized and has returned to intended running a finger over it is very pleasurable. So in my experience my inner skin is pleasurable and works along with my glans to enhance pleasure. Outer skin covering your glans will help it dekeratinize but outer skin will not be pleasurable, it will be outer skin. Hope this helps.

2
resensingOPRestoring | RCI - 4•

Interesting. My questions specifically relate to your claim that outer skin might dekeratinize but "will not be pleasurable". Are you aware of actual experiences from restored men to support this?

1
goimghooded20Restoring | RCI - 8•

Yep. If your on restoringforeskin here is a link to a guy that restored with t-tape but did not focus on inner skin. He has a lot of outer skin on the inside. I’m sure he can answer your questions.

http://www.restoringforeskin.org/users/tormod

3
resensingOPRestoring | RCI - 4•

Thanks, this is a useful lead toward getting a real-world answer

1
lboyhedarkaflRestoring | CI-2•

Why would the outer skin dekeratinize in the first place? It's always supposed to be exposed it just simple doesn't has the same properties as inner skin does. It might help dekerantinize the glans but itself won't change at all.

1
resensingOPRestoring | RCI - 4•

It's certainly reasonable to believe that, yes. But the fact that the mucosa can keratinize and become virtually indistinguishable from outer skin, and then dekeratinize again in the right conditions (restoration); plus the fact that a layer of keratinized epidermis appears to be the only difference between mucosa and outer skin in the first place (the outer skin is not exactly like the skin on your hand or arm), leads me to think it's not completely impossible that outer skin might dekeratinize and become mucosal as well.

You and I are both speculating, though. That's why I'm looking for reports from men who can say what actually happened for them, or for science that points to what one could expect.

2
needletothebar•

"inner skin" is a misnomer. the inner tissue is mucosa, not skin.

2
Agile-Necessary-8223Restoring | CI-6•

Interesting.

I don't mean to pick at what you wrote, but from what I've learned since I started restoring, several of the things you wrote need some clarification.

It turns out that inner foreskin isn't actually skin. From Wikipedia:

The outside of the foreskin is a continuation of the skin on the shaft of the penis, but the inner foreskin is a mucous membrane like the inside of the eyelid or the mouth.

So what is a mucous membrane? Again from Wikipedia:

A mucous membrane or mucosa is a membrane that lines various cavities in the body and covers the surface of internal organs. It consists of one or more layers of epithelial cells overlying a layer of loose connective tissue.

The 'loose connective tissue' IIRC is the superficial fascia of the penis, sometimes known as the 'dartos layer'. It underlies both outer and inner skin and its loose connectivity with the Buck's fascia that surrounds the inner erectile structure of the penis gives the skin its mobility.

OK, so what are epithelial cells? Wikipedia again:

Epithelium /ˌɛpɪˈθiːliəm/[1] is one of the four basic types of animal tissue, along with connective tissue, muscle tissue and nervous tissue. It is a thin, continuous, protective layer of compactly packed cells with little intercellular matrix. Epithelial tissues line the outer surfaces of organs and blood vessels throughout the body, as well as the inner surfaces of cavities in many internal organs. An example is the epidermis, the outermost layer of the skin. [emphasis added]

So inner foreskin is most similar to the epidermis of outer skin, but inner foreskin is mucosal and outer skin isn't. That distinction isn't altered by circumcision, keratinization or dekeratinization, or restoration.

As for your questions:

  • If the outer skin is folded over and kept in contact with the glans full-time, it should dekeratinize over time, both because it is protected and because it is in contact with the glans, which is mucosal tissue.
  • Outer skin folded over and resting against the glans will not, however, ever become mucosal tissue, as far as I can tell. I haven't found any specific reference that confirms this, but it's hard to believe that a transformation like this could happen.

I too would be interested in hearing from restorers who have ended up with outer skin functioning as inner skin.

And, of course, if anything I posted isn't accurate, PLEASE correct me. I'm here to learn.

Cheers.

2
resensingOPRestoring | RCI - 4•

Thanks.

Please see the edits to clarify my original question.

Your second bullet point gets specifically to the question I have. You state that it's "hard to believe that a transformation like this could happen." That's exactly where my question begins: what are the experiences of men with such a situation in their restored foreskins, and what does the science say, if anyone has relevant references?

5
Agile-Necessary-8223Restoring | CI-6•

This is definitely an interesting question. I'm reading through the excerpt of Dr. Fahmy's book that Google has, lots of history stuff I only vaguely knew.... I had no idea the French Revolution was caused by phimosis..... and then some anatomy, but the preview ended before it got to anything germane to our discussion. I don't think I'm going to pay $23 for the Kindle copy.

Apropos of nothing at all, I used to drive past Al Ahzar University Medical School in Cairo on a regular basis when I lived there for 8 years on the '90s... the good ol' days, for sure.

At any rate, it doesn't sound like any of us has the necessary expertise to answer the fundamental question of whether any transformation occurs in the inner or outer foreskin tissue either when the inner skin is left uncovered by circumcision or, in the case of the outer, when it is permanently covered by restoration and used in place of inner skin.

If Dr. Fahmy doesn't give a definitive answer, it's entirely possible that this is something that hasn't been studied in detail. His book is the most comprehensive study of the foreskin/prepuce I've ever seen, not that I've seen a lot of books like that, but I've read quite a few papers and other literature on the subject.

So until a subject matter expert appears, it looks like we are sorta stuck!

Cheers.

