r/LOTR_on_Prime•
Eraldir

The argument about "lore accuracy" is so hypocritical

Discussion

The PJ trilogy is beloved all around and yet it made a lot of glaring changes. Peter Jackson deleted 50% of the story, changed a third of the themes and most characters have completely different character arcs and personalities than their book counterparts. But somehow there they don't care about accuracy, call the trilogy a masterpiece.

I probably don't need to explain how much story was cut for the movies. Even more so the content they added which never was in the books (something a lot of people seem to suddenly despise about the amazon series).

Dozens of characters were cut and yet no one says the trilogy ruined Tolkien. Tom Bombadil, Radagast, Erestor, Glorfindel, Erkenbrand, Quickbeam, Ghan-Buri-Ghan, Elfhelm, Beregond, Bergil, Imrahil, the entire grey company, Eladan and Elrohir, even bloody Caradhras. And some of these were quite important to the story.

Some characters were added and no cries there either. Except, curiously, for Arwen. Isn't it strange that no one minds added or expanded characters unless it is a woman? I thought the haters weren't bigots...

And then we come to all the characters that were changed. 5 out of 9 members of the fellowship are completely unrecogniseable. Aragorn, Legolas, Gimli, Merry, and Frodo are polar opposites of their book versions and Boromir, Pippin and Gandalf experience some decent deviations. Only Sam remains and even he gets some upgrades in certain places. Aragorn is completely certain of his destiny in the books and even comes across as down right arrogant. Legolas is sunshine personified and keeps moral up better than even Aragorn. Gimli is a triggerhappy pragmatist who faces fears and develops love that should not be possible. Merry is a loyal and calm organizer who has serious self worth issues in the final book. And Frodo is so courageous he gets compared to freaking Beren while in the movies he constantly is on the verge of tears and never shows courage that surpasses that of his companions. Eomer in the movies is a brash asshole far too long and his friendship with Legolas and Gimli is deleted, Theoden is a whining whimp for most of the movies, Eowyn is not nearly proud enough or suicidal enough. She has depression ffs while in the movie she is a bit lovesick! Treebeard is a delusional idiot who betrays his sole duty for existing and somehow misses his herd being murdered. And don't get me started on Faramir. That guy literally betrayed all the values his book version was there to represent. And Denethor was far more than a rude tomato muncher.

No one says the trilogy is garbage because of this or that it ruined the story. But when an elf has the wrong skin colour or when the story deviates slightly to fit the format of a TV show (which still isn't even confirmed by the way) then these people suddenly cry about accuracy. Anyone who doesn't hate the trilogy cannot complain about accuracy in the show, let alone about something so trivial as hair styles.

Posted Feb 19, 2022, 4:45 PM UTC

102132
Loading comments…