
Eraldir
u/Eraldir

I had a hard time understanding Sauron in this show, especially the contradiction between repentent Sauron and evil deceiving Sauron. But I think I now have managed it and we can analyse and summarise his character fully now.
Just like in the books Sauron didn't serve Morgoth because he agreed with him. In the show we don't yet know precisely why he joined but it seems to be similar to his motivations in the lore. When Morgoth fell he sais he was finally free of his fist around his throat. He initially takes over as dark lord, kills Finrod and commands all evil beings to Forodwaith. There he conducts experiments on smithing and the unseen world but fails just like Celebrimbor does later in
Repost because of rule violation.
Sauron impersonating Finrod to manipulate Galadriel was superb acting! Finrod's actor is a genius, even if you don't like his hair.
In that scene you could tell it wasn't Finrod. Not just logically because of the previous scene and because his dialogue was twisted, but also because of his acting.
His facial expressions were just a tad off. He smiled too much and his smile was too wide. But not overly so, just enough to feel strange and different to the smile we knew. When he wasn't smiling his face was weirdly hard and stoney, lacking the warmth Finrod had shown in ep1. There was an almost predatory look in his eyes. He also moved his face too much whi
The tantrum thrown over the whole mithril thing was highly amusing to me. The show makes up a fairy tale about mithril, openly states that it is just a fairy tale and many people still cry about "ReWrItInG tOlKiEn". We all know those are just more of the petty haters who already hate the show and are now seeking for post hoc justification for that hatred (and maybe some are not haters but lack listenting comprehension idk) but after Episode 6 I do have a question for those.
What now? You believe Sauron is dead now too?
I mean, Adar said he killed him and you believe everything a character in this show claims, even when the show itself doesn't. So I guess he is dead now. Sorry to all the
In episode 1, in the garden of the fallen, Elrond sais the following to Galadriel:
"Only in the blessed realm can that which is broken in you be healed"
Aside from it being a nicely written line and being integral to their characters, I felt a real shock in that moment. My mind immediately jumped to Celebrian. Galadriel's daughter and Elrond's wife, who was captured by orcs, tortured mercilessly and quite possibly raped by the orcs before Elladan and Elrohir freed her.
It is said that her mind and spirit were so broken that even Elrond could not help her and so she was sent to Valinor, leaving behind her parents, her husband, and her children in the hope of finally finding healing. Only
From the very first scene we see the dwarves in and throughout the rest of the 2 episodes I was struck by how perfectly the dwarves were portrayed. First of all Khazad-dûm looks magnificent! It looks utterly epic and grand, while also retaining the feel of actually being lived in and carved into the hard rock. Utilities and technology are present and logical. They even had the holes for light to fall in through the ceiling!
Second the dwarves and their manneurisms are superb! Their rowdy but also super competitive and loyal nature is portrayed well while also combining their rough discipline with humour. Durin's duel with Elrond, although not in the books, is totally something I could see t
The PJ trilogy is beloved all around and yet it made a lot of glaring changes. Peter Jackson deleted 50% of the story, changed a third of the themes and most characters have completely different character arcs and personalities than their book counterparts. But somehow there they don't care about accuracy, call the trilogy a masterpiece.
I probably don't need to explain how much story was cut for the movies. Even more so the content they added which never was in the books (something a lot of people seem to suddenly despise about the amazon series).
Dozens of characters were cut and yet no one says the trilogy ruined Tolkien. Tom Bombadil, Radagast, Erestor, Glorfindel, Erkenbrand, Quickb


![[spoilers ep1] Always listen to the end](https://i.redd.it/3tq8kelo6zt81.jpg)


