[Spoiler: Heavensward] I didn't realize an MMO could break my heart as much as this story has
Posted May 14, 2022, 9:17 AM UTC
Posted May 14, 2022, 9:17 AM UTC
I've been legitimately reading as much fanfiction as I can of this character to fill the void in my soul
Oh, do not look at him so. A smile better suits a hero.
I finished the MSQ of heavensward tonight and my friends have been just teasing me while I sit there thinking about him, saying “a smile better suits a hero” and referencing the scene constantly
It's true though. His character really wouldn't want you stuck in mourning. He loved you, and wanted you to face it all with a smile.
Honour him.
(Also do the firmament questline when you can, it will give you some deep warm feels).
I’ll make sure to do that, thank you!
In a lot of ways I really like the mask that I have for my current outfit after that line; my WoL is struggling to accept his words and follow them and she doesn’t want to show her smile to anyone but him.
[removed]
Ok, that's just mean.
There's a questline you might want to do. Go to House Fortemps Manor and get the quest from the manservant "The Paths We Walk".
That doesn't unlock until later, OP's only just finished 3.0 by the sounds of things.
It gets better/worse for your emotions. Have fun!
you are going to enjoy Dark Knight job quest especially the stormblood one
I'm the same way with some characters from later expansions.
It's weird. Haurchefaunt's death didn't do anything crazy for me, but I understand the WoL's mental state afterwards.
Ysayle, though... oof.
Haurchefant’s death didn’t really hit me until I told his dad. Then I bawled.
Yeah, the scene with Lord Fortemps made the death feel all the more real and painful. It wasn't just an anime death for plot reasons, it was someone's son, a loving friend, and a true companion.
People talk about how they don't like that Hauche death is still referenced all these years and expansions later, but for some it was a very real moment.
Yea i mean we spent quite a bit of time with him from ARR days. He helped out the MC so much in the story and he is just a great person. Hard not to like him, imo. Yea the dad scene was rough when he broke down. I immediately wanted revenge when he died lmao. Had me speechless in That moment like bro did they just kill off HAURCHEBRO?!
I actually do like that they reference Hauche death, but please I need more Ysayle reference ; ;
!I know we already got more Ysayle reference in EW. I liked it. Still I need more!!!<
Yea, for me it was after, specially when going through the DRK stuff. On his death it was just “Buddy I am a Tank what are you doing?!?!” and before that he was just the little too friendly boss who got your back no matter what cause reasons.
After? You see WoL being ripped to pieces over it, having to tell his dad, the fact it kinda clicked that he was a exile yet still was happy to everyone.
He was to good for us.
I didn't cry, but it did hit harder when we told Lord Fortemps.
When he gave us the shield before we went to Azys Lla... hoo boy.
I'm the same way. Moenbryda hit me hard too despite only being around for a couple hours.
Moen had so much life and character and personally put into her few quests that you grow attached to her more than any other scion up to that point. Especially with how stiff the rest of ARR was. And then she's just gone and you have to move on.
EW: >!The scene with her parents still brings me to tears every time I see it in a streamers video.!<
I cried so fucking hard in the reunion. Jesus
Urianger's VA did a bang up job there.
For me Moen was a "sad, but meh, just a side char" moment. Between the introduction and killing of her wasn't enough time for me to really build a connection with her character.
Yet in that short time she has more personality than all of the Scions except maybe Alphinaud up to that point. Least to me.
Darn shame. I kind of appreciate it in a "gone too soon, and we characterise her by seeing how her loss affects others" way, but I feel like they really regretted offing her like an hour after you meet her.
Also we could stand to have more Roes in the party.
Same. I wish we had more time with her.
When Thancred said goodbye to Ryne in 5.3 Jesus Christ I cried like a kids with a skinned knee. That scene was me saying going bye to my 19yr old daughter that passed away about 6mnth prior. I literally had to walk away from my machine and take a break for quite a few hours with my wife asking what made me cry like this.
