How long do you think it'll take before a coup happens in KSA?
Things don't look so well for them
Posted Mar 26, 2022, 6:42 AM UTC
Things don't look so well for them
Posted Mar 26, 2022, 6:42 AM UTC
Won’t happen lol
None. Saudi Arabia will be absorbed into the Pan Arab state inshallah.
And anyways, the Saudi people have livelihood, they do not need revolution or anything.
Tbh as much as i hate all mena governments, our leaders will prefer to destroy their whole countries before falling down.
Most of the royal family are weak and cowards so don’t expect anything from them
The religious leaders are very wealthy and corrupt so again don’t expect anything from them
And the Saudis army is a joke and just for the show so again don’t expect anything from them
A coup will happened only if the United States wanted one since MBS is ruining America’s interests in the region
Yeah the US almost always has the last laugh. If MbS gets too cocky for the US, the US will remove him without a second thought.
1 year 🤡
People seem to not understand the Saudi population confidence in the government and how all is working towards a brighter future. They also fail to realize that the ruling family and the citizens have ties that goes no less than 300 years ago. Previous Arab monarchies that fell don’t even have a fraction of legitimacy the Al Sauds have. Love it or not, Saudi Arabia is on the path to be a successful country.
Well, we just have certain ideas about how governments functions, and how monarchies functions and what features do they have more than the other political systems, we don't think much about the saudi street the same way we don't think much of the Syrian or Egyptian street when it comes to political analysis.
Not anytime soon inshallah
MBS weakened 3 out of 4 important pillars in the legitimacy of his throne.
The military legitimacy by killing Abdulaziz al-Fagham and failing in Yemen.
The religious legitimacy by imprisoning the scholars and looking as if he wants normalization with Israel.
The legitimacy within the royal family by killing/imprisoning his relatives.
The last one is the tribal legitimacy, this all threatens with a silent coup being planned that learnt it lessons from the coup in Turkey and the revolutions of the Arab world generally. The USA and other countries are busy with their economies and the diplomacy of MBS is failing in all possible ways, Iran and Yemen are a big fat mess too.
u/Cergun- you seem to hate me but nonetheless I'm interested in your opinion.
I don't hate you, but again, I don't like you either.
To answer your question, a coup doesn't appear to be anywhere in the Horizon. Not anytime soon. Other than that, it's ridiculous to expect people to predict what will happen more than 3 years from now. Damn, people were speculating whether Russia would invade Ukraine or not hours before the actual invasion.
Damn, people were speculating whether Russia would invade Ukraine or not hours before the actual invasion.
I've always knew about it and most of the political analysts I follow speculated about it.
Other than that, it's ridiculous to expect people to predict what will happen more than 3 years from now.
You can do so, you just need a lot of time and effort, any analyst expected the Taliban to win, you can expect Assad to fall in 2024-2025 etc
when do you think we will expect to see a coup?
[deleted]
1- Al-faghm was a bodyguard, not the CO of the army and he wasn’t killed by the government
2- 95% of Saudis are happy that the religious authority was destroyed.
3- MBS has no rival within the royal family, the last one was stripped of his power 5 years ago and is now irrelevant.
4- Tribal loyalties are something that disappeared almost a century ago, the tribal sheiks don’t have any real power over their tribes
u/shahdp what do you think?
A coup can never happen in saudi arabia. Why would saudis ever want that to happen? The average saudi lives a relatively better life than any other arab, excluding other gulfies ofc. When a normal citizen with such life sees what coups did in other countries, especially arab ones; why would they want that to happen in their country? When everything is stable and the government takes good care of them?
To even think about the possibility of a coup is ridiculous. If you say that to any saudi they’d simply think you’re joking and not take you seriously.
I agree, outsiders are very disconnected to the everyday life of a Saudi that’s way they have this opinion.
Cuz we all know a revolution in KSA happens through the average Saudi and not the military or royal family lmao.
A coup can never happen in saudi arabia.
It always happens in similar conditions, it had happened in many arab monarchies before, and the ME has always been unstable with Syria for example having a military coup every second, MBS has failed to learn the lessons.
The average saudi lives a relatively better life than any other arab, excluding other gulfies ofc. When a normal citizen with such life sees what coups did in other countries, especially arab ones; why would they want that to happen in their country? When everything is stable and the government takes good care of them?
That doesn't mean anything, coups happen within the people of power, and not outside them, the only benefit the saudi street can give a coup is accepting it, that's enough, a revolution in Syria wasn't correlated with a revolution within the Syrian government, but prior to that the people didn't want Assad yet he succeeded in a coup, KSA doesn't have a sectarian government though.
To even think about the possibility of a coup is ridiculous.
Monarchies in the ME got so much coups historically, Egypt and Syria merged and broke, monarchy here and there got dethroned, now it's about time the instability reach the old levels.
Saudi is not syria or egypt, you can compare those countries to saudi in many things, but not when it comes to military coups and revolutions, its just not the same.
Lets say a coup or a revolution did happen in saudi, who’s the leader of such revolution? Whats their agenda? If you believe there’s a chance of a coup happening, you should have someone or some group in mind who can actually dethrone house saud.
Spoiler alert: no one can dethrone them
Join the Official Discord Server of AskMiddleEast: https://discord.gg/S26wZPk9xE
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
[removed]
The thing is not only Saudis support Al Saud all GCC citizens support them and would never want them to be removed. If the Saudi monarch fall all GCC countries will follow suit and become the next Iraq or Syria. The citizens now know this very well and won’t be fooled by promises of democracy and self-rule.
Never We love them
[removed]
People are weirdly confident that the fall of the longest lasting governments in the middle east will happen any day now. I still see people talking about how the Jordanian government is on its last legs. And I've read enough history to know that a lot of powerful people and intellectuals have thought it was near collapse for 78 years now. Here's my prediction on Saudi Arabia. MBS or a member of his family will still be in power in 30 years.
Everyone saw the fragility of Iraq, Syria and Libya and think it will happen to everyone else.
Thing is, Saudi Arabia has the biggest economy in the Middle East, it is the most stable. Every Saudi I know likes the administration and safety of their country.
The ones who advocate for the destruction of the Saudi state are mostly non Saudis who either think Saudi is too extreme or not extreme enough and Redditors who think Saudi Arabia will be a liberal paradise and all women wear miniskirts.
I don't want it destroyed, I'm happy for the Saudis, I think they deserve a better government but the coup can't guarantee anything.
RemindME! 30 years "Why are you still on reddit?"
I will be messaging you in 30 years on 2052-03-26 06:56:03 UTC to remind you of this link
CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.
^(Parent commenter can ) ^(delete this message to hide from others.)
I’ve seen “research articles” saying that the government will be overthrown “very soon” since the 90’s. People who push that don’t have any backing and it’s only because they hate Saudi. There is overwhelming support for the monarchy because they take care for citizens, enforce sharia, etc. all the soy boys hoping for a coup will cry once they realise the royal family is popular
I will give it a year or two, the legitimacy within the military, the royal family, the religious institution and the saudi street is broken, the Ukrainian thing made the US and other governments busy with their economies, it's the best environment.
It all really depends on the US. Once they've had enough, they'll remove the Saudi royal family with someone who sucks them off at first call.