Inner and outer skin: Do they differ by nature or only because of placement?
Reading u/silversweep's question got me thinking again about what is known or unknown about the mucosal properties of inner skin vs outer skin.
We all know that for an intact penis, the inner skin [see Edit below: yes, "inner skin" is not the same as "skin" per se] is mucosal, lies atop the normally mucosal skin of the glans when the penis is flaccid. We also know that the inner skin keratinizes after circumcision and becomes seemingly identical to the normally keratinized outer skin.
In reading some anatomical and histological descriptions, it seems that the inner and outer skin are extremely similar [Edit— albeit with different names, "mucosa" and "skin"], with the main difference being the keratinized layer (epidermis) in the outer and lack thereof in the inner.
I couldn't find any information that made it clear whether outer skin is different by nature, or whether it has an epidermis primarily because it experiences different conditions (abrasion, air, no contact with the glans) from what intact or restored inner skin does.
Let's take the example of men who restore mostly outer skin, so that it folds over and plays the role that inner skin normally would have in an intact penis by covering the dekeratinized glans. Two main questions emerge for me:
- Does that portion of outer skin (which now acts like inner skin) fully dekeratinize?
- Does it differ histologically from intact inner skin (i.e., would it be distinguishable from inner skin under a microscope)?
Men with restored foreskins where outer skin is the main component that covers your glans, what would you say?
And if anyone can point to histology or anatomy that clears up these questions, that would be great.
I'm focusing on restoring my scar line to the tip of my eventual foreskin, but for those that can't, or don't want to bother growing enough inner skin to do so, it would be great to be more clear about how much it matters.
EDIT 1:
Several of you have pointed out correctly that the term "inner skin" is incorrect, and that it refers to mucosa or mucous membrane of the inner lamina of the prepuce. I've used the term "inner skin" just because it's a phrase that is common in this sub.
There appear to be two clear differences between skin and mucosa:
- their names, which doesn't in and of itself help us understand when or if one can behave like the other, as we know is the case at least in one direction (from mucosal intact foreskin, to keratinized, skin-like "inner skin" of a cut foreskin)
- the presence or not of an epidermis consisting of dead, keratinized cells
We know that mucosa of the so-called "inner skin", when exposed to air and abrasion over time, will keratinize and be structurally very close to, if not identical to, "outer skin". We know that this same tissue, which resembles "outer skin" (is it histologically identical, I wonder?) will dekeratinize and become mucosal.
What I think we don't know is whether the outer skin, in prolonged contact with the glans, will 1) fully dekeratinize and 2) be structured similarly to mucosa. Several of you have opinions about it, but I have yet to find anything either anecdotally or scientifically compelling to confirm one way or another.
Having looked through Normal and Abnormal Pupice, by Mohamed A. Baky Fahmy, a fairly comprehensive guide to the anatomy, histology, pathology, and more of the foreskin, there seems to be very little difference between the inner lamina of the prepuce ("inner skin") and the outer, other than the presence of an epidermal, keratinized layer on the outer. That's what led me to my question. Because if the mucosal inner lamina, seemingly differing only from the outer lamina because of its lack of a keratinized epidermis, can transform into what is basically skin by gaining a keratinized outer layer, then it's reasonable to wonder if its partner, the keratinized outer lamina, could similarly transform into a mucosa.
EDIT 2:
I've added some relevant info from Fahmy's book and another article in this comment.
Posted Feb 7, 2022, 11:59 PM UTC · edited
I'd like to know this from a biology-restorer... They'll probably use words like histology... 😄
My layperson's undstanding is that inner skin isn't 'skin' as such, because it's mucosal like the insides of your cheeks. Inner skin on us when keratinized is a different texture to outer skin. I'd like to know more too.
KoT 👊
Yes, I've used the term "inner skin" just because it's a phrase that is common in this sub. I recognize that the so-called inner skin is actually mucosal. Yet when it keratinizes, it's pretty much identical to so-called outer skin.