The writing in this game is just so amazingly good. I love that they don’t always shoot for a happy ending.
Same here. I actually thought it was Fortemp's eldest son at the time. Didn't realize it was the guy from the keep. Moenbryda might have been tougher, but she wasn't around long enough and her demise was a bit cheesy.
Same here. Haurchefaunt was like a "Dang, that sucks." for me. Whereas Ysayle's had me sobbing.
Ysayle is the one who took on Lady Shiva? Honestly for me, it felt less like a sad death and more like a redemptive one. She had found out the hard way that most of what she idolized had long been lost and what little she clutched was false. She had caused death, and anguish for others in a ruthless mission of repeating the mistakes of the past.
So for me at least, her finale was more a grandiose end of a life mission, setting the future on track towards her real hopes and dreams for the first time.
What got me with it was that Hraesvelgr brought her to the battle, and called his horde to protect her while she summoned the false Shiva.
Ysayle had such a good redemption arc. She didn't deserve to die...
I was really hoping she was going to at least make it to the 3.X content, maybe get in on the Nidhogg rematch (there was no way he was dead at The Aery, no chance in hell).
My disappointment was immeasurable and my day was ruined. I may have vented against Thordan and Ascian Prime.
I took his death so hard. I yelled at the screen, cried, and then had to stop playing for a couple of days because I needed some time to process it.
For those we have lost. For those we can yet save.
Ever and always. For we who walk before may lead those who follow after.
Don't get me wrong, I've found no expansion to be weak so far, but Heavensward will always be my favourite. There's just something so perfect about the story, the characters and so on. I think it's helped by the sudden ramp up in story in the pre-expansion patch content too though.
Agreed! I loved Shadowbringers and Endwalker. I was ugly crying at the end of them both! But there's something about Heavensward that makes me think about it quite often and I want to replay it.
I feel the same way. I think it's because, fantastical setting aside, you don't need to suspend your disbelief the way you have to for later expansions. Modern audiences have personal experience with racial tension, corrupt religious organizations or governments, and class warfare. It's much easier to relate to a character if you see them facing the same problems you've dealt with in real life.
I also feel like there was something more compelling about the HW bad guys (omitted for spoilers) than the old Garleans and Ascians. They've done some really cool stuff with those guys, but in HW you could kinda understand their reasoning and stuff and they didn't just seem evil for the sake of evil. Obviously we've learnt the Garleans and Ascians motives and goals now, but it's way way further down the line. It was much more succinct in HW.
Also happy cake day!
[removed]
This. I started playing back in 2016 and HW just has some many amazing memories. I think it's also where the cast found it's footing. I didn't think much of it my first go round, but replaying the older stuff makes me realize just how stiff ARR was, compared to what was to follow.
Just you wait until shadowbringers. MGS3, Silent Hill 2, etc. These games made ke sad and well up a little.
FF14 is the only game whre I've uncontrollably had tears running down my face. Twice
I knew. I always knew.
[deleted]
Remember us. Remember that we once lived.
[Call him by his name]
The rains have ceased...
Broke me
It's incredible how much of an impact he has on the WoL just you wait and see. Also read the tales from heavensward if you haven't, especially the thoughts unspoken (I think this is the one not sure). Get urself ready for them tears, also there's a side quest that starts on fortemps manor and the butler is the quest giver and its called "the paths we walk" I suggest doing all that questline since you get an especial emote and you learn new things about heavensward in general!!
"Pay respects to a friend."
It was good to visit, after all that time. I think when I finish up Stormblood I'll go visit again, I think he'd like to know how things are going.
first thing i did after EW, got there and stayed there till i had taken everything in
Francel’s dialogue at the grave changes as you progress through the MSQ, too. He starts off saying “It never gets any easier, does it?” and now he says “So you would visit him still? He would be glad.”
ooh i didnt know that, i just saw (from what i can remember) the second one, anyways both would and still make me feel sad and happy at the same time.
