What’s the pros and cons to a united ireland?

Question

I want to start doing my own research on all this, but it seems like a massive topic. Could you lovely folk give me some opinions / info on what the pros and cons would be? Cheers!

Posted Apr 24, 2022, 11:32 AM UTC

027
MaelVogue•

Pro: no more of these threads

Con: endless threads on which Tayto to use going forward

35
Time-Tradition905•

I want to start doing my own research. Someone give me all their research.

16
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
rightenoughLurgan•

Pro: Arlene moves to Scotland

Con: Toll roads

6

In fairness I think the only reason we don’t have toll roads is people would laugh themselves to death if you suggested paying to travel to Larne.

1
Duppy06•

Transitioning to a UI would be a major ball ache.

4
Spider_plant_man•

Pro testants.

Con atholics

Or something?

3
taarup•

Pros: Jim Allister going apeshit. Jamie Bryson going apeshit. UK doesn't want us.

Con: Cost of living. Ireland doesn't want us.

3†
sgour•

Pro: Long term, economically better for NI - a tiny island with two of everything makes little sense. Being able to watch Jamie Bryson lose his shit over it.

Con: VRT. No free at point of use health care/having to pay for GP visits if you dont have a medical card

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
BBK89DGL•

con: Dublin

1†
No_Breakfast9351Belfast•

Pro: Bryson has a nervous breakdown and has to be emitted to an asylum

Con: themens will start murder

1
Sad-Feedback-5532•

Pro: vos

Cons: Half a million Irish hating unionists get forced into a country they don't want. We spend decades trying to work together under a new government while the planet burns....It's just cons really. There are no positives. Just make Northern Ireland a better place and if you want to unite anything, unite the people on the island first, then maybe consider border changes.

Fuck this debate

1
Kashara1989•

Pro: Economic benefits

Con: Would have to pay for healthcare.

-2†
Itburns12345•

Give the tories enough time and that 2nd one will be true regardless of united ireland or not :(

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1

The economic benefit of a united Ireland? Lol

0†
Kashara1989•

A United Ireland would bring about the removal of duplication of services on the island. This would lead to much more efficient and effective public services. A United Ireland would also bring about the transfer of fiscal powers from London. Focused and suitable economic policy would result in the creation of tens of thousands of jobs. A United Ireland would also benefit from economies of scale, greater efficiencies and synergies.

3
[deleted]•

You say a lot of stuff, but nothing to back it up. Here's one for you: a united Ireland would mean southerners would have to fork out hand over fist to keep the parasitic state known as Northern Ireland at the current standard of living. You know, to replace the 20 billion or so odd quid the brits funnel in here every year?

0

Absolute nonsense. As recently as 2016 standard of living was 20% higher in N. Ireland. House prices, cost of living, no health care- N. Ireland leaving in of the strongest for one of the weakest economies in Europe would be 10 times worse than brexit.

-3†
zipmcjingles•

ROI is richer than UK per Capita. I'd love to know where you get your numbers from. NI is also one of the most deprived areas of UK.

6

One of the most deprived countries in western Europe joining the fastest growing area of the eurozone. If you’re denying there’s economic benefits to that, especially post-Brexit, you’re thinking emotionally not logically.

GNI* is the metric used to measure the Irish economy while controlling for the influence of multinationals taking advantage of the tax arrangement. Even when using that metric Ireland is far richer than the north and GB.

2
hullabalookitten•

Can the mods restrict these types of questions?

The sub is choked to death with them or some variation of it ceaselessly. Usually they're simply a guise for a brand of of Sinn bot to regurgitate the same tired panacea type drivel. Hobbiests from abroad with an extremely poor grasp of ni or southern IRA/sinn fein fetishists to stroke off over.

Do your own research, post your findings on the sub for others to examine or scrutinise. If you're genuinely that curious..take up the mantle instead of handing it to others and asking them to do your grunt work..

-4