DoneebOPgobble gobble (formerly pilsen)•

A bit into the pandemic L&E was selling their 21 year Willett single barrels “Longman” and “Eagle” for $6,000 and $5,500, respectively. We all know the market is bananas so here’s a quick review of each bottle. The “Longman” notes are from when I had it in 2015 (at $20/pour…now $140/220) and “Eagle” I had last night.

“Longman” - Incredibly herbal. Herbs dominate everything. No spice, astonishingly no oak. This is strange. About a 4 on the t8ke scale.

“Eagle” - Nose is nice: brown sugar & oak. The palate falls to absolute pieces. There’s nail polish with a splash of oak and a bit of urethane*, though not as much as I’d like. This is a 3 on the t8ke scale. Smells nice, but it is not enjoyable.

Curiously, they still have bottles of these. They sold bottles of “Eagle” back when they first got the barrel and presumably sold bottles of each over the years, while also having it on the menu consistently. I can’t imagine a high yield from 21 year old barrels so I’m really not sure how they still have this in stock.

Bonus Henry McKenna L&E select from 2013: barrelled on 2/11/2003 barrel #1040 - nondescript bourbon! Your typical caramel & vanilla without anything that stands out. 5 on the t8ke scale. HM has always been hit or miss but decent for a $30 bottle, winning an award didn’t make it taste any better but it did make it double in price.

I’ll admit I’m a bit of a curmudgeon when it comes to the current whiskey market, but the moral of the story is: Expensive, rare, high age statements, and a once-lauded NDP do not equate to something tasty. If you have the cash and inclination to try these, I’d recommend looking elsewhere.

*If you’re unfamiliar with urethane, u/Cojirob did several incredible writeups on it. Here is one.

8