This game will continue to rip your heart out. Have lots of tissue on hand. And maybe some eye drops.
Yup, and this isn’t limited to main scenario. The Shadowbringers trial series left me a sobbing mess by the end. Such an impactful questline
Trial series. Is that the one where it starts with The Cinder Drift and continues on from there? I did that trial and its neat but didn’t continue after that. I should! I did the Eden raids and that got pretty emotional at the end. I really liked that.
Yes you definitely want to continue after that. Fair warning the solo duty boss fight can be rather tricky
Sorry to bring back a week old discussion but….
I did finish this trial series just this morning. It was well worth it. Difficult fights but super fun! And the story was very well done and left me quite emotional as well. I am impressed this game does such well made stories outside of the MSQ. There’s always a reason to check out side stuff it seems.
No, please; I don't want to remember...
Beautiful picture, by the way! 💝 Your WoL is lovely.
No love for Ysyale though? You spend more time with her during the MSQ than with Haurch, and her sacrifice was just as effective as Haurch’s
#RememberYsyale
man, seeing Ysayle's sacrifice after not hearing from her since she found out the truth vom Hraesvelgr really broke me but at the same time made me happy she got one last badass moment.
From a story perspective her sacrifice was great. The cutscene it happens in kind of feels a bit jank in hindsight now though.
Th impact of Ysayle's death was diluted by happening so soon after Haurchefant's, IMO.
never found myself caring much for Ysyale, even with the noble sacrifice.
It was a heartbreaking scene losing her as well.
Thank you so much!!! This is kind of my third “version” of this glam so far, and I’ll kind of just stop and stare at her and get excited because I love it so much. The ruby red shire robe is so striking and the mask + white pants do so much for it as well.
I think it's a wonderful ensemble! Keep up the great work~ ♡
He was that one guy I can fully trust my bank detail including my PIN. In world full of scheming people, half-arsed people and selfish people, he was the only one who supported you because he genuinely liked you as a person.
I'll never forget how him and only he took me when the whole world that I have saved betrayed me. Just feels too hard to see him go like this... First time I cried for a video game character.
Oh, you sweet, summer child.
ShB:
!The rains have ceased, and we have been graced with another beautiful day. But you are not here to see it.!<
EW:
!Yes. Upon your return, I will gift you a beautiful flower.!<
The voice actor in ShB has to be given RIDICULOUS kudos, the delivery is so gutwrenching
You just reached the base camp to Mount HurtsSoGood. Get ready to climb to Emotional Damage midcamp (Stormblood->Shadowbringers) and summit ImNotCryingYourCrying Peak (Endwalker).
Good luck, more heart break and joy is yet to come if you jus finished HW!
Sorrow of Werlyt...
God I cried like a baby and wasn't prepared
I absolutely balled durring every single scene of that story. How incredibly fucked up, and in such a good way.
I know right? I just want to hug everyone involved
Unpopular opinion: I don't get why everyone falls apart over Haurchefant's death. He didn't particularly stand-out in ARR more than any of the other low-level quest givers, and basically disappeared after giving the "welcome to the HW expansion" speech. He's not even the first of the WoL's allies to die in the MSQ.
Haurchefant just didn't do much for me; I can think of more impactful deaths in other games >!(and even this one)!<.
I’ve always loved side characters who feel more like their own people than just companions. Characters who do their own thing and just act how they want, and I feel like Haurchefant does that. The way he unabashedly shows his love for the WoL and just his general demeanor.
If you’ve played Skyrim, it’s the same reason Serana Volkihar is such a good character. The amount that she likes you is not dependent on how much you like her, and the same is true for Haurchefant.
Besides.. I’m a sucker for romance. At the end of Heavensward talking to everyone before leaving for Azys Lla I found myself going “oh I need to talk to my romance boy- oh..” I just very much enjoy that relationship with the player character.
well, he was given the most dramatic death which probably accounts for a lot.
[deleted]
for me it was specifically because I didn't pay much attention to him and rudely skipped over a lot of his dialogue in ARR and such. he always seemed shady to me the way he was so unabashedly positive and praiseful about the WoL. but the moment he got pierced, it all suddenly clicked in my head that he truly meant every word he'd ever spoken and I felt so horrible for ever doubting or otherwise ignoring such an honest man.
The greatest expansion experience I will ever get to have. This was my “BC” “WOTLK” moment, going in completely not knowing what to expect, experiencing a true final fantasy journey with party members, it was incredible. Now I’ve got the songs stuck in my head haha
Heavensward
Beneath the gazing stars
Vales deep and forests dark
Betrayed by loyal hands, Her wrath stirred
Bound fast unto our fate
One path, one burden great
Yet ever do our aching souls point Heavensward
Ever rings out our song
Yes, ever do our aching souls march Heavensward
As they've done for so long
To their trespass
We are Witness
Here to pass this
Final sentence
No forgiveness
No deliverance
Only Justice
Only Vengeance
Wills unbending
Faith unending
Stone defending
Now our steel shall sing
Guide us, O mighty Fury
Guide us to victory!
Dys An Sohm In (Our slumber disturbed,)
Rohs An Kyn Ala na (All my brothers wake.)
Mah Morn Na-ah-ah-ahrr (The saviors must perish.)
Sahl Djahs Afah An (Vengeance will be ours.)
Eorzea!
Dragonsong
Children of the land do you hear
Echoes of truths that once rang clear
Two souls intertwined
One true love they did find
Bringing land and heavens near
But flames that burned full bright soon fell dark
Memories dimmed by shadowed hearts
In the waxing gloom
Did wane the lovers' moon
Watching as their worlds drift apart.
One soul's cry
A passion welling within
Sacrifice
A final plea to her kin
Yet this bond of hope
By treachery was broke
Scattering her words to the wind
Swelling overlong
Seas of blood are a song
And death an afterthought
To those who fight for naught
A throne lying empty
A reign incomplete
Alone for eternity
A pain without cease
Children of the land answer this
Why must you turn to empty bliss
Tell me why break trust
Why turn the past to dust
Seeking solace in the abyss
Tell me why create
A circle none can break
Why must you let go
The life you were bestowed
This I fear I'll never know
Never know...
I’m a Stormblood motif stan, but Heavensward’s quest turn in and complete is the perfect flavor for this expansion. Man, I love FFXIV
Rowena sells an item called “a knight to remember” highly recommend getting two or more for your house/apartment/fc quarters
I so know what you mean... I love and hate that npc that appears every time you visit the grave saying "it never gets easier, does it..?" Shadowbringers came very close but Heavensward will always be the one that touched me most. I just sat there after that cutscene and thought.. why can't I just cast Raise..? Please...
His dialogue changes if you go after Endwalker :)
But also, rezzing only brings players back from unconsciousness. It can’t heal a gaping wound to the gut. :(
Oh, I have to visit again, then.
Yeah, I was a paladin in that instance so the first thought was "no~, let me get hit, you idiot!"
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think there's a true resurrection spell out there. An NPC named Sylphie that you encounter on the Conjurer questline performs it at one point, though to her detriment in the end.
Great googly moogly just wait. 😥😥 Very seldom does a video game give me real feels, which is why I love FFXIV.
I don't play anymore, but whenever I played PLD, I would always glam to that shield.
All I can say is, wait until Shadowbringers and Endwalker. I love Heavensward, but it's my third favorite expansion now. Shadowbringers and Endwalker both topped it in feels.
You can look forward to ALL the emotions, my friend. You'll build up a crew of True Companions, you'll gain more friends and lose some as well. You'll laugh, cry, gasp in confusion, feel dread, feel failure, feel the absolute RUSH of a perfect dramatic climax.
And it will be beautiful.
I read this in a certain someone's voice.
So true...
The writing in this game is world class!!!