3
resensingOPRestoring | RCI - 4•

Very cool that you recognize the name of the med school in Cairo!

I appreciate your thoughtful response, and that you understand that what I'm asking about doesn't yet have a definitive answer in our circles, even though people have assumptions, which may very possibly be valid, about what the answer may be.

Yeah, Fahmy's book is quite in-depth. I suppose we could always attempt to contact the doctor himself!

1
estimatoRestoring | CI-7•

My two cents worth. We seem to all agree that we are talking about two different kinds of tissue, mucosa and epidermis. Would outer skin, in constant contact with the moisture present inside the closed area of a covered glans be susceptible to react like skin on other parts of our body in constant contact with moisture? Becoming wrinkled, like our fingers in the pool, potentially developing fungal infections, like athlete's foot? Whereas mucosa, designed to be wet doesn't have those vulnerabilities.

Now, nerves. The nerves in these two types of tissue are completely different. It's those meisner's corpusles that are in the remnants of our original mucosa that bring us the heightened sensitivity and rapidly adaptive sensations that I and a few others have come to appreciate in a manner never expected. Any effort at restoration should try to optimize whatever is left of these nerves, therefore growth from the centerline of our scar, in both directions.

So...my conclusion is that we should, if at all possible, restore both types of tissue for the most gratifyingly effective results.

2
resensingOPRestoring | RCI - 4•

Thanks for your reply. I tend to agree with you that we should restore both inner and outer skin, but I remain curious about what the real-world differences are between the two, if we put aside our assumptions.

Yes, there are two main types of tissue in the foreskin—mucosa and skin with an epidermal layer—but not every mucosa in the body behaves identically, nor does every skin with an epidermal layer. Only the skin of the undersides of our feet and our palms, and not the rest of the skin of our bodies, become wrinkled when wet for a period of time, for instance (which interestingly is not a passive response but an active one, mediated by the nervous system, and believed to perhaps be related to needing extra grip when we're walking and manipulating things in water).

In Normal and Abnormal Pupice by Mohamed A. Baky Fahmy, it is apparent that the outer skin of the foreskin is unique, and not identical to skin elsewhere:

The skin (outer) layer of the prepuce shows typical characteristics of a thin, true skin. However, there are distinctive features that characterize the prepuce histologically from other parts of the body:

- The papillary dermis is rich in nerves and lymphoid cells.

- Dense capillary networks can be observed in both the upper and lower dermal zones.

- Lacks of the dense collagenous zone, both in density and thickness, which usually seen in most areas of the body

- Scant in lanugo hair follicles, sweat and sebaceous glands.

- Although limited in number, melanocytes can be observed.

- There are scattered smooth muscle bundles located in the lower reticular dermal zone.

- Elastin fibers and bundles are very abundant and dense.

So we can see that when we compare outer skin to, say arm or outer cheek skin, it's a loose comparison and not really accurate.

Fahmy goes on further about the outer skin:

Dermis of the Prepuce

The dermis of the prepuce consists of connective tissue, blood vessels, nerve trunks, Meissner corpuscles within the papillae, and occasionally scattered sebaceous and sweat glands. The dermis of the male prepuce appears to have more elastic fibres than the lamina propria. The difference between the elastic fibres in the lamina propria and dermis may also help form the ‘muzzle’ configuration around the glans penis. The elastic tissue of the prepuce dermis, along with the dartos muscle and frenulum, tether the prepuce and help return it to its anatomically correct position after deployment during erection or after manual retraction. The clitoral prepuce has only a dermal component with fewer elastic fibres than the male prepuce (Fig. 6.2).

Nerve fibres of the dermis are arranged into a deeper and a more superficial network. These networks constitute the chief form of innervation of human prepuce. The deeper net is oriented with the rete of arterioles in the reticular layer and may be considered limited to this portion of the dermis

To your point about nerves, notice above that the dermis of the prepuce contains Meissner corpuscles. Reading through these descriptions and the larger chapter they're pulled from, it's difficult to discern very much difference between outer and inner skin (as we call them in this subreddit) other than the layer of keratinized epithelium (a.k.a. epidermis) in the outer skin.

The prepuce by C. J. Cold and J. R. Taylor supports these impressions (I think) in the sections "Mucosal epithelium (inner plate of the prepuce)", "Dermis of the prepuce", and "Outer epithelium (glabrous skin of the prepuce)". The latter section starts:

The outer epithelium of the prepuce consists of stratified squamous cells that are keratinized.

This again leads me to consider the idea that if mucosal skin's epithelium keratinizes, as we all know it does, and dekeratinizes, as we know it does—perhaps so too might the outer skin.

It's interesting to keep these questions open as we learn more.

2
BumbleFlex19Restoring | CI-7•

By nature, that's why cut penises appear two-tone despite it being keratanized. Inner skin is a mucous membrane, thinner, and more sensitive.

1
resensingOPRestoring | RCI - 4•

Interesting idea regarding the two tones. I'm curious what information leads you to believe that the inner skin is thinner. Is it thinner for you? Mine is not.

2
VeteranScorp1972•

The difference of your cheek and lips. One is external and the other is internal

0
resensingOPRestoring | RCI - 4•

What I'm looking for are first-hand accounts or scientific literature. While the analogy you shared is useful, we know that outer skin of the foreskin is unique. It is not identical to skin elsewhere on our bodies--including the cheek. Without medical or experiential knowledge, we shouldn't assume it will behave or react identically to "regular" skin.

2
VeteranScorp1972•

It is literally the same as the inside of your cheek.

0