Worth watching after 5th season?

Season 5

Hi guys, I started watching supernatural for the first time a couple of months ago and I have now finished the 5th season. I have read somewhere online that the writers originally intended for the show to stop after that. Since it’s very long I worry that it will just be downhill from here as it often happens with this kind of series. So i’m looking for advice: is it worth it to keep going? Does the show keeps on being as great as it is so far?

Posted Mar 8, 2022, 11:58 AM UTC

9696

Has its ups and downs, but trust me, carry on! You will miss so much if you don't!

144
CardamonFives•

There will be peace when you are done

40
Sa_Chan52•

Lay your weary head to rest

27
lemonkid_word•

Don't you cry no more

13
neela84•

I see what you did there

27
ChriscraftPC1•

You will always remember

7

You guys just made my day😆

4
Petrichor02•

If your primary interest in the show is the characters and their various adventures, keep going. There's enough good throughout the next ten seasons to keep you enjoying the show more often than not.

If your primary interest in the show is the lore and overarching story, stop watching. Maybe look up a list of the more fun or meta episodes if you're into them and just watch some of those. But don't continue watching the show for the strength and continuity of the show's lore and story because you will likely find yourself increasingly frustrated with the show as it continues.

Bottom line, the show keeps being fun after Season 5, despite some rough patches, and the characters never deviate too far from their normal, likable selves, but if you're a lore nerd, you will constantly find yourself asking whether the writers even watched the first five seasons at a certain point.

70
psyfuck•

Like when they randomly decided reapers were angels 😂

33
CoeurdePirate222•

For me, I just kinda turned my brain off super logical mode and just enjoyed what was in front of me, because I do love the stories and characters. It was easy after that for the most part!

22
psyfuck•

Exactly! Once you stop going wtf, you can sit back and enjoy (and even make fun) 😂

7
snowmvp•

I didn't know that, I thought they were something different :D

2
Judgejudyx•

Neither did the writers

3
mkranstack•

The only way to know if you'll enjoy it going forward is to try Season 6. It's got some absolute stunners as far as creative comedy goes so if you don't enjoy that then you'll have your answer.

2
Kremlin_Da_Gremlin•

In my opinion, the first 5 seasons of the show are gritty and dark and mature with obvious comedy here and there. Whereas the seasons after that aren’t as dark and slowly devolve into meme territory, you will not be able to predict what crazy shenanigans will happen as the series goes on and it’s hilarious

46
Judgejudyx•

Post season 5 supernaturals my favorite comedy. They have the best meta episodes. In my opionon supernaturals best episode is the french mistake which is all meta. No spoilers obv

6
WhiteWalter1•

One of my absolute favorite episodes!

1

Okay hands down seasons 1-5 are a perfect story on their own

While you won’t get the perfect storyline, you WILL get great episodes, fun new characters, character development, and some fantastic one shot episodes

there are sooo many good things to come BUT you will get frustrated at the lack of planning/missed opportunities/lost story lines

19
DeanandCrowleyhourWhere's the pie?•

Keep going! Supernatural has skyrocketed to the best show ever for me. I’m on my first watch and in season 13. My husband started watching with me in season 12 and now he’s into it, too. 😄

14
Ok_Assumption138•

It’s my first watch and I’m on 12! 😁

3

Keep on going man, finished my first run just couple of months back, don't remember why I never watched it before. It's in my Fav list now

2
Ok_Assumption138•

Me too! I’ve become obsessed hahah

1
Asha_Brea•

Lots of great characters and episodes after season 5.

13
Cosmic_R3m1x1•

Though it was intentionally meant to end after season 5, you're missing out on 2/3 of the show. You don't get to see what it becomes. It has its up and downs, like others have said, but 6-15 is part of the shows identity

9
SPNLucifer•

6-11

1
Independent-Cow69•

For the boys, only for the boys

8
[deleted]•

[removed]

6
Judgejudyx•

Bro dont post spoilers he said hes on season 5

3
SPNLucifer•

No spoilers here, OP is finished with season 5

1
Judgejudyx•

Read the second to last paragraph it spoils a lot

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Morrigan_NicDanu•

I think it's worth it. Didnt even know people dislike past season 5. The Darkness alone is worth it.

5
Old-While-1229•

I’d watch it. Is it as good as seasons 1-5: no, but you’d be missing some really good episodes and arcs

5
thebluerayxx•

100% continue. Yes the plan was 5 seasons and the write strike put undue pressure on them but the show just keeps rising up and up for the next 10 seasons. I watched the show from start to finish and I'm willing to watch 15 season again. Supernatural became one of my favorite shows and I highly recommend to carry on my wayward son.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4†
MaggieMay-19•

Kripke isn't even involved.

For the sake of factual accuracy, let me say that Kripke was heavily involved in outlining the plotlines of season 6. He handed over the title of showrunner, but the way the writers room operates is that as soon as the show knows it has a next season, the writers/showrunner start to work on that season. That happened pretty early in the season 5 run, and both Kripke and Sera Gamble have acknowledged how heavily involved he was in s6.

Also Kripke's initial plan was 3 seasons, not 5. If you enjoyed seasons 4 and 5, which heavily involved Sera Gamble during the outlines phase (she was the champion of expanding the Supernatural universe to include angels) then I think you might also enjoy what happens next.

5
Judgejudyx•

Angels werent even suppose to be in supernatural originally. The show was suppose to only be 3 seasons. All 15 seasons are still worth watching if you enjoy the characters

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1†
MaggieMay-19•

Your rant is funny lol!

I'm just interested in factual accuracy. My sources are the dvd extras, specifically the documentaries about angels and the commentary episodes from season 4, plus one panel interview with Kripke from one of the 2012 conventions (can't remember which one but from YouTube) where he explained his involvement in s6 and how he seems to have avoided the flack for it by not being the showrunner.

You're allowed to like what you like for whatever reason you like, dude, but please don't claim your opinions are facts, or get your factual claims wrong. And it's kinda rude to spend so much of your post voicing your assumptions about me personally. To misquote Sam:

...don’t dump your whackadoo all over me(sic).

8
_Valisk•

It’s kind of insane to say “anyone who disagrees with me is a crazy tumblr fanboy.”

2
traymarie•

You’ll enjoy it until season 11 hits

4
SPNLucifer•

*12

1
xtnts•

Definitely watch it! Separate seasons 1-5 and the rest and you’ll be good. It has its ups and downs but it’s still very much entertaining :)

3
wwwdotWeirdperson•

Carry on, my wayward son

3
nukajoe•

It kind of depends. Im glad I finished all 15 seasons. I had all kinds of issues with the shows changes retcons and general choices but overall I still ha fun and liked it. I doh think seasons 6-15 makes seasons 1-5 any less enjoyable, but I'm not super bothered by retcons.

3
theclancinator14•

SPN is in my top 3 shows of all time. It's a great ride for all 15 seasons. like any show, there are plot holes and episodes, story lines and characters we like better than others. I mean, we can pick it apart forever (and we do that here on this sub all the time but in a nice, respectful way) but that's part of loving a long-running, successful show with a huge following. at the end of the day, it was a great production. awesome cast and crew. and well worth 15 seasons and even multiple re-watches. when it ends, you'll wonder what you're going to do without them. and most of what you watch after this won't be the same caliber. keep going and enjoy every minute!

3

Seasons 3-5 are probably the best seasons created for Supernatural. I should warn you that the next few seasons kinda suck in comparison. It’s all definitely worth the watch though, even if it’s just to make fun of them with friends who are also avid fans!

3
lionne6•

There’s a lot of good episodes and characters and ideas that come in later seasons. Unfortunately, there’s also a lot of fan service and clunky handling of plot arcs. Sometimes it feels straight up like bad fan fiction. I made it to season 13 and just found it unwatchable by season 14. I tuned in during season 15 to find Dean threatening and railing impotently at God himself, and it was so wince-worthy I never went back. I did watch clips of the last episode though to know how it ended, and am apparently one of the few people who think they nailed it. It’s difficult to say….there’s still lots of great stuff in later episodes. But it does become far less gritty, dark, and dedicated to horror. And it sets up some interesting ideas and then fails to execute them. I guess you just have to try it and see for yourself